The current study evaluated the potential of clinical parameters and circulating biomarkers to distinguish sepsis from SIRS in patients admitted with systemic inflammation. Clinical parameters, leukocyte counts and platelets were measured on admission. Circulating C-reactive protein (CRP), procalcitonin (PCT) and cytokine concentrations were quantified using laser immunonephelometry, immunoluminescence and a Bio-Plex suspension bead array system respectively. Blood, sputum, urine, peritoneal and cerebrospinal fluid were sent for microscopy and culture. Based on clinical information and the results of microbiological testing, 62 patients were classified retrospectively into 2 groups, those with sepsis (n = 37) or SIRS (n = 25). Mean body temperature was higher and blood pressure lower in the sepsis patients. Circulating concentrations of CRP, PCT, interleukin (IL)-10 and IL-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra) were significantly higher in patients with sepsis, with IL-10 identified as the best biomarker in differentiating sepsis from SIRS. The biomarkers that best predicted overall mortality were platelet counts >PCT ≥ CRP > IL-6 > IL-1Ra. These findings demonstrate that patients with sepsis have significantly increased levels of the immunosuppressive/anti-inflammatory cytokines, IL-1Ra and IL-10, compared to those with SIRS, consistent with a more intense counteracting anti-inflammatory response, while a biomarker profile including platelets, PCT, CRP, IL-6 and IL-1Ra may be useful to predict mortality.