Remote sensing of suspended particulate matter (SPM) is crucial for water-quality monitoring, as it influences turbidity, light availability, or nutrient transport. This study aims to provide a comprehensive evaluation of twelve common and well-used SPM models for the Ocean and Land Color Instrument (OLCI) on-board Sentinel-3 satellite, based on different methods and assumptions, including estimation from water-leaving reflectance or proxies, a combination of semi-analytical equations, and machine learning algorithms. The models are tested in three stages: 1) performance assessment on in-situ measurements, 2) matchup exercise with OLCI and 3) visual assessment of satellite SPM products. The models are first tested on the GLORIA dataset (n = 767, 0.21 g.m−3 <SPM <2,626.82 g.m−3). The matchup analysis is then conducted in French coastal waters using the SOMLIT dataset (n = 71, 0.2 g.m−3 <SPM <722 g.m−3), based on the standard OLCI L2 remote sensing reflectance product. Finally, the visual assessment of the SPM maps provided by the twelve models is conducted for two French coastal sites. Results show that the algorithms proposed by Jiang et al. [ Remote. Sens. Environ. 258, 112386 (2021)10.1016/j.rse.2021.112386 ] and Novoa et al. [ Remote. Sens. 9, 61 (2017)10.3390/rs9010061 ] exhibit the highest score and the most accurate retrievals when compared to in-situ measurements. However, the matchup exercise shows that the method from Jiang et al. demonstrates more overall accurate SPM retrievals (Error = 49.85%, Bias = 0.55%, RMSLE = 0.35, Slope = 1.06). The visual assessment of SPM maps reveals that this model displays a larger dynamic range, making it suitable for applications in regions with a wide range of SPM concentrations. The sensitivity of these models to the atmospheric correction procedure is further explored. When all OLCI spectra are taken into account for the matchup exercise, the performance of the algorithms from Han et al. [ Remote. Sens. 8, 211 (2016)10.3390/rs8030211 ] improve, relative to the other one. Finally, the standard OLCI SPM product is evaluated, and the advantages of using the OLCI standard product over the MODIS one for studying coastal waters are discussed.
Read full abstract