The Silurian organic-rich hot shale deposits represent the origin of 80–90% Paleozoic sourced hydrocarbons on the entire Saharan Platform. As such, it is an area of significant interest for exploring its potential as an unconventional reservoir and gaining new insights into its properties. In this study, the geochemical and mineralogical analysis of eighty-two borehole samples from three studied wells (T, B, and M) located in Jeffara Basin, in southeastern Tunisa, distributed over a depth between 1200 m and 2200 m, show that the hot shale layer has significant potentials of an unconventional shale gas reservoir. According to the rock-eval and GCMS results, the total organic carbon (TOC) of the hot shale deposits is good to great, ranging between 0.54 wt% and 23.86 wt%, and the average hydrogen index (HI) is around ∼200 mg HC/g of TOC, which indicates that the hot shales were originally rich in type II/III organic matter (OM). The thermal maturity of the preserved OM is determined by the kerogen type with values varying from 0.4% to 1%, and Tmax values reaching 460 °C in T, B, and M wells which indicate that the hot shales preserved early mature to mature OM placed within oil/gas generation window. The calculated geochemical parameters reveal an average hydrocarbon generation potential (HGP) for the three studied wells of 20.37 kg HC/ton rock. In addition, the transformation ratios (TR) in T, B, and M wells are, respectively, 21.12%, 30% and 35.25%. However, only B and M wells show a cross-over layer, with oil saturation index (OSI) exceeding 100%, with significant potential as a hydrocarbon saturated source rock, making it a considerable target for unconventional oil exploration. Relevant results of Rock-Eval, biomarkers and XRD exhibit coherent features that reflect reducing marine conditions during the lower Silurian period. Moreover, the mineralogical composition was investigated to estimate the importance of frackable mineral fractions such as quartz (∼15%) and carbonates (calcite-dolomite). Mineral brittleness index (MBI) was calculated and compared to a well-known unconventional reservoir in the Neal shale member of the Floyd shale group in the Black Warrior Basin (US), which displays moderate to low MBI. The hot shales in the study area have a considerable MBI, which could be easily enhanced by hydraulic fracturing to liberate oil/gas from the potentially saturated unconventional shale reservoir.