MLR, ioi.i, 2006 223 Undoubtedly, in terms of disseminating that 'basic information', the volume is a success: with the publication of this collection, a foundation stone has been set down. The volume divides into five sections: a consideration of the material conditions of writing, reading, and publishing, and then four chronological slices from the Tudor era until the Common wealth. Within each section, chapters consider the institutions of literary production: the court, London, the Church, the theatre, the household. There are no chapters on single authors; instead, each chapter ranges across a diver? sity of material?literature is understood in its broadest sense as 'all knowledge [. . .] transmitted in written form' (p. 6)?and so authors recur across various discussions. Old friends crop up in new places. The chapters are, almost without exception, cogent, sometimes masterful, sum? maries of the state of scholarship, written by the scholars one would hope to see in? volved (Martin Butler, David Scott Kastan, Barbara Lewalski, Harold Love, Arthur Marotti, Nigel Smith). There are absolutely no surprises: indeed, many ofthe chap? ters are synopses of their authors' longer works. Lawrence Manley's 'Literature and London', forinstance, is his magnificent Literature and Culture in Early Modern Lon? don (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), in miniature. But it is not really the function of this volume to surprise. As a register of early modern literary studies at the turn of the century?like those epitomes of history and classical learning pub? lished in the seventeenth century?this Cambridge History is a valuable resource. If the collection succeeds in 'general coverage' (p. 1), the ambition to read literature as 'at once [. . .] agent and [. . .] product' is less systematically achieved. Mueller's chapter on the Church demonstrates how productive this methodology can be, as she shows an acute sensitivity to the particular languages of the religious prose of William Tyndale, Simon Fish, and others?demonstrating how texts both 'giv[e] ex? pression to and tak[e] expression from'. Other chapters, however, defy this ambition, and read literature as a passive register of context, an adornment to a pre-textual reality. David Loades on national identity presents a narrative of high politics driven by rulingpersonalities. When Loades makes the magnificently problematic claim that "The partnership between the realm and the monarch was a little like that between a horse and a rider' (p. 214), it feels a long way from the editors' assertion that the 'Cambridge History [. . .] breaks down the background/foreground dichotomy' (p. 4) 'to [. . .] challenge monolithic views of power' (p. 8). In collaborative projects there is inevitably a gap between theoretical claims and contributing chapters; while these inconsistencies do not fundamentally undermine the achievement of this state-of-thenation collection, they are significant since the editors' stated ambition is to embody 'recent [. . .] methodological developments in English literary studies' (p. 1). University of Reading Adam Smyth John Donne and Conformityin Crisis in the Late Jacobean Pulpit. By Jeanne Shami. (Studies in Renaissance Literature, 13) Cambridge: Brewer. 2003. ix + 318 pp. ?50; $85. ISBN 0-85991-789-4. The author of this magnificent book, Jeanne Shami, shot to international scholarly fame with her discovery in December 1992 that the anonymously catalogued British Library MS Royal 17. B. XX was a rare contemporaneous scribal copy of John Donne's 1622 Gunpowder Plot sermon. The real significance of this discovery was Shami's definitive attribution of the correcting hand to Donne himself. Shami makes clear in the book under review how much we lose in approaching any sermon in a printed edition, for of course all sermons originated as performances. Her biblio? graphy alone, listing manuscript and printed primary sources, published secondary 224 Reviews material, and unpublished Ph.D.s and papers, is staggering. Shami furthermore pro? vides an exemplary general index as well as indexes of references to Donne and to his sermons. Shami focuses on 1621-25, the final turbulent years of the reign of James VI & I, concluding with a brilliant account of the firstsermon Donne preached before Charles I, on 3 April 1625 at St James's Palace. There are good grounds for this focus. The Synod of Dort had met in 1618-19 with James's delegation of the...