Loan Loss Provisions Research Articles

Smoothing bank results: the moderating effect of gender in boards of directors and periods of crisis

The main objective of this study is to analyze whether European banks engage in the practice of income smoothing through the discretionary use of Loan Loss Provisions (LLP). At the same time, it aims to assess whether periods of crisis and the gender diversity of the board of directors of European banks have a moderating effect on the practice of smoothing bank results through the use of LLP. To achieve this objective, we used a panel of 378 listed banks from 39 European countries fron 2003 to 2021. To test the research hypotheses, a fixed effects model was used. In addition, to check for potential differences at regional level, the sample was broken down into four regions. Empirical evidence was obtained suggesting that the banks in the sample tend to use LLP to smooth their results. In addition, the empirical evidence suggests that periods of crisis and the gender diversity of the banks' board of directors have a moderating effect, in the negative sense, on the income smoothing practices of the banks in the sample. Breaking down the European sample into different regions, the results suggest that the practice of income smoothing through the use of LLP tends to be a reality for the listed banks in all four regions considered. In addition, and expectably, periods of crisis and the gender diversity of the board of directors tend to have a slightly different impact on the practice of income smoothing between the various regions. To the best of our knowledge, this study contributes to clarifying the literature on the impact of the 2007 financial crisis on the practice of bank income smoothing. In addition, it will be one of the first to comprehensively investigate the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and gender diversity on the practice of smoothing bank results through the use of LLP in the European context.

Determinant of Earnings Management Pre and Post PSAK 109 in Indonesian Banks

This study aims to determine the differences in Earnings Management and the effect of Institutional Ownership, Managerial Ownership, Audit Committee Competencies, Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR), and Nonperforming Loan (NPL) on Earnings Management proxied by Discretionary Loan Loss Provision (DLLP) pre and post-PSAK 109 implementation in Indonesian bank listed on the Indonesian Stock Exchange (IDX). This study uses Ordinary Least Square (OLS) regression and Wilcoxon signed-rank test to test the hypothesis. The study used the period pre and post implementation of PSAK 109. We traced each bank's financial report listed on the IDX from 2017 to 2020 to anticipate early implementation. Using purposive sampling, we obtained 40 pre-PSAK 109 and 40 post-PSAK 109 bank samples. This study found no difference in earnings management pre and post-PSAK 109. Institutional Ownership, Managerial Ownership, and Audit Committee Competencies do not affect Earnings Management pre and post-PSAK 109. NPL is positively related to Earnings Management pre and post-PSAK 109, and CAR is positively related to Earnings Management pre-PSAK 109 but has no effect on Earnings Management post-PSAK 109. This study provides additional information for standard setters and OJK regarding monitoring earnings management practices in banking pre and post-PSAK 109.

Loan loss provisions of European banks – Does macroprudential tightening matter?

In this paper, we study the relation between macroprudential policy and loan loss provisioning policy of European banks between 1996 and 2019. We analyse both the level of loan loss provisions (LLP) and their use in income smoothing by banks. Overall, we demonstrate that macroprudential tightening actions are associated with changes in LLP policy. Banks decrease their LLP when macroprudential policies are tightened and this result is particularly strong under Basel III. In parallel, we find that macroprudential tightening exacerbates income smoothing in the pre-Basel III period and diminishes it under Basel III. Links between LLP policy and macroprudential policy strongly depend on the category of tools that are being tightened. In particular, instruments relating to provisioning standards are associated with increased LLP, while lower LLP are observed when a tightening occurs in tools connected with taxes on financial institutions and activities.

An in-depth analysis of financial metrics and their interrelations in shaping the performance of commercial banks in Cambodia

This study aims to systematically identify and analyze key financial metrics that influence the performance of commercial banks in Cambodia. Utilizing 2023 data from the National Bank of Cambodia across 59 banks, the research adopts an explanatory framework based on cross- sectional data analysis. The findings reveal that Loan Growth (LG) exhibits no statistical significance in relation to Return on Equity (ROE), suggesting that increases in lending do not necessarily enhance bank profitability in the Cambodian context. Conversely, Non-Performing Loans (NPL) demonstrate a marginally significant positive relationship with ROE, indicating that effective management of these loans can still yield profitability. Additionally, the Loan to Deposit Ratio (LDR) shows a significant negative impact on ROE, suggesting that higher liquidity risks associated with elevated LDR levels may hinder profitability. The study further confirms that Market Share (MS), Loan Loss Provision (LLP), Cost to Income Ratio (CIR), Effective Tax Rate (ETR), and Net Interest Margin (NIM) significantly influence ROE. These results underscore the importance of effective risk management, operational efficiency, and strategic financial planning in enhancing bank profitability. Recommendations for Cambodian commercial banks include improving risk management practices, focusing on loan portfolio quality, optimizing LDR, implementing cost efficiency measures, and enhancing tax management strategies.

An integrated analysis of key financial metrics driving commercial bank performance in Cambodia

This study aims to systematically identify and analyze key financial metrics that influence the performance of commercial banks in Cambodia. Utilizing 2023 data from the National Bank of Cambodia across 59 banks, the research adopts an explanatory framework based on cross-sectional data analysis. Findings reveal a statistically significant positive correlation between Non-Performing Loans (NPLs) and Return on Assets (ROA), suggesting effective NPL risk management by Cambodian banks, contrary to traditional financial theory. Loan Growth (LG) does not significantly impact ROA, indicating that external factors like market conditions and loan quality are more critical. Furthermore, Market Share (MS) has no significant impact on ROA, suggesting that market share may not be a critical determinant of bank performance in Cambodia. A significant negative relationship is observed between the Loan to Deposit Ratio (LDR) and ROA, suggesting that higher LDRs expose banks to liquidity risks and reduced profitability. Both Loan Loss Provision (LLP) and Cost to Income Ratio (CIR) negatively affect ROA, while the Effective Tax Rate (ETR) shows a marginally positive relationship. The Net Interest Margin (NIM) significantly impacts ROA, underscoring the importance of managing interest-earning assets and liabilities. Recommendations include investing in advanced risk management frameworks, enhancing loan quality, maintaining a balanced LDR, utilizing technology for cost efficiency, focusing on effective tax planning, and optimizing NIM through competitive pricing. Future research should explore additional contextual factors that affect profitability dynamics in the Cambodian banking sector.. Keywords: Commercial Banks, Financial Metrics, Return on Assets (ROA), Non-Performing Loans (NPLs), Loan to Deposit Ratio (LDR), Cost to Income Ratio (CIR), Effective Tax Rate (ETR), Net Interest Margin (NIM), Loan Growth (LG), Market Share (MS).

Bank audit committee financial expertise and timely loan loss recognition

AbstractThis study investigates the effects of audit committee financial expertise on the timeliness of banks' loan loss provisions. I employ two regulatory shocks that mandated audit committee expertise—the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Improvement Act in 1991 (FDICIA) and a modified listing standard for NYSE and NASDAQ firms in 1999—as quasi‐exogenous settings to investigate the effects of audit committee financial expertise on the timeliness of loan loss provisioning. Using a difference‐in‐differences research design, I find that the timeliness of loan loss provisions increases with audit committee financial expertise both for the FDICIA treatment group, which had larger banks than the control group, and for the NYSE and NASDAQ exchange treatment group, which had smaller banks than the control group. Further, I find that the results are stronger for banks that have lower regulatory scrutiny, are audited by Big 4 auditors, and do not have staggered boards. Finally, I find that audit committee financial expertise decreases discretionary loan loss provisions and financial restatements. Overall, these findings suggest the importance of audit committee financial expertise in loan‐related matters, which is particularly relevant in the context of the recent Current Expected Credit Losses implementation.

How Does Macroprudential Policy Impact Bank Risk-Taking and Profitability: Evidence from Indian Commercial Banks

ABSTRACT This study analyses the impact of macroprudential policy (MaPP) on Indian banks’ risk-taking and profitability. Using commercial bank data from 2004–05 to 2019–20, the risk-taking is measured by Z-score, and loan loss provision and profitability by return on average assets and return on average equity, respectively. Employing the panel system-GMM technique, the study finds. (1) MaPP mitigates bank risk-taking by enhancing the bank’s stability and reducing the procyclicality of loan loss provisions. (2) MaPP is found to have a positive impact on bank profitability. (3) MaPP is found to be more effective in the context of private and foreign banks as compared to nationalized banks. (4) Within the macroprudential toolkit, reserve requirements and risk-weights are found to have a positive impact on risk-taking and profitability, whereas provisioning requirements are found to have a negative impact.

Loan delinquency in private sector banks in Kerala

The Indian Banking Sector faces significant difficulties in recovering debt. The banker must understand the underlying causes of loan delinquency to address the problem efficiently. A delinquent loan becomes a NPL (Non Performing Loan) when the borrower failed to repay the loan for a period of 90 days or more. Delinquency is the sign of increased credit risk, warnings of willful default, poor asset quality management and operational inefficiency. It may help to predict the loan loss provision for the sub standard, doubtful and loss assets. This article explores the various causes of loan delinquencies of private-sector banks operating in Kerala. The analysis revealed that the retails and SMEs registered high level of loan delinquency. A significant difference was found between the old and new generation private sector banks for the Poor loan portfolio management, inadequate collateral, inadequate monitoring and follow-up. From the mean score it is evident that the NPA management in new generation private sector banks is appreciable when compared to old generation private sector banks.

Deposit insurance and credit union earnings opacity

This study examines the impact of deposit insurance coverage on credit union earnings opacity. For identification, we employ the provisions outlined in Section 136 of the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act, which raised the upper limit of deposit insurance coverage from $100,000 to $250,000. Using variation in insured deposits brought about by the differential impact of the change to deposit insurance arrangements and a difference-in-differences approach, we find that credit unions experiencing a substantial rise in insured deposits tend to exercise more discretion over loan loss provisions, leading to an increase in earnings opacity. This is most evident for small and medium sized credit unions.

The Effect of the Current Expected Credit Loss Approach on Banks’ Lending during Stress Periods: Evidence from the COVID-19 Recession

ABSTRACT In the wake of the financial crisis, policymakers expressed the concern that the incurred loss model delays loan loss recognition to economic stress periods and thereby exacerbates banks’ lending contraction during these periods. Addressing this concern, the FASB issued Accounting Standards Update 2016-13, which requires large public banks to accrue for loan losses using the current expected credit loss (CECL) approach starting in January 2020. We hypothesize and find that banks that adopted CECL prior to the COVID-19 pandemic increased loan loss provisions and reduced loan growth during the accompanying recession more than other banks. The lending contraction is stronger for adopting banks with low regulatory capital and low loan impairment and is primarily driven by commercial loans. Lastly, we find that counties in which CECL-adopting banks have higher market share experience larger increases in unemployment rates during the recession and slower subsequent recoveries. Data Availability: Data are available from the public sources cited in the text. JEL Classifications: E32; G21; G28; M41; M48.

IMPACT OF CREDIT RISK MANAGEMENT ON PROFITABILITY OF COMMERCIAL BANKS: A CASE STUDY IN VIETNAM

The main purpose of this study is to examine the impact of credit risk management on profitability of commercial banks in Vietnam. While the existing literature emphasizes the necessity for a more in-depth study and additional empirical evidence to elucidate intricate relationships between market dynamics and credit risk, particularly in the context of commercial banks in Southeast Asia, there remains a gap in comprehensive studies, with a specific focus on Vietnam. The secondary data was collected from 20 commercial banks from the country for the period of 11 years, from 2012 to 2022. The study used non-performing loans ratio (NPLR), capital adequacy ratio (CAR) as well as loan-loss provision ratio (LLPR) as proxies of credit risk while the financial performance is measured by return on equity (ROE). Moreover, the bank's characteristics, such as its size (SIZE), the macroeconomic inflation rate (INF), and a dummy variable that looks at how ownership type (OWN) affects the bank's profitability are all applied to quantify the independent variables. The model does not exhibit the multicollinearity issue, according to the mean Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) data. The regression results reveal that SIZE, CAR and INF variables have a significant positive effect on ROE, while the NPLR variable has an opposite significant effect on ROE. Nevertheless, there is no connection between the ROE-measured financial performance of commercial banks and the OWN or LLPR variables. This offers further valuable insights to bankers and policy makers in credit risk management of commercial banks in Vietnam to enhance the stability of the Vietnamese banking system.

Effect of loan-loss provisioning on financial performance of deposit taking SACCOs in Kirinyaga County, Kenya

Savings and Credit Co-operatives in Kenya are required to adhere to regulations set by the SACCOs Regulation Authority. Among the regulations is the requirement that the management has to present a myriad of reports including; the Capital Adequacy Return report, Liquidity Statement report, Statement of Financial Position and Statement of Deposit Return. The Return on Investments report compares land, building, and financial assets to SACCO's total assets and its core capital. Despite the existence of prudential guidelines, their influence on the financial performance of deposit-taking SACCOs in Kenya remains contentious with some claiming regulatory compliance in the form of SASRA prudential guidelines has a positive influence while others argue that SASRA regulation has insignificant influence on the financial performance of deposit taking SACCOs. This study seeks to determine the effect of loan-loss provisioning on the financial performance of Deposit-taking SACCOs in Kirinyaga County, Kenya. The study adopted a cross-section descriptive research design. The study population was 10 deposit-taking SACCOs in Kirinyaga County over the period 2017-2022 relying on secondary data. Data analysis involved descriptive and inferential statistics. From the inferential results, the study concluded that loan-loss provisioning positively and significantly affected the financial performance of the deposit-taking SACCOs in Kirinyaga County. The study recommended that the deposit-taking SACCOs in Kirinyaga County ought to strive to be capital-adequate as well as manage their loans efficiently. Being capital-adequate ensures that the SACCOs can expand their operations and hence be sustainable, competitive, and finally profitable. Managing its loans through periodic classification of the loans and having room for loan loss provision ensures the sustainability of the SACCOs.

Impact of IFRS 9 Implementation and Audit Committee Effectiveness on Earnings Management in The Indonesian Banking Sector

Background- The implementation of IFRS 9, utilizing the Expected Credit Loss (ECL) method, along with effective oversight from the audit committee, can be a relevant strategy to anticipate earnings management practices. Purpose- to examine the impact of IFRS 9 implementation and audit committee supervision on restricting managerial discretion in loan loss provisions. Design/methodology/approach- This study will use a quantitative analysis method using secondary data from an annual report. The sampling method used in this study was purposive sampling, which resulted in selecting 42 banks listed on the Indonesian Stock Exchange from 2017 to 2022. This study uses the data panel analysis method with the STATA analysis tool. Findings- This research found that the implementation of IFRS 9 and audit committees had an impact on increasing bank managerial discretion. This explains that the implementation of IFRS 9 and the audit committee have not been able to limit managerial discretion, which may be due to the influence of unstable economic conditions due to the pandemic and countercyclical policy to anticipate the impact of the pandemic. Research limitation- The potential impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on research outcomes related to managerial discretion and the effectiveness of audit committee oversight. Originality/Value- To enhance the literature related to the trends of the impact of PSAK implementation in Indonesia on earnings management more comprehensively by extending the research period and contributing to the literature by employing multiple criteria to identify the quality of oversight provided by the audit committee.

Analisis Faktor Pertumbuhan Kredit Bank Komersil Di Indonesia

This research analyzes the influence of Non-Performing Loans, Loan to Deposit Ratio, Loan Loss Provision, Equity Asset Ratio, Liquidity Ratio, Gross Domestic Product, Inflation, Interest Rate, Bank Capital, and Bank Size on Loan Growth Rate in banking companies listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange (BEI) from 2019 to 2023. The method used is regression multiple panels with secondary data obtained through purposive sampling, covering 205 financial reports from 41 companies. The results of the analysis using Eviews 12 show that Non-Performing Loans, Loan to Deposit Ratio, Loan Loss Provision, Equity Asset Ratio, Liquidity Ratio, Gross Domestic Product, Inflation, Interest Rate, Bank Capital, and Bank Size have a significant influence on Loan Growth Rate. This research provides important insights into the factors influencing loan growth in the Indonesian banking sector, as well as implications for risk management and banking policy.

The influence of diversifying income sources on the financial performance: An empirical study on Vietnamese commercial banks

This research investigates the impact of income diversification on the financial outcomes of commercial banks in Vietnam. The analysis utilizes financial reports from 26 Vietnamese commercial banks spanning from 2012 to 2022. A variety of analytical methods, including the Pooled Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) model, Fixed Effects Model (FEM), Random Effects Model (REM), and System Generalized Method of Moments (SGMM) models, were employed to evaluate the data. The findings suggest that diversifying income streams enhances the financial health of commercial banks. The case of Vietnamese banks indicates that bank growth and an increase in borrowing activities positively influence financial results. Additionally, it is recommended for banks to manage deposit ratios of customers and lower the ratio of loan loss provisions to optimize financial performance.

The role of loan loss provisions in income inequality: Evidence from a sample of banking institutions

This study explores the empirical link between income inequality and banks’ Loan Loss Provisions (LLPs) through a sample of banking institutions from 132 countries, applying a panel regression methodology. The evidence reveals that higher LLPs have a positive impact on income inequality, and the findings remain valid across various model specifications and income inequality measures. The results also hold against various robustness tests, such as different bank sizes, developed vs. emerging countries, the impact of the 2008 global financial crisis, and the controlling for risk. The implications are relevant for stakeholders, including regulators that endeavor to protect banking systems against expected and unexpected losses via LLPs. Specifically, since credit decisions have substantial effects on income inequality, regulators should mitigate the accumulation of LLPs, allowing more funds to be available for other banking system activities and functions.

Loan loss provisions and the deposit rates yield curve at US banks

Loan loss provisions and the deposit rates yield curve at US banks

IFRS-9, expected loan loss provisioning and bank liquidity creation: early evidence

PurposeThe relevance of both microeconomic and macroeconomic factors in driving banks’ liquidity creation within a cross-country setup has been addressed in prior research. The purpose of this study is to explore whether and how the recent International Financial Reporting Standards-9 (IFRS-9) accounting standards affect this relationship.Design/methodology/approachThe author exploits the staggered implementation of IFRS-9 across countries and use a difference-in-differences framework to tease out the causal impact.FindingsThe findings indicate that the enactment of IFRS-9 leads to an increase in asset-side liquidity creation and a decline of broadly similar magnitude in liability-side liquidity creation. As a result, total liquidity creation remains unaltered. Disaggregatedly, the evidence shows that all the key channels on the asset and liability side are instrumental in explaining this behaviour.Originality/valueThe author views this as one of the early studies in a cross-country setup to explore the interlinkage between IFRS-9 and bank liquidity creation. Since liquidity creation measure provides a comprehensive metric of liquidity supplied by banks to the market, the study seeks to inform the policy debate on the role of these recently instituted accounting standards on bank liquidity behaviour.

Relationship between Financial Risk Exposure and Non-Performing Loans of Commercial Banks in Kenya

Currently, there is a financial crisis affecting commercial banks in Kenya occasioned by high levels of loan loss provision as a result of Non-Performing Loans. The past decade has seen the collapse of major banks like Chase Bank among others. This trend on Non-Performing Loans of the institutions requires urgent measures to reverse failure to which the entire sector is likely to collapse, and customers would lose a significant amount of their deposits. This study sought to investigate the effect of credit risk and liquidity risk on non-performing loans (NPLs) of commercial banks in Kenya and appraise the moderating effect of firm age on the relationship between financial risk exposure on non-performing loans of commercial banks in Kenya. The study was underpinned by liquidity preference theory. The examination adopted a positivist paradigm guided by explanatory research design. The study targeted 40 commercial banks as the unit of analysis while branch managers, operations and risk managers were the units of observation drawn from the banks adding to 120 respondents and census was used. The study collected both primary data using structured questionnaire on the independent variable and secondary data from publications by Central Bank of Kenya (CBK) and respective banks and the same was analyzed through the statistical package for social sciences (SPSS) version 26 in a descriptive and inferential manner. The study established that credit risk (p<0.05) and liquidity risk (p<0.05) were all found to have significant effect on NPLs of commercial banks in Kenya and significantly moderated by their sizes. It was concluded that financial risk exposure has significant effect on NPLs of commercial banks in Kenya. It was recommended that finance manages working in commercial banks in Kenya to balance the investment in short term and long-term assets to maintain operational liquidity levels for better management of liquidity risks. Credit managers working for commercial banks in Kenya need to review the existing credit risk management efforts and mechanisms to minimize exposure to NPLs.

The bright side of common ownership: Evidence from bank transparency

Over 74% of US banks share common ownership with other banks. Our analysis of a large sample of US banks reveals that those with greater common ownership demonstrate heightened transparency. This manifests as reduced discretion in loan loss provisions, improved financial statement readability, and enhanced comparability. We pinpoint three underlying mechanisms: decreased private information gathering, increased stock liquidity, and diminished managerial incentives for opacity. Furthermore, these commonly owned banks exhibit lower crash risk due to their improved transparency. Our findings hold after using various proxies and two endogeneity-reduction methods: a difference-in-differences analysis based on the 2009 Blackrock–Barclays Global Investors merger and an instrumental variable approach using Russell 2000 index inclusions. Overall, our study underscores the positive impact of common ownership in the banking sector.