Long-duration Gamma-ray Burst Host Research Articles

A Surprising Lack of Metallicity Evolution with Redshift in the Long Gamma-Ray Burst Host Galaxy Population

The number of long-duration gamma-ray burst (LGRB) host galaxies with measured metallicities and host masses has expanded sufficiently to investigate how the distributions of these properties change with redshift. Using the combined host galaxy metallicity sample from Graham & Fruchter and Krühler et al., we find a surprising lack of evolution in the LGRB metallicity distribution across different redshifts. In particular, the fraction of LGRB hosts with relatively high metallicity (12+log(O/H) ≥ 8.4) remains essentially constant out to z = 2.5. This result is at odds with the evolution in the mass–metallicity relation of typical galaxies, which become progressively more metal poor with increasing redshift. A similar result is found when converting the LGRB host galaxy mass distribution taken from the Swift GRB Host Galaxy Legacy Survey (SHOALS) sample to a corresponding metallicity distribution by applying a redshift-dependent mass–metallicity relation. The SHOALS sample is compiled using an unbiased selection function implying that the observed lack of evolution in the host galaxy high-metallicity distribution is not caused by selection effects. However, the LGRB host galaxy metallicities estimated from the stellar mass are typically a quarter dex higher at all redshifts than the metallicity we measure spectroscopically. This implies that using mass–metallicity relationships to estimate host metallicities will thus produce a substantial systematic bias.

The host galaxies and explosion sites of long-duration gamma ray bursts: Hubble Space Telescope near-infrared imaging

We present the results of a Hubble Space Telescope WFC3/F160W SNAPSHOT sur- vey of the host galaxies of 39 long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) at z < 3. We have non-detections of hosts at the locations of 4 bursts. Sufficient accuracy to as- trometrically align optical afterglow images and determine the location of the LGRB within its host was possible for 31/35 detected hosts. In agreement with other work, we find the luminosity distribution of LGRB hosts is significantly fainter than that of a star formation rate-weighted field galaxy sample over the same redshift range, indicating LGRBs are not unbiasedly tracing the star formation rate. Morphologi- cally, the sample of LGRB hosts are dominated by spiral-like or irregular galaxies. We find evidence for evolution of the population of LGRB hosts towards lower-luminosity, higher concentrated hosts at lower redshifts. Their half-light radii are consistent with other LGRB host samples where measurements were made on rest-frame UV obser- vations. In agreement with recent work, we find their 80 per cent enclosed flux radii distribution to be more extended than previously thought, making them intermedi- ate between core-collapse supernova (CCSN) and super-luminous supernova (SLSN) hosts. The galactocentric projected-offset distribution confirms LGRBs as centrally concentrated, much more so than CCSNe and similar to SLSNe. LGRBs are strongly biased towards the brighter regions in their host light distributions, regardless of their offset. We find a correlation between the luminosity of the LGRB explosion site and the intrinsic column density, N_H , towards the burst.

THE RELATIVE RATE OF LGRB FORMATION AS A FUNCTION OF METALLICITY

ABSTRACT There is now strong evidence that long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) are preferentially formed in low-metallicity environments. However, the magnitude of this effect and its functional dependence on metallicity have not been well characterized. In our previous paper, we compared the metallicity distribution of LGRB host galaxies to that of star-forming galaxies in the local universe. Here we build upon this work by in effect dividing one distribution by the other, and thus directly determine the relative rate of LGRB formation as a function of metallicity in the low-redshift universe. We find a dramatic cutoff in LGRB formation above a metallicity of in the KK04 scale, with LGRBs forming between 10 and 50 times more frequently per unit star formation below this cutoff than above. Furthermore, our data suggest that the rate of LGRB formation per unit star formation continues to fall above this break. We estimate that the LGRB formation rate per unit star formation may drop by as much as a factor of 100 between one-third solar and solar metallicity.

THE OFFSET AND HOST LIGHT DISTRIBUTIONS OF LONG GAMMA-RAY BURSTS: A NEW VIEW FROM HST OBSERVATIONS OF SWIFT BURSTS

ABSTRACT We present the results of an extensive Hubble Space Telescope imaging study of 105, mostly Swift, long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) spanning 0.03 &lsim; z &lsim; 9.4 ?> , which were localized using relative astrometry from ground- and space-based afterglow observations. We measure the distribution of LGRB offsets from their host centers and their relation to the underlying host light distribution. We find that the host-normalized offsets of LGRBs are more centrally concentrated than expected for an exponential disk profile, &lang; R / R h &rang; ?> = 0.63, and in particular they are more concentrated than the underlying surface brightness profiles of their host galaxies and more concentrated than supernovae. The fractional flux distribution, with a median of 0.78, indicates that LGRBs prefer some of the brightest locations in their host galaxies but are not as strongly correlated as previous studies indicated. Importantly, we find a clear correlation between offset and fractional flux, where bursts at offsets R / R h &lsim; 0.5 ?> exclusively occur at fractional fluxes &gsim; 0.6 ?> , while bursts at R / R h &gsim; 0.5 ?> have a uniform fractional flux distribution. This indicates that the spatial correlation of LGRBs with bright star-forming regions seen in the full sample is dominated by the contribution from bursts at small offset and that LGRBs in the outer parts of galaxies show no preference for unusually bright regions. We conclude that LGRBs strongly prefer the bright, inner regions of their hosts, indicating that the star formation taking place there is more favorable for LGRB progenitor production. This indicates that environmental factors beyond metallicity, such as binary interactions or IMF differences, may operate in the central regions of LGRB hosts.

A quiescent galaxy at the position of the long GRB 050219A

Long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) are produced by the collapse of very massive stars. Due to the short lifetime of their progenitors, LGRBs pinpoint star-forming galaxies. We present here a multi-band search for the host galaxy of the long dark GRB 050219A within the enhanced Swift/XRT error circle. We used spectroscopic observations acquired with VLT/X-shooter to determine the redshift and star-formation rate of the putative host galaxy. We compared the results with the optical/IR spectral energy distribution obtained with different facilities. Surprisingly, the host galaxy is a old and quiescent early-type galaxy at z = 0.211 characterised by an unprecedentedly low specific star-formation rate. It is the first LGRB host to be also an early-type post-starburst galaxy. This is further evidence that GRBs can explode in all kind of galaxies, with the only requirement being an episode of star-formation.

The Host Galaxies of Long-Duration Gamma-Ray Bursts

Long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) are the signatures of extraordinarily high-energy events occurring in our universe. Since their discovery, we have determined that these events are produced during the core-collapse deaths of rare young massive stars. The host galaxies of LGRBs are an excellent means of probing the environments and populations that produce their unusual progenitors. In addition, these same young stellar progenitors make LGRBs and their host galaxies valuable, potentially powerful tracers of star formation and metallicity at high redshifts. However, properly utilizing LGRBs as probes of the early universe requires a thorough understanding of their formation and the host environments that they sample. This review looks back at some of the recent work on LGRB host galaxies that has advanced our understanding of these events and their cosmological applications, and considers the many new questions that we are poised to pursue in the coming years.

ARE SUPERLUMINOUS SUPERNOVAE AND LONG GRBs THE PRODUCTS OF DYNAMICAL PROCESSES IN YOUNG DENSE STAR CLUSTERS?

Super Luminous supernovae (SLSN) occur almost exclusively in small galaxies (SMC/LMC-like or smaller), and the few SLSN observed in larger star-forming galaxies always occur close to the nuclei of their hosts. Another type of peculiar and highly energetic supernovae are the broad-line type Ic SNe (SN Ic-BL) that are associated with long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs). Also these have a strong preference for occurring in small (SMC/LMC-like or smaller) star-forming galaxies, and in these galaxies LGRBs always occur in the brightest spots. Studies of nearby star-forming galaxies that are similar to the hosts of LGRBs show that these brightest spots are giant HII regions produced by massive dense young star clusters with many hundreds of O- and Wolf-Rayet-type stars. Such dense young clusters are also found in abundance within a few hundred parsecs from the nucleus of larger galaxies like our own. We argue that the SLSN and the SN Ic-BL/LGRBs are exclusive products of two types of dynamical interactions in dense young star clusters. In our model the high angular momentum of the collapsing stellar cores required for the "engines" of a SN Ic-BL results from the post-main sequence mergers of dynamically produced cluster binaries with almost equal-mass components. The merger produces a critically rotating single helium star with sufficent angular momentum to produce a LGRB; the observed "metal aversio" of LGRBs is a natural consequence of the model. We argue that, on the other hand, SLSN could be the products of runaway multiple collisions in dense clusters, and we present (and quantize) plausible scenarios of how the different types of SLSNs can be produced.

THE METAL AVERSION OF LONG-DURATION GAMMA-RAY BURSTS

Recently, it has been suggested that the metallicity aversion of long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) is not intrinsic to their formation, but rather a consequence of the anti-correlation between star-formation and metallicity seen in the general galaxy population. To investigate this proposal, we compare the metallicity of the hosts of LGRBs, broad-lined Type Ic (Ic-bl) supernovae (SNe), and Type II SNe to each other and to the metallicity distribution of star-forming galaxies using the SDSS to represent galaxies in the local universe and the TKRS for galaxies at intermediate redshifts. The differing metallicity distributions of the LGRB hosts and the star formation in local galaxies forces us to conclude that the low-metallicity preference of LGRBs is not primarily driven by the anti-correlation between star-formation and metallicity, but rather must be overwhelmingly due to the astrophysics of the LGRBs themselves. Three quarters of our LGRB sample are found at metallicities below 12+log(O/H) < 8.6, while less than a tenth of local star-formation is at similarly low metallicities. However, our SN samples are statistically consistent with the metallicity distribution of the general galaxy population. Using the TKRS population of galaxies, we are able to exclude the possibility that the LGRB host metallicity aversion is caused by the decrease in galaxy metallicity with redshift. The presence of the strong metallicity difference between LGRBs and Ic-bl SNe largely eliminates the possibility that the observed LGRB metallicity bias is a byproduct of a difference in the initial mass functions of the galaxy populations. Rather, metallicity below half-solar must be a fundamental component of the evolutionary process that separates LGRBs from the vast majority of Ic-bl SNe and from the bulk of local star-formation.

On The Metal Aversion of LGRBs

Recently, it has been suggested that the metallicity aversion of long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) is not intrinsic to their formation, but rather a consequence of the anti-correlation between star-formation and metallicity seen in the general galaxy population. To investigate this proposal, we compare the metallicity of the hosts of LGRBs, broad-lined Type Ic (Ic-bl) supernovae (SNe), and Type II SNe to each other and to the metallicity distribution of star-forming galaxies using the SDSS to represent galaxies in the local universe and the TKRS for galaxies at intermediate redshifts. The differing metallicity distributions of the LGRB hosts and the star-formation in local galaxies forces us to conclude that the low-metallicity preference of LGRBs is not primarily driven by the anti-correlation between star-formation and metallicity, but rather must be overwhelmingly due to the astrophysics of the LGRBs themselves. Three quarters of our LGRB sample are found at metallicities below 12+log(O/H) < 8.6, while less than a tenth of local star-formation is at similarly low metallicities. However, our SN samples are statistically consistent with the metallicity distribution of the general galaxy population. Using the TKRS population of galaxies, we are able to exclude the possibility that the LGRB host metallicity aversion is caused by the decrease in galaxy metallicity with redshift. The presence of the strong metallicity difference between LGRBs and Ic-bl SNe largely eliminates the possibility that the observed LGRB metallicity bias is a byproduct of a difference in the initial mass functions of the galaxy populations. Rather, metallicity below half-solar must be a fundamental component of the evolutionary process that separates LGRBs from the vast majority of Ic-bl SNe and from the bulk of local star-formation.

Metallicity properties of the simulated host galaxies of long gamma-ray bursts and the fundamental metallicity relation

By combining high-resolution N-body simulations with semi-analytical models of galaxy formation, we study the implications of the collapsar model for long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) on the metallicity properties of the host galaxies. The cosmological model that we use reproduces the fundamental metallicity relation – the metallicity decreases with increasing star formation rate for galaxies of a given stellar mass. This was recently discovered for the Sloan Digital Sky Survey galaxies. We select host galaxies that house pockets of gas particles, that are young and that have different thresholds for their metallicities; these can be sites of LRGB events, according to the collapsar model. The simulated samples are compared with 18 observed LGRB hosts with the aim of discovering whether the metallicity is a primary parameter. We find that a threshold of metallicity for the LGRB progenitors, within the model galaxies, is not necessary to reproduce the observed distribution of host metallicities. The low metallicities of most LGRB hosts are consistent with the expectation that GRBs trace star formation. The star formation rate appears to be the primary parameter tracing the occurrence of a burst event. Finally, we show that only a few LGRBs are observed in massive, highly extinct galaxies, despite the fact that these galaxies are expected to produce many such events. We identify these missing events with the fraction of dark LGRBs.

THE HOST GALAXIES OF GAMMA-RAY BURSTS. II. A MASS-METALLICITY RELATION FOR LONG-DURATION GAMMA-RAY BURST HOST GALAXIES

We present a statistically robust mass-metallicity (M-Z) relation for long-duration gamma-ray burst (LGRB) host galaxies at z < 1. By comparing the LGRB host M-Z relation to samples representative of the general star-forming galaxy population, we conclude that LGRBs occur in host galaxies with lower metallicities than the general population, and that this trend extends to z ~ 1, with an average offset of -0.42 +/- 0.18 from the M-Z relation for star-forming galaxies. Our sample in this work includes new spectroscopic data for 6 LGRB host galaxies obtained at the Keck and Magellan telescopes, as well as 2 new host galaxies from the literature. Combined with data from our previous work, this yields a total sample of 6 LGRB host galaxies at z < 0.3 and 10 host galaxies at 0.3 < z < 1. We have determined a number of interstellar medium properties for our host galaxies using optical emission-line diagnostics, including metallicity, ionization parameter, young stellar population age, and star formation rate. Across our full sample of 16 LGRB hosts we find an average metallicity of log(O/H) + 12 = 8.4 +/- 0.3. Notably, we also measure a comparatively high metallicity of log(O/H) + 12 = 8.83 +/- 0.1 for the z = 0.296 host galaxy of GRB 050826. We also determine stellar masses (M*) for our LGRB host galaxy sample, finding a mean stellar mass of log(M*/Msun) = 9.25 (+0.19,-0.23).

THE HOST GALAXIES OF GAMMA-RAY BURSTS. I. INTERSTELLAR MEDIUM PROPERTIES OF TEN NEARBY LONG-DURATION GAMMA-RAY BURST HOSTS

We present the first observations from a large-scale survey of nearby (z < 1) long-duration gamma-ray burst (LGRB) host galaxies, which consist of eight rest-frame optical spectra obtained at Keck and Magellan. Along with two host galaxy observations from the literature, we use optical emission line diagnostics to determine metallicities, ionization parameters, young stellar population ages, and star formation rates. We compare the LGRB host environments to a variety of local and intermediate-redshift galaxy populations, as well as the newest grid of stellar population synthesis and photoionization models generated with the Starburst99/Mappings codes. With these comparisons we investigate whether the GRB host galaxies are consistent with the properties of the general galaxy population, and therefore whether they may be used as reliable tracers of star formation. We find that LGRB host galaxies generally have low-metallicity ISM environments out to z ~ 1. The ISM properties of our GRB hosts, including metallicity, ionization parameter, and young stellar population age, are significantly different from the general galaxy population, host galaxies of nearby broad-lined Type Ic supernovae, and nearby metal-poor galaxies.

THE HIGH-METALLICITY EXPLOSION ENVIRONMENT OF THE RELATIVISTIC SUPERNOVA 2009bb

We investigate the environment of the nearby (d ~ 40Mpc) broad-lined Type Ic supernova SN 2009bb. This event was observed to produce a relativistic outflow likely powered by a central accreting compact object. While such a phenomenon was previously observed only in long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs), no LGRB was detected in association with SN 2009bb. Using an optical spectrum of the SN 2009bb explosion site, we determine a variety of ISM properties for the host environment, including metallicity, young stellar population age, and star formation rate. We compare the SN explosion site properties to observations of LGRB and broad-lined SN Ic host environments on optical emission line ratio diagnostic diagrams. Based on these analyses, we find that the SN 2009bb explosion site has a very high metallicity of ~2x solar, in agreement with other broad-lined SN Ic host environments and at odds with the low-redshift LGRB host environments and recently proposed maximum metallicity limits for relativistic explosions. We consider the implications of these findings and the impact that SN 2009bb's unusual explosive properties and environment have on our understanding of the key physical ingredient that enables some SNe to produce a relativistic outflow.

Modeling the ISM Properties of Metal-Poor Galaxies and Gamma-Ray Burst Hosts

AbstractRecent research has suggested that long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs) occur preferentially in low-metallicity environments, but the exact nature of this correlation is currently a matter of intense debate. We use the newest generation of the Starburst99/Mappings code to generate an extensive suite of cutting-edge stellar population synthesis models, covering a wide range of physical parameters specifically tailored for modeling the ISM environments of metal-poor galaxies and LGRB host galaxies. With our models, we generate optical emission line diagnostics, which will allow us to examine the ISM properties and stellar populations of a variety of galaxy populations in unprecedented detail. While accurately modeling low-metallicity galaxies still poses a challenge to these models, future improvements to these grids will have profound consequences for our understanding of metal-poor galaxies, their ISM environments, and the nature of their role as the hosts of LGRBs.

Spatially Resolved Properties of the GRB 060505 Host: Implications for the Nature of the Progenitor1

GRB 060505 was the first well-observed nearby possible long-duration gamma-ray burst ( GRB) that had no associated supernova. Here we present spatially resolved spectra of the host galaxy of GRB 060505, an Sbc spiral, at redshift z = 0.0889. The GRB occurred inside a star-forming region in the northern spiral arm at 6.5 kpc from the center. From the position of the emission lines, we determine a maximum rotational velocity for the galaxy of v similar to 212 km s(-1), corresponding to a mass of 1.14 x 10(11) M (circle dot) within 11 kpc from the center. By fitting single-age spectral synthesis models to the stellar continuum, we derive a very young age for the GRB site, confirmed by photometric and H alpha line measurements, of around similar to 6 Myr, which corresponds to the lifetime of a 32M(circle dot) star. The metallicity derived from several emission-line measurements varies throughout the galaxy and is lowest at the GRB site. Using the Two Degree Field Galaxy Redshift Survey we can locate the host galaxy in its large-scale (similar to Mpc) environment. The galaxy lies in the foreground of a filamentary overdensity, extending southwest from the galaxy cluster Abell 3837 at z = 0.0896. The properties of the GRB site are similar to those found for other long-duration GRB host galaxies with high specific star formation rate and low metallicity, which is an indication that GRB 060505 originated from a young, massive star that died without making a supernova.

The host galaxies of long-duration gamma-ray bursts in a cosmological hierarchical scenario

We developed a Monte Carlo code to generate long-duration gamma-ray burst (LGRB) events within cosmological hydrodynamical simulations consistent with the concordance Λ cold dark matter model. As structure is assembled, LGRBs are generated in the substructure that formed galaxies today. We adopted the collapsar model so that LGRBs are produced by single, massive stars at the final stage of their evolution. We found that the observed properties of the LGRB host galaxies (HGs) are reproduced if LGRBs are also required to be generated by low-metallicity stars. The low-metallicity condition imposed on the progenitor stars of LGRBs selects a sample of HGs with mean gas abundances of 12 + log O/H ≈ 8.6. For z < 1 the simulated HGs of low-metallicity LGRB progenitors tend to be faint, slow rotators with high star formation efficiency, compared with the general galaxy population, in agreement with observations. At higher redshift, our results suggest that larger systems with high star formation activity could also contribute to the generation of LGRBs from low-metallicity progenitors since the fraction of low-metallicity gas available for star formation increases for all systems with look-back time. Under the hypothesis of our LGRB model, our results support the claim that LGRBs could be unbiased tracers of star formation at high redshifts.

The metallicity dependence of the long-duration gamma-ray burst rate from host galaxy luminosities

We investigate the difference between the host galaxy properties of core-collapse supernovae (CC SNe) and long-duration gamma-ray bursts (LGRBs), and quantify a possible metallicity dependence of the efficiency of producing LGRBs. We use a sample of 16 CC SNe and 16 LGRBs from Fruchter et al. which have similar redshift distributions to eliminate galaxy evolution biases. We make a forward prediction of their host galaxy luminosity distributions from the overall cosmic metallicity distribution of star formation. The latter is based on luminosity functions, star formation rates (SFRs) and luminosity-metallicity (L-Z) relations of galaxies. This appioach is supported by the finding that LGRB hosts follow the L-Z relations of star-forming galaxies. We then compare predictions for metallicity-dependent event efficiencies with the observed host data. We find that ultraviolet-based SFR estimates predict the host distribution of CC SNe perfectly well in a metallicity-independent form. In contrast, LGRB hosts are on average fainter by one magnitude, almost as faint as the Large Magellanic Cloud. Assuming this to be a metallicity effect, the present data are insufficient to discriminate between a sharp cut-off and a soft decrease in efficiency towards higher metallicity. For a sharp cut-off, however, we find a best value for the cut-off metallicity, as reflected in the oxygen abundance, 12 + log (O/H) lim ≃ 8.7 ± 0.3 at 95 per cent confidence including systematic uncertainties, in the calibration of Asplund, Grevesse & Sauval. This value is somewhat lower than the traditionally quoted value for the Sun, but is comparable to the revised solar oxygen abundance. LGRB models that require sharp metallicity cut-offs well below approximately one-half the revised solar metallicity appear to be effectively ruled out, as they would require fainter LGRB hosts than those that are observed. We also discuss the likely implications of the still ongoing metallicity 'calibration debate'.

The short-duration GRB 050724 host galaxy in the context of the long-duration GRB hosts

We report optical and near-infrared broad band observations of the short-duration GRB 050724 host galaxy, used to construct its spectral energy distribution (SED). Unlike the hosts of long-duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), which show younger stellar populations, the SED of the GRB 050724 host galaxy is optimally fitted with a synthetic elliptical galaxy template based on an evolved stellar population (age ~2.6 Gyr). The SED of the host is difficult to reproduce with non-evolving metallicity templates. In contrast, if the short GRB host galaxy metallicity enrichment is considered, the synthetic templates fit the observed SED satisfactorily. The internal host extinction is low (A_v \~< 0.4 mag) so it cannot explain the faintness of the afterglow. This short GRB host galaxy is more massive (~5x10^10 Mo) and luminous (~1.1 L*) than most of the long-duration GRB hosts. A statistical comparison based on the ages of short- and long-duration GRB host galaxies strongly suggests that short-duration GRB hosts contain, on average, older progenitors. These findings support a different origin for short- and long-duration GRBs.