Male Sterile Phenotype Research Articles

A new CMS source in Nicotiana developed via somatic cybridization between N. tabacum and N. alata

Cytoplasmic somatic hybrids (cybrids) between the two sexually incompatible species Nicotiana tabacum and Nicotiana alata were constructed. A total of 33 green regenerants were obtained after fusion of protoplasts from a tobacco cytoplasmic chlorophyll-deficient mutant and gamma irradiation-inactivated leaf protoplasts of N. alata. Twenty nine of them were male sterile and displayed an altered stamen morphology (formation of petaloid and stigmoid structures instead of stamens). Southern-blot analyses of eight CMS plants using N. alata-specific nuclear repetitive DNA and cpDNA probes revealed that they contained nuclear genetic material of N. tabacum and chloroplasts from N. alata. Restriction-enzyme analysis of mitochondrial DNAs of the cybrids in question showed different patterns consisting of an incomplete mix of mtDNA fragments from both parents, as well as new fragments. Southern-blot analysis of mtDNAs with a sunflower atpA probe gave the same recombinant hybridization pattern for all analyzed cybrids, indicating that high-frequency specific recombination occurs in the atpA region. Analysis of the progeny from three successive backcrosses of the studied cybrids with N. tabacum demonstrated a strict cytoplasmic inheritance of the male-sterile phenotype.

Genetic dissection of sperm individualization in Drosophila melanogaster.

The morphogenesis of spermatids generally takes place within a syncytium, in which all spermatid nuclei descended from a primary spermatocyte remain connected via an extensive network of cytoplasmic bridges. A late step in sperm maturation therefore requires the physical resolution of the syncytium, or cyst, into individual cells, a process sometimes referred to as sperm individualization. Despite the identification of specialized machinery involved in the individualization of Drosophila spermatids (Tokuyasu, K. T., Peacock, W. J. and Hardy, R. W. (1972) Z. Zellforsch 124, 479-506), and of many Drosophila genes mutable to male-sterile phenotypes, little is known of the mechanisms by which this extensive remodeling of the cyst is accomplished. Here, the identification of a major cytoskeletal component of the individualization complex as actin is confirmed with a simple fluorescence assay. Using rhodamine-phalloidin as a probe, the individualization complex is readily visualized forming around bundles of spermatid nuclei at one end of highly elongated cysts, then translocating along the length of the cysts. The structure of the individualization complex in a male-sterile clathrin heavy chain (Chc) mutant is observed to be reduced or disrupted relative to wild-type, consistent with the individualization-deficient phenotype of this mutant. Using the fluorescence assay, a sampling of male-sterile mutant phenotypes in which spermatogenesis proceeds to the assembly of highly elongated cysts distinguishes at least four different phenotypic classes: (1) mutations (nanking class) that block or significantly retard the assembly of the actin-based individualization complex around the nuclear bundle, (2) mutations (dud class) in which the individualization complex assembles in/around the nuclear bundle, but fails to translocate down the cyst, (3) mutations (mulet class) that allow the assembly of a morphologically normal individualization complex around the nuclear bundle, but result in a breakdown in the complex after it begins to translocate down the cyst, and (4) mutations (purity of essence class) that allow the assembly of a motile but morphologically altered or reduced individualization complex. Individualization also fails in a number of mutants with altered nuclear shape, consistent with the hypothesis that spermatid nuclei provide a physical scaffolding for the assembly of the individualization complex. Genetic analysis suggests that a substantial number of additional loci with phenotypes distinguishable with this assay remain to be identified. The large proportion of male-sterile mutations resulting in a late block to spermatogenesis, in which highly elongated cysts fail to be individualized, suggest a substantial susceptibility of this process to a broad range of cellular perturbations. The massive reorganization of cyst cytoplasm required at individualization is expected to be a correspondingly complex function requiring exquisite coordination of multiple cytoplasmic functions, and may account for the previously noted high frequency with which Drosophila genes are mutable to male-sterile phenotypes.

RNA editing in plant mitochondria, cytoplasmic male sterility and plant breeding.

RNA editing in plant mitochondria is a post-transcriptional process involving the partial change of C residues into U. These C to U changes lead to the synthesis of proteins with an amino acid sequence different to that predicted from the gene. Proteins produced from edited mRNAs are more similar to those from organisms where this process is absent. This biochemical process involves cytidine deamination. The cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) phenotype generated by the incompatibility between the nuclear and the mitochondrial genomes is an important agronomical trait which prevents inbreeding and favors hybrid production. The hypothesis that RNA editing leads to functional proteins has been proposed. This hypothesis was tested by constructing transgenic plants expressing a mitochondrial protein translated from mRNA. The transgenic unedited protein was addressed to the mitochondria leading to the appearance of mitochondrial dysfunction and generating the male sterile phenotype in transgenic tobacco plants. Male sterile plants were also obtained by expressing specifically a bacterial ribonuclease in the anthers. The economical benefits of artificially engineered male-sterile plants or carrying the (native) spontaneous CMS phenotype, implies the restoration to obtain fertile hybrids that will be used in agriculture. Restoration to fertility of transgenic plants was obtained either by crossing male-sterile plants carrying the unedited mRNA with plants carrying the same RNA, but in the antisense orientation or, in the case of plants expresing the ribonuclease, by crossing male-sterile plants with plants expressing an inhibitor specific of this enzyme.

Low-copy-number molecules are produced by recombination, actively maintained and can be amplified in the mitochondrial genome of Brassicaceae: relationship to reversion of the male sterile phenotype in some cybrids.

A PCR analysis of mitochondrial (mt) genomes of cybrid rapeseed plants revealed substoichiometric concentrations of molecules bearing different configurations of the gene (orf138) responsible for Ogura cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS). These substoichiometric molecules are also present in plants bearing the unmodified Ogura cytoplasm. In one cybrid family, which shows reversion of the male sterile phenotype, we observed changes in the respective proportions of these molecules. The phenotypic (sterility-fertility) reversion occurs as a result of a modification of the equilibrium state between the different forms of the orf138 gene and is very probably determined by the level of expression of this gene. Stable situations are always characterized by one predominant form; the others, when present, exist in substoichiometric amounts. We report results indicating that the different forms of the orf138 gene are continuously interconverted by recombination and that an active mechanism is involved in the maintenance of some substoichiometric molecules.

Mosaic open reading frames in the Arabidopsis thaliana mitochondrial genome.

In the mitochondrial genome of Arabidopsis thaliana eight mosaic open reading frames arose by recombination of fragments duplicated from one or more mitochondrial genes. These duplications represent unedited sequences, suggesting their derivation from genomic DNA rather than RNA. Five of the chimeric reading frames contain the information for the N-terminus of the original polypeptide and 5' upstream regions. These observations suggest that the generation of novel open reading frames in plant mitochondria can occur rather easily by chance extensions of duplicated gene fragments. The presence of so many mosaic open reading frames in the normal Arabidopsis thaliana mitochondrial genome suggests that such recombined sequences interfere only occasionally and fortuitously with the peak mitochondrial performance presumably required during pollen maturation, and usually do not cause a cytoplasmic male sterile phenotype.

A cytoplasmic male sterility-associated mitochondrial protein causes pollen disruption in transgenic tobacco.

In higher plants, dominant mitochondrial mutations are associated with pollen sterility. This phenomenon is known as cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS). It is thought that the disruption in pollen development is a consequence of mitochondrial dysfunction. To provide definitive evidence that expression of an abnormal mitochondrial gene can interrupt pollen development, a CMS-associated mitochondrial DNA sequence from common bean, orf239, was introduced into the tobacco nuclear genome. Several transformants containing the orf239 gene constructs, with or without a mitochondrial targeting sequence, exhibited a semi sterile or male-sterile phenotype. Expression of the gene fusions in transformed anthers was confirmed using RNA gel blotting, ELISA, and light and electron microscopic immunocytochemistry. Immunocytological analysis showed that the ORF239 protein could associate with the cell wall of aberrant developing microspores. This pattern of extracellular localization was earlier observed in the CMS common bean line containing orf239 in the mitochondrial genome. Results presented here demonstrate that ORF239 causes pollen disruption in transgenic tobacco plants and may do so without targeting of the protein to the mitochondrion.

Transgenic male-sterile plant induced by an unedited atp9 gene is restored to fertility by inhibiting its expression with antisense RNA.

We have previously shown that the expression of an unedited atp9 chimeric gene correlated with male-sterile phenotype in transgenic tobacco plant. To study the relationship between the expression of chimeric gene and the male-sterile trait, hemizygous and homozygous transgenic tobacco lines expressing the antisense atp9 RNA were constructed. The antisense producing plants were crossed with a homozygous male-sterile line, and the F1 progeny was analyzed. The offspring from crosses between homozygous lines produced only male-fertile plants, suggesting that the expression antisense atp9 RNA abolishes the effect of the unedited chimeric gene. In fact, the plants restored to male fertility showed a dramatic reduction of the unedited atp9 transcript levels, resulting in normal flower development and seed production. These results support our previous observation that the expression of unedited atp9 gene can induce male sterility.

A 610 kb YAC clone harbors 7 cM of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) DNA that includes the male sterile 14 gene and a hotspot for recombination.

Pollen development requires both sporophytic and gametophytic gene expression. We are using a map-based cloning technique to isolate sporophytic genes which, when mutant, cause pollen abortion and a male sterile (ms) phenotype in tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum). We have genetically characterized one ms locus (ms14) using RFLP analysis and identified flanking markers. High-resolution genomic physical mapping indicates that the ms14 locus is located in a approximately 300 kb region. We have identified a YAC clone with an insert size of approximately 610 kb that contains the ms14-linked markers, reflects the organization of the physical map and therefore most probably contains the ms14 gene. In addition, we present evidence that the relationship between physical and genetic distance in this chromosomal region changes abruptly from approximately 105-140 kb/cM to less than 24kb/cM, and suggest that the TG393-TG104 region is a hotspot for recombination.

Genomic recombination of the mitochondrial atp6 gene in Arabidopsis thaliana at the protein processing site creates two different presequences.

In the mitochondrial genome of the flowering plant Arabidopsis thaliana the atp6 open reading frame is located on the border of one of the repeats resulting in two copies with different presequence extensions. The two presequences of 135 and 97 amino acids respectively show no similarity to each other, while the mature protein sequences are identical. Both preproteins are most likely synthesized in Arabidopsis mitochondria from promoter elements upstream of each copy. The presence of two arrangements in the mitochondrial genome of fertile Arabidopsis plants suggests this recombination to be unrelated to a cytoplasmic male sterile phenotype. This recombination precisely at the mature protein terminus is reminiscent of the domain shuffling model in protein evolution.

Genetic aspects of artificial fertilization

Artificial fertilization protocols were developed to circumvent natural reproduction barriers. Genetically determined barriers were commonly estimated at approximately 30%. This review presents an overview of possible genetic barriers and divides them into four different groups for discussion of their specific aspects. Obviously, genetically determined sterility factors are mostly associated with the phenotype of severe idiopathic male sterility. Before the development of ICSI, the treatment of this patient group showed only a low rate of success. Now many scientists are afraid that ICSI will not only increase this rate of success significantly, but will also increase the rate of genetically determined diseases, including sterility, to ICSI offspring.

Co-segregation of the maize dwarf mosaic virus resistance gene, Mdm1, with the nucleolus organizer region in maize

The mdm1 locus on the short arm of chromosome six confers resistance in maize to five strains of the maize dwarf mosaic virus (MDMV), an aphid transmitted potyvirus. The location of mdm1 in relation to RFLP and morphological loci on the short arm of chromosome six was determined using BC1 and F2 mapping populations. The following map order and distance in cM was obtained from the F2 population; jc1270-2.5-npi245-1.6-umc85/po1-0.5-mdm1/nor-0.5-bnl6.29A-0.5-npi235-0.8-npi101A-4.3-numc59. No recombination between mdm1 and the nucleolus organizer region (nor) was detected, as determined using a probe from the intergenic spacer region of the rDNA repeat. In order to resolve the relationship between mdm1 and the nor, and to recover recombinants around mdm1, a highresolution map within the polymitotic1 (po1) yellow kernel1 (y1) interval was generated using [po1 y1 tester (po1 mdm1 y1) x Pa405 (Po1 Mdm1 Y1)] F2 plants. The recessive po1 allele imparts a male-sterile phenotype when homozygous and since po1 and y1 are closely linked, the majority of fertile plants from white endosperm (y1/y1) F2 kernels will arise though a recombination event between the Pa405 Po1 allele and the y1 allele of the po1 y1 tester. Plants from 7,650 white (y1/y1) F2 kernels were examined (15,300 chromosomes) and a total of 626 F2∶3 recombinant families was recovered. Analysis of these recombinants revealed that mdm1 cosegregates with the nor. This lack of recombination between mdm1 and the nor suggests that: either (1) mdm1 is located in the region flanking the nor and recombination is suppressed within that region, or (2) mdm1 is located within the nor.

RNA editing of the tobacco mitochondrial orf38/220.

An alloplasmic, male-sterile tobacco line obtained by sexual hybridization, resulting in introgression of the Nicotiana bigelovii cytoplasm into the Nicotiana tabacum species, is characterized by male-sterile flowers that have filaments with flat-fringed ends instead of normal stamens, and a split corolla (Burk, 1960; Chaplin, 1964). A mitochondrially encoded chimeric gene, orf38/220, corresponding to a fusion of an orf coding for 38 amino acids and the sequence coding for the carboxy-terminal 220 amino acids of the ATPase a subunit (atpA), was found to be associated with the cytoplas'mic male-sterile phenotype (P. Bergman, W. Kofer, G. Hakansson, and K. Glimelius, unpublished data). Our studies show that this chimeric gene is a target for posttranscriptional editing in which seven cytosines are replaced by uridines in the mitochondrial mRNA (Table I). At the protein level, three Pro codons (codons 180,221, and 246) were changed to Leu codons, as previously described for sugar beet atpA mRNAs (Senda et al., 1993). We have identified four additional sites of editing, codons 96 and 115 in which the Pro codon is edited to Ser, codon 142 in which Ser becomes a Leu codon, and codon 155 in which the Leu codon is transformed into a Phe codon. Eight independent clones were sequenced; three of them were fully edited, whereas in five of the clones codon 115 was unedited. Furthermore, in one of these clones codon

Cell-specific regulation of gene expression in mitochondria during anther development in sunflower.

Mitochondrial gene expression was characterized during meiosis in sunflower anthers. In situ hybridization experiments showed that there was a marked accumulation of four mitochondrial gene transcripts (atpA, atp9, cob, and rrn26) in young meiotic cells. This pattern of transcript accumulation was only detected for mitochondrial genes and not for transcripts of two nuclear genes (atpB and ANT) encoding mitochondrial proteins or another nuclear gene transcript (25S rRNA). Immunolocalization studies showed that the pattern of accumulation of the protein product of the atpA gene, the F1-ATP synthase alpha subunit, reflects that of the transcript. The expression of the novel mitochondrial orf522, which is associated with the cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) phenotype, was also studied by in situ hybridization. The orf522 transcripts were reduced in abundance in meiotic cells in the presence of fertility restorer genes. These results suggest that mitochondrial gene expression is regulated in a cell-specific fashion in developing anthers and that the restorer gene(s) may act cell specifically.

Male-sterile phenotype of the neurological mouse mutant weaver.

The autosomal recessive murine mutation weaver (wv) affects postnatal differentiation in at least three neuronal populations in the brain: dopamine-containing neurons in the mid-brain, and granule and Purkinje cells in the cerebellum. Neuronal populations vulnerable to the actions of weaver die in the midst of development. In addition, homozygous weaver males are sterile. We show by a histological analysis of epididymides and testes that the cause of male sterility in weaver is lack of sperm. The epididymides of the adult weaver mice examined were devoid of sperm, and few seminiferous tubules in the adult weaver's testes contained elongated spermatids. Most tubules were marked by moderate to severe degeneration of the seminiferous epithelium. A developmental study showed that the mutant phenotype emerged after the third postnatal week. By postnatal day 28, the development of weaver sperm lagged behind that of the wild-type and some seminiferous tubules contained degenerating germ cells. By postnatal day 35, terminal differentiation of spermatids appeared to be arrested in many tubules and degeneration of the seminiferous epithelium was widespread. The heterozygotes were unaffected at all ages sampled. We conclude that the normal allele at the weaver locus is necessary for spermiogenesis and the maintenance of spermatogenesis.

RNA editing of transcripts of a chimeric mitochondrial gene associated with cytoplasmic male-sterility in Brassica.

The orf224 gene is a chimeric open reading frame associated with the Polima or pol cytoplasmic male sterility of Brassica napus. The first 58 codons and 5' upstream region of orf224 are derived from a conventional mitochondrial gene, orfB, while the origin of the remaining portion of the gene is unknown. Transcripts of the orf224 gene were found to be edited at a single site in the region of the gene that does not correspond to a known sequence. Oligonucleotides corresponding to the edited and unedited forms were shown to hybridize specifically to respective in vitro orf224 transcripts. Analysis of floral mtRNA by this method indicated that virtually all orf224 transcripts of both sterile and fertile, nuclear-restored pol cytoplasm plants are edited. Our results indicate that transcripts of novel, CMS-associated genes may be edited, but that, at least in this case, the degree of editing does not appear to be directly related to the male-sterile phenotype.

Molecular analysis of cytoplasmic male sterility in chives (Allium schoenoprasum L.)

The mitochondria of chive plants with normal N or male-sterile S cytoplasms have been examined by restriction fragment analysis and Southern hybridizations of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and in organello protein biosynthesis. Restriction fragment patterns of the mtDNA differed extensively between N-and S-cytoplasms. The percentage of fragments with different mobility varied between 44-48% depending on the restriction enzyme used. In contrast to mtDNA, the restriction fragment patterns of the chloropolast DNA from N- and S-cytoplasms were identical. The organization of the analyzed mitochondrial genes coxII, coxIII, nad1 and nad3 was different in N- and S-cytoplasms. Comparison of mitochondrial proteins analyzed by in organello translation revealed an 18-kDa protein present only in S-cytoplasm. The restorer gene X suppressed the synthesis of that protein in S-cytoplasm. Thus, the 18-kDa protein seems to be associated with the cytoplasmic male-sterile phenotype.

The expression of alternative oxidase and alternative respiratory capacity in cytoplasmic male sterile common bean

The alternative respiratory pathway is present in all plant species investigated to date. Yet, the role of the alternative pathway is not clear. Some evidence suggests an important role in pollen development. We undertook this study to investigate the expression of alternative oxidase, in comparison with expression of a component of cytochrome oxidase, during pollen formation in common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Expression was evaluated immunohistochemically. In addition, we compared both the alternative oxidase capacity in young seedling tissues and alternative oxidase expression in developing flower buds of isonuclear cytoplasmic male sterile and male fertile bean lines. We observed no evidence of an association between the abnormal pollen development of CMS bean and changes in alternative oxidase expression or capacity. We did observe a tissueand stage-specific pattern of expression of alternative oxidase, differing from the expression pattern of cytochrome oxidase subunit II, during anther development in normal bean lines. Although no association was evident between the cytoplasmic male sterility phenotype and differential expression of alternative oxidase, the regulated pattern of alternative oxidase expression in developing anthers does suggest that the alternative pathway may play a role in microgametogenesis and microsporogenesis.

Transposon tagging of a male sterility gene in Arabidopsis.

Transformation of the well-studied maize transposable elements into other plant species should enable transposon tagging methodology to be used for the isolation of interesting genes in the heterologous host. Here we describe the isolation of a transposon-tagged male sterile mutant in Arabidopsis thaliana using the maize Enhancer-Inhibitor transposable element system introduced into Arabidopsis. The mutant lacks pollen, preventing normal self-fertilization, a characteristic important for production of hybrid seed in many crop plants. We have identified an Enhancer-transposase-mediated Inhibitor element insertion responsible for the male sterile phenotype, and isolated the corresponding gene named MALE STERILITY 2. Critical evidence that the Inhibitor-element-containing gene is involved in the male sterile phenotype is provided by the DNA sequences of new excision-derived alleles from independent stable fertile and male sterile progeny of the original mutant.

Male-sterility induction in transgenic tobacco plants with an unedited atp9 mitochondrial gene from wheat.

Cytoplasmic male sterility in plants is associated with mitochondrial dysfunction. We have proposed that a nuclear-encoded chimeric peptide formed by mitochondrial sequences when imported into the mitochondria may impair organelle function and induce male sterility in plants. A model developed to test this hypothesis is reported here. Assuming that the editing process in higher plant mitochondria reflects a requirement for producing active proteins, we have used edited and unedited coding sequences of wheat ATP synthase subunit 9 (atp9) fused to the coding sequence of a yeast coxIV transit peptide. Transgenic plants containing unedited atp9 exhibited either fertile, semifertile, or male-sterile phenotypes; controls containing edited atp9 or only the selectable marker gave fertile plants. Pollen fertility ranged from 31% to 75% in fertile plants, 10% to 20% in semifertile plants, and < 2% in male-sterile plants. Genetic and molecular data showed that the chimeric plasmid containing the transgene is inherited as a Mendelian trait. The transgenic protein is imported into the mitochondria. The production and frequency of semifertile or male-sterile transgenic plants conform to the proposed hypothesis.

Modifications of Mitochondrial DNA Cause Changes in Floral Development in Homeotic-like Mutants of Tobacco.

To investigate the influence of mitochondrial genes on stamen development of higher plants, protoplasts from three different, male-sterile tobacco cultivars were fused. The fused cells were cultured individually into calli, from which plants were regenerated. Cybrid plants were obtained that exhibited flowers with recombined biparental male-sterile morphology and with novel male-sterile stamens that differed from any types from sexual or somatic hybridizations described previously. The male-sterile morphologies of these cybrids and their parents support the hypothesis that nuclear-mitochondrial interaction occurs at several stages in tobacco floral development and that several mitochondrial genes are necessary for normal stamen and corolla development. Analysis by restriction endonuclease digestion of mitochondrial DNA of male-sterile cybrids and their parents revealed that the mitochondrial DNA of male-sterile cybrids with parental floral morphology was unchanged when compared with parental mitochondrial DNA. Cybrids that were morphologically similar to one parent's male-sterile phenotype had mitochondrial DNA almost identical to that parent, whereas cybrids with recombined biparental or novel male-sterile phenotypes contained mitochondrial DNA different from both male-sterile parents and from each other. A set of mitochondrial DNA fragments could be correlated with split corollas, a feature found in several tobacco male-sterile cultivars. DNA gel blot analysis using a number of mitochondrial genes confirmed the conclusions based on ethidium bromide staining of mitochondrial DNA restriction digests.