Pea phytoalexins (-)-maackiain and (+)-pisatin have opposite C6a/C11a configurations, but biosynthetically how this occurs is unknown. Pea dirigent-protein (DP) PsPTS2 generates 7,2'-dihydroxy-4',5'-methylenedioxyisoflav-3-ene (DMDIF), and stereoselectivity toward four possible 7,2'-dihydroxy-4',5'-methylenedioxyisoflavan-4-ol (DMDI) stereoisomers was investigated. Stereoisomer configurations were determined using NMR spectroscopy, electronic circular dichroism, and molecular orbital analyses. PsPTS2 efficiently converted cis-(3R,4R)-DMDI into DMDIF 20-fold faster than the trans-(3R,4S)-isomer. The 4R-configured substrate's near β-axial OH orientation significantly enhanced its leaving group abilities in generating A-ring mono-quinone methide (QM), whereas 4S-isomer's α-equatorial-OH was a poorer leaving group. Docking simulations indicated that the 4R-configured β-axial OH was closest to Asp51, whereas 4S-isomer's α-equatorial OH was further away. Neither cis-(3S,4S)- nor trans-(3S,4R)-DMDIs were substrates, even with the former having C3/C4 stereochemistry as in (+)-pisatin. PsPTS2 used cis-(3R,4R)-7,2'-dihydroxy-4'-methoxyisoflavan-4-ol [cis-(3R,4R)-DMI] and C3/C4 stereoisomers to give 2',7-dihydroxy-4'-methoxyisoflav-3-ene (DMIF). DP homologs may exist in licorice (Glycyrrhiza pallidiflora) and tree legume Bolusanthus speciosus, as DMIF occurs in both species. PsPTS1 utilized cis-(3R,4R)-DMDI to give (-)-maackiain 2200-fold more efficiently than with cis-(3R,4R)-DMI to give (-)-medicarpin. PsPTS1 also slowly converted trans-(3S,4R)-DMDI into (+)-maackiain, reflecting the better 4R configured OH leaving group. PsPTS2 and PsPTS1 provisionally provide the means to enable differing C6a and C11a configurations in (+)-pisatin and (-)-maackiain, via identical DP-engendered mono-QM bound intermediate generation, which PsPTS2 either re-aromatizes to give DMDIF or PsPTS1 intramolecularly cyclizes to afford (-)-maackiain. Substrate docking simulations using PsPTS2 and PsPTS1 indicate cis-(3R,4R)-DMDI binds in the anti-configuration in PsPTS2 to afford DMDIF, and the syn-configuration in PsPTS1 to give maackiain.