Abstract Background Successful reconstruction of contracted sockets requires the implantation of an allograft or auto graft. Amniotic membrane and oral mucosa are still the most commonly used substitutes for reconstruction of large conjunctival defects in contracted eye sockets. Aim of the Work To conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis estimating the efficacy of amniotic membrane versus mucous membrane grafting in reconstruction of mild to moderate contracted eye sockets. Materials and Methods A comprehensive literature search was conducted across the following databases: Google scholar, PubMed, MEDS, web of science, EMBASE and Cochrane Library for published studies from the 1st of January 1990 to the 1st of December 2022. According to the inclusion and exclusion criteria, four studies (published between 2006 and 2018) were included in the presented meta-analysis; they included 72 patients with mild to moderate contracted eye sockets. Results This study demonstrated a higher average upper fornix (UF) depth among patients in amniotic membrane grafting (AMG) group as compared to patients in mucous membrane grafting (MMG) group with a difference of + 1.08 mm in favor of AMG group, the overall effect is border line significant P = 0.06. Also, a higher average lower fornix (LF) depth was found among patients in AMG group compared to patients in MMG group with a mean difference of + 0.99 mm in favor of AMG group, the overall effect is highly statistically significant P < 0.0001. The average socket volume was higher in AMG group in comparison to patients in MMG group with a mean difference of + 0.14 mm in favor of AMG group, and the overall effect is border line significant P = 0.05. A lower percentage of complications was found in AMG group (21.6%) as compared to MMG group (26%) with no significant difference statistically; P value >0.05. Conclusion The presented analytical study revealed that AMG achieves superior clinical results in comparison to the MMG in reconstruction of mild to moderate cases of contracted sockets regarding socket volume, and upper and lower forniceal widening. It also carries lower risk of complications.
Read full abstract