Lisa Benz St. John's excellent book is a meticulously researched, theoretically engaged comparative study of three queens-consort who reigned in early fourteenth- century England: Margaret of France (ca. 1279–1318), second wife of Edward I; Isabella of France (1295–1358), wife of Edward II; and Philippa of Hainault (ca. 1310 or 1315–1369), wife of Edward III. They lived in tumultuous times that witnessed war with Scotland and France, struggles with testy nobles, the rocky reign of Edward II, Isabella's coup, and Edward III's counter-coup. Through it all, these queens incrementally used the symbolic power of status, marriage, and motherhood to offset the disadvantages of gender and achieve, to varying degrees, considerable authority to administer estates and lands and sometimes to govern as regent. As a longitudinal study, this book resembles J. L. Laynesmith's The Last Medieval Queens: English Queenship, 1445–1503 (2004) and Kavita Mudan Finn's The Last Plantagenet Consorts: Gender, Genre, and Historiography, 1440–1627 (2012), but it is strikingly different. Laynesmith focused on what it meant to be a queen and Finn analyzed narrative depictions of queens, but St. John looks at what queens actually did. Deeply rooted in archival material, this is a political history that interrogates some long-held notions of power and authority in the practice of queenship.
Read full abstract