"Soft" hydrogel-based macroporous scaffolds have been widely used in tissue engineering and drug delivery applications due to their hydrated interfaces and macroporous structures, but have drawbacks related to their weak mechanics and often weak adhesion to cells. In contrast, "hard" poly(caprolactone) (PCL) electrospun fibrous networks have desirable mechanical strength and ductility but offer minimal interfacial hydration and thus limited capacity for cell proliferation. Herein, we demonstrate the fabrication of interpenetrating nanofibrous networks based on coelectrospun PCL and poly(oligoethylene glycol methacrylate) (POEGMA) nanofibers that exhibit the mechanical benefits of PCL but the interfacial hydration benefits of hydrogels. The electrospinning process results in partially aligned but interpenetrating fiber network with minimal internal phase separation, leading to anisotropic but strong mechanical properties even in the hydrated state; apparent ultimate tensile strengths of the swollen scaffolds ranged from 429 ± 39 kPa in the direction of fiber alignment (longitudinal) to 86 ± 25 kPa perpendicular to fiber alignment (cross-longitudinal), typical of PCL-based scaffolds and enabling efficient suture retention in different directions. However, contact angle measurements indicate hydrogel-like interfacial properties due to the presence of the interpenetrating POEGMA network. C2C12 myoblast proliferation in the PCL-POEGMA scaffolds was 50% higher than that observed on PCL-only scaffolds, a result attributed to the presence of the more hydrophilic POEGMA interpenetrating nanofiber network. Overall, this method is demonstrated to represent a facile single-step strategy to fabricate strong macroporous but still interfacially hydrophilic scaffolds for tissue engineering applications.