Introduction: A particularly aggressive course of chronic sinusitis with nasal polyps is seen in patients with bronchial asthma and hypersensitivity to non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs). These patients often report exacerbation associated with consumption of foods reach in salicylates. Therefore, the authors analyzed the effect of a low-salicylate diet (LSD) on the course of chronic sinusitis with polyps in patients with NSAID-exacerbated respiratory disease (N-ERD) to answer the question: which patients would obtain the best therapeutic benefit? Methods: Adult patients with N-ERD were selected for dietary intervention with LSD. Patients were seen on two occasions: at an initial visit and a follow-up after 12 weeks of diet. At both visits, an evaluation was performed with total nasal symptom score (TNSS) and modified Lund-Kennedy (L-K) endoscopy score. Results: Forty patients (21 female, 52.5%, median and IQR of age 52; 43.5–61) used LSD for 12 weeks. Initial analysis of dietary intervention in the whole group revealed a significant decrease in TNSS and each symptom assessed separately, and the L-K score. The group was further divided into two subgroups based on the distance between NSAID intake and the beginning of symptoms: patients with immediate (n = 9; 22.5%) or non-immediate (n = 31; 77.5%) symptoms. The absolute change in nasal obstruction, itching, TNSS, and L-K scores were significantly higher in patients with immediate than with non-immediate symptoms. Conclusion: Results of the study indicate that patients with N-ERD and immediate symptoms may clinically benefit more from an LSD as an additional therapeutic option than patients with non-immediate symptoms.