Segatella is a prevalent genus within individuals’ gut microbiomes worldwide, especially in non-Western populations. Although metagenomic assembly and genome isolation have shed light on its genetic diversity, the lack of available isolates from this genus has resulted in a limited understanding of how members’ genetic diversity translates into phenotypic diversity. Within the confines of a single gut microbiome, we have isolated 63 strains from diverse lineages of Segatella. We performed comparative analyses that exposed differences in cellular morphologies, preferences in polysaccharide utilization, yield of short-chain fatty acids, and antibiotic resistance across isolates. We further show that exposure to Segatella isolates either evokes strong or muted transcriptional responses in human intestinal epithelial cells. Our study exposes large phenotypic differences within related Segatella isolates, extending this to host-microbe interactions.