Magnetosphere-ionosphere System Research Articles

Importance of the dusk-dawn interplanetary magnetic field component (IMF By) to magnetospheric convection in Earth’s magnetotail plasma sheet

The solar wind and its embedded magnetic field, the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) together with magnetic reconnection power the large-scale plasma and magnetic flux circulation in the Earth’s magnetosphere-ionosphere system. This circulation is termed as convection and its strength is controlled by the north-south IMF component (IMF Bz). In recent years, an interest has arisen to investigate the lesser-known role of the dusk-dawn component (IMF By) in convection. It has been previously known though that prevailing nonzero IMF By can cause plasma flow asymmetries in the high-latitude ionosphere, but how the magnetospheric flows, for instance, in the magnetotail plasma sheet are affected, remains to be investigated. In this article, we introduce the recent progress and the latest achievements in the research of the influence of IMF By on tail plasma sheet convection. The research progress has been rapid and it has revealed that both fast and slow convection are affected in a manner that is in accordance with the asymmetries observed in the ionospheric convection. The results indicate the significance of the IMF By component on magnetospheric convection and they represent a major advance in the field of solar wind-magnetosphere coupling.

Probabilistic modelling of substorm occurrences with an echo state network

Abstract. The relationship between solar-wind conditions and substorm activity is modelled with an approach based on an echo state network. Substorms are a fundamental physical phenomenon in the magnetosphere–ionosphere system, but the deterministic prediction of substorm onset is very difficult because the physical processes that underlie substorm occurrences are complex. To model the relationship between substorm activity and solar-wind conditions, we treat substorm onset as a stochastic phenomenon and represent the stochastic occurrences of substorms with a non-stationary Poisson process. The occurrence rate of substorms is then described with an echo state network model. We apply this approach to two kinds of substorm onset proxies. One is a sequence of substorm onsets identified from auroral electrojet intensity, and the other is onset events identified from activity of Pi2 pulsations, which are irregular geomagnetic oscillations often associated with substorm onsets. We then analyse the response of substorm activity to solar-wind conditions by feeding synthetic solar-wind data into the echo state network. The results indicate that the effect of the solar-wind speed is important, especially for Pi2 substorms. A Pi2 pulsation can often occur even if the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) is northward, while the activity of auroral electrojets is depressed during northward IMF conditions. We also observe spiky enhancements in the occurrence rate of substorms when the solar-wind density abruptly increases, which might suggest an external triggering due to a sudden impulse of solar-wind dynamic pressure. It seems that northward turning of the IMF also contributes to substorm occurrences, though the effect is likely to be minor.

Three principal components describe the spatiotemporal development of mesoscale ionospheric equivalent currents around substorm onsets

Abstract. Substorms are a commonly occurring but insufficiently understood form of dynamics in the coupled magnetosphere–ionosphere system, associated with space weather disturbances and auroras. We have used principal component analysis (PCA) to characterize the spatiotemporal development of ionospheric equivalent currents as observed by the International Monitor for Auroral Geomagnetic Effects (IMAGE) magnetometers during 28 substorm onsets identified by Frey et al. (2004). Auroral observations were provided by all-sky cameras. We found that the equivalent currents can typically be described by three components: a channel of poleward equivalent current (wedgelet), a westward electrojet (WEJ) associated with an auroral arc, and a vortex. The WEJ and vortex are located at the equatorward end of the channel, which has been associated with bursty bulk flows (BBFs) by previous studies. Depending on its polarity, the vortex either indents the WEJ and arc equatorward or bulges the WEJ poleward while winding the arc into an auroral spiral. In addition, there may be a background current system associated with the large-scale convection. The dynamics of the WEJ, vortex, and channel can describe up to 95 % of the variance of the time derivative of the equivalent currents during the examined 20 min interval. Rapid geomagnetic variations at the substorm onset location, which can drive geomagnetically induced currents (GICs) in technological conductor networks, are mainly associated with the oscillations of the WEJ, which may be driven by oscillations of the transition region between dipolar and tail-like field lines in the magnetotail due to the BBF impact. The results contribute to the understanding of substorm physics and to the understanding of processes that drive intense GICs.

Physical effects from the powerful Tonga volcanic eruption of January 15, 2022, in the earth–atmosphere–ionosphere–magnetosphere system

The powerful Tonga volcanic explosion and eruption has been reliably determined to cause numerous processes on a global scale; nevertheless, a comprehensive model of these processes is absent in the literature, which remains an urgent scientific objective. The purpose of this paper is to thoroughly analyze and model the main physical processes that accompanied the volcanic explosion within the Earth (lithosphere, tectonosphere, ocean) – atmosphere – ionosphere – magnetosphere (EAIM) system on January 15, 2022. The study attempts, for the first time, to comprehensively model or estimate the magnitude of the main effects arising in the solid Earth, the troposphere, the ionosphere, and in the magnetosphere. The effects include a rich assortment of waves: Lamb, sound, seismic, tsunami, infrasonic, and atmospheric gravity waves, which propagated on a global scale, with the blast wave launching secondary tsunamis and seismic waves. The powerful waves nonlinearly distorted their profiles and suffered nonlinear attenuation, while the electrical processes in the troposphere caused perturbations in the global electric circuit enhancing the strength of the ionospheric electric fields by one to two orders of magnitude that led to the emergence of secondary processes in the magnetosphere and radiation belts. The volcanic explosion excited all resonators in the EAIM system, perturbing their parameters. Resonances occurred in the Earth's solid shell (Rayleigh wave), in the Earth–ionosphere cavity (Schumann resonances), in the atmosphere (acoustic resonance), in the ionosphere (Alfvén resonances), and in the magnetosphere (magnetospheric resonance). The magnetic effect has been estimated of the submarine volcanic explosion and eruption (∼100–1000 nT), the tsunami (∼0.1 nT), of the volcanic plume (∼1–10 nT), and in the ionosphere due to the ionospheric hole (ΔB ∼ 0.1–10 nT) and an external current in the atmospheric wave field (ΔB ∼ 0.1–1 nT). The magnetospheric effects were caused by electromagnetic emissions in the ∼10–100 kHz band generated by lightning in the volcanic plume, which triggered the precipitation of energetic radiation belt particles into the ionosphere. This is the first time that feedback and main coupling processes, positive and negative, have been observed to emerge among the EAIM system components.

A Tropical Cyclone or Typhoon as an Element of the Earth–Atmosphere–Ionosphere–Magnetosphere System: Theory, Simulations, and Observations

The premise has been validated that a tropical cyclone (TC, typhoon, hurricane), one of the most powerful large-scale formations systematically arising in the atmosphere, is an element of the ocean–atmosphere–ionosphere–magnetosphere system. The TC plays a crucial role with regard to a global-scale mass and energy exchange in this system. The study of this system encompasses a broad spectrum of physical phenomena occurring and processes operating within the system components, as well as the mechanisms of their interactions. The problem under discussion pertains to interdisciplinary science. Its scope ranges from different Earth sciences to geospace sciences, which comprise the physics of the ocean, meteorology, the physics of the Earth’s atmospheric and space environment, etc. Observations of the ionospheric response to the impact of a number of unique typhoons made using multifrequency multiple path oblique incidence ionospheric sounding have confirmed the definitive role that the internal gravity waves and infrasound play in producing atmospheric–ionospheric disturbances. It has been demonstrated that these disturbances are capable of significantly affecting the characteristics of high-frequency radio waves.

A review of N+ observations in the ionosphere-magnetosphere system

Most studies have yet to consider and assess the transport and energization of N+ ions throughout the ionosphere-magnetosphere system, in addition to that of O+ and other heavy ion species. The limited observational record of N+ presence in near-Earth plasma, partly due to instrument limitations to distinguish ion species of similar masses, has obscured its significant contribution to the near-Earth plasma. This letter reviews the most notable observations of N+ ions, starting from the early low altitude measurements from Sputnik III in the ionosphere to the measurements reported by the Enhanced Polar Outflow Probe (e-POP) mission. The available observational data set suggests that nitrogen ions are constant companions of outflowing oxygen ions, and their abundances vary with season, solar cycle, time of day, and geomagnetic activity. This strong record of nitrogen presence in the ionosphere-magnetosphere system raises the question of ionic composition and the need for caution when interpreting O+ measurements from current missions.

A system science methodology develops a new composite highly predictable index of magnetospheric activity for the community: the whole-Earth index E(1)

For community use, a new composite whole-Earth index E(1) and its matching composite solar wind driving function S(1) are derived. A system science methodology is used based on a time-dependent magnetospheric state vector and a solar wind state vector, with canonical correlation analysis (CCA) used to reduce the two state vectors to the two time-dependent scalars E(1)(t) and S(1)(t). The whole-Earth index E(1) is based on a diversity of measures via six diverse geomagnetic indices that will be readily available in the future: SML, SMU, Ap60, SYMH, ASYM, and PCC. The CCA-derived composite index has several advantages: 1) the new “canonical” geomagnetic index E(1) will provide a more powerful description of magnetospheric activity, a description of the collective behavior of the magnetosphere–ionosphere system. 2) The new index E(1) is much more accurately predictable from upstream solar wind measurements on Earth. 3) Indications are that the new canonical geomagnetic index E(1) will be accurately predictable even when as-yet-unseen extreme solar wind conditions occur. The composite solar wind driver S(1) can also be used as a universal driver function for individual geomagnetic indices or for magnetospheric particle populations. To familiarize the use of the new index E(1), its behavior is examined in different phases of the solar cycle, in different types of solar wind plasma, during high-speed stream-driven storms, during CME sheath-driven storms, and during superstorms. It is suggested that the definition of storms are the times when E(1) >1.

Earth’s magnetotail variability during supersubstorms (SSSs): A study on solar wind–magnetosphere–ionosphere coupling

Supersubstorm (SSS) events are associated with extremely intense westward auroral electrojet currents (the minimum SuperMAG AL or SML <-2500nT) resulting from the solar wind-magnetosphere coupling. We present, for the first time, variability of the Earth’s magnetotail and coupling from the solar wind to magnetotail, geosynchronous orbit and auroral ionosphere during the SSS events. Five intervals with multiple SSSs were identified when the Cluster spacecraft was well inside the inner magnetotail. The SSS events are found to be characterized by turbulent magnetotail plasma sheet and injection of energetic (∼100eV to ∼100keV) electrons and protons. Injection of energetic protons from the plasma sheet causes electromagnetic ion cyclotron waves that lead to pitch angle scattering of the outer radiation belt MeV electrons and loss to the atmosphere during the SSSs. The SSS events are found to be associated with interplanetary magnetic clouds characterized by slowly varying interplanetary magnetic fields. An overall increase in the turbulence is recorded from the solar wind to the inner magnetosphere-ionosphere system during the SSSs. From the wavelet and cross-wavelet analyses, the inner magnetosphere and ionosphere are found to respond quasi-periodically at ∼1.5-4hours, and sporadically at shorter timescales of ∼0.5-1.5hours.

Editorial: Understanding the causes of asymmetries in Earth’s magnetosphere-ionosphere system

Editorial: Understanding the causes of asymmetries in Earth’s magnetosphere-ionosphere system

Universal Time variations in the magnetosphere

We study the dependencies of Earth’s magnetosphere on Universal Time, UT. These are introduced because Earth’s magnetic axis is not aligned with the rotational axis and complicated because it is eccentric, which makes the offset of the magnetic and rotation poles considerably greater in the Southern hemisphere and the longitudinal separation of the magnetic poles less than 180°: hence consequent UT variations in the two hemispheres are not in equal in amplitude nor in exact antiphase and do not cancel, as they would for a geocentric dipole. We use long series of a variety of geomagnetic data to demonstrate the inductive effect of motions of the polar caps in a “geocentric-solar” frame, which is phase-locked to the Russell-McPherron (R-M) effect on solar-wind magnetosphere coupling. This makes the response of the magnetosphere-ionosphere system different for the two polarities of the Y-component of the Interplanetary Magnetic Field in the GSEQ reference frame, explaining the difference in response to the March and September equinox peaks in solar wind forcing. The sunward/antisunward pole-motion effect is detected directly in satellite transpolar voltage data and is shown to have a greater effect on the geomagnetic data than the full dipole tilt effect which generates the equinoctial pattern, the potential origins of which are discussed in terms of the dipole tilt effect on ionospheric conductivities and the stability of the near-Earth tail. Persistent UT variations in Region-1 and Region-2 field-aligned currents and in partial ring current indices are presented: their explanation is an important challenge for numerical modelling of the magnetosphere-ionosphere-thermosphere system which we need to quantify the relative contributions of the various mechanisms and to give understanding of the effect of arrival time on the response of the system to large, geoeffective disturbances in interplanetary space.Plain language summary: The effect on terrestrial space weather of Earth’s magnetic axis not being aligned with the rotational axis is investigated. It is complex because not only do these two axes not align in direction (the “dipole tilt”), the magnetic axis does not pass through the centre of the Earth, which sets a requirement for an “eccentric” model of the field and not the commonly-used “geocentric” one. For many years, it has been known that the dipole tilt gives a peak in geomagnetic activity at the equinoxes (the semi-annual variation) through the “Russell-McPherron” (R-M) effect. However, although the variation with Universal Time is consistent with the R-M effect for the September equinox, it is not for the March equinox. We here solve this long-standing puzzle by investigating the effects of the motions of the two poles in a frame fixed with respect to both the Earth and the Sun for an eccentric dipole model. But solving one puzzle generates many others. We present observations of the Universal Time variations that these mechanisms combine to generate, which set an important challenge to the numerical modelling of the near-Earth space environment.

Dynamical information flow within the magnetosphere-ionosphere system during magnetic storms

The direct role of successive intense magnetospheric substorms in injecting/energizing particles into the storm-time ring current is still debated and controversial. Whereas in the recent past it has been observed the absence of a net information flow between magnetic storms and substorms, previous in-situ satellite observations have evidenced that ionospheric-origin ions dominate the population of the ring current during the main phase of geomagnetic storms. As a matter of fact, the controversy arises mainly by the use of sophisticated data-driven techniques somewhat contradicting in-situ measurements. In this framework, the main aim of this work is to attempt an adaption of the powerful information-theoretic approach, i.e., the transfer entropy, in a consistent way with physics modeling and observations and to explore the possible motivations behind the underlying contradictions that emerge when these techniques are used. Our idea is to characterize the dynamics of the information flow within the magnetosphere-ionosphere system using a database of geomagnetic storms instead of considering a long time series of geomagnetic indices. We found a net information flow between the external driver and the geomagnetic indices and also between high and low latitude indices themselves, which turns out to be very well localized during the different phases of a magnetic storm.

A regional classification of time spectral amplitudes in total electron content: Southeastern United States during solar cycle 24

To investigate the meso-scale structure (100 s of km) of the ionosphere at mid-latitudes, the spectral properties in calculated total electron content (TEC) at a cluster of GPS receivers in and around Florida are analyzed. The ionosphere does not respond exactly the same to periodic solar driving at different locations around the planet, due to the complex electrodynamic interactions of the coupled magnetosphere-ionosphere system. Therefore, at each GPS receiver in the cluster we compare spatio-temporal variations of the spectral amplitudes for diurnal, solar rotation, and seasonal oscillations. The amplitudes for these dominant oscillations are organized with respect to magnetic latitude of the receiver. A low-latitude and high-latitude station are also included to put the mid-latitude ionospheric response into a global context. The amplitudes of diurnal, seasonal, and solar rotation signals are well ordered by magnetic latitude, superposed with meso-scale deviations between stations separated by ∼100s of km. The results suggest that spatio-temporal variations of spectral amplitudes in the mid-latitude ionosphere are not dominated by a single process. This conclusion is based on our finding that at high latitude, the shape of the diurnal signal varies significantly less with solar activity compared to low- and mid-latitudes, and additionally, that the ratio of annual to semi-annual amplitudes fluctuates around 1 with time and from station-to-station only at mid-latitudes.

The magnetosphere-ionosphere observatory (MIO) mission concept

MIO (Magnetosphere-Ionosphere Observatory) is designed to definitively fix a cause-and-effect problem: In the nightside magnetosphere-ionosphere system we don’t know what is connected to what. The MIO mission concept is to operate a powerful 1-MeV electron accelerator on a main spacecraft in the equatorial nightside magnetosphere: the electron beam is directed into the atmospheric loss cone to deposit ionizing electrons in the atmosphere sufficient to optically illuminate the magnetic footpoint of the spacecraft while 4 nearby daughter spacecraft make equatorial magnetospheric measurements. A network of ground-based optical imagers across Alaska and Canada will locate the optical beamspot thereby unambiguously establishing the magnetic connection between equatorial magnetospheric measurements and ionospheric phenomena. Critical gradient measurements will be made to discern magnetospheric field-aligned-current generator mechanisms. This enables the magnetospheric drivers of various aurora, ionospheric phenomena, and field-aligned currents to be determined. In support of the Solar and Space Physics (Heliophysics) 2022 Decadal Survey, an experienced team of engineers and scientists at The Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory (APL) have developed a NASA HMCS (Heliospheric Mission Concept Study) mission concept that can achieve the science objectives. The mission concept presented here is the result of trade studies that optimized the mission with regard to factors such as science objectives, concept study requirements, space environment, engineering constraints, and risk. This Methods paper presents an overview of the MIO concept.

What produces and what controls the spatial-temporal structuring of the magnetospheric chorus waves that create the pulsating aurora: An unsolved problem in need of new measurements

In this Perspective article discussing solved and unsolved problems in space physics, the focus is on the unsolved problem of the spatial-temporal variability of the magnetospheric plasma waves that produce the spatial-temporal atmospheric luminosity of the pulsating aurora. In particular the outstanding issue of what causes the spatial-temporal variations of the chorus-wave intensities is highlighted: Two great unknowns are (1) how does it work and (2) what are the controlling factors. The point is made that the whistler-mode chorus waves that produce the pulsating aurora are the same chorus waves that energize the Earth’s electron radiation belt. Hence, beyond not understanding the cause of pulsating aurora there is (1) a lack of understanding of the magnetosphere-ionosphere system behavior and (2) a lack of understanding of how the electron radiation belt is energized. It is noted that the pulsating aurora is perhaps the most-obvious example of an “emergent phenomena” in the magnetosphere-ionosphere-thermosphere system, and so perhaps the clearest indication that the magnetosphere-ionosphere-thermosphere system is a truly “complex system”, not just a complicated system. Future needs for solving this unsolved problem are discussed: the most-critical need is argued to be gaining an ability to measure cold-electron structuring in the equatorial magnetosphere.

Editorial: Coupled feedback mechanisms in the magnetosphere-ionosphere system

Editorial: Coupled feedback mechanisms in the magnetosphere-ionosphere system

What are the fundamental modes of energy transfer and partitioning in the coupled Magnetosphere-Ionosphere system?

The fundamental processes responsible for energy exchange between large-scale electromagnetic fields and plasma are well understood theoretically, but in practice these theories have not been tested. These processes are ubiquitous in all plasmas, especially at the interface between high and low beta plasmas in planetary magnetospheres and other magnetic environments. Although such boundaries pervade the plasma Universe, the processes responsible for the release of the stored magnetic and thermal plasma energy have not been fully identified and the importance of the relative impact of each process is unknown. Despite advances in understanding energy release through the conversion of magnetic to kinetic energy in magnetic reconnection, how the extreme pressures in the regions between stretched and more relaxed field lines in the transition region are balanced and released through adiabatic convection of plasma and fields is still a mystery. Recent theoretical advances and the predictions of large-scale instabilities must be tested. In essence, the processes responsible remain poorly understood and the problem unresolved. The aim of the White Paper submitted to ESA’s Voyage 2050 call, and the contents of this paper, is to highlight three outstanding open science questions that are of clear international interest: (i) the interplay of local and global plasma physics processes: (ii) the partitioning during energy conversion between electromagnetic and plasma energy: and (iii) what processes drive the coupling between low and high beta plasmas. We present a discussion of the new measurements and technological advances required from current state-of-the-art, and several candidate mission profiles with which these international high-priority science goals could be significantly advanced.

Dependence of the global dayside reconnection rate on interplanetary magnetic field By and the earth’s dipole tilt

In the recent years, significant attention has been given to the combined effect of Interplanetary Magnetic Field (IMF) duskward component (By) and dipole tilt on the global magnetosphere-ionosphere system response. Numerous studies have pointed out that when the Earth’s magnetic dipole is tilted away from the Sun (negative dipole tilt during northern winter), and IMF has a positive By component, the effects on ionospheric currents, particle precipitation, ionospheric convection, and average size of the auroral oval, is significantly more enhanced, compared to when IMF By is negative. Furthermore, this IMF By polarity effect reverses when Earth’s dipole is tilted in the opposite direction. The underlying cause has remained unclear. Our analysis shows that substorms tend to be stronger during the same IMF By and dipole tilt polarity combination. Taken together with earlier results showing also more frequent substorms during the same conditions, our observations suggests that when IMF By and dipole tilt have opposite signs, there is a more efficient global dayside reconnection rate. We also show analysis of the occurrence frequency of periods of Steady Magnetospheric Convection, substorm onset latitude, and the isotropic boundary of proton precipitation, that are all consistent with our conclusion that the combination of IMF By and dipole tilt polarity affect the global dayside reconnection rate.

Daring to think of the impossible: The story of Vlasiator

Vlasiator is the world’s first global Eulerian hybrid-Vlasov simulation code, going beyond magnetohydrodynamics in the solar wind—magnetosphere—ionosphere system. This paper gives the story of Vlasiator. An important enabler of Vlasiator is the rapid increase of computational resources over the last decade, but also the open-minded, courageous forerunners, who have embraced this new opportunity, both as developers but also as co-authors of our papers. Typically, when starting a new coding project, people think about the presently available resources. But when the development continues for multiple years, the resources change. If instead, one targets to upcoming resources, one is always in possession of a code which does not contain large legacy parts that are not able to utilize latest resources. It will be interesting to see how many modelling groups will take the opportunity to benefit from the current high-performance computing trends, and where are we in the next 10 years. In the following, a simulation that directly handles and manipulates the phase space density f(r,v,t) is referred to as a Vlasov approach, whereas a simulation system that traces phase space samples by their kinetic characteristics of motion is a Particle-in-Cell approach. This terminology is consistent with its use in the magnetospheric simulation community.

Simulating the Responses of the Magnetosphere–Ionosphere System to the IMF By Reversal

The interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) By component can cause asymmetric features in the magnetosphere-ionosphere system and influence the electromagnetic energy input. In this study, we use the Space Weather Modeling Framework (SWMF) to study the transient dynamics after a sudden change in the IMF By component exerts on the magnetosphere system. Simulation results reveal that under northward IMF conditions, an abrupt change of the IMF By from duskward to dawnward induces a dawnward geomagnetic field firstly in the cusp region and then in both the near-Earth and magnetotail regions. The signal of the new y-component of the geomagnetic field in the near-Earth region extends tailward while that in the magnetotail moves Earthward, leading the middle-tail region to react last. We investigate in detail the transitional change of the y-component of the geomagnetic field and compare it to the scenario under southward IMF conditions, and find that the latter case reacts in a much simpler manner and the responses are faster globally.

Magnetosphere-Ionosphere Coupling: Implications of Non-Equilibrium Conditions

The response times of the coupled magnetosphere-ionosphere-thermosphere system are, on average, greater than the autocorrelation timescales of solar wind forcing. This means that the system is rarely, if ever, in equilibrium. Departures from equilibrium are a key component of the Expanding-Contracting Polar Cap (ECPC) model of convection excitation in both the magnetosphere and ionosphere, driven by the Dungey reconnection cycle of opening and re-closing magnetospheric field lines. Averaging over sufficiently long timescales reduces data to the equivalent of steady-state conditions, which hides the physical mechanisms involved and allows us to map electric fields from interplanetary space to the ionosphere–but this is not valid, either physically or generally, because of magnetic induction effects. Only for transient phenomena on sufficiently short timescales do the mechanisms associated with non-equilibrium fully manifest themselves. Nevertheless, because of both ever-changing solar wind conditions and Earth’s dipole tilt, eccentricity and rotation, the magnetosphere is always tending towards a perpetually-evolving equilibrium configuration and there are important implications of transient events for understanding the general behavior of the coupled magnetosphere-ionosphere-thermosphere system and its response to solar wind forcing. We here discuss one example: as a consequence of the importance of departures from equilibrium inherent in the ECPC model, the solar wind dynamic pressure PSW influences the magnetosphere-ionosphere convection response to the generation of open field lines by reconnection in the dayside subsolar magnetopause. We here demonstrate this effect in a statistical survey of observations and show that it is as predicted by the ECPC model and that, through it, PSW has an influence on flux transport in the magnetosphere-ionosphere system.