Leaving Group pK Research Articles

Experimental and Theoretical Insights into the Mechanisms of Sulfate and Sulfamate Ester Hydrolysis and the End Products of Type I Sulfatase Inactivation by Aryl Sulfamates

Type I sulfatases catalyze the hydrolysis of sulfate esters through S-O bond cleavage and possess a catalytically essential formylglycine (FGly) active-site residue that is post-translationally derived from either cysteine or serine. Type I sulfatases are inactivated by aryl sulfamates in a time-dependent, irreversible, and active-site directed manner consistent with covalent modification of the active site. We report a theoretical (SCS-MP2//B3LYP) and experimental study of the uncatalyzed and enzyme-catalyzed hydrolysis of aryl sulfates and sulfamates. In solution, aryl sulfate monoanions undergo hydrolysis by an S(N)2 mechanism whereas aryl sulfamate monoanions follow an S(N)1 pathway with SO2NH as an intermediate; theory traces this difference to the markedly greater stability of SO2NH versus SO3. For Pseudomonas aeruginosa arylsulfatase-catalyzed aryl sulfate hydrolysis, Brønsted analysis (log(V(max)/K(M)) versus leaving group pK(a) value) reveals β(LG) = -0.86 ± 0.23, consistent with an S(N)2 at sulfur reaction but substantially smaller than that reported for uncatalyzed hydrolysis (β(LG) = -1.81). Common to all proposed mechanisms of sulfatase catalysis is a sulfated FGly intermediate. Theory indicates a ≥26 kcal/mol preference for the intermediate to release HSO4(-) by an E2 mechanism, rather than alkaline phosphatase-like S(N)2 substitution by water. An evaluation of the stabilities of various proposed end-products of sulfamate-induced sulfatase inactivation highlights that an imine N-sulfate derived from FGly is the most likely irreversible adduct.

Structure and Mechanism of PhnP, a Phosphodiesterase of the Carbon-Phosphorus Lyase Pathway

PhnP is a phosphodiesterase that plays an important role within the bacterial carbon-phosphorus lyase (CP-lyase) pathway by recycling a "dead-end" intermediate, 5-phospho-α-d-ribosyl 1,2-cyclic phosphate, that is formed during organophosphonate catabolism. As a member of the metallo-β-lactamase superfamily, PhnP is most homologous in sequence and structure to tRNase Z phosphodiesterases. X-ray structural analysis of PhnP complexed with orthovanadate to 1.5 Å resolution revealed this inhibitor bound in a tetrahedral geometry by the two catalytic manganese ions and the putative general acid residue H200. Guided by this structure, we probed the contributions of first- and second-sphere active site residues to catalysis and metal ion binding by site-directed mutagenesis, kinetic analysis, and ICP-MS. Alteration of H200 to alanine resulted in a 6-33-fold decrease in k(cat)/K(M) with substituted methyl phenylphosphate diesters with leaving group pK(a) values ranging from 4 to 8.4. With bis(p-nitrophenyl)phosphate as a substrate, there was a 10-fold decrease in k(cat)/K(M), primarily the result of a large increase in K(M). Moreover, the nickel ion-activated H200A PhnP displayed a bell-shaped pH dependence for k(cat)/K(M) with pK(a) values (pK(a1) = 6.3; pK(a2) = 7.8) that were comparable to those of the wild-type enzyme (pK(a1) = 6.5; pK(a2) = 7.8). Such modest effects are counter to what is expected for a general acid catalyst and suggest an alternate role for H200 in this enzyme. A Brønsted analysis of the PhnP reaction with a series of substituted phenyl methyl phosphate esters yielded a linear correlation, a β(lg) of -1.06 ± 0.1, and a Leffler α value of 0.61, consistent with a synchronous transition state for phosphoryl transfer. On the basis of these data, we propose a mechanism for PhnP.

Mechanism of intramolecular catalysis in the hydrolysis of alkyl monoesters of 1,8-naphthalic acid

Hydrolysis of alkyl 1,8-naphthalic acid monoesters 1a-d is subject to highly efficient intramolecular nucleophilic catalysis by the neighboring COOH group. The reactivity for the COOH reaction depends on the leaving group pK(a), with values of β(LG) of -0.50, consistent with a mechanism involving rate determining breakdown of tetrahedral addition intermediates. The release of the steric strain of the peri-substitiuents in the highly reactive alkyl 1,8-naphthalic acid monoesters is fundamental to understand the observed special reactivity in this intramolecular reaction. DFT calculations show how the proton transfers involved in the cleavage of the neutral ester can be catalyzed by solvent water, thus facilitating the departure of poor alkoxide leaving groups.

Brønsted Analysis and Rate-Limiting Steps for the T5 Flap Endonuclease Catalyzed Hydrolysis of Exonucleolytic Substrates

During replication and repair flap endonucleases (FENs) catalyze endonucleolytic and exonucleolytic (EXO) DNA hydrolyses. Altering the leaving group pK(a), by replacing the departing nucleoside with analogues, had minimal effect on k(cat)/K(M) in a T5FEN-catalyzed EXO reaction, producing a very low Brønsted coefficient, β(lg). Investigation of the viscosity dependence of k(cat)/K(M) revealed that reactions of EXO substrates are rate limited by diffusional encounter of enzyme and substrate, explaining the small β(lg). However, the maximal single turnover rate of the FEN EXO reaction also yields a near zero β(lg). A low β(lg) was also observed when evaluating k(cat)/K(M) for D201I/D204S FEN-catalyzed reactions, even though these reactions were not affected by added viscogen. But an active site K83A mutant produced a β(lg) = -1.2 ± 0.10, closer to the value observed for solution hydrolysis of phosphate diesters. The pH-maximal rate profiles of the WT and K83A FEN reactions both reach a maximum at high pH and do not support an explanation of the data that involves catalysis of leaving group departure by Lys 83 functioning as a general acid. Instead, a rate-limiting physical step, such as substrate unpairing or helical arch ordering, that occurs after substrate association must kinetically hide an inherent large β(lg). It is suggested that K83 acts as an electrostatic catalyst that stabilizes the transition state for phosphate diester hydrolysis. When K83 is removed from the active site, chemistry becomes rate limiting and the leaving group sensitivity of the FEN-catalyzed reaction is revealed.

Selenium in Thioredoxin Reductase: A Mechanistic Perspective

Most high M(r) thioredoxin reductases (TRs) have the unusual feature of utilizing a vicinal disulfide bond (Cys(1)-Cys(2)) which forms an eight-membered ring during the catalytic cycle. Many eukaryotic TRs have replaced the Cys(2) position of the dyad with the rare amino acid selenocysteine (Sec). Here we demonstrate that Cys- and Sec-containing TRs are distinguished by the importance each class of enzymes places on the eight-membered ring structure in the catalytic cycle. This hypothesis was explored by studying the truncated enzyme missing the C-terminal ring structure in conjunction with oxidized peptide substrates to investigate the reduction and opening of this dyad. The peptide substrates were identical in sequence to the missing part of the enzyme, containing either a disulfide or selenylsulfide linkage, but were differentiated by the presence (cyclic) and absence (acyclic) of the ring structure. The ratio of these turnover rates informs that the ring is only of modest importance for the truncated mouse mitochondrial Sec-TR (ring/no ring = 32), while the ring structure is highly important for the truncated Cys-TRs from Drosophila melanogaster and Caenorhabditis elegans (ring/no ring > 1000). All three enzymes exhibit a similar dependence upon leaving group pK(a) as shown by the use of the acyclic peptides as substrates. These two factors can be reconciled for Cys-TRs if the ring functions to simultaneously allow for attack by a nearby thiolate while correctly positioning the leaving group sulfur atom to accept a proton from the enzymic general acid. For Sec-TRs the ring is unimportant because the lower pK(a) of the selenol relative to a thiol obviates its need to be protonated upon S-Se bond scission and permits physical separation of the selenol and the general acid. Further study of the biochemical properties of the truncated Cys and Sec TR enzymes demonstrates that the chemical advantage conferred on the eukaryotic enzyme by a selenol is the ability to function at acidic pH.

Enhanced Complexity and Catalytic Efficiency in the Hydrolysis of Phosphate Diesters by Rationally Designed Helix‐Loop‐Helix Motifs

HJ1, a 42-residue peptide that folds into a helix-loop-helix motif and dimerizes to form a four-helix bundle, successfully catalyzes the cleavage of "early stage" DNA model substrates in an aqueous solution at pH 7.0, with a rate enhancement in the hydrolysis of heptyl 4-nitrophenyl phosphate of over three orders of magnitude over that of the imidazole-catalyzed reaction, k(2)(HJ1)/k(2)(Im) = 3135. The second-order rate constant, k(2)(HJ1) was determined to be 1.58x10(-4) M(-1) s(-1). The catalyst successfully assembles residues that in a single elementary reaction step are capable of general-acid and general-base catalysis as well as transition state stabilization and proximity effects. The reactivity achieved with the HJ1 polypeptide, rationally designed to catalyze the hydrolysis of phosphodiesters, is based on two histidine residues flanked by four arginines and two adjacent tyrosine residues, all located on the surface of a helix-loop-helix motif. The introduction of Tyr residues close to the catalytic site improves efficiency, in the cleavage of activated aryl alkyl phosphates as well as less activated dialkyl phosphates. HJ1 is also effective in the cleavage of an RNA-mimic substrate, uridine-3'-2,2,2-trichloroethyl phosphate (leaving group pK(a) = 12.3) with a second-order rate constant of 8.23x10(-4) M(-1) s(-1) in aqueous solution at pH 7.0, some 500 times faster than the reaction catalyzed by imidazole, k(2)(HJ1)/k(2)(Im) = 496.

A Mechanistic Study of the Alkaline Hydrolysis of Diaryl Sulfate Diesters

Nearly all of the reported studies of reactions of sulfate diesters are for dialkyl or alkyl aryl diesters, which undergo reaction by carbon-oxygen bond fission. Sulfuryl transfer reactions of sulfate diesters (RO-SO(2)-OR') proceeding by attack at sulfur have been little explored. When both ester groups are aryl groups the hydrolysis reaction (sulfuryl transfer to water) occurs by way of attack at sulfur. The alkaline hydrolysis of diaryl sulfate diesters was shown to obey first-order kinetics with respect to [(-)OH] and proceed through S-O bond fission, in a mechanism that is most likely concerted. Activation parameters for 4-chloro-3-nitrophenyl phenyl sulfate and 4-nitrophenyl phenyl sulfate gave the following respective values: Delta H(++) = 88.0 +/- 0.1 and 84.83 +/- 0.06 kJ mol(-)(1) and Delta S(++) = -37 +/- 1 and -50.2 +/- 0.5 J mol(-)(1) deg(-)(1). The dependence of the second-order rate constant for hydrolysis on leaving group pK(a) was analyzed giving a beta(lg) slope of -0.7 +/- 0.2 and a Leffler alpha parameter value of 0.36. A (15)k kinetic isotope effect (KIE) for the hydroxide attack on 4-nitrophenyl phenyl sulfate of 1.0000 +/-0.0005 and an (18)k(lg) KIE value of 1.003+/-0.002 were obtained.

Probing the transition-state structure of dual-specificity protein phosphatases using a physiological substrate mimic.

Dual-specificity phosphatases (DSPs) belong to the large family of protein tyrosine phosphatases that contain the active-site motif (H/V)CxxGxxR(S/T), but unlike the tyrosine-specific enzymes, DSPs are able to catalyze the efficient hydrolysis of both phosphotyrosine and phosphoserine/threonine found on signaling proteins, as well as a variety of small-molecule aryl and alkyl phosphates. It is unclear how DSPs accomplish similar reaction rates for phosphoesters, whose reactivity (i.e., pK(a) of the leaving group) can vary by more than 10(8). Here, we utilize the alkyl phosphate m-nitrobenzyl phosphate (mNBP), leaving-group pK(a) = 14.9, as a physiological substrate mimic to probe the mechanism and transition state of the DSP, Vaccinia H1-related (VHR). Detailed pH and kinetic isotope effects of the V/K value for mNBP indicates that VHR reacts with the phosphate dianion of mNBP and that the nonbridge phosphate oxygen atoms are unprotonated in the transition state. (18)O and solvent isotope effects indicate differences in the respective timing of the proton transfer to the leaving group and P-O fission; with the alkyl ester substrate, protonation is ahead of P-O fission, while with the aryl substrate, the two processes are more synchronous. Kinetic analysis of the general-acid mutant D92N with mNBP was consistent with the requirement of Asp-92 in protonating the ester oxygen, either in a step prior to significant P-O bond cleavage or in a concerted but asynchronous mechanism in which protonation is ahead of P-O bond fission. Collectively, the data indicate that VHR and likely all DSPs can match leaving-group potential with the timing of the proton transfer to the ester oxygen, such that diverse aryl and alkyl phosphoesters are turned over with similar catalytic efficiency.

Detailed dissection of a new mechanism for glycoside cleavage: alpha-1,4-glucan lyase.

The unusual enzyme, Gracilariopsis alpha-1,4-glucan lyase of the sequence-related glycoside hydrolase family 31, cleaves the glycosidic bond of alpha-1,4-glucans via a beta-elimination reaction involving a covalent glycosyl-enzyme intermediate (Lee, S. S., Yu, S., and Withers, S. G. (2002) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 124, 4948-4949). The classical bell-shaped pH dependence of k(cat)/K(m) indicates two ionizable groups in the active site with apparent pK(a) values of 3.05 and 6.66. Brønsted relationships of log k(cat) versus pK(a) and log(k(cat)/K(m)) versus pK(a) for a series of aryl glucosides both show a linear monotonic dependence on leaving group pK(a) with low beta(lg) values of 0.32 and 0.33, respectively. The combination of these low beta(lg) values with large secondary deuterium kinetic isotope effects (k(H)/k(D) = 1.16 - 1.19) on the first step indicate a glycosylation step with substantial glycosidic bond cleavage and proton donation to the leaving group oxygen at the transition state. Developed oxocarbenium ion character of the transition state is also suggested by the potent inhibition afforded by acarbose and 1-deoxynojirimycin (K(i) = 20 and 130 nM, respectively) and by the substantial rate reduction afforded by adjacent fluorine substitution. For only one substrate, 5-fluoro-alpha-D-glucopyranosyl fluoride, was the second elimination step shown to be rate-limiting. The large alpha-secondary deuterium kinetic isotope effect (k(H)/k(D) = 1.23) at C-1 and the small primary deuterium kinetic isotope effect (k(H)/k(D) = 1.92) at C-2 confirm an E2 mechanism with strong E1 character for this second step. This considerable structural and mechanistic similarity with retaining alpha-glucosidases is clear evidence for the evolution of an enzyme mechanism within the family.

Transition state differences in hydrolysis reactions of alkyl versus aryl phosphate monoester monoanions.

Although aryl phosphates have been the subject of numerous experimental studies, far less data bearing on the mechanism and transition states for alkyl phosphate reactions have been presented. Except for esters with very good leaving groups such as 2,4-dinitrophenol, the monoanion of phosphate esters is more reactive than the dianion. Several mechanisms have been proposed for the hydrolysis of the monoanion species. (18)O kinetic isotope effects in the nonbridging oxygen atoms and in the P-O(R) ester bond, and solvent deuterium isotope effects, have been measured for the hydrolysis of m-nitrobenzyl phosphate. The results rule out a proposed mechanism in which the phosphoryl group deprotonates water and then undergoes attack by hydroxide. The results are most consistent with a preequilibrium proton transfer from the phosphoryl group to the ester oxygen atom, followed by rate-limiting P-O bond fission, as originally proposed by Kirby and co-workers in 1967. The transition state for m-nitrobenzyl phosphate (leaving group pK(a) 14.9) exhibits much less P-O bond fission than the reaction of the more labile p-nitrophenyl phosphate (leaving group pK(a) = 7.14). This seemingly anti-Hammond behavior results from weakening of the P-O(R) ester bond resulting from protonation, an effect which calculations have shown is much more pronounced for aryl phosphates than for alkyl ones.

Probing the function of conserved residues in the serine/threonine phosphatase PP2Calpha.

Human PP2Calpha is a metal-dependent phosphoserine/phosphothreonine protein phosphatase and is the representative member of the large PPM family. The X-ray structure of human PP2Calpha has revealed an active site containing a dinuclear metal ion center that is coordinated by several invariant carboxylate residues. However, direct evidence for the catalytic function of these and other active-site residues has not been established. Using site-directed mutagenesis and enzyme kinetic analyses, we probed the roles of conserved active-site amino acids within PP2Calpha. Asp-60 bridges metals M1 and M2, and Asp-239 coordinates metal M2, both of which were replaced individually to asparagine residues. These point mutations resulted in >or=1000-fold decrease in k(cat) and >or=30-fold increase in K(m) value for Mn(2+). Mutation of Asp-282 to asparagine caused a 100-fold decrease in k(cat), but no significant effect on K(m) values for metal and substrate, consistent with Asp-282 activating a metal-bound water nucleophile. Mutants T128A, E37Q, D38N, and H40A displayed little or no alterations on k(cat) and K(m) values for substrate or metal ion (Mn(2+)). Analysis of H62Q and R33A yielded k(cat) values that were 20- and 2-fold lower than wild-type, respectively. The mutant R33A showed a 8-fold higher K(m) for substrate, while the K(m) observed with H62Q was unaffected. A pH-rate profile of the H62Q mutant showed loss of the ionization that must be protonated for activity. Brönsted analysis of substrate leaving group pK(a) values for H62Q indicated a greater dependency (slope -0.84) on leaving group pK(a) in comparison to wild-type (slope -0.33). These data provide strong evidence that His-62 acts as a general acid during the cleavage of the P-O bond.

The Catalytic Mechanism of Cdc25A Phosphatase

Cdc25 phosphatases are dual specificity phosphatases that dephosphorylate and activate cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs), thereby effecting the progression from one phase of the cell cycle to the next. Despite its central role in the cell cycle, relatively little is known about the catalytic mechanism of Cdc25. In order to provide insights into the catalytic mechanism of Cdc25, we have performed a detailed mechanistic analysis of the catalytic domain of human Cdc25A. Our kinetic isotope effect results, Bronsted analysis, and pH dependence studies employing a range of aryl phosphates clearly indicate a dissociative transition state for the Cdc25A reaction that does not involve a general acid for the hydrolysis of substrates with low leaving group pK(a) values (5.45-8.05). Interestingly, our Bronsted analysis and pH dependence studies reveal that Cdc25A employs a different mechanism for the hydrolysis of substrates with high leaving group pK(a) values (8.68-9.99) that appears to require the protonation of glutamic acid 431. Mutation of glutamic acid 431 into glutamine leads to a dramatic drop in the hydrolysis rate for the high leaving group pK(a) substrates and the disappearance of the basic limb of the pH rate profile for the substrate with a leaving group pK(a) of 8.05, indicating that glutamic acid 431 is essential for the efficient hydrolysis of substrates with high leaving group pK(a). We suggest that hydrolysis of the high leaving group pK(a) substrates proceeds through an unfavored but more catalytically active form of Cdc25A, and we propose several models illustrating this. Since the activity of Cdc25A toward small molecule substrates is several orders of magnitude lower than toward the physiological substrate, cyclin-CDK, we suggest that the cyclin-CDK is able to preferentially induce this more catalytically active form of Cdc25A for efficient phosphothreonine and phosphotyrosine dephosphorylation.

On the magnitude and specificity of medium effects in enzyme-like catalysts for proton transfer.

Medium effects are normally studied by comparing the rates of reactions in different solvents. However, medium effects at the active site of enzymes differ dramatically from bulk solvents, both in their diversity (the presence of more than one type of "solvent") and in their spatial arrangement. We describe medium effects in a simple catalytic system, obtained by systematic alkylation of a polymeric scaffold bearing amine groups to give synzymes that catalyze the Kemp elimination of benzisoxazoles with remarkable efficiency. Our analysis indicates that catalysis by these synzymes is driven primarily by specific, localized enzyme-like medium effects, and these effects seem to differ dramatically from the nonspecific medium effects (i.e., desolvation activation) exhibited by solvents. Ligand-binding studies indicate that the synzyme active sites provide localized microenvironments affording a combination of hydrophobic and apolar regions on one hand and dipolar, protic, and positively charged on the other. Such localized microenvironments are not available in bulk solvents. A Brønsted (leaving group) analysis indicates that, in comparison to solvent catalysis, the efficiency of synzyme catalysis shows little sensitivity to leaving group pK(a). We show that enzyme-like medium effects alone, in the absence of efficient positioning of the catalytic amine base relative to the substrate, can give rise to rate accelerations as high as 10(5), for both activated and nonactivated substrates. Supported by the accidental identification of active sites on the surfaces of noncatalytic proteins and the promiscuous activities found in many enzymes, our findings suggest that the interfaces of protein surfaces and their hydrophobic cores provide a microenvironment that is intrinsically active and may serve as a basis for further evolutionary improvements to give proficient and selective enzymes.

Mechanistic study of beta-xylosidase from Trichoderma koningii G-39.

The catalytic mechanism of the beta-xylosidase purified from the culture filtrate of Trichoderma koningii G-39 was investigated. By NMR spectroscopy, the stereochemistry of the enzyme catalyzing the hydrolysis of 2,4-dinitrophenyl and p-nitrophenyl-beta-D-xylosides was found unequivocally to involve retention of the anomeric configuration. Based on the k(cat) values of a series of arylxylosides with leaving group pK(a)s in the range of 4-10, an extended Bronsted plot was constructed with a slope (beta(lg)) near zero. Enzymatic hydrolysis of aryl-beta-D-xylosides in acetate buffer (pH 4.0) containing 3 or 5% methanol showed a constant product ratio (methylxyloside/xylose), indicating the presence of a common intermediate, probably the xylosyl-enzyme intermediate. In the presence of DTT, the k(cat) values of p-cyanophenyl-beta-D-xylopyranoside and p-nitrophenyl-beta-D-xylopyranoside increased greatly. A two-step mechanism involving the formation and breakdown of the xylosyl-enzyme intermediate was therefore proposed. The rate-limiting step is the breakdown of the intermediate. The secondary deuterium kinetic isotope effect (k(H)/k(D)) measured for 2,4-dinitrophenyl-beta-D-xyloside was 1.02+/-0.01, suggesting that the transition state for breakdown of the xylosyl-enzyme intermediate is S(N)2-like.

Kinetic and site-directed mutagenesis studies of the cysteine residues of bovine low molecular weight phosphotyrosyl protein phosphatase.

The roles of the 8 conserved cysteines and 1 arginine in the low molecular weight phosphotyrosyl protein phosphatases were investigated using site-directed mutagenesis of the recombinant bovine heart enzyme. Single mutants of cysteine to serine were studied for each cysteine; alanine replacements were also made for Cys-12, Cys-17, and Arg-18. The CD spectra of the purified proteins were effectively superimposable, consistent with the conclusion that no major structural alterations had occurred, but 1H NMR spectroscopy did reveal some spectral shifts in the aromatic region. Kinetic analysis of the mutant proteins demonstrated that only Cys-12, Cys-17, and Arg-18 had significantly altered catalytic activity toward the substrate p-nitrophenyl phosphate at pH 5. The Cys-12 and Arg-18 mutants were effectively inactive. Thus, it is concluded that Cys-12 is the catalytic nucleophile, and Arg-18 presumably serves an essential function in substrate binding. The C17S mutant had 6% residual activity compared with wild type protein, whereas the C17A mutant had 37% activity. Consistent with the observed activity of the Cys-17 mutant, a covalent phosphocysteine intermediate was trapped and identified by 31P NMR. Further kinetic analysis of C17A using several aryl phosphate monoester substrates with different leaving group pK alpha values indicated that no change in the rate-determining step of the catalytic mechanism had occurred, that is, dephosphorylation of the covalent phosphoenzyme intermediate remains rate-limiting. The C17A mutant had a 4-fold higher phosphate Ki and slightly higher Km values for p-nitrophenyl phosphate suggesting that Cys-17 may be important for optimal positioning of the substrate phosphate moiety.