GROUP, Vol. 35, No.i,March 2011 Theater Reviews Reviews of The Pitmen Painters by Lee Hall, a British playwright, a Manhattan Theatre Club presentation at the Samuel J.Friedman Theatre on Broadway, and AftertheRevolution by Amy Herzog, a Playwrights Horizon, production at the Peter JaySharp Theatre on 42nd Street. Reviewed by Bernard Frankel1 In whatis hopedtobe a regular feature ofGROUPy we arebeginning to review recent works from thetheater andfilm world. Spaceandtimepermit onlya small sampling from a large universe. Whatwillbeselected willbeinteresting, enlightening ,andtimely. Theworlds ofartandgroup therapy havemuchtooffer eachother. There hasbeenanoveremphasis ontheinterpretation ofartintopsychotherapeutic theory andmeanings, butnotenough ontheunconscious asanevolving artform as appliedto a therapy group.Thegroup, a glimpseofhistory through time,is an artistic development ofevolving meanings. Itcanbecalledtheartofliving, aswell as theliving ofart. IfI hadtochoosebetween a movieanda play, I wouldinvariably gofor theplay. Whilebotharestaged, theplayseemsmorelikelifeas lived,morespontaneous, more dependent oncharacter development. I never think ofthemovies asa placeto seekregenerative experience. Inmovies, I generally escapetheworld, andinplays, I meettheworldanew.Ofcourse, I amrevealing mybiasesthrough thesesloppy generalizations. Butifyouthink ofwhathasstoodthetestoftime, bringing tous theinfinite waysoftranslating manamidst allhiscontexts, theplayisyetanother context ofinfinity refreshed. ThePitmanPainters is aboutfiveWelshminersreplete withWelshaccents, circa1934, whohavesignedup foran artappreciation course, sponsored bytheir union.Truetothespirit ofworking-class useofmanuallabor, learning bytheory 1 Clinical Professor, Adelphi University, Derner Institute, Posgraduate Training, Garden City, New York. Bernard Frankel, PhD, ABPP, LCD, LCSW, LFAGPA. E-mail: bfbc@optonline.net. ISSN 0362-4021©2011 Eastern Group Psychotherapy Society 81 82 FRANKEL isreplaced byhands-on learning very quickly. In thisinstance, itis a paintbrush. Themenmakeartandundergo thedevelopment ofcreative experience. Fromthe simple imitative useofbrush, color, andcanvas, interspersed witha smallamount ofinteractive dialogue, their capacity toform images oncanvasismatched bytheir capacity toform meanings andcritiques. Thecreation ofartandofintellect aresimultaneous developments, aseachminer feeds oiftheother, spiraling intohigher levelsofdiversity. Forusgroup therapists, itis a wonderful exampleofa "workgroup." Whilethereisjealousy, envy, and "apple polishing," themainthrust iscompetition asexcellence without "one-down" results. They never forget their humble roots, anddespite upper-class temptations andaspirations, they stay together andgrow. Thedialogueiswonderful, pungent, salty, andfolksy, eventhough theWelsh accentis noteasy.Themenbecameknownas theAshington GroupinEngland. Featured asthe"Pitmen Painters," they hadsomecommercial success. Thepaintings arewonderful whenshown onstage with thepainter framing them with words. The original mystery ofmeaning isdeciphered bytheir owncreative work, andtoseeits form inthepaintings istobeinspired. Ifthis playcomestoBroadway, dontmissit. After theRevolution , thesecondplay, is a fractured family drama.As a small family group ofthree generations, theplotconcerns idealization andbetrayal. The background isof1930s to'6osMarxists andfellow travelers waiting for the"revolution ," andtheir progeny, infused with politically progressive ideals.I livedthrough theeraofWorldWorldII, theCold War, McCarthyism, theHollywood Ten,the Rosenbergs, and AlgerHiss.Itwas noteverybody whowas invited tojoin the Comnunist Party in1946, orwhostoodguardatPeekskill in1947, soPaulRobeson couldsing without being lynched. Thosewere exciting times compared tothepallid, homogenized ideologies oftoday. Thethemes ofthis play would befamiliar toallfamily therapists: subgroups ofthe valuedandthedevalued, family myths andfamily secrets, scapegoating, behaviorconforming transferences, projective identifications, systems homeostasis, andthe identified patient. Theoldersister toEmmaisa recovering drugaddict. Aswith the identified patient andscapegoating, thefamily needshertoholdthefamily myth together andpreserve theperfect daughter. Asa heroic andundaunted family, their rageattheir socialpersecution isdisplaced ontotheaddict: inshort, thepreservationoftheneededidentity , the"good" while needing roomfor the"bad." Itreminds meofmyfamily's myriad attempts toconcealthat, intheDepression ofthe1930s, wewerereceiving welfare. Whata quickimmigrant acculturation totheshameof government handouts andthelike - hooray for theTeaParty! Theplaysdistinction liesineachcharacter beinga product ofhistorical reality. EachepochofitsJewish liberal urban cultural history isrepresented bya character in theplay, whoisa modification ofitspredecessor. Grandpa Joe, themartyred Marxist , isfollowed bysonBen,whopallidly waitsfor the"revolution," andbydaughter Emma,a lawyer whoheadsa foundation forciviljustice.Thesemajorcharacters Theater Reviews: lhePitmen Painters andAfter the Revolution 83 portray thepolitical andsocialimprint ofthetimes, ascharacter structure ismodified tobothretain family origin andlivecontextually inreality. Grandpa wasa spyfor theSovietUnioninWorld WarII. Purists, whoseekthe "trueand uncontaminated" hero,cannotintegrate patriot and spylivingin one identity. Purists do notallowcontexts as a meansofunderstanding oneanother. On theother hand,thelossofidealsseemstobreedtheblended personality ofour time. AsVictor Frankl putit:No oneisimmune from suffering. Whatdistinguishes onepersonfrom another aretherootsoftheir suffering. ...
Read full abstract