The lack of carefully optimized extraction techniques for the analysis of compounds with diverse polarities limits the identification of toxic pollutants in aqueous environmental matrices, particularly those that are considered persistent and mobile organic compounds (PMOCs). Tailored extraction techniques for specific classes of chemicals often result in very low to no extraction of either very polar or relatively non-polar chemicals, depending on the sorbent used. Hence, it is crucial to develop a balanced extraction for a wider range of polarity, especially for non-target analysis of chemical residues, in order to capture the occurrence of the full profile of micropollutants. Herein, a tandem solid-phase extraction (SPE) technique incorporating both hydrophilic-lipophilic balance (HLB) and mixed-mode cation exchange (MCX) sorbents was developed to extract and analyze 60 model compounds with a wide range of polarities (log Kow from ‐1.9 to 5.5) from untreated sewage matrices. Extraction efficiencies were assessed in NanoPure™ water and untreated sewage samples; 51 compounds in NanoPure™ water and 44 compounds in untreated sewage had ≥60 % extraction recoveries using the developed tandem SPE method. The method limits of detection ranged from 0.25 to 88 ng/L in untreated sewage matrix. The applicability of the extraction method was demonstrated in untreated wastewater samples; using the tandem SPE for suspect screening analysis captured an additional 22 compounds that were not extracted when using the HLB sorbent only. The optimized SPE method was also evaluated for the extraction of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) by analyzing the same sample extracts under negative electrospray ionization liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). The wastewater samples revealed the presence of sulfonamide-, sulfonic-, carboxylic-, and fluorotelomer sulfonic- PFAS with chain lengths 8, 4–8, 4–9, and 8, respectively, indicating that the tandem SPE procedure provides an efficient one-step extraction for the analysis of PMOCs that include pharmaceuticals, pesticides, and PFAS.