Mammalian Purple Acid Phosphatases Research Articles

Optimization of an α-aminonaphthylmethylphosphonic acid inhibitor of purple acid phosphatase using rational structure-based design approaches

Purple acid phosphatases (PAPs) are ubiquitous binuclear metallohydrolases that have been isolated from various animals, plants and some types of fungi. In humans and mice, elevated PAP activity in osteoclasts is associated with osteoporosis, making human PAP an attractive target for the development of anti-osteoporotic drugs. Based on previous studies focusing on phosphonate scaffolds, as well as a new crystal structure of a PAP in complex with a derivative of a previously synthesized α-aminonaphthylmethylphosphonic acid, phosphonates 24–40 were designed as new PAP inhibitor candidates. Subsequent docking studies predicted that all of these compounds are likely to interact strongly with the active site of human PAP and most are likely to interact strongly with the active site of pig PAP. The seventeen candidates were synthesized with good yields and nine of them (26–28, 30, 33–36 and 38) inhibit in the sub-micromolar to nanomolar range against pig PAP, with 28 and 35 being the most potent mammalian PAP inhibitors reported with Ki values of 168 nM and 186 nM, respectively. This study thus paves the way for the next stage of drug development for phosphonate inhibitors of PAPs as anti-osteoporotic agents.

Rational Design of Potent Inhibitors of a Metallohydrolase Using a Fragment-Based Approach.

Metallohydrolases form a large group of enzymes that have fundamental importance in a broad range of biological functions. Among them, the purple acid phosphatases (PAPs) have gained attention due to their crucial role in the acquisition and use of phosphate by plants and also as a promising target for novel treatments of bone-related disorders and cancer. To date, no crystal structure of a mammalian PAP with drug-like molecules bound near the active site is available. Herein, we used a fragment-based design approach using structures of a mammalian PAP in complex with the MaybridgeTM fragment CC063346, the amino acid L-glutamine and the buffer molecule HEPES, as well as various solvent molecules to guide the design of highly potent and efficient mammalian PAP inhibitors. These inhibitors have improved aqueous solubility when compared to the clinically most promising PAP inhibitors available to date. Furthermore, drug-like fragments bound in newly discovered binding sites mapped out additional scaffolds for further inhibitor discovery, as well as scaffolds for the design of inhibitors with novel modes of action.

An Approach to More Accurate Model Systems for Purple Acid Phosphatases (PAPs).

The active site of mammalian purple acid phosphatases (PAPs) have a dinuclear iron site in two accessible oxidation states (Fe(III)2 and Fe(III)Fe(II)), and the heterovalent is the active form, involved in the regulation of phosphate and phosphorylated metabolite levels in a wide range of organisms. Therefore, two sites with different coordination geometries to stabilize the heterovalent active form and, in addition, with hydrogen bond donors to enable the fixation of the substrate and release of the product, are believed to be required for catalytically competent model systems. Two ligands and their dinuclear iron complexes have been studied in detail. The solid-state structures and properties, studied by X-ray crystallography, magnetism, and Mössbauer spectroscopy, and the solution structural and electronic properties, investigated by mass spectrometry, electronic, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), and Mössbauer spectroscopies and electrochemistry, are discussed in detail in order to understand the structures and relative stabilities in solution. In particular, with one of the ligands, a heterovalent Fe(III)Fe(II) species has been produced by chemical oxidation of the Fe(II)2 precursor. The phosphatase reactivities of the complexes, in particular, also of the heterovalent complex, are reported. These studies include pH-dependent as well as substrate concentration dependent studies, leading to pH profiles, catalytic efficiencies and turnover numbers, and indicate that the heterovalent diiron complex discussed here is an accurate PAP model system.

Separation of a milk acid phosphatase from a purified lactoferrin fraction and identification as a member of the mammalian purple acid phosphatase family

Active acid phosphatase (AcP), 37 kDa, was completely separated from the purified lactoferrin fraction of bovine milk (LF-rich fraction). The N-terminal amino acid sequence of the 37 kDa molecule had 84% homology with bovine uteroferrin (Uf)-like protein. The 37 kDa molecule has an optimum pH range of 4.5–5.0 and an optimum temperature of 60 °C. The AcP activity of the iron removal 37 kDa molecule (iron-depleted LF-rich fraction) was approximately half that of the iron-containing sample (LF-rich fraction). The activity increased in a time-dependent manner on tryptic digestion. These profiles correspond to the mammalian purple acid phosphatase (PAP) family (Uf, Type-5 and tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase: EC3.1.3.2). It seems reasonable to propose that the active molecule in the LF-rich fraction is an undocumented bovine PAP-family protein.

Synthesis, modelling and kinetic assays of potent inhibitors of purple acid phosphatase

Purple acid phosphatases (PAPs) are binuclear metallohydrolases that have been isolated from various mammals, plants, fungi and bacteria. In mammals PAP activity is associated with bone resorption and can lead to bone metabolic disorders such as osteoporosis; thus human PAP is an attractive target to develop anti-osteoporotic drugs. Based on a previous lead compound and rational drug design, acyl derivatives of α-aminonaphthylmethylphosphonic acid were synthesised and tested as PAP inhibitors. Kinetic analysis showed that they are good PAP inhibitors whose potencies improve with increasing acyl chain length. Maximum potency is reached when the number of carbons in the acyl chain is between 12 and 14. The most potent inhibitor of red kidney bean PAP is the dodecyl-derivative with K(ic)=5 μM, while the most potent pig PAP inhibitor is the tetradecyl-derivative with K(ic)=8 μM, the most potent inhibitor of a mammalian PAP yet reported.

Expression and proteolytic processing of mammalian purple acid phosphatase in CHO-K1 cells

Rat recombinant purple acid phosphatase (PAP) stably expressed in fibroblast-like CHO-K1 cells was purified and characterized with respect to post-translational modifications such as N-glycosylation and proteolytic processing in order to elucidate subcellular and molecular pathways for proteolytic activation. In these cells, proteolytically processed PAP was more abundant than the monomeric form. PAP-transfected CHO-K1 cells were expressing active cathepsin K intracellularly, which was partially co-localized with PAP. However, neither cathepsin K nor trypsin digestion of the purified monomeric PAP in vitro did result in a two-subunit form with kinetic and electrophoretic properties resembling the endogenous cellular two-subunit form. Treatment of PAP-transfected CHO-K1 cells with the cysteine proteinase inhibitor E-64 suggested that only a minor fraction of secreted PAP is processed intracellularly by cysteine proteinases. These data do not support a dominant or critical role for cathepsins or trypsin-like serine proteinases in the proteolytic activation of PAP in CHO-K1 cells, implicating yet unidentified proteinases in the proteolytic processing of both intracellular and secreted PAP in this cell line.

Mammalian-like Purple Acid Phosphatases in Plants

Purple acid phosphatases(PAPs) comprise of a family of binuclear metal-containing hydrolases, some members of which have been isolated and characterized from animal, plant and fungal sources [1]. PAPs not only catalyze the hydrolyses of a wide range of phosphate esters and anhydrides under acidic reaction conditions, but also catalyze the generation of hydroxyl radicals in a Fenton-like reaction, by virtue of the presence of a redox-active binuclear metal center. Inmammals, the hydroxyl radicals so generated may be important for the degradation of connective tissue(in osteoclasts) and the defense against bacteria(in macrophages). Mammalian PAPs from several species have been isolated and characterized [1].

Direct observation of multiple protonation states in recombinant human purple acid phosphatase

To date, most spectroscopic studies on mammalian purple acid phosphatases (PAPs) have been performed at a single pH, typically pH 5. The catalytic activity of these enzymes is, however, pH dependent, with optimal pH values of 5.5-6.2 (depending on the form). For example, the pH optimum of PAPs isolated as single polypeptides is around pH 5.5, which is substantially lower that of proteolytically cleaved PAPs (ca. pH 6.2). In addition, the catalytic activity of single polypeptide PAPs at their optimal pH values is four to fivefold lower than that of the proteolytically cleaved enzymes. In order to elucidate the chemical basis for the pH dependence of these enzymes, the spectroscopic properties of both the single polypeptide and proteolytically cleaved forms of recombinant human PAP (recHPAP) and their complexes with inhibitory anions have been examined over the pH range 4 to 8. The EPR spectra of both forms of recHPAP are pH dependent and show the presence of three species: an inactive low pH form (pH<pK( a,1)), an active form (pK( a,1)<pH<pK( a,2)), and an inactive high pH form (pH>pK( a,2)). The pK( a,1) values observed by EPR for the single polypeptide and proteolytically cleaved forms are similar to those previously observed in kinetics studies. The spectroscopic properties of the enzyme-phosphate complex (which should mimic the enzyme-substrate complex), the enzyme-fluoride complex, and the enzyme-fluoride-phosphate complex (which should mimic the ternary enzyme-substrate-hydroxide complex) were also examined. EPR spectra show that phosphate binds to the diiron center of the proteolytically cleaved form of the enzyme, but not to that of the single polypeptide form. EPR spectra also show that fluoride binds only to the low pH form of the enzymes, in which it presumably replaces a coordinated water molecule. The binding of fluoride and phosphate to form a ternary complex appears to be cooperative.

Substrate positioning by His92 is important in catalysis by purple acid phosphatase

Proteolysis of single polypeptide mammalian purple acid phosphatases (PAPs) results in the loss of an interaction between the loop residue Asp146 and the active site residues Asn91 and/or His92. While Asn91 is a ligand to the divalent metal of the mixed-valent di-iron center, the role of His92 in the catalytic mechanism is unknown. Site-directed mutagenesis of His92 was performed to examine the role of this residue in single polypeptide PAP. Conversion of His92 into Ala, which eliminates polar interactions of this residue with the active site, resulted in a 10-fold decrease in catalytic activity at the optimal pH. Conversely, conversion of this residue into Asn, which cannot function as either a proton donor or acceptor, but can provide hydrogen-bonding interactions, resulted in a three-fold increase in activity at the optimal pH. Both mutant enzymes had more acidic pH optima, with pK(es,1) values consistent with the involvement of an iron(III) hydroxide unit or a hydroxide in the second coordination sphere in catalysis. These results, together with EPR data, support a role of His92 in positioning either the nucleophile or the substrate, rather than directly in acid or base catalysis. The existence of an extensive hydrogen-bonding network that could fine-tune the position of His92 is consistent with this proposal.

Phosphate forms an unusual tripodal complex with the Fe–Mn center of sweet potato purple acid phosphatase

Purple acid phosphatases (PAPs) are a family of binuclear metalloenzymes that catalyze the hydrolysis of phosphoric acid esters and anhydrides. A PAP in sweet potato has a unique, strongly antiferromagnetically coupled Fe(III)-Mn(II) center and is distinguished from other PAPs by its increased catalytic efficiency for a range of activated and unactivated phosphate esters, its strict requirement for Mn(II), and the presence of a mu-oxo bridge at pH 4.90. This enzyme displays maximum catalytic efficiency (k(cat)/K(m)) at pH 4.5, whereas its catalytic rate constant (k(cat)) is maximal at near-neutral pH, and, in contrast to other PAPs, its catalytic parameters are not dependent on the pK(a) of the leaving group. The crystal structure of the phosphate-bound Fe(III)-Mn(II) PAP has been determined to 2.5-A resolution (final R(free) value of 0.256). Structural comparisons of the active site of sweet potato, red kidney bean, and mammalian PAPs show several amino acid substitutions in the sweet potato enzyme that can account for its increased catalytic efficiency. The phosphate molecule binds in an unusual tripodal mode to the two metal ions, with two of the phosphate oxygen atoms binding to Fe(III) and Mn(II), a third oxygen atom bridging the two metal ions, and the fourth oxygen pointing toward the substrate binding pocket. This binding mode is unique among the known structures in this family but is reminiscent of phosphate binding to urease and of sulfate binding to lambda protein phosphatase. The structure and kinetics support the hypothesis that the bridging oxygen atom initiates hydrolysis.

N-glycosylation influences the latency and catalytic properties of mammalian purple acid phosphatase

Purple acid phosphatase (PAP), also known as tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase or uteroferrin, contains two potential consensus N-glycosylation sites at Asn 97 and Asn 128. In this study, endogenous rat bone PAP was found to possess similar N-glycan structures as rat recombinant PAP heterologously expressed in baculovirus-infected Sf9 insect cells. PAP from Sf9 cells was shown to contain two N-linked oligosaccharides, whereas PAP expressed by mammalian CHO-K1 cells was less extensively glycosylated. The extent of N-glycosylation affected the catalytic properties of the enzyme, as N97Q and N128Q mutants, containing a single oligosaccharide chain, exhibited a lower substrate affinity and catalytic activity compared to those of the fully glycosylated PAP in the native, monomeric state. The differences in substrate affinity and catalytic activity were abolished and partially restored, respectively, by proteolytic cleavage in the loop domain, indicating that the extent of N-glycosylation influences the interaction of the repressive loop domain with catalytically important residues.

A model of the acid sphingomyelinase phosphoesterase domain based on its remote structural homolog purple acid phosphatase

Sequence profile and fold recognition methods identified mammalian purple acid phosphatase (PAP), a member of a dimetal-containing phosphoesterase (DMP) family, as a remote homolog of human acid sphingomyelinase (ASM). A model of the phosphoesterase domain of ASM was built based on its predicted secondary structure and the metal-coordinating residues of PAP. Due to the low sequence identity between ASM and PAP (approximately 15%), the highest degree of confidence in the model resides in the metal-binding motifs. The ASM model predicts residues Asp 206, Asp 278, Asn 318, His 425, and His 457 to be dimetal coordinating. A putative orientation for the phosphorylcholine head group of the ASM substrate, sphingomyelin (SM), was made based on the predicted catalysis of the phosphorus-oxygen bond in the active site of ASM and on a structural comparison of the PAP-phosphate complex to the C-reactive protein-phosphorylcholine complex. These complexes revealed similar spatial interactions between the metal-coordinating residues, the metals, and the phosphate groups, suggesting a putative orientation for the head group in ASM consistent with the mechanism considerations. A conserved sequence motif in ASM, NX3CX3N, was identified (Asn 381 to Asn 389) and is predicted to interact with the choline amine moiety in SM. The resulting ASM model suggests that the enzyme uses an SN2-type catalytic mechanism to hydrolyze SM, similar to other DMPs. His 319 in ASM is predicted to protonate the ceramide-leaving group in the catalysis of SM. The putative functional roles of several ASM Niemann-Pick missense mutations, located in the predicted phosphoesterase domain, are discussed in context to the model.

Porcine purple acid phosphatase: heterologous expression, characterization, and proteolytic analysis

Uteroferrin is an iron-binding glycoprotein, which is abundantly synthesized in porcine uterine glandular endometrium and believed to be involved in maternal/fetal iron transport. In the present study, uteroferrin has been cloned and functionally expressed using baculovirus-infected insect host cells Spodoptera frugiperda. The work also addresses the possible role of proteolytic cleavage to facilitate the release of uteroferrin-bound iron. The enzyme secreted in culture medium exhibits a molecular mass and catalytic properties similar to native porcine uteroferrin. The specific activity was estimated at 233 U/mg using p-nitrophenyl phosphate as substrate. Partial cleavage of the enzyme with trypsin resulted in a 1.7-fold enhancement in specific activity and a two-subunit polypeptide as observed in preparations of most mammalian purple acid phosphatases. Digestion with the aspartic protease pepsin resulted in a 2.5-fold enzyme inactivation correlated with the appearance of low molecular weight polypeptide fragments and the release of enzyme-bound iron.

Phosphatase and Oxygen Radical-Generating Activities of Mammalian Purple Acid Phosphatase Are Functionally Independent

Bone-resorbing osteoclasts and activated macrophages express large amounts of tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP), an iron-containing enzyme with unknown biological function. We studied acid phosphatase (AcP) and reactive oxygen species (ROS)-generating activities of recombinant rat TRAP. pH optimum was 4.5 for AcP activity and 6.5 for ROS-generating activity. Replacement of His113 and His216 by site-directed mutagenesis severely inhibited AcP activity, but had no significant effects on ROS-generating activity. Substrate specificity was not affected by the mutations. These results suggest that AcP and ROS-generating activities of TRAP are functionally independent.

Mutational analysis of the interaction between active site residues and the loop region in mammalian purple acid phosphatases.

Mammalian purple acid phosphatases (PAPs) can be divided into two groups, which exhibit distinct spectroscopic and kinetics properties: PAPs that consist of a single 36 kDa polypeptide, and PAPs that have undergone limited proteolysis to give two fragments with masses of 16 and 20 kDa, respectively. Proteolysis results in an increase in enzymatic activity, an increase in the optimal pH for activity, and a change in the g(z)() value of the characteristic EPR spectrum of the mixed-valence binuclear iron center. It has been proposed that these changes are due to the loss of interactions between Asp146 in an exposed loop region and active site residues upon proteolysis. In the present study, site-directed mutagenesis of Asp146 in recombinant rat bone PAP (recRPAP) has confirmed this hypothesis. Conversion of Asp146 into Ala, which eliminates the interaction of the side chain with the active site, resulted in an enzyme with properties typical of PAPs isolated in proteolytically cleaved forms. The Asp146Asn and Asp146Glu mutants were also prepared and examined to assess the effects of altered electrostatic interactions and side-chain length. Limited proteolysis of all three mutant enzymes with cathepsin L resulted in a significant increase in catalytic activity. Thus, although the interaction between Asp146 and (an) active site residue(s) is the major factor responsible for the low catalytic activity of uncleaved PAPs, other interactions are also important. Since both p-nitrophenyl phosphate and osteopontin, a potential in vivo substrate, show the same level of activation, the observed increase in catalytic activity upon proteolysis is likely to be due to electrostatic rather than steric effects. EPR spectra of FeZn-recRPAP before and after cleavage by cathepsin L suggest that cleavage primarily affects the divalent metal site. The observation that pK(es,1) is also sensitive to changes at the divalent site is consistent with the proposal that the nucleophilic hydroxide is that bridging the divalent and trivalent metals.

The Highly Exposed Loop Region in Mammalian Purple Acid Phosphatase Controls the Catalytic Activity

Recombinant human purple acid phosphatase (recHPAP) provides a convenient experimental system for assessing the relationship between molecular structure and enzymatic activity in mammalian purple acid phosphatases (PAPs). recHPAP is a monomeric protein with properties similar to those of uteroferrin (Uf) and other PAPs isolated as single polypeptide chains, but its properties differ significantly from those of bovine spleen PAP (BSPAP) and other PAPs isolated as proteolytically “clipped” forms. Incubation of recHPAP with trypsin results in proteolytic cleavage in an exposed region near the active site. The product is a tightly associated two-subunit protein whose collective spectroscopic and kinetics properties resemble those of BSPAP. These results demonstrate that the differences in spectroscopic and kinetics properties previously reported for mammalian PAPs are the result of proteolytic cleavage. Mass spectrometry shows that a three-residue segment, D-V-K, within the loop region is excised by trypsin. This finding suggests that important interactions between residues in the excised loop and one or more of the groups that participate in catalysis are lost or altered upon proteolytic cleavage. Analysis of available structural data indicates that the most important such interaction is that between Asp 146 in the exposed loop and active-site residues Asn 91 and His 92. Loss of this interaction should result in both an increase in the Lewis acidity of the FeII ion and an increase in the nucleophilicity of the FeIII-bound hydroxide ion. Proteolytic cleavage thus constitutes a potential physiological mechanism for regulating the activity of PAP in vivo.

The highly exposed loop region in mammalian purple acid phosphatase controls the catalytic activity.

Recombinant human purple acid phosphatase (recHPAP) provides a convenient experimental system for assessing the relationship between molecular structure and enzymatic activity in mammalian purple acid phosphatases (PAPs). recHPAP is a monomeric protein with properties similar to those of uteroferrin (Uf) and other PAPs isolated as single polypeptide chains, but its properties differ significantly from those of bovine spleen PAP (BSPAP) and other PAPs isolated as proteolytically "clipped" forms. Incubation of recHPAP with trypsin results in proteolytic cleavage in an exposed region near the active site. The product is a tightly associated two-subunit protein whose collective spectroscopic and kinetics properties resemble those of BSPAP. These results demonstrate that the differences in spectroscopic and kinetics properties previously reported for mammalian PAPs are the result of proteolytic cleavage. Mass spectrometry shows that a three-residue segment, D-V-K, within the loop region is excised by trypsin. This finding suggests that important interactions between residues in the excised loop and one or more of the groups that participate in catalysis are lost or altered upon proteolytic cleavage. Analysis of available structural data indicates that the most important such interaction is that between Asp 146 in the exposed loop and active-site residues Asn 91 and His 92. Loss of this interaction should result in both an increase in the Lewis acidity of the Fe(II) ion and an increase in the nucleophilicity of the Fe(III)-bound hydroxide ion. Proteolytic cleavage thus constitutes a potential physiological mechanism for regulating the activity of PAP in vivo.

Expression and distribution of tartrate-resistant purple acid phosphatase in the rat nervous system.

Tartrate-resistant purple acid phosphatase (TRAP) of osteoclasts and certain cells of the monocyte-macrophage lineage belongs to the family of purple acid phosphatases (PAPs). We provide here evidence for TRAP/PAP expression in the central and peripheral nervous systems in the rat. TRAP/PAP protein was partially purified and characterized from the trigeminal ganglion, brain, and spinal cord. The TRAP activity (U/mg tissue) in these tissues was about 10-20 times lower than in bone. Reducing agents, e.g. ascorbate and ferric iron, increased the TRAP activity from the neural tissues (nTRAP) and addition of oxidizing agents completely inactivated both bone and nTRAP. The IC(50) for three known oxyanion inhibitors of TRAP/PAP was similar for bone and nTRAP with the same rank order of potency (molybdate > tungstate > phosphate). This indicates that the redox-sensitive binuclear iron center characteristic of mammalian PAPs is present also in nTRAP. Western blots of partially purified nTRAP revealed a band with the expected size of 35 kD. The expression of TRAP in the trigeminal ganglion, brain, and spinal cord was confirmed at the mRNA level by RT-PCR. In situ hybridization histochemistry demonstrated TRAP mRNA expression in small ganglion cells of the trigeminal ganglion, in alpha-motor neurons of the ventral spinal cord, and in Purkinje cells of the cerebellum. TRAP-like immunoreactivity was encountered in the cytoplasm of neuronal cell bodies in specific areas of both the central and the peripheral nervous system. Together, the data demonstrate that active TRAP/PAP is expressed in certain parts of the rat nervous system.

Purple acid phosphatases from bacteria: similarities to mammalian and plant enzymes

Mammalian and plant purple acid phosphatases have similar active site structures despite low sequence identity (<20%). Although no bacterial enzyme has been purified, a sequence database search revealed that genes that could encode potential purple acid phosphatases may be restricted to a small number of organisms (i.e. myco- and cyanobacteria). Analysis of their deduced amino acid sequences and predicted secondary structures indicates that the cyanobacterial enzyme is similar to both the mammalian and the recently discovered low-molecular-weight plant purple acid phosphatases, while the mycobacterial enzyme is homologous to the fungal and high-molecular-weight plant purple acid phosphatases. Homology models indicate that both bacterial proteins appear to be similar to mammalian purple acid phosphatases in the immediate vicinity of the active site. It is likely that these enzymes act as Fenton-type catalysts in order to prevent damage caused by reactive oxygen species generated by invaded host cells ( M. tuberculosis) or by the light-harvesting complex ( Synechocystis sp.).

Identification of mammalian-like purple acid phosphatases in a wide range of plants

Purple acid phosphatases (PAPs) comprise a family of binuclear metal-containing hydrolases, members of which have been isolated from plants, mammals and fungi. Polypeptide chains differ in size (animal ∼35 kDa, plant ∼55 kDa) and exhibit low sequence homology between kingdoms but all residues involved in co-ordination of the metal ions are invariant. A search of genomic databases was undertaken using a sequence pattern which includes the conserved residues. Several novel potential PAP sequences were detected, including the first known examples from bacterial sources. Ten plant ESTs were also identified which, although possessing the conserved sequence pattern, were not homologous throughout their sequences to previously known plant PAPs. Based on these EST sequences, novel cDNAs from sweet potato, soybean, red kidney bean and Arabidopsis thaliana were cloned and sequenced. These sequences are more closely related to mammalian PAP than to previously characterized plant enzymes. Their predicted secondary structure is similar to that of the mammalian enzyme. A model of the sweet potato enzyme was generated based on the coordinates of pig PAP. These observations strongly suggest that the cloned cDNA sequences represent a second group of plant PAPs with properties more similar to the mammalian enzymes than to the high molecular weight plant enzymes.