Radiation Dose Rate Research Articles

Characterization of an Inorganic Powder-Based Scintillation Detector Under a UHDR Electron Beam

(1) Background: Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) radiation therapy needs a reliable dosimetry solution and scintillation detectors are promising candidates. In this study, we characterized an inorganic powder-based scintillation detector under a 9 MeV UHDR electron beam. (2) Methods: A mixture of ZnS:Ag powder and optic glue was coupled to an 8 m Eska GH-4001-P polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) optical fiber. We evaluated the dependence of the detector on dose per pulse (DPP), pulse repetition frequency (PRF), and pulse width (PW). Additionally, we determined the stability and the reproducibility of the detector. (3) Results: The signal ratio between the PMMA clear optical fiber and the ZnS:Ag scintillator was around 210. ZnS:Ag produced a signal yield 54 times greater than that of a BCF-12 plastic scintillator. Signal variation with PRF changes was under 0.5%. The signal was linear to the integrated dose up to the maximum deliverable dose, 180 Gy. The variation in signal was linear to the change in both PW and DPP. Regarding stability, the standard deviation of 10 consecutive irradiations was 0.83%. For the reproducibility, all daily measurements varied within ±1.5%. (4) Conclusions: These findings show that the ZnS:Ag detector can be used for accurate dosimetry with UHDR beams.

In situ measurement of environmental $$\gamma$$ radiation dose rates of key nuclides for large radioactive surface sources

In situ measurement of environmental $$\gamma$$ radiation dose rates of key nuclides for large radioactive surface sources

Ultra-high dose rate (FLASH) radiotherapy: revolutionizing tumor targeting and microenvironmental dynamics in cancer treatment.

Ultra-high dose rate (FLASH) radiotherapy: revolutionizing tumor targeting and microenvironmental dynamics in cancer treatment.

Oxidative stress on the male reproductive organs of wild mice collected from an area contaminated by radioactive materials in Fukushima

The Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant accident caused the release of large amounts of radioactive material into the environment. Radiation from radionuclides cause DNA lesions, mainly via oxidation, which adversely affect wild organisms by damaging their germ cells. Here, we investigated the effects of radiation on the reproductive organs of Japanese field mice (Apodemus speciosus) by estimating the dose rate of radiation exposure, the accumulation of DNA lesions, and the expression of DNA repair enzymes. In highly contaminated areas, mouse testes received a radiation dose rate > 0.1 mGy/d. According to the International Commission on Radiological Protection, there is a very low probability of effects in the reference rat species at this exposure level. The results of the current study do not definitively conclude that the expression of 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase 1 and superoxide dismutase in mouse testes increase with dose rate and lifetime dose. However, 8-hydroxy-2′-deoxyguanosine accumulation increases in a dose rate- and lifetime dose-dependent manner in mouse testes, but is not observed in the sperm of the cauda epididymis. These results suggest that, although DNA lesions occurred in male germ cells of Fukushima mice, most were successfully repaired by DNA repair enzymes at the observed gene expression level.

OPOS-1000: Advancing the efficiency of VVER-1000 spent nuclear fuel cask loading

This study delves into the optimization of dual-purpose casks utilized for storing and transporting spent nuclear fuel from VVER-1000 reactors. Central to this investigation is the assessment of radiation dose rates surrounding the casks, facilitated by the novel OPOS-1000 calculation tool, which incorporates adjoint flux techniques for enhanced precision. This tool enables the strategic placement of hotter fuel assemblies at the core, surrounded by cooler ones, effectively minimizing radiation exposure through a carefully designed zoning strategy. Detailed analyses conducted with OPOS-1000 offer insights into the optimal configuration offuel assemblies to reduce radiation levels, presenting a significant advancement in spent fuel cask loading efficiency. This research’s findings have the potential to streamline the loading process and influence the certification of new fuel types for existing casks, marking a pivotal step forward in spent nuclear fuel management.

Analysis of the decay process of the radiation dose rate using open data on the Internet

Analysis of the decay process of the radiation dose rate using open data on the Internet

Calculation and application research on real-time source term diffusion in NPP auxiliary building under accident circumstances

Abstract In the light of radioactive material leakage (due to containment bypass or failure) to the auxiliary building and its service compartments under severe accident circumstances, key techniques related to accident source terms in the nuclear emergency building were researched. During the research, the source-term diffusion and migration patterns were simulated in the building compartments, including the simulation of the gradual diffusion and decay process (driven by circulating air) of fission-derived gases and aerosol toward each compartment. Besides that, by taking a M310 unit at Fangjiashan NPP as the application object, the scenarios of initial accidents of LB/MB/SB-LOCA, MSLB and SGTR were chosen to establish a real-time diffusion calculation model for in-building radioactive source terms under nuclear accident circumstances. While considering the circumstances before and after being intervened by accident mitigation measures, the concentration distribution of radionuclides in the auxiliary building and personnel total-exposure radiation dose rate were quickly assessed online, and a basis was provided for the visualization of radiation dosage and the assessment of received radiation dosage and injury & death hazards during personnel activities outside the main control room.

Long-term effects of continuous low dose-rate gamma-ray irradiation on mouse hematopoietic cells.

The present work investigates the long-term effects of continuous low dose-rate (20mGy/day to total doses of 1-8Gy) gamma-ray exposure on the hematopoietic cells of specific pathogen-free C3H/HeN mice. Peripheral white blood cell (WBC) counts decreased on days 206, 471, and 486, with no significant changes in red blood cell (RBC) and platelet (PLT) counts. The number of colony forming units (CFU-S and CFU-GM) in the bone marrow and spleen from irradiated mice decreased with increasing total dose on day-12 and day-7. The decrease in bone marrow CFU-S persisted throughout the 400-day irradiation period and did not show any recovery up to 210days postirradiation. These findings suggest that the effects of low-dose-rate (LDR) radiation on the hematopoietic system remain long after the 400-day irradiation was completed. Further investigation showed no significant difference in life spans of non-irradiated W/Wv (c-kit-deficient) mice inoculated with hematopoietic stem cells from irradiated (20mGy/day for 400days) or nonirradiated wild-type mice. These results suggest that the effects of continuous low-dose-rate irradiation are more pronounced in hematopoietic stromal cells than in HSCs themselves.

Toxicity assessment following conventional radiation therapy and pulsed low dose rate radiation therapy: an in vivo animal study

BackgroundPulsed low dose rate radiotherapy (PLDR) is a new radiation delivery method, in which the fractional dose is divided into sub-fractional doses with periodical time breaks in between. The goal of our study is to assess the toxicity on healthy tissues resulting from PLDR as compared to conventional radiotherapy (CRT) using the same physical X-ray dose.MethodsWe analyzed the weight and survival time for CRT and PLDR groups and studied the inflammatory cytokine transforming Growth Factor-β (TGF-β), usually released following irradiation. Histopathological and immunohistochemical analyses were conducted for intestinal and bone marrow tissues from rats subjected to 8 Gy whole- body irradiation using CRT and PLDR techniques. We investigated genotoxicity by performing a comet assay (CA) in splenic tissues.ResultsOur findings showed an improvement in survival time with PLDR versus CRT by 82%.The mean survival time for CRT rats’ group was 6.3 days, while it was 35.9 days for PLDR group.The weight of CRT group decreased gradually by 3.7%, while weight of PLDR group increased gradually by 2.4%.CRT resulted in more cellular atrophy in bone marrow and intestinal tissues than in PLDR treatments as shown by hematoxylin and eosin staining analysis. In addition, the transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) expression in bone marrow and intestinal tissues of CRT was higher than those expressed in tissues from PLDR as demonstrated by the Immuno reactive score (IRS). It was10(0.53) and 9.8(0.55) for BM and intestinal tissues, respectively from CRT group and 5.8(0.63) for PLDR for both tissues. The measured CA parameters were larger with CRT compared to PLDR, where the Tail Length (TL), Tail DNA % (TD%) and Tail Moment (TM) measurements were 25.4(3.4), 56.5(7.6) % and 20.5(3.5) for CRT, 7.3(1.9), 30.0(7.2) % and 5.7(1.8) for PLDR, with P value 0.000064, 0.0004 and 0.00017, respectively.ConclusionThis study indicates that PLDR can reduce the toxicity on normal tissues compared to CRT.

Construction of a realistic voxel phantom of the Japanese red fox (Vulpes vulpes japonica) based on MRI imaging and estimation of its background external radiation dose rate from environmental radionuclides.

In this study, we selected the Japanese red fox (Vulpes vulpes japonica) as a representative mid-size mammal from the forests near the spent nuclear fuel reprocessing plant at Rokkasho. A fox voxel phantom was constructed based on magnetic resonance imaging of a female red fox caught in Rokkasho. This phantom consisted of 264×321×383 voxels (each voxel size: 0.78×0.78×2mm) with internal organs. The external radiation dose rate to the voxel phantom by beta and gamma rays from environmental radionuclides was estimated using a Monte Carlo code (EGS4 and UCPIXEL). We estimated the dose rates to the phantom on the ground and in an average fox burrow in the Rokkasho forest, which were 11 and 27 nGy h-1, respectively. Assuming that the animal on the ground was irradiated by cosmic rays of 27 nGy h-1, the total external dose rate was evaluated to be 38 nGy h-1. Based on the assumption that the fox lives on the ground for 12h and in the burrow for 12h, the dose rate was estimated to be 33 nGy h-1.

Does environmental enrichment mitigate the adverse effects of chronic low dose-rate radiation exposure on mice?

The purpose of the study was to determine whether environmental enrichments (EE) can mitigate the adverse effects of chronic low-dose-rate radiation exposure in mice. Female B6C3F1 mice were continuously exposed to 20mGyd-1 gamma-rays under specific-pathogen-free conditions since 8weeks of age for 400d. After completion of the radiation exposure, OV3121 cells, derived from an ovarian granulosa cell tumor, were inoculated subcutaneously alongside age-matched non-irradiated control mice. Irradiated mice were shown to have a significantly reduced ability to eliminate inoculated tumors. The results indicate that EE may be able to mitigate the adverse effects of low-dose-rate radiation exposure, but the effects vary greatly and are complex depending on the type of EE.

RBIO-02. DEVELOPMENT OF FLASH-CAR RADIOIMMUNOTHERAPY FOR PEDIATRIC BRAIN TUMORS

Abstract Pediatric brain tumors including medulloblastoma and high-grade glioma are generally refractory to T cell-based immunotherapy, largely due to an immune-hostile microenvironment infiltrated extensively with immunosuppressive macrophages. Ultra-high dose rate (FLASH) radiotherapy holds promise for treating solid tumors, given the potential lower toxicity in normal tissues and possible favorable impact on tumor immunity. Using a genetically engineered mouse model of medulloblastoma and glioma, we show that FLASH radiation stimulates pro-inflammatory polarization in tumor macrophages. Single-cell transcriptome analysis shows that FLASH proton beam radiation skews macrophages towards proinflammatory phenotypes and increases T cell infiltration in the medulloblastoma model. Further bulk transcriptome analyses reveal that FLASH radiation reduces peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR)-γ and arginase-1 expression and inhibits immunosuppressive macrophage polarization under stimulus-inducible conditions. Mechanistically, FLASH radiation abrogates lipid oxidase expression and oxidized low-density lipid (oxLDL) generation to reduce PPARγ activity, while standard radiation induces reactive oxygen species (ROS)-dependent PPARγ activation in macrophages. Notably, FLASH radiotherapy improves infiltration and activation of chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cells and sensitizes tumors to GD2 CAR T immunotherapy in the autochthonous medulloblastoma and syngeneic glioma models. These findings suggest that FLASH radiotherapy may reprogram macrophage lipid metabolism to reverse tumor immunosuppression and that combination FLASH-CAR radioimmunotherapy may offer exciting opportunities for treatment of pediatric brain tumor.

Influence of electron radiation of spring barley seeds on phytopathogenic microflora

Under the conditions of a model pot experiment, the effect of electron irradiation on the phytopathogenic microflora of plant roots and leaves was studied. The studies were carried out on spring barley seeds of the Vladimir variety (reproduction 1), affected by helminthosporiosis (pathogen Bipolaris sorokiniana Shoem.), (natural infectious background). This pathogen causes root rot and leaf spot. The grain was irradiated using a wide-aperture electron accelerator “Duet” with a mesh plasma cathode and the output of the generated beam of a large cross-section into the atmosphere in doses of 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 kGy. The total administered dose was increased by changing the number of pulses. The radiation dose rate was 100 Gy/pulse, the electron energy was 130 keV (mode 1) and 160 keV (mode 2). The depth of dose absorption did not exceed 300 μm. Based on the conducted studies on the effect of electron irradiation on root rot (pathogen Bipolaris sorokiniana) of spring barley, it was noted that in the tillering and heading phases, when irradiating seed material with a dose of 2 kGy in mode 1 (130 keV), the disease incidence and prevalence decreased by more than 1.5 times compared to the non-irradiated control. In the phase of full grain maturity, the highest value of root infestation (45–50%) and prevalence (95–100%) of Bipolaris sorokiniana were recorded, but statistically significant differences between the irradiated variants and the control were absent. The records of the damage of vegetative plants showed that in the tillering phase, for all irradiation variants in mode 1, the degree of damage to leaves 1–3 increased by 23% compared to the control, and in the heading phase, the degree of damage to the upper leaves (1–3) exceeded the control when irradiated at doses of 2–5 kGy (mode 1) and 1–5 kGy (mode 2) – 2.1–2.8 times for 1 leaf, 1.9–2.0 times for 2 leaves and 1.2 times for 3 leaves.

Initial feasibility cohort of temporally modulated pulsed proton re-irradiation (TMPPR) for recurrent high-grade intracranial malignancies

Recurrent high-grade intracranial malignancies have a grim prognosis and uniform management guidelines are lacking. Re-irradiation is underused due to concerns about irreversible side effects. Pulsed-reduced dose rate radiotherapy (PRDR) aims to reduce toxicity while improving tumor control by exploiting dose-rate effects. We share our initial experience with temporally modulated pulsed proton re-irradiation (TMPPR), focusing on workflow, safety, feasibility, and outcomes for the first patient cohort. TMPPR was administered to patients with recurrent or progressive central nervous system malignancies using intensity modulated proton therapy with three fields. Patient and treatment data were collected, responses categorized using RANO assessment, and toxicities graded using CTCAE v5.0. Five patients received TMPPR between October 2022 and May 2023, with a median age of 54 years (Range: 32–72), and a median time from initial radiotherapy to re-RT of 23 months (Range 14–40). Treatment was completed without delay, with a median dose of 60 GyRBE in 30 fractions. Initial treatment response assessment showed complete (n = 1) or partial (n = 3) responses. Limited toxicity was observed, primarily grade 2 alopecia and one case of radiation necrosis graded at 2. This early experience demonstrates the feasibility of TMPPR delivery, highlighting the importance of prospective evaluations in the re-irradiation setting.

Proton FLASH Irradiation Using a Synchrotron Accelerator: Differences by Irradiation Positions

PurposeTo establish an ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) radiation system using a synchrotron proton beam accelerator and to compare the effects by irradiation positions on cultured cells and chick embryos. Methods and MaterialsProtons for UHDR were obtained by applying high-frequency power at much higher levels than usual to extract all protons within approximately 50 ms. Subsequently, monitoring with a Faraday cup was performed immediately after synchrotron extraction and the waveform was adjusted accordingly. Four cultured tumor lines, two normal cell lines, and chick embryos were used. Ultra-high dose-rate radiation (UHDR-RT) at 6-18 Gy (200-300 Gy/s, single exposure) and conventional dose-rate radiation (Conv-RT) at 6-18 Gy (3 Gy/s) were administered to the 1-cm spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP) and the plateau region preceding SOBP. Following irradiation, disparities in cell growth rates and cell cycle progression were assessed, and cell survival was evaluated via colony assay. Chick embryos were also examined for survival. ResultsUHDR-RT was achieved at a range of 40 to 800 Gy/s, encompassing both plateau and peak phases. In vitro studies demonstrated similar cell-killing effects between UHDR-RT and Conv-RT in cancer cells. Significant apoptotic effects and G2 arrest were observed during the cell cycle under peak UHDR-RT conditions. The FLASH effect was not observed in normal single cells under normal atmospheric conditions. Stronger cell-killing effects were noted in V79 spheroids exposed to peak UHDR-RT than peak Conv-RT. Moreover, in chick embryos, an increase in survival rate, indicative of the FLASH effect, was observed. ConclusionsThe FLASH effect was also achieved with UHDR-RT using a synchrotron proton beam accelerator in chick embryos. The cell-killing effects in cancer cells were higher with peak UHDR-RT which may be due to the higher linear energy transfer at the SOBP.

Effects of ultra-high dose rate radiotherapy with different fractions and dose rate on acute and chronic lung injury in mice

Ultra-high dose rate radiotherapy (FLASH radiation) can naturally render normal tissues around the tumor tissue resistant to radiotherapy. In contrast, the tumor tissue remains sensitive to radiation under the same conditions. However, the effects of different fractions and dose rates on FLASH radiation remain unclear. This study aimed to determine the optimal dose rate and fraction of FLASH radiation for thoracic radiotherapy. Female Balb/c mice aged 6–8 weeks were irradiated with different dose rates (100 Gy/s or 250 Gy/s) and fractions (1, 2, or 4). Survival was observed in mice receiving 30Gy, with lung tissue examined for acute radiation damage 48 h post-radiation. Late radiation pneumonia and survival rates were monitored in mice irradiated with 20 Gy. The median overall survival (OS) was not reached on the 95th day for mice irradiated with 250 Gy/s FLASH radiation, while it was 89.5 days for those irradiated with 100 Gy/s (P = 0.0436). Mice irradiated with 30 Gy/2 Fr and 250 Gy/s FLASH had shorter median OS than those with 30 Gy/1F (P = 0.0132). However, there was no significant difference in OS between mice irradiated with 30 Gy/2 F and 30 Gy/4 F. Survival curves for mice receiving 20 Gy showed no significant difference in toxicity between different dose rates and fractions. FLASH radiation at 250 Gy/s reduced the incidence of acute radiation pneumonitis in mice compared to 100 Gy/s. Different fractions of irradiation influenced survival in mice, but they were only observed in acute radiation reactions and not chronic radiation reactions. Among the tested fraction methods, fraction 2 had the worst impact on the survival of mice, while fractions 1 and 4 showed similar effects and improved survival compared to fraction 2.

Characterization of a time-resolved, real-time scintillation dosimetry system for ultra-high dose rate radiation therapy applications

BackgroundScintillation dosimetry has promising qualities for ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) radiotherapy (RT), but no system has shown compatibility with mean dose rates (DR‾) above 100 Gy/s and doses per pulse (Dp) exceeding 1.5 Gy typical of UHDR (FLASH)-RT. The aim of this study was to characterize a novel scintillation dosimetry system with the potential of accommodating UHDRs. Methods and MaterialsWe undertook a thorough dosimetric characterization of the system on an UHDR electron beamline. The system's response as a function of dose, DR‾, Dp, and the pulse dose rate (DRp) was investigated, as was the system's dose sensitivity (signal per unit dose) as a function of dose history. The capabilities of the system for time-resolved dosimetric readout were also evaluated. ResultsWithin a tolerance of ±3%, the system exhibited dose linearity and was independent of DR‾ and Dp within the tested ranges of 1.8–1341 Gy/s and 0.005–7.68 Gy, respectively. A 6% reduction in the signal per unit dose was observed as DRp was increased from 8.9e4 to 1.8e6 Gy/s. The dose delivered per integration window of the continuously sampling photodetector had to remain between 0.028 and 11.56 Gy to preserve a stable signal response per unit dose. The system accurately measured Dp of individual pulses delivered at up to 120 Hz. The day-to-day variation of the signal per unit dose in a reference setup varied by up to ±13% but remained consistent (<±2%) within each treatment day and showed no signal loss as a function of dose history. ConclusionsWith daily calibrations and DRp-specific correction factors, the system reliably provides real-time, millisecond-resolved dosimetric measurements of pulsed conventional and UHDR beams from typical electron linacs, marking an important advancement in UHDR dosimetry and offering diverse applications to FLASH-RT and related fields.

Characterizing devices for validation of dose, dose rate, and LET in ultra high dose rate proton irradiations.

Ultra high dose rate (UHDR) radiotherapy using ridge filter is a new treatment modality known as conformal FLASH that, when optimized for dose, dose rate (DR), and linear energy transfer (LET), has the potential to reduce damage to healthy tissue without sacrificing tumor killing efficacy via the FLASH effect. Clinical implementation of conformal FLASH proton therapy has been limited by quality assurance (QA) challenges, which include direct measurement of UHDR and LET. Voxel DR distributions and LET spectra at planning target margins are paramount to the DR/LET-related sparing of organs at risk. We hereby present a methodology to achieve experimental validation of these parameters. Dose, DR, and LET were measured for a conformal FLASH treatment plan involving a 250-MeV proton beam and a 3D-printed ridge filter designed to uniformly irradiate a spherical target. We measured dose and DR simultaneously using a 4D multi-layer strip ionization chamber (MLSIC) under UHDR conditions. Additionally, we developed an "under-sample and recover (USRe)" technique for a high-resolution pixelated semiconductor detector, Timepix3, to avoid event pile-up and to correct measured LET at high-proton-flux locations without undesirable beam modifications. Confirmation of these measurements was done using a MatriXX PT detector and by Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. MC conformal FLASH computed doses had gamma passing rates of>95% (3mm/3% criteria) when compared to MatriXX PT and MLSIC data. At the lateral margin, DR showed average agreement values within 0.3% of simulation at 100Gy/s and fluctuations ∼10% at 15Gy/s. LET spectra in the proximal, lateral, and distal margins had Bhattacharyya distances of<1.3%. Our measurements with the MLSIC and Timepix3 detectors shown that the DR distributions for UHDR scenarios and LET spectra using USRe are in agreement with simulations. These results demonstrate that the methodology presented here can be used effectively for the experimental validation and QA of FLASH treatment plans.

Measurements of Heavy Elements and Radioactivity Concentration Levels in Types of Fertilizers and Pesticides Commonly Used in Sana’a Yemen

This study aims to measure heavy metals (HMs) concentration and radioactivity concentration levels in fertilizer and pesticide samples collected from local markets in Sana’a, Yemen. Gamma spectroscopy employing a Survey Sodium Iodide NaI (TI) RIIDEYM-G detector was used for radiation and dose assessments. As for heavy metal analyses, this study used Inductively Coupled Optical Emission Spectroscopy (ICP-OES). Thirty samples were collected from local markets in Sana’a, Yemen. Radioactivity measurements show low levels of radioactivity concentration. The average dose rates due to fertilizer and pesticide samples were 1.14 and 1.07 mSv/y, respectively. These values are nearly equal to the recommended annual radiation dose rate limit (1mSv/y) recommended by the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP). For heavy metal analysis, it was found that the average concentrations of heavy metals (HMs) (cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), iron (Fe), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), and zinc (Zn)) in the fertilizer samples were 1.08 mg/kg, 4.944 mg/kg, 13.8495 mg/kg, 274.371 mg/kg, 3.30446 mg/kg, 15.35686 mg/kg, and 24.4547 mg/kg, respectively. Heavy metal concentrations in fertilizer samples were mainly less than European (EU) guideline limits, with the exception of a few samples. The average concentrations of heavy metals (Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, Ni, Pb, and Zn) in the pesticide samples were 0.8 mg/kg, 0.5784 mg/kg, 52.280 mg/kg, 73.4651 mg/kg, 2.4482 mg/kg, 3.199 mg/kg, and 1.1309 mg/kg, respectively. The heavy metal concentrations in pesticide samples were less than the corresponding values in fertilizer samples.

Radiation adaptive response for constant dose-rate irradiation in high background radiation areas

AbstractThe presented paper describes the problem of human health in regions with high level of natural ionizing radiation in various places in the world. The radiation adaptive response biophysical model was presented and calibrated for the special case of constant dose-rate irradiation. The calibration was performed for the data of residents of several high background radiation areas, like Ramsar in Iran, Kerala in India or Yangjiang in China. Studied end-points were: chromosomal aberrations, cancer incidence and cancer mortality. For the case of aberrations, among collected publications about 45% have shown the existence of adaptive response. Average reduction of chromosomal aberrations was ∼ 10%, while for the case of cancer incidence it was ∼ 15% and ∼ 17% for cancer mortality (each taking into account only results showing adaptive response). Results of the other 55% of data regarding chromosomal aberrations have been tested with the LNT (linear no-threshold) hypothesis, but results were inconsistent with the linear model. The conditions for adaptive response occurrence are still unknown, but it is postulated to correlate with the distribution of individual radiosensitivity among members of surveyed populations.