Structural epilepsies can manifest months or years after the occurrence of an initial epileptogenic insult, making them amenable for secondary prevention. However, development of preventive treatments has been challenged by a lack of biomarkers for identifying the subset of individuals with the highest risk of epilepsy after the epileptogenic insult. Four different rat models of epileptogenesis were investigated to identify differentially expressed circulating microRNA (miRNA) and isomiR profiles as biomarkers for epileptogenesis. Plasma samples were collected on day 2 and day 9 during the latency period from animals that did or did not develop epilepsy during long-term video-electroencephalographic monitoring. miRNAs and isomiRs were identified and measured in an unsupervised manner, using a genome-wide small RNA sequencing platform. Receiver operating characteristic analysis was performed to determine the performance of putative biomarkers. Two days after an epileptogenic insult, alterations in the levels of several plasma miRNAs and isomiRs predicted epileptogenesis in a model-specific manner. One miRNA, miR-3085, showed good sensitivity (but low specificity) as a prognostic biomarker for epileptogenesis in all four models (area under the curve = .729, sensitivity = 83%, specificity = 64%, p < .05). Identified plasma miRNAs and isomiRs are mostly etiology-specific rather than common prognostic biomarkers of epileptogenesis. These data imply that in preclinical and clinical studies, it may be necessary to identify specific biomarkers for different epilepsy etiologies. Importantly, circulating miRNAs like miR-3085 with high negative predictive value for epileptogenesis in different etiologies could be useful candidates for initial screening purposes of epileptogenesis risk.