ABSTRACT The aim of this exploratory study was to gather survey data from itinerant teachers of the deaf (IToDs) to better understand the impact of different classroom scenarios on 6- to 9-year-old Deaf or hard of hearing students’ listening and learning. Across two surveys, 109 IToDs (Study 1) and 18 IToDs (Study 2) were either asked to list the positive or negative implications for students’ listening and learning during lecture-style lessons, guided-learning groups, and self-directed/independent work (Study 1), or were asked to rank the importance of each of the implications (Study 2). The different types of classroom scenarios differentially impacted students’ listening and learning outcomes. In lecture-style, the IToDs reported that assistive devices worked well, but there was less support for the student in this scenario. For guided-learning, IToDs identified background noise as problematic, but as the students were engaged in classroom discussions, the IToDs felt that it was also a beneficial scenario for developing social skills. When students were engaged in self-directed/independent work, IToDs noted that while the quieter environment could be beneficial for the student’s concentration, it can also be quite isolating for the student. Overall, this study provided helpful insights from IToDs into the factors affecting listening and learning during different classroom scenarios for students who are Deaf or hard of hearing. The challenges and benefits these students encounter in the different learning settings revealed valuable insights that can be utilized by educators and policymakers aiming to optimize educational outcomes for this demographic.