To characterize changes in opioid, gabapentin, and pregabalin utilization patterns and cost trends between 2008 and 2018 in a Louisiana workers' compensation claims population and explore the role of gabapentinoids as alternative analgesics during the opioid epidemic. Filled prescriptions for gabapentinoids and opioids were studied for 11 years in a cohort of 18,737 claimants. The proportion of claimants prescribed gabapentin increased 2-fold (8.9% to 18.9%) and average drug cost per claimant decreased 22% ($612 to $480). The proportion of claimants prescribed pregabalin decreased approximately 80% (11.7% to 2.5%) and average drug cost per claim increased 224% ($911 to $2952). Proportion of claimants prescribed opioids decreased 20% (80% to 64.2%) and average drug cost per claim decreased 46% ($691 to $371). Utilization increased substantially for gabapentin and decreased for pregabalin and opioids.