Abstract Background and Aims Left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) categories are based on left ventricular mass index (LVMi). This study aimed to generate sex-stratified, statistically-derived thresholds of mortality according to LVMi within a large, real-world patient cohort. Methods and Results Echocardiographic and linked mortality data were extracted from the National Echocardiography Database of Australia. LVH categories were first defined according to American Society of Echocardiography (ASE) criteria in 303,548 adults comprising 155,668 men (aged 61.3±17.3 years) and 147,880 women (61.8±18.3 years). Sex-specific mild to severe thresholds of increasing 5-year mortality based on LVMi increments were generated. Overall, 36,198 men (23.3%) and 38,898 women (26.3%) had LVH. Actual 5-year mortality rose from 16.9%-38.3% and 11.9%-31.2% in men and women with no LVH versus LVH, respectively. The statistical threshold at which LVMi was associated with increased mortality was lower than traditional LVH criteria in both men (Figure A, ≥88g/m2 versus ≥115g/m2) and women (Figure B, ≥82g/m2 versus ≥95g/m2). For men versus lowest-risk LVMi, the fully adjusted risk of 5-year mortality was 14% (95%CI 1.03-1.25) and 68% higher (95%CI 1.49-1.90) when LVMi levels were mildly (88 to <116) to severely (≥140g/m2) increased, respectively. In women, the equivalent LVMi thresholds of 82 to <112 and ≥140g/m2 were associated with a 13% (95%CI 1.03-1.24), and 81% higher (95%CI 1.58-2.08) 5-year mortality risk. Conclusion A high proportion of men and women have LVMi levels associated with elevated mortality risk that are lower than those traditionally used to diagnose or manage LVH. Such individuals may benefit from more proactive recognition and clinical management.