Large volumes of seawater have passed through the rocky subseafloor throughout Earth's history. The scale of circulation is sufficiently large to impact the cycling of marine dissolved organic carbon (DOC), one of the largest pools of reduced carbon on Earth whose sources and sinks remain enigmatic, and to sequester carbon over geologic timescales. While the fate of DOC in numerous mafic systems has been examined, no previous reports are available on the less studied but still abundant ultramafic systems. We analyzed the concentration and composition of DOC from the Lost City hydrothermal field (30°N, Mid-Atlantic Ridge), a long-lived ultramafic system with minimal magmatic input. We show that per liter of seawater, more DOC is removed and a rate >650 times faster rate than in mafic ridge flank systems. Simultaneously, newly synthesized 14C-free organics are exported into the water column, adding a pre-aged component to the deep DOC pool. The sequestration of oceanic organic molecules onto minerals could partially account for the substantial total organic carbon present in ultramafic rocks, which is currently interpreted as evidence of chemoautotrophy or abiotic synthesis.