Liquid Organelles Research Articles

Rabies virus phosphoprotein exhibits thermoresponsive phase separation with a lower critical solution temperature.

Rabies virus (RABV) generates membrane-less liquid organelles (Negri bodies) in the cytoplasm of its host cell, where genome transcription and replication and nucleocapsid assembly take place, but the mechanisms of their assembly and maturation remain to be explained. An essential component of the viral RNA synthesizing machine, the phosphoprotein (P), acts as a scaffold protein for the assembly of these condensates. This intrinsically disordered protein forms star-shaped dimers with N-terminal negatively charged flexible arms and C-terminal globular domains exhibiting a large dipole moment. Our study shows that in vitro self-association of RABV P drives a complex thermoresponsive phase separation with a lower critical solution temperature. Protein dimers assemble already below the saturation concentration, and condensation is driven by attractive conformation-specific interactions leading to reentrant liquid phase separation over a narrow range of salt concentration. We propose a minimal molecular model in which P can adopt three limit conformational states and the disordered N-terminal arms control the interactions between giant dipoles that is consistent with our observations.

Liquid-liquid phase inclusion bodies in acute and persistent parainfluenaza virus type 5 infections.

Cytoplasmic inclusion bodies (IBs) are a common feature of single-stranded, non-segmented, negative-strand RNA virus (Mononegavirales) infections and are thought to be regions of active virus transcription and replication. Here we followed the dynamics of IB formation and maintenance in cells infected with persistent and lytic/acute variants of the paramyxovirus, parainfluenza virus type 5 (PIV5). We show that there is a rapid increase in the number of small inclusions bodies up until approximately 12 h post-infection. Thereafter the number of inclusion bodies decreases but they increase in size, presumably due to the fusion of these liquid organelles that can be disrupted by osmotically shocking cells. No obvious differences were observed at these times between inclusion body formation in cells infected with lytic/acute and persistent viruses. IBs are also readily detected in cells persistently infected with PIV5, including in cells in which there is little or no ongoing virus transcription or replication. In situ hybridization shows that genomic RNA is primarily located in IBs, whilst viral mRNA is more diffusely distributed throughout the cytoplasm. Some, but not all, IBs show incorporation of 5-ethynyl-uridine (5EU), which is integrated into newly synthesized RNA, at early times post-infection. These results strongly suggest that, although genomic RNA is present in all IBs, IBs are not continuously active sites of virus transcription and replication. Disruption of IBs by osmotically shocking persistently infected cells does not increase virus protein synthesis, suggesting that in persistently infected cells most of the virus genomes are in a repressed state. The role of IBs in PIV5 replication and the establishment and maintenance of persistence is discussed.

3D Puzzle at the Nanoscale-How do RNA Viruses Self-Assemble their Capsids into Perfectly Ordered Structures.

The phenomenon of RNA virus self-organization, first observed in the mid-20th century in tobacco mosaic virus, is the subject of extensive research. Efforts to comprehend this process intensify due to its potential for producing vaccines or antiviral compounds as well as nanocarriers and nanotemplates. However, direct observation of the self-assembly is hindered by its prevalence within infected host cells. One of the approaches involves in vitro and in silico research using model viruses featuring a ssRNA(+) genome enclosed within a capsid made up of a single type protein. While various pathways are proposed based on these studies, their relevance in vivo remains uncertain. On the other hand, the development of advanced microscopic methods provide insights into the events within living cells, where following viral infection, specialized compartments form to facilitate the creation of nascent virions. Intriguingly, a growing body of evidence indicates that the primary function of packaging signals in viral RNA is to effectively initiate the virion self-assembly. This is in contrast to earlier opinions suggesting a role in marking RNA for encapsidation. Another noteworthy observation is that many viruses undergo self-assembly within membraneless liquid organelles, which are specifically induced by viral proteins.

RNA Helicase Vasa as a Multifunctional Conservative Regulator of Gametogenesis in Eukaryotes.

Being a conservative marker of germ cells across metazoan species, DEAD box RNA helicase Vasa (DDX4) remains the subject of worldwide investigations thanks to its multiple functional manifestations. Vasa takes part in the preformation of primordial germ cells in a group of organisms and contributes to the maintenance of germline stem cells. Vasa is an essential player in the piRNA-mediated silencing of harmful genomic elements and in the translational regulation of selected mRNAs. Vasa is the top hierarchical protein of germ granules, liquid droplet organelles that compartmentalize RNA processing factors. Here, we survey current advances and problems in the understanding of the multifaceted functions of Vasa proteins in the gametogenesis of different eukaryotic organisms, from nematodes to humans.

Ebola virus inclusion bodies are liquid organelles whose formation is facilitated by nucleoprotein oligomerization

ABSTRACT Viral RNA synthesis of several non-segmented, negative-sense RNA viruses (NNSVs) takes place in inclusion bodies (IBs) that show properties of liquid organelles, which are formed by liquid–liquid phase separation of scaffold proteins. It is believed that this is driven by intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) and/or multiple copies of interaction domains, which for NNSVs are usually located in their nucleo – and phosphoproteins. In contrast to other NNSVs, the Ebola virus (EBOV) nucleoprotein NP alone is sufficient to form IBs without the need for a phosphoprotein, and to facilitate the recruitment of other viral proteins into these structures. While it has been proposed that also EBOV IBs are liquid organelles, this has so far not been formally demonstrated. Here we used a combination of live cell microscopy, fluorescence recovery after photobleaching assays, and mutagenesis approaches together with reverse genetics-based generation of recombinant viruses to study the formation of EBOV IBs. Our results demonstrate that EBOV IBs are indeed liquid organelles, and that oligomerization but not IDRs of the EBOV nucleoprotein plays a key role in their formation. Additionally, VP35 (often considered the phosphoprotein-equivalent of EBOV) is not essential for IB formation, but alters their liquid behaviour. These findings define the molecular mechanism for the formation of EBOV IBs, which play a central role in the life cycle of this deadly virus.

Rabies virus P protein binds to TBK1 and interferes with the formation of innate immunity-related liquid condensates

Viruses must overcome the interferon-mediated antiviral response to replicate and propagate into their host. Rabies virus (RABV) phosphoprotein P is known to inhibit interferon induction. Here, using a global mass spectrometry approach, we show that RABV P binds to TBK1, a kinase located at the crossroads of many interferon induction pathways, resulting in innate immunity inhibition. Mutations of TBK1 phosphorylation sites abolish P binding. Importantly, we demonstrate that upon RABV infection or detection of dsRNA by innate immunity sensors, TBK1 and its adaptor proteins NAP1 and SINTBAD form dynamic cytoplasmic condensates that have liquid properties. These condensates can form larger aggregates having ring-like structures in which NAP1 and TBK1 exhibit locally restricted movement. P binding to TBK1 interferes with the formation of these structures. This work demonstrates that proteins of the signaling pathway leading to interferon induction transiently form liquid organelles that can be targeted by viruses.

New Perspectives on the Biogenesis of Viral Inclusion Bodies in Negative-Sense RNA Virus Infections.

Infections by negative strand RNA viruses (NSVs) induce the formation of viral inclusion bodies (IBs) in the host cell that segregate viral as well as cellular proteins to enable efficient viral replication. The induction of those membrane-less viral compartments leads inevitably to structural remodeling of the cellular architecture. Recent studies suggested that viral IBs have properties of biomolecular condensates (or liquid organelles), as have previously been shown for other membrane-less cellular compartments like stress granules or P-bodies. Biomolecular condensates are highly dynamic structures formed by liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS). Key drivers for LLPS in cells are multivalent protein:protein and protein:RNA interactions leading to specialized areas in the cell that recruit molecules with similar properties, while other non-similar molecules are excluded. These typical features of cellular biomolecular condensates are also a common characteristic in the biogenesis of viral inclusion bodies. Viral IBs are predominantly induced by the expression of the viral nucleoprotein (N, NP) and phosphoprotein (P); both are characterized by a special protein architecture containing multiple disordered regions and RNA-binding domains that contribute to different protein functions. P keeps N soluble after expression to allow a concerted binding of N to the viral RNA. This results in the encapsidation of the viral genome by N, while P acts additionally as a cofactor for the viral polymerase, enabling viral transcription and replication. Here, we will review the formation and function of those viral inclusion bodies upon infection with NSVs with respect to their nature as biomolecular condensates.

Measles Virus Forms Inclusion Bodies with Properties of Liquid Organelles.

Nonsegmented negative-strand RNA viruses, including measles virus (MeV), a member of the Paramyxoviridae family, are assumed to replicate in cytoplasmic inclusion bodies. These cytoplasmic viral factories are not membrane bound, and they serve to concentrate the viral RNA replication machinery. Although inclusion bodies are a prominent feature in MeV-infected cells, their biogenesis and regulation are not well understood. Here, we show that infection with MeV triggers inclusion body formation via liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS), a process underlying the formation of membraneless organelles. We find that the viral nucleoprotein (N) and phosphoprotein (P) are sufficient to trigger MeV phase separation, with the C-terminal domains of the viral N and P proteins playing a critical role in the phase transition. We provide evidence suggesting that the phosphorylation of P and dynein-mediated transport facilitate the growth of these organelles, implying that they may have key regulatory roles in the biophysical assembly process. In addition, our findings support the notion that these inclusions change from liquid to gel-like structures as a function of time after infection, leaving open the intriguing possibility that the dynamics of these organelles can be tuned during infection to optimally suit the changing needs during the viral replication cycle. Our study provides novel insight into the process of formation of viral inclusion factories, and taken together with earlier studies, suggests that Mononegavirales have broadly evolved to utilize LLPS as a common strategy to assemble cytoplasmic replication factories in infected cells.IMPORTANCE Measles virus remains a pathogen of significant global concern. Despite an effective vaccine, outbreaks continue to occur, and globally ∼100,000 measles-related deaths are seen annually. Understanding the molecular basis of virus-host interactions that impact the efficiency of virus replication is essential for the further development of prophylactic and therapeutic strategies. Measles virus replication occurs in the cytoplasm in association with discrete bodies, though little is known of the nature of the inclusion body structures. We recently established that the cellular protein WD repeat-containing protein 5 (WDR5) enhances MeV growth and is enriched in cytoplasmic viral inclusion bodies that include viral proteins responsible for RNA replication. Here, we show that MeV N and P proteins are sufficient to trigger the formation of WDR5-containing inclusion bodies, that these structures display properties characteristic of phase-separated liquid organelles, and that P phosphorylation together with the host dynein motor affect the efficiency of the liquid-liquid phase separation process.

Influenza A virus ribonucleoproteins form liquid organelles at endoplasmic reticulum exit sites

Influenza A virus has an eight-partite RNA genome that during viral assembly forms a complex containing one copy of each RNA. Genome assembly is a selective process driven by RNA-RNA interactions and is hypothesized to lead to discrete punctate structures scattered through the cytosol. Here, we show that contrary to the accepted view, formation of these structures precedes RNA-RNA interactions among distinct viral ribonucleoproteins (vRNPs), as they assemble in cells expressing only one vRNP type. We demonstrate that these viral inclusions display characteristics of liquid organelles, segregating from the cytosol without a delimitating membrane, dynamically exchanging material and adapting fast to environmental changes. We provide evidence that viral inclusions develop close to endoplasmic reticulum (ER) exit sites, depend on continuous ER-Golgi vesicular cycling and do not promote escape to interferon response. We propose that viral inclusions segregate vRNPs from the cytosol and facilitate selected RNA-RNA interactions in a liquid environment.

Characterization of the phosphoprotein of human metapneumovirus and its role in formation of viral liquid organelles

Human metapneumovirus (HMPV) is a recently identified RNA virus that frequently causes lower respiratory tract infections in infants, the elderly, and the immunocompromised, yet it has no FDA approved antivirals or vaccines. Understanding how HMPV replicates could help identify targets for development of new therapeutics. A key aspect of the viral replication cycle of HMPV is the formation of membrane‐less, liquid‐like replication and transcription centers termed inclusion bodies (IBs). A major component of IBs is the tetrameric HMPV phosphoprotein (P), which contains N and C terminal domains that lack defined secondary structures, called intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs). IDRs are thought to be involved in formation of liquid organelles through a process called liquid‐liquid phase separation (LLPS). However, the role P plays in IB formation and function is not understood. Our overall hypothesis is that the IDRs and post‐translational modifications of the phosphoprotein allow it to facilitate LLPS for IB formation. Western blots of cell lysate show two distinct bands for HMPV P, both of which contain phosphorylated protein and are detectable with either C terminal or N terminal HA tags. However, a C terminal HA tag disrupts IBs when co‐transfected with N, suggesting interactions through the C terminal domain are critical for IB formation. Purified P can form liquid‐like droplets without the presence of N, indicating it plays an important role in LLPS. Future studies will identify which domains of P are critical for LLPS and how phosphorylation and other modifications of P contribute to IB formation.Support or Funding InformationWe gratefully acknowledge the NIH/NIAID grant R01 AI3200001873 for supporting our research.This abstract is from the Experimental Biology 2019 Meeting. There is no full text article associated with this abstract published in The FASEB Journal.

Structure and Function of Negri Bodies.

Replication and assembly of many viruses occur in viral factories which are specialized intracellular compartments formed during viral infection. For rabies virus, those viral factories are called Negri bodies (NBs). NBs are cytoplasmic inclusion bodies in which viral RNAs (mRNAs as well as genomic and antigenomic RNAs) are synthesized. NBs are spherical, they can fuse together, and can reversibly deform when encountering a physical barrier. All these characteristics are similar to those of eukaryotic membrane-less liquid organelles which contribute to the compartmentalization of the cell interior. Indeed, the liquid nature of NBs has been confirmed by FRAP experiments. The co-expression of rabies virus nucleoprotein N and phosphoprotein P is sufficient to induce the formation of cytoplasmic inclusions recapitulating NBs properties. Remarkably, P and N have features similar to those of cellular proteins involved in liquid organelles formation: N is an RNA-binding protein and P contains intrinsically disordered domains. An overview of the literature indicates that formation of liquid viral factories by phase separation is probably common among Mononegavirales. This allows specific recruitment and concentration of viral proteins. Finally, as virus-associated molecular patterns recognized by cellular sensors of RNA virus replication are probably essentially present in the viral factory, there should be a subtle interplay (which remains to be characterized) between those liquid structures and the cellular proteins which trigger the innate immune response.

Polyhedra, spindles, phage nucleus and pyramids: Structural biology of viral superstructures.

Viral infection causes comprehensive rearrangements of the cell that reflect as much host defense mechanisms as virus-induced structures assembled to facilitate infection. Regardless of their pro- or antiviral role, large intracellular structures are readily detectable by microscopy and often provide a signature characteristic of a specific viral infection. The structural features and localization of these assemblies have thus been commonly used for the diagnostic and classification of viruses since the early days of virology. More recently, characterization of viral superstructures using molecular and structural approaches have revealed very diverse organizations and roles, ranging from dynamic viral factories behaving like liquid organelles to ultra-stable crystals embedding and protecting virions. This chapter reviews the structures, functions and biotechnological applications of virus-induced superstructures with a focus on assemblies that have a regular organization, for which detailed structural descriptions are available. Examples span viruses infecting all domains of life including the assembly of virions into crystalline arrays in eukaryotic and bacterial viruses, nucleus-like compartments involved in the replication of large bacteriophages, and pyramid-like structures mediating the egress of archaeal viruses. Among these superstructures, high-resolution structures are available for crystalline objects produced by insect viruses: viral polyhedra which function as the infectious form of occluded viruses, and spindles which are potent virulence factors of entomopoxviruses. In turn, some of these highly symmetrical objects have been used to develop and validate advanced structural approaches, pushing the boundary of structural biology.

Spatiotemporal regulation of liquid-like condensates in epigenetic inheritance.

Non-membrane bound organelles such as nucleoli, processing bodies, cajal bodies, and germ granules form via spontaneous self-assembly of specific proteins and RNAs. How these biomolecular condensates form and interact are poorly understood. Here we identify two proteins, ZNFX-1 and WAGO-4, that localize to C. elegans germ granules (P granules) in early germline blastomeres. Later in germline development, ZNFX-1/WAGO-4 separate from P granules to define an independent liquid-like condensate that we term the Z granule. In adult germ cells, Z granules assemble into ordered tri-condensate assemblages with P granules and Mutator foci, which we term the PZM granule. Finally, we show that one biological function of ZNFX-1 and WAGO-4 is to interact with silencing RNAs in the C. elegans germline to direct transgenerational epigenetic inheritance (TEI). We speculate that the temporal and spatial ordering of liquid droplet organelles may help cells organize and coordinate the complex RNA processing pathways underlying gene regulatory systems, such as RNA-directed TEI.

Controlling compartmentalization by non-membrane-bound organelles.

Compartmentalization is a characterizing feature of complexity in cells, used to organize their biochemistry. Membrane-bound organelles are most widely known, but non-membrane-bound liquid organelles also exist. These have recently been shown to form by phase separation of specific types of proteins known as scaffolds. This forms two phases: a condensate that is enriched in scaffold protein separated by a phase boundary from the cytoplasm or nucleoplasm with a low concentration of the scaffold protein. Phase separation is well known for synthetic polymers, but also appears important in cells. Here, we review the properties of proteins important for forming these non-membrane-bound organelles, focusing on the energetically favourable interactions that drive condensation. On this basis we make qualitative predictions about how cells may control compartmentalization by condensates; the partition of specific molecules to a condensate; the control of condensation and dissolution of condensates; and the regulation of condensate nucleation. There are emerging data supporting many of these predictions, although future results may prove incorrect. It appears that many molecules may have the ability to modulate condensate formation, making condensates a potential target for future therapeutics. The emerging properties of condensates are fundamentally unlike the properties of membrane-bound organelles. They have the capacity to rapidly integrate cellular events and act as a new class of sensors for internal and external environments.This article is part of the theme issue ‘Self-organization in cell biology’.

Life and Work of Stress Granules and Processing Bodies: New Insights into Their Formation and Function.

The dynamic formation of stress granules (SGs), processing bodies (PBs), and related RNA organelles regulates diverse cellular processes, including the coordination of functionally connected messengers, the translational regulation at the synapse, and the control of viruses and retrotransposons. Recent studies have shown that pyruvate kinase and other enzymes localize in SGs and PBs, where they become protected from stress insults. These observations may have implications for enzyme regulation and metabolic control exerted by RNA-based organelles. The formation of these cellular bodies is governed by liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) processes, and it needs to be strictly controlled to prevent pathogenic aggregation. The intracellular concentration of key metabolites, such as ATP and sterol derivatives, may influence protein solubility, thus affecting the dynamics of liquid organelles. LLPS in vitro depends on the thermal diffusion of macromolecules, which is limited inside cells, where the condensation and dissolution of membrane-less organelles are helped by energy-driven processes. The active transport by the retrograde motor dynein helps SG assembly, whereas the anterograde motor kinesin mediates SG dissolution; a tug of war between these two molecular motors allows transient SG formation. There is evidence that the efficiency of dynein-mediated transport increases with the number of motor molecules associated with the cargo. The dynein-dependent transport may be influenced by cargo size as larger cargos can load a larger number of motors. We propose a model based on this emergent property of dynein motors, which would be collectively stronger during SG condensation and weaker during SG breakdown, thus allowing kinesin-mediated dispersion.

Dysregulation of Phase Separation in Cancer

Liquid-liquid phase separation leads to demixing of proteins from solution and results in a dense, protein-rich phase, which co-exists with a light phase depleted of protein. Recent findings support a model in which phase separation is the biophysical driving force for the formation of membrane-less organelles in the cell, such as stress granules, nucleoli and nuclear speckles. Current open questions are: (i) How is phase separation propensity encoded in the protein sequence, (ii) are dense liquid droplets used as reaction compartments in the cell, and (iii) is physiological phase separation disrupted in disease states? To address them, we study the interaction of the tumor suppressor Speckle-type POZ protein (SPOP), a substrate adaptor of a ubiquitin ligase, with its substrates. SPOP localizes to different liquid membrane-less organelles in the cell nucleus, where it encounters its substrates, but it is never found diffuse in the cell. However, its recruitment mechanism to these organelles is not understood. Here, we show for the first time that SPOP undergoes liquid-liquid phase separation with substrate proteins, and that this mechanism underlies its recruitment to membrane-less organelles. Multivalency of SPOP and substrate for each other drive their ability to phase separate. Moreover, we present strong evidence that the SPOP/substrate assemblies are active ubiquitination compartments in vitro and in cells. SPOP cancer mutations reduce the propensity for phase separation and tune the material properties of mesoscale assemblies. In the cell, cancer mutants fail to localize to the proper organelles and to recruit substrate. We propose that SPOP has evolved a propensity for phase separation in order to target substrates localized in membrane-less compartments. Our results provide mechanistic insights into the contributions of structured and disordered domains to phase separate, enzymatic activity inside liquid organelles, and disruption of phase separation by cancer mutations.

Negri bodies are viral factories with properties of liquid organelles

Replication of Mononegavirales occurs in viral factories which form inclusions in the host-cell cytoplasm. For rabies virus, those inclusions are called Negri bodies (NBs). We report that NBs have characteristics similar to those of liquid organelles: they are spherical, they fuse to form larger structures, and they disappear upon hypotonic shock. Their liquid phase is confirmed by FRAP experiments. Live-cell imaging indicates that viral nucleocapsids are ejected from NBs and transported along microtubules to form either new virions or secondary viral factories. Coexpression of rabies virus N and P proteins results in cytoplasmic inclusions recapitulating NBs properties. This minimal system reveals that an intrinsically disordered domain and the dimerization domain of P are essential for Negri bodies-like structures formation. We suggest that formation of liquid viral factories by phase separation is common among Mononegavirales and allows specific recruitment and concentration of viral proteins but also the escape to cellular antiviral response.

Phase behaviour of disordered proteins underlying low density and high permeability of liquid organelles

Many intracellular membraneless organelles form via phase separation of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) or regions (IDRs). These include the Caenorhabditis elegans protein LAF-1, which forms P granule-like droplets in vitro. However, the role of protein disorder in phase separation and the macromolecular organization within droplets remain elusive. Here, we utilize a novel technique, ultrafast-scanning fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, to measure the molecular interactions and full coexistence curves (binodals), which quantify the protein concentration within LAF-1 droplets. The binodals of LAF-1 and its IDR display a number of unusual features, including 'high concentration' binodal arms that correspond to remarkably dilute droplets. We find that LAF-1 and other in vitro and intracellular droplets are characterized by an effective mesh size of ∼3-8 nm, which determines the size scale at which droplet properties impact molecular diffusion and permeability. These findings reveal how specific IDPs can phase separate to form permeable, low-density (semi-dilute) liquids, whose structural features are likely to strongly impact biological function.

Phosphorylation-mediated RNA/peptide complex coacervation as a model for intracellular liquid organelles.

Biological cells are highly organized, with numerous subcellular compartments. Phosphorylation has been hypothesized as a means to control the assembly/disassembly of liquid-like RNA- and protein-rich intracellular bodies, or liquid organelles, that lack delimiting membranes. Here, we demonstrate that charge-mediated phase separation, or complex coacervation, of RNAs with cationic peptides can generate simple model liquid organelles capable of reversibly compartmentalizing biomolecules. Formation and dissolution of these liquid bodies was controlled by changes in peptide phosphorylation state using a kinase/phosphatase enzyme pair. The droplet-generating phase transition responded to modification of even a single serine residue. Electrostatic interactions between the short cationic peptides and the much longer polyanionic RNAs drove phase separation. Coacervates were also formed on silica beads, a primitive model for localization at specific intracellular sites. This work supports phosphoregulation of complex coacervation as a viable mechanism for dynamic intracellular compartmentalization in membraneless organelles.

Colocalization and Sequential Enzyme Activity in Aqueous Biphasic Systems: Experiments and Modeling

Subcellular compartmentalization of biomolecules and their reactions is common in biology and provides a general strategy for improving and/or controlling kinetics in metabolic pathways that contain multiple sequential enzymes. Enzymes can be colocalized in multiprotein complexes, on scaffolds or inside subcellular organelles. Liquid organelles formed by intracellular phase coexistence could provide an additional means of sequential enzyme colocalization. Here we use experiment and computation to explore the kinetic consequences of sequential enzyme compartmentalization into model liquid organelles in a crowded polymer solution. Two proteins of the de novo purine biosynthesis pathway, ASL (adenylosuccinate lyase, Step 8) and ATIC (5-aminoimidazole-4-carboxamide ribonucleotide transformylase/inosine monophosphate cyclohydrolase, Steps 9 and 10), were studied in a polyethylene glycol/dextran aqueous two-phase system. Dextran-rich phase droplets served as model liquid compartments for enzyme colocalization. In this system, which lacks any specific binding interactions between the phase-forming polymers and the enzymes, we did not observe significant rate enhancements from colocalization for the overall reaction under our experimental conditions. The experimental results were used to adapt a mathematical model to quantitatively describe the kinetics. The mathematical model was then used to explore additional, experimentally inaccessible conditions to predict when increased local concentrations of enzymes and substrates can (or cannot) be expected to yield increased rates of product formation. Our findings indicate that colocalization within these simplified model liquid organelles can lead to enhanced metabolic rates under some conditions, but that very strong partitioning into the phase that serves as the compartment is necessary. In vivo, this could be provided by specific binding affinities between components of the liquid compartment and the molecules to be localized within it.