The Canadian boreal forest is still lacking investigation into compatible species mixtures that can lead to higher growth rates than monospecific or pure stands. The effect of species mixtures on stand productivity can vary with stem density, species proportion, site characteristics, and climate variation. We investigated mixed stands of black spruce (Picea mariana) and tamarack (Larix laricina) in eastern Canadian boreal forests. Using modern forest survey data, we analyzed stand basal area variation in 756 mature stands exclusively composed of these two species over a study area spanning 535,000 km². We generated a linear relationship between mixed stand basal area and stem density, and the residual of this relation was used as response variable named ‘residual basal area’. Positive and negative deviations of residual basal area were analysed with generalized additive models and quantile regressions with tamarack basal area, climate, and site characteristics as explanatory variables. The selected model included tamarack basal area, mean seasonal precipitation, degree days, mean annual temperature, stand age, latitude, longitude, and the type of surficial deposit. Tamarack exhibited a linear positive effect on predicted residual basal area. The most significant effect was observed from the interaction between tamarack basal area and stand age, predicting positive residual basal area of 16 m² ha−1 when stand aged was 150 years old and tamarack basal area was between 12 and 17 m² ha−1. Quantile regressions revealed that tamarack could enhance basal area while increasing black spruce stem size and density. Landscape managers may consider the establishment of mixed black spruce and tamarack stands to favor secondary growth in eastern Canadian boreal forests.