Leaf Wax Hydrogen Isotope Research Articles

Changes in Indo-Pacific Warm Pool hydroclimate and vegetation during the last deglaciation

Drying across much of the Indo-Pacific Warm Pool (IPWP) during the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) has been widely recognized from interpretations of sedimentological, geochemical, and paleoecological records. Reconstructions of precipitation isotopic compositions have emerged as a powerful tool to reconstruct rainfall amount in many tropical regions, yet it has proven difficult to reconcile precipitation isotope records from the IPWP with records of widespread drying. To evaluate the signals preserved in precipitation isotope records, we produced new hydrogen and carbon isotope records from Lake Towuti and Lake Matano in Sulawesi, Indonesia using long-chain n-alkanes. We then compared these new records to existing n-alkanoic acid records from the same lakes and compiled available marine runoff, salinity, leaf wax hydrogen isotope (δ2Hwax), and leaf wax carbon isotope (δ13Cwax) records in the IPWP. During the last deglaciation, marine runoff and salinity proxies reveal that precipitation amount began to increase dramatically between ∼12.3 ka at the end of the Younger Dryas. A principal component analysis of precipitation isotope records indicates a shift from more 2H-enriched to 2H-depleted waxes at ∼12.3 ka as sea level rise inundates most of the Sunda and Sahul shelves, coincident with runoff and salinity proxies, suggesting precipitation isotopes respond strongly to rainfall amount in this region. Over 70% of IPWP δ13Cwax records show a transition from more to less 13C-enriched waxes beginning about 19.9 ka, prior to the reconstructed increases in precipitation. We suggest that vegetation shifted in response to the changing seasonality of precipitation. The dramatic changes in the IPWP during the last deglaciation highlight the capacity for the region to experience dynamic changes in precipitation, vegetation, and atmospheric circulation.

Climatic controls on leaf wax hydrogen isotope ratios in terrestrial and marine sediments along a hyperarid-to-humid gradient

Abstract. The hydrogen isotope composition of leaf wax biomarkers (δ2Hwax) is a valuable tool for reconstructing continental paleohydrology, since it serves as a proxy for the hydrogen isotope composition of precipitation (δ2Hpre). To yield robust palaeohydrological reconstructions using δ2Hwax in marine archives, it is necessary to examine the impacts of regional climate on δ2Hwax and assess the similarity between marine sedimentary δ2Hwax and the source of continental δ2Hwax. Here, we examined an aridity gradient from hyperarid to humid along the Chilean coast. We sampled sediments at the outlets of rivers draining into the Pacific as well as soils within catchments and marine surface sediments adjacent to the outlets of the studied rivers and analyzed the relationship between climatic variables and δ2Hwax values. We found that apparent fractionation between leaf waxes and source water is relatively constant in humid and semiarid regions (average: −121 ‰). However, it becomes less negative in hyperarid regions (average: −86 ‰) as a result of evapotranspirative processes affecting soil and leaf water 2H enrichment. We also observed that along strong aridity gradients, the 2H enrichment of δ2Hwax follows a non-linear relationship with water content and water flux variables, driven by strong soil evaporation and plant transpiration. Furthermore, our results indicate that δ2Hwax values in marine surface sediments largely reflect δ2Hwax values from the continent, confirming the robustness of marine δ2Hwax records for paleohydrological reconstructions along the Chilean margin. These findings also highlight the importance of considering the effects of hyperaridity in the interpretation of δ2Hwax values and pave the way for more quantitative paleohydrological reconstructions using δ2Hwax.

Low-frequency orbital variations controlled climatic and environmental cycles, amplitudes, and trends in northeast Africa during the Plio-Pleistocene

The eastern Mediterranean sapropels, paced by insolation, provide a unique archive of African monsoon strength over the Late Neogene. However, the longer-term climate of this region lacks characterization within the context of changes in ice volume, sea surface temperature gradients, and terrestrial ecosystems. Here, we examine C28n-alkanoic acid leaf wax hydrogen and carbon isotopes in sapropels, sourced from northeast Africa, along with vegetation-corrected precipitation isotopes, derived from astronomically dated sediment cores from ODP 160 Sites 966 and 967 since 4.5 million years ago. Despite sampling only wet-phase sapropels for African monsoon variability, we find a larger range in hydrogen isotopes than previously published data across wet-dry precession cycles, indicating the importance of long-term modulation of Green Sahara phases throughout the Neogene. An influence of orbital properties on regional monsoonal hydroclimate is observed, controlling up to 50% of total hydrogen isotope variance, but large changes outside of these typical frequencies account for at least 50% of the total variance. This secular trend may track changes in ice volume, tropical sea surface temperature, sea surface temperature gradients, or even lower-frequency orbital cycles. Long-term hydroclimate and environmental shifts provide new contexts for milestone events in northeast African hominin dispersal and evolution.

Plio‐Pleistocene Southwest African Hydroclimate Modulated by Benguela and Indian Ocean Temperatures

AbstractFuture projections of southwestern African hydroclimate are highly uncertain. However, insights from past warm climates, like the Pliocene, can reveal mechanisms of future change and help benchmark models. Using leaf wax hydrogen isotopes to reconstruct precipitation (δDp) from Namibia over the past 5 million years, we find a long‐term depletion trend (−50‰). Empirical mode decomposition indicates this trend is linked to sea surface temperatures (SSTs) within the Benguela Upwelling System, but modulated by Indian Ocean SSTs on shorter timescales. The influence of SSTs on reconstructed regional hydroclimate is similar to that observed during modern Benguela Nio events, which bring extreme flooding to the region. Isotope‐enabled simulations and PlioMIP2 results suggest that capturing a Benguela Nio‐like state is key to accurately simulating Pliocene, and future, regional hydroclimate. This has implications for future regional climate, since an increased frequency of Benguela Nios poses risk to the ecosystems and industries in the region.

Long-term ecological responses of a lowland dipterocarp forest to climate changes and nutrient availability.

Understanding the long-term impact of projected climate change on tropical rainforests is critical given their central role in the Earth's system. Palaeoecological records can provide a valuable perspective on this problem. Here, we examine the effects of past climatic changes on the dominant forest type of Southeast Asia - lowland dipterocarp forest. We use a range of proxies extracted from a 1400-yr-old lacustrine sedimentary sequence from north-eastern Philippines to determine long-term vegetation responses of lowland dipterocarp forest, including its dominant tree group dipterocarps, to changes in precipitation, fire and nutrient availability over time. Our results show a positive relationship between dipterocarp pollen accumulation rates (PARs) and leaf wax hydrogen isotope values, which suggests a negative effect of drier conditions on dipterocarp abundance. Furthermore, we find a positive relationship between dipterocarp PARs and the proxy for phosphorus availability, which suggests phosphorus controls the productivity of these keystone trees on longer time scales. Other pollen taxa show widely varying relationships with the abiotic factors, demonstrating a high diversity of plant functional responses. Our findings provide novel insights into lowland dipterocarp forest responses to changing climatic conditions in the past and highlight potential impacts of future climate change on this globally important ecosystem.

Holocene precipitation hydrogen isotopic values on Nilgiri Plateau (southern India) suggest a combined effect of precipitation amount and transport paths

Paleoclimate investigations of the peat deposits in the Nilgiri Plateau, an important paleoclimate archive of India, are mainly restricted to the carbon isotope composition ((δ13C) of plant-derived materials and pollen studies. However, it is unclear whether these proxies reflect past variability in temperature or hydrology. Here, we report the hydrogen and carbon isotopic variability of n-alkanoic acid of chain length 28 (δDC28and δ13CC28, respectively) and demonstrate that the peatland leaf wax hydrogen isotopes provide a sensitive record of past hydrology. The decoupling of δ13CC28and δD of vegetation-corrected rain during the Holocene indicate that δD of the leaf wax compounds mainly respond to past hydrological variability whereas δ13C variations might reflect the temperature-controlled variability of C3 and C4 vegetation. Conforming with the other paleoclimate records from the region, the δDC28variations showed a reducing precipitation trend since the early Holocene. However, a large amplitude of reconstructed δD of rain (~44‰) during the Holocene indicated changes in the moisture source and trajectory could be an additional factor contributing to the orbital-scale δD variability of proxies from the Indian region.

Continuous mass loss acceleration of Qiangyong Glacier, southern Tibetan plateau, since the mid-1880s inferred from glaciolacustrine sediments

Himalayan glaciers have been shown by satellite observations to be losing mass at accelerated rates since the mid-1970s, posing severe challenges to downstream water resource availability, ecological functioning, and glacial hazard prevention. Reconstructing long-term glacier fluctuations beyond the satellite era is consequently crucial to fully understand this acceleration. However, glacier reconstructions in the Himalayas are mainly based on discontinuous moraine chronologies, with the most recent ones marking only the timing and position of the Little Ice Age (LIA; 1250–1850 CE) maxima of Himalayan glaciers. Here, we reconstruct continuous records of the activity of Qiangyong Glacier, southern Tibetan Plateau, since the onset of the LIA (1316–2004 CE) and associated variation in precipitation, by retrieving glacier melting and advancing signals from grain size and analysing leaf wax hydrogen isotopes in the same glaciolacustrine sediments. We show that the glacier was relatively stable during the LIA, with its terminus shifting within ∼100 m, depending on the combined effects of precipitation and temperature. However, it retreated by ∼150 m under maximum precipitation conditions at the end of the LIA (approximately 1845–1866 CE) and, most importantly, has exhibited accelerated mass loss since the mid-1880s. Comparisons with regional and Northern Hemisphere temperatures suggest that climate warming rather than decreased precipitation since the end of the LIA plays a primary role in driving this accelerated mass loss. Our glaciolacustrine record add a continuous perspective on the variability of Himalayan glaciers, especially their mass loss status since the end of the LIA.

Expansion and Intensification of the North American Monsoon During the Pliocene

AbstractSouthwestern North America (SWNA), like many subtropical regions, is predicted to become drier in response to anthropogenic warming. However, during the Pliocene, when carbon dioxide was above pre‐industrial levels, multiple lines of evidence suggest that SWNA was much wetter. While existing explanations for a wet Pliocene invoke increases in winter rain, recent modeling studies hypothesize that summer rain may have also played an important role. Here, we present the first direct evidence for an intensified mid‐Pliocene monsoon in SWNA using leaf wax hydrogen isotopes. These new records provide evidence that the mid‐Pliocene featured an intensified and expanded North American Monsoon. Using proxies and isotope‐enabled model simulations, we show that monsoon intensification is linked to amplified warming on the southern California margin relative to the tropical Pacific. This mechanism has clear relevance for understanding present‐day monsoon variations, since we show that intervals of amplified subtropical warming on the California margin, as are seen during modern California margin heat waves, are associated with a stronger monsoon. Because marine heat waves are predicted to increase in frequency, the future may bring intervals of “Pliocene‐like” rainfall that co‐exist with intensifying megadrought in SWNA, with implications for ecosystems, human infrastructure, and water resources.

Linking sedimentary and speleothem precipitation isotope proxy records to improve lacustrine and marine 14C chronologies

The chronology of geological records in lacustrine, peatland and marine sediments for the late glacial depends mainly on 14C dating technology, which provides the basic database for global paleoclimate research. However, 14C reservoir correction always challenges the accuracy of the 14C chronology of terrestrial and marine sediments and the uncertainty of the 14C chronology associated with the carbon reservoir effect becomes critical for high resolution paleoclimate studies. Here, based on the hypothesis of synchronization of precipitation isotopes, we verify and identify a series of in-phase points of precipitation isotopes (IPPIs) between sediment leaf-wax hydrogen and stalagmite-calcite oxygen isotopes. Because stalagmite oxygen isotope records are accurately dated by U–Th dating technology, the ages of stalagmite IPPIs could be used to improve 14C reservoir correction of lacustrine IPPIs. We found that reservoir-corrected 14C ages of lacustrine, peat, and marine IPPIs are scattered with an average uncertainty of 1 ka when compared with the corresponding IPPIs on U–Th age scales. We suggest that the reservoir age correction at different time intervals could be further adjusted by using the U–Th age-backed IPPIs, which largely reduces the uncertainty of the 14C chronology and thus provides more accurate paleoclimate records.

Orbital controls on eastern African hydroclimate in the Pleistocene

Understanding eastern African paleoclimate is critical for contextualizing early human evolution, adaptation, and dispersal, yet Pleistocene climate of this region and its governing mechanisms remain poorly understood due to the lack of long, orbitally-resolved, terrestrial paleoclimate records. Here we present leaf wax hydrogen isotope records of rainfall from paleolake sediment cores from key time windows that resolve long-term trends, variations, and high-latitude effects on tropical African precipitation. Eastern African rainfall was dominantly controlled by variations in low-latitude summer insolation during most of the early and middle Pleistocene, with little evidence that glacial–interglacial cycles impacted rainfall until the late Pleistocene. We observe the influence of high-latitude-driven climate processes emerging from the last interglacial (Marine Isotope Stage 5) to the present, an interval when glacial–interglacial cycles were strong and insolation forcing was weak. Our results demonstrate a variable response of eastern African rainfall to low-latitude insolation forcing and high-latitude-driven climate change, likely related to the relative strengths of these forcings through time and a threshold in monsoon sensitivity. We observe little difference in mean rainfall between the early, middle, and late Pleistocene, which suggests that orbitally-driven climate variations likely played a more significant role than gradual change in the relationship between early humans and their environment.

Lacustrine leaf wax hydrogen isotopes indicate strong regional climate feedbacks in Beringia since the last ice age

The Late-Quaternary climate of Beringia remains unresolved despite the region's role in modulating glacial-interglacial climate and as the likely conduit for human dispersal into the Americas. Here, we investigate Beringian temperature change using an ∼32,000-year lacustrine record of leaf wax hydrogen isotope ratios (δ2Hwax) from Arctic Alaska. Based on Monte Carlo iterations accounting for multiple sources of uncertainty, the reconstructed summertime temperatures were ∼3 °C colder (range: −8 to +3 °C) during the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM; 21-25 ka) than the pre-industrial era (PI; 2–0.1 ka). This ice-age summer cooling is substantially smaller than in other parts of the Arctic, reflecting altered atmospheric circulation and increased continentality which weakened glacial cooling in the region. Deglacial warming was punctuated by abrupt events that are largely synchronous with events seen in Greenland ice cores that originate in the North Atlantic but which are also controlled locally, such as by the opening of the Bering Strait between 13.4 and 11 ka. Our reconstruction, together with climate modeling experiments, indicates that Beringia responds more strongly to North Atlantic freshwater forcing under modern-day, open-Bering Strait conditions than under glacial conditions. Furthermore, a 2 °C increase (Monte Carlo range: −1 to +5 °C) over the anthropogenic era reverses a 6 °C decline (Monte Carlo range: −10 to 0 °C) through the Holocene, indicating that recent warming in Arctic Alaska has not surpassed peak Holocene summer warmth.

Local effects on soil leaf wax hydrogen isotopes along a west to east transect through the Pamirs, Tajikistan

Understanding the control mechanisms that affect soil leaf wax hydrogen isotopes is crucial when interpreting these data in the context of paleoclimatic reconstructions. Within a pilot study we aimed to evaluate the regional controls on leaf wax δ2H in the Central Asian Pamir Mountains (Tajikistan), a region characterized by pronounced hydroclimatic gradients. Soil and tap water samples were collected along a ca. 1000 km west-east-gradient, spanning ca. 3100 m of altitude difference. The results give evidence of variable environmental control on soil leaf wax δ2H values in different sub-regions of the study area. In the western and central Pamirs, the plant lipids mirror the signal of a mostly riverine water source, with an isotopic signature mainly controlled by winter and spring precipitation. With ca. –1.3‰ change per 100 m altitude, soil leaf wax derived isotopic lapse rates in these samples are lower than in other Asian high-altitude settings and the global average, which confirms earlier findings from surface water analysis from the Pamirs. In contrast, soil samples from the shielded Karakul basin showed significantly higher δ2H values. Those most likely reflect the more positive isotope signal of a predominant summer precipitation in the arid eastern Pamirs, with potential additional enrichment due to local vapor recycling and soil- and leaf water evapotranspiration. While the predominant water source (precipitation vs river water) plays an important role on a local scale, the results further highlight the significance of regional climate effects on isotopic signals incorporated into leaf waxes.

Paleoclimate Significance of Reconstructed Rainfall Isotope Changes in Asian Monsoon Region

AbstractSpeleothem oxygen isotope (δ18Oc) records have been regarded as a critical reference to study past Asian monsoon variability. However, existing δ18Oc records in the Indian monsoon region are fragmented in time coverage and/or sampling resolution since the last deglaciation. Also, the climatic interpretation of δ18Oc is still obscure. Here, we report a continuous and centennial‐resolved leaf wax hydrogen isotope (δDwax) record over the past ∼28 ka from Lugu Lake in Indian‐monsoon influenced southwestern China. Our new record shows striking consistency with the well‐established δ18Oc record in East Asian monsoon‐influenced southeastern China, revealing a spatially coherent change and thus a similar physical process in rainfall isotopes in the broader Asian monsoon region. Based on the combination with the TraCE21ka simulation, we propose reconstructed long‐term and millennial‐scale isotope changes could be influenced by the intensity of local convection along the monsoon trough, which extends from the Indian subcontinent across to the Philippines in summer.

Fossil leaf wax hydrogen isotopes reveal variability of Atlantic and Mediterranean climate forcing on the southeast Iberian Peninsula between 6000 to 3000 cal. BP.

Many recently published papers have investigated the spatial and temporal manifestation of the 4.2 ka BP climate event at regional and global scales. However, questions with regard to the potential drivers of the associated climate change remain open. Here, we investigate the interaction between Atlantic and Mediterranean climate forcing on the south-eastern Iberian Peninsula during the mid- to late Holocene using compound-specific hydrogen isotopes from fossil leaf waxes preserved in marine sediments. Variability of hydrogen isotope values in the study area is primarily related to changes in the precipitation source and indicates three phases of increased Mediterranean sourced precipitation from 5450 to 5350 cal. BP, from 5150 to 4300 cal. BP including a short-term interruption around 4800 cal. BP, and from 3400 to 3000 cal. BP interrupted around 3200 cal. BP. These phases are in good agreement with times of prevailing positive modes of the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) and reduced storm activity in the Western Mediterranean suggesting that the NAO was the dominant modulator of relative variability in precipitation sources. However, as previously suggested other modes such as the Western Mediterranean Oscillation (WeMO) may have altered this overall relationship. In this regard, a decrease in Mediterranean moisture source coincident with a rapid reduction in warm season precipitation during the 4.2 ka BP event at the south-eastern Iberian Peninsula might have been related to negative WeMO conditions.

Northward Shifts in the Polar Front Preceded Bølling and Holocene Warming in Southwestern Scandinavia

AbstractThe last deglaciation in northern Europe provides an opportunity to study the hydrologic component of abrupt climate shifts in a region with complex interactions between ice sheets and oceanic and atmospheric circulation. We use leaf wax hydrogen isotopes (δ2H) to reconstruct summer precipitation δ2H and aridity in southwestern Norway from 15.8 to 11.5 ka. We identify transitions to a more proximal moisture source before the ends of Heinrich Stadial 1 and the Younger Dryas, prior to local warming and increased primary productivity in both instances. We infer these changes in moisture delivery to southwestern Norway to be a response to northward shifts in the polar front caused by warm water intrusion into the North Atlantic, which preceded abrupt warming in the circum‐North Atlantic. These results suggest that moisture transport pathways shift northward as warm surface ocean water reaches higher latitudes in the North Atlantic.

Western Pacific Ocean influences on monsoon precipitation in the southwestern Chinese Loess Plateau since the mid-Holocene

Numerous paleoclimate records on reconstructed monsoon precipitation isotopes (δDp and δ18Op) have been published to infer past hydroclimate changes in Asian monsoon region. However, there are still debates on whether or not these reconstructed δDp or δ18Op can represent changes of monsoon precipitation. In this study, we report a ~ 5000 year record of leafwax hydrogen isotope (δDwax) from a 6.67-m-long sediment core collected in Beilianchi (BLC) Lake in the southwestern Chinese Loess Plateau. Based on analyses of the instrumental precipitation isotopes, precipitation amounts, and moisture sources, we find that δDp in the southwestern Chinese Loess Plateau shows distinct negative correlation with amounts of summer (from April to September) monsoon precipitation at inter-annual scales. This is further supported by the observed negative relation between precipitation amounts and regional lake-sediments and speleothems inferred δDp (or δ18Op) values at decadal scales over the past 60 years. Therefore, our reconstructed ~ 35-year resolution monsoon precipitation, inferred from δDwax, reveals a long-term decrease since the mid-Holocene. Superimposed on this trend, there are several multi-centennial to millennial-scale fluctuations for increased monsoon precipitation at 4500–4000 years BP, 2900–2400 years BP and 1200–700 years BP and decreased precipitation at 3900–3000 years BP, 2200–1300 years BP, and 500–0 years BP. Reanalyses of instrumental data and Kiel Climate Model on regional atmosphere circulations show that moisture of this region is mainly derived from the western Pacific Ocean through the East Asian summer monsoon circulation at inter-annual to inter-decadal, and millennial timescales. We conclude that monsoon rainfall in the southwestern Chinese Loess Plateau is likely connected with changes in sea surface temperatures and migrations of the ITCZ in the western Pacific Ocean.

Late Eocene–Oligocene High Relief Paleotopography in the North Central Tibetan Plateau: Insights From Detrital Zircon U–Pb Geochronology and Leaf Wax Hydrogen Isotope Studies

AbstractThe knowledge of provenance and paleoelevation of late Cretaceous‐Cenozoic terrestrial basins is crucial in discriminating different topography growth models for Tibetan Plateau. The Hoh Xil Basin is located in the north central Tibetan Plateau, and its thick sediments provide an excellent record for investigating the growth history of Tibetan Plateau. Here we present an integrated study by applying detrital zircon U–Pb geochronology and leaf wax n‐alkane hydrogen isotope analysis to the Yaxicuo Group in the Tuotuohe subbasin of the southern Hoh Xil Basin. Maximum depositional age from the youngest detrital zircon U–Pb ages, along with previous palynological data, indicates that the Yaxicuo Group was deposited during late Eocene–Oligocene. Provenance analysis shows that the Yaxicuo Group was mainly sourced from the northern Qiangtang and Songpan‐Ganzi terranes. Detrital zircon age spectra of the Yaxicuo Group samples show 33–50 Ma age group in the Tuotuohe subbasin, which is distinctive from those in the Erdaogou subbasin to the north, suggestive of formation of watershed within the Hoh Xil Basin and the tectonic transition from foreland to hinterland basin. The most negative leaf wax hydrogen isotope value yields an estimate of paleoelevation of ~4 km, which records the high elevation of the source regions in the northern Qiangtang. We argue that sedimentary record of the Yaxicuo Group with the interpreted transition from foreland to hinterland basin is the result of the northward propagation of the upper crustal shortening, which in combination with other deep processes caused the surface uplift of the Hoh Xil Basin.

A long-term, high-latitude record of Eocene hydrological change in the Greenland region

A range of proxy approaches have been used to reconstruct short-term changes to Earth's hydrological cycle during the early Eocene hyperthermals. However, little is known about the response of Earth's hydrological and biogeochemical systems to long-term Cenozoic cooling, which began following the Early Eocene Climatic Optimum (53.3 – 49.4 million years ago; Ma). Here, we use the molecular distribution and isotopic composition of terrestrial biomarkers preserved in marine sediments of ODP Site 913, East Greenland, to develop a long-term record of high-latitude hydrological change between 50 and 34 Ma. There is a marked decline in the concentration of conifer-derived diterpenoids and angiosperm-derived triterpenoids during the Eocene. As the input of wind-blown conifer pollen remains stable during this interval, this implies that decreasing di- and triterpenoid concentrations reflect declining influence of fluvial inputs – and perhaps terrestrial runoff – throughout the Eocene. Branched GDGTs and bacterial-derived hopanes indicate an increased input of soil- and kerogen-derived organic matter, respectively, after 38 Ma. This coincides with evidence for ice rafted debris and suggests input of organic matter via glacial processes. This also implies some continental glaciation occurred on East Greenland in the middle-to-late Eocene. Leaf wax hydrogen isotopes extending throughout this section – the first such long-term record from the Paleogene - indicate that precipitation δ2H was persistently higher than that of modern coastal Greenland, consistent with warmer ocean source waters and enhanced poleward moisture transport. Non-intuitively, however, this effect appears to have been smallest during the warmest part of the record, and higher δ2H values occur in the middle Eocene. Although interpretation of these hydrogen isotope trends is unclear, they clearly indicate – alongside the changes in biomarker abundances – a perturbed hydrological cycle through the Eocene in coastal Greenland. More long-term records are required to ascertain if this represents regional or global hydrological reorganisation.

Synchronous rise of African C4 ecosystems 10 million years ago in the absence of aridification

Grasslands expanded globally during the late Cenozoic and the development of these ecosystems shaped the evolution of many faunal groups, including our hominin ancestors. The emergence of these ecosystems has been dated in many regions, but the origins of the iconic African C4 savannah grasslands remain poorly known, as do the causal factors that led to their establishment. Here we document their origins with the distinct carbon isotope signature from the hot-, arid- and low-CO2-adapted C4 grasses that dominate modern savannahs and grasslands. We use the carbon isotope values of leaf-wax molecules in deep-sea drill cores to measure the rise of African C4 ecosystems. We also reconstruct African palaeohydroclimate change from leaf-wax hydrogen isotope values and dust deposition rates in these cores. We find that C4-dominated ecosystems expanded synchronously across Northwestern and East Africa after 10 million years ago. This was not accompanied by substantial changes in palaeohydrology or dust deposition, precluding aridification as a causal factor. The expansion of C4 grasses was coincident, however, with dramatic high-latitude cooling and increased pole–Equator temperature gradients. We suggest that declining atmospheric CO2 levels were a direct cause of the C4 grassland expansion. Aridification did not cause the expansion of ecosystems using the C4 photosynthetic pathway in parts of Africa 10 million years ago, according to leaf-wax analyses in deep-sea drill cores, leaving declining atmospheric carbon dioxide levels as the most plausible cause.

WaxPSM: A Forward Model of Leaf Wax Hydrogen Isotope Ratios to Bridge Proxy and Model Estimates of Past Climate

AbstractThe D/H ratio of epicuticular plant waxes (δDwax) preserved in sedimentary archives is a powerful tool for paleoclimate reconstruction, but comparisons to other proxy records or to climate model simulations requires a proxy system model (PSM) that accounts for transformations between δDprecip and δDwax. Here we present a new, publicly available PSM for plant waxes, WaxPSM. WaxPSM predicts δDwax from observational data or any isotope‐enabled modern, paleo, or future climate model experiment. δD values of the C29 n‐alkane are calculated based on precipitation or soil water δD and observed apparent fractionation values, adjusted for plant‐type differences. Using WaxPSM, we assess three key uncertainties in δDwax records: the degree to which variations in δD may reflect changes in vegetation rather than climate, structural uncertainties that arise from limited water isotopic observations, and the impacts of land cover change on climate reconstructions during the Last Glacial Maximum and the Preindustrial period. Parametric and structural uncertainties can cause δDwax variations up to 50‰, but in most cases, the differences are ∼10–30‰. The drier subtropics are additionally impacted by the incorrect structural assumption that plants' source water, δDsoil, is isotopically similar to the climate variable of interest, δDprecip. We recommend a coordinated, systematic effort to elevate observational constraints on δDprecip, δDsoil, and the δD of multiple compound classes, which would dramatically reduce parametric and structural uncertainties and allow further complexity to be built into the model.