Introduction and importanceNutcracker syndrome (NCS) is a rare condition characterized by left renal vein compression and presents with diverse clinical manifestations. This case series study aims to evaluate the clinical presentations and outcomes of patients with NCS and varicocele. Case presentationWe reviewed the cases of four male patients, aged 15 to 19 years, who presented with recurrent and grade 3 varicocele after varicocelectomy. All patients reported pain in the hypogastric, flank, or groin areas. Despite the absence of hematuria, NCS was diagnosed based on duplex ultrasound and contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CT) scans. Patients underwent open surgical interventions, including gonadal vein transposition or saphenous vein bypass. Clinical discussionThe absence of hematuria in these cases poses a diagnostic challenge, as current diagnostic criteria for NCS relies on its presence. Our findings underscore the need to consider NCS in patients with varicocele, even in the absence of hematuria. Surgical interventions were effective in resolving the symptoms. After NCS surgery, the varicocele in one patient resolved, and three patients underwent varicocelectomy successfully without recurrence throughout the recovery period. ConclusionThis case series highlights the diagnosis of NCS presenting with varicocele and local pain without hematuria, emphasizing the need for improved diagnostic and management approaches.