Intrinsic Membrane Permeability Research Articles

Predicting the intrinsic membrane permeability of Caco-2/MDCK cells by the solubility-diffusion model

Membrane permeability is one of the main determinants for the absorption, distribution, metabolism and excretion of compounds and is therefore of crucial importance for successful drug development. Experiments with artificial phospholipid membranes have shown that the intrinsic membrane permeability (P0) of compounds is well-predicted by the solubility-diffusion model (SDM). However, using the solubility-diffusion model to predict the P0 of biological Caco-2 and MDCK cell membranes has proven unreliable so far. Recent publications revealed that many published P0 extracted from Caco-2 and MDCK experiments are incorrect. In this work, we therefore used a small self-generated set as well as a large revised set of experimental Caco-2 and MDCK data from literature to compare experimental and predicted P0. The P0 extracted from Caco-2 and MDCK experiments were systematically lower than the P0 predicted by the solubility-diffusion model. However, using the following correlation: log P0,Caco-2/MDCK = 0.84 log P0,SDM – 1.85, P0 of biological Caco-2 and MDCK cell membranes was well-predicted by the solubility-diffusion model.

Effects of Aqueous Boundary Layers and Paracellular Transport on the Efflux Ratio as a Measure of Active Transport Across Cell Layers.

The efflux ratio (ER), determined by Caco-2/MDCK assays, is the standard in vitro metric to establish qualitatively whether a compound is a substrate of an efflux transporter. However, others have also enabled the utilisation of this metric quantitatively by deriving a relationship that expresses the ER as a function of the intrinsic membrane permeability of the membrane (P0) as well as the permeability of carrier-mediated efflux (Ppgp). As of yet, Ppgp cannot be measured directly from transport experiments or otherwise, but the ER relationship provides easy access to this value if P0 is known. However, previous derivations of this relationship failed to consider the influence of additional transport resistances such as the aqueous boundary layers (ABLs) and the filter on which the monolayer is grown. Since single fluxes in either direction can be heavily affected by these experimental artefacts, it is crucial to consider the potential impact on the ER. We present a model that includes these factors and show both mathematically and experimentally that this simple ER relationship also holds for the more realistic scenario that does not neglect the ABLs/filter. Furthermore, we also show mathematically how paracellular transport affects the ER, and we experimentally confirm that paracellular dominance reduces the ER to unity and can mask potential efflux.

Pitfalls in evaluating permeability experiments with Caco-2/MDCK cell monolayers

When studying the transport of molecules across biological membranes, intrinsic membrane permeability (P0) is more informative than apparent permeability (Papp), because it eliminates external (setup-specific) factors, provides consistency across experiments and mechanistic insight. It is thus an important building block for modeling the total permeability in any given scenario. However, extracting P0 is often difficult, if not impossible, when the membrane is not the dominant transport resistance. In this work, we set out to analyze Papp values measured with Caco-2/MDCK cell monolayers of 69 literature references. We checked the Papp values for a total of 318 different compounds for the extractability of P0, considering possible limitations by aqueous boundary layers, paracellular transport, recovery issues, active transport, a possible proton flux limitation, and sink conditions. Overall, we were able to extract 77 reliable P0 values, which corresponds to about one quarter of the total compounds analyzed, while about half were limited by the diffusion through the aqueous layers. Compared to an existing data set of P0 values published by Avdeef, our approach resulted in a much higher exclusion of compounds. This is a consequence of stricter compound- and reference-specific exclusion criteria, but also because we considered possible concentration-shift effects due to different pH values in the aqueous layers, an effect only recently described in literature. We thus provide a consistent and reliable set of P0, e.g. as a basis for future modeling.

Revisiting the pKa-Flux method for determining intrinsic membrane permeability

Intrinsic membrane permeability is one of several factors that critically determine the intestinal absorption of a chemical. The intrinsic membrane permeability of a chemical is usually extracted from transwell experiments with Caco-2 or MDCK cells, preferably by the pKa-Flux method, which is considered the method of choice when aqueous boundary layer effects need to be excluded. The pKa-Flux method has two variants, the iso-pH method, where apical and basolateral pH are equal, and the gradient-pH method, where apical and basolateral pH are different. The most commonly used method is the gradient-pH method, as it is intended to reflect the pH-conditions in the gastrointestinal tract. However, concentration-shift effects caused by the applied pH-difference between apical and basolateral compartment in the gradient-pH method have not been considered in the evaluation of the experimental data in the past. Consequently, incorrect intrinsic membrane permeabilities have been determined. In this work, we present a revised method for extracting the intrinsic membrane permeability from gradient-pH data that considers concentration-shift effects in the basolateral aqueous boundary layer and filter as well as in the cytosol. Furthermore, we propose the use of the iso-pH method, where only concentration-shift effects in the cytosol need to be considered, as an alternative to the gradient-pH method. We use the five lipophilic bases amantadine, chloroquine, propranolol, venlafaxine and verapamil as examples to compare gradient-pH method and iso-pH method with regard to the extractability of the intrinsic membrane permeability. For lipophilic bases, the iso-pH method proves to be advantageous. All intrinsic membrane permeabilities determined in this work were substantially higher than the intrinsic membrane permeabilities reported in literature.

Impact of cholesterol and sphingomyelin on intrinsic membrane permeability

Transwell experiments with Caco-2 or MDCK cells are the gold standard for determining the intestinal permeability of chemicals. The intrinsic membrane permeability (P0), that can be extracted from these experiments, might be comparable to P0 measured in black lipid membrane (BLM) experiments and P0 predicted by the solubility-diffusion model. Unfortunately, the overlap between experimental P0,Caco-2/MDCK and P0,BLM data is very small. So far, differences between both approaches have been attributed to the cholesterol and sphingomyelin content of cell membranes, but the database is too sparse to thoroughly test this theory. To create a diverse dataset, we measured P0,BLM of ten chemicals in BLM experiments using DPhPC and DPhPC/cholesterol/sphingomyelin membranes. The results were compared to predicted BLM data and experimental Caco-2/MDCK data obtained from literature. While P0,BLM of all chemicals was well predicted by the solubility-diffusion model, P0,Caco-2/MDCK was only predictable for rather hydrophilic compounds with logarithmic hexadecane/water partition coefficients below −0.5. The effect of cholesterol and sphingomyelin on P0,BLM was negligibly small.

Propidium uptake and ATP release in A549 cells share similar transport mechanisms

The lipid bilayer of eukaryotic cells’ plasma membrane is almost impermeable to small ions and large polar molecules, but its miniscule basal permeability in intact cells is poorly characterized. This report describes the intrinsic membrane permeability of A549 cells toward the charged molecules propidium (Pr2+) and ATP4−. Under isotonic conditions, we detected with quantitative fluorescence microscopy, a continuous low-rate uptake of Pr (∼150 × 10−21 moles (zmol)/h/cell, [Pr]o = 150 μM, 32°C). It was stimulated transiently but strongly by 66% hypotonic cell swelling reaching an influx amplitude of ∼1500 (zmol/h)/cell. The progressive Pr uptake with increasing [Pr]o (30, 150, and 750 μM) suggested a permeation mechanism by simple diffusion. We quantified separately ATP release with custom wide-field-of-view chemiluminescence imaging. The strong proportionality between ATP efflux and Pr2+ influx during hypotonic challenge, and the absence of stimulation of transmembrane transport following 300% hypertonic shock, indicated that ATP and Pr travel the same conductive pathway. The fluorescence images revealed a homogeneously distributed intracellular uptake of Pr not consistent with high-conductance channels expressed at low density on the plasma membrane. We hypothesized that the pathway consists of transiently formed water pores evenly spread across the plasma membrane. The abolition of cell swelling-induced Pr uptake with 500 μM gadolinium, a known modulator of membrane fluidity, supported the involvement of water pores whose formation depends on the membrane fluidity. Our study suggests an alternative model of a direct permeation of ATP (and other molecules) through the phospholipid bilayer, which may have important physiological implications.

Importance of two-dimensional cation clusters induced by protein folding in intrinsic intracellular membrane permeability.

We investigated the cell penetration of Sp1 zinc finger proteins (Sp1 ZF) and the mechanism via which the total cationic charge and distribution of cationic residues on the protein surface affect intracellular trafficking. Sp1 ZFs showed intrinsic cell membrane permeability. The intracellular transfer of Sp1 ZFs other than 1F3 was dependent on the total cationic charge. Investigation of the effect of cationic residue distribution on intracellular membrane permeability revealed that the cellular uptake of unfolded Zn2+-non-coordinating Ala mutants was lower than that of the wild type. Therefore, the total cationic charge and distribution of cationic residues on the protein played crucial roles in intracellular translocation. Mutational studies revealed that the two-dimensional cation cluster on the protein surface significantly improved their cellular uptake. This study will contribute to the design of artificial cargoes that can efficiently transport target substances into cells.

Prediction of negative food effect induced by bile micelle binding on oral absorption of hydrophilic cationic drugs

The purpose of the present study was to quantitatively predict the negative food effect induced by bile micelle binding on the oral absorption of hydrophilic cationic drugs. The intrinsic membrane permeability and bile micelle unbound fraction of 12 model drugs (7 tertiary amines, 3 quaternary ammoniums, and 2 neutral drugs) were calculated from the experimental Caco-2 permeability data (Papp) under fasted and fed conditions. From these input data, the fraction of a dose absorbed (Fa) was predicted using the gastrointestinal unified theoretical framework, a mechanism-based oral absorption model. The predicted Fa ratio (fed/fasted) was then compared with the in vivo fed/fasted area under the plasma concentration–time curve ratio (AUCr). The AUCr values of tertiary amines and neutral drugs were appropriately predicted (absolute average fold error (AAFE) = 1.19), whereas those of quaternary ammoniums were markedly underestimated (AAFE = 4.70). The Papp ratio (fed/fasted) predicted AUCr less quantitatively (AAFE = 1.30 for tertiary amines and neutral drugs). The results of the present study would lead to a better understanding of negative food effect on oral drug absorption.

Techniques to Determine the Effects of Jasmonates on Root Hydraulic Conductivity.

Plants subjected to drought and saline stress conditions suffer from tissue dehydration. Such dehydration is caused by the imbalance between root water uptake by roots and water loss by transpiration. Therefore, determination of root hydraulic properties is crucial to understand plant water balance. Root hydraulic conductivity (L) can be used to estimate root water transport capacity. L depends on root architecture (length and diameter of the root and proliferation of secondary roots), radial water transport pathway (root xylem vessels, plasmodesmata, apoplastic space, caspary bands), and on intrinsic membrane permeability to water (aquaporins, water membrane protein channels). Different methods have been developed to measure L, such as Pressure Chamber, Free Exudation, High-Pressure Flowmeter (HPFM), and Root Pressure Probe (RPP). In this chapter, we will focus on Pressure Chamber, Free Exudation, and HPFM methods which have been used to determine the effect of jasmonates (JA) on root hydraulic conductivity.

Intrinsic Membrane Permeability to Small Molecules.

Spontaneous solute and solvent permeation through membranes is of vital importance to human life, be it gas exchange in red blood cells, metabolite excretion, drug/toxin uptake, or water homeostasis. Knowledge of the underlying molecular mechanisms is the sine qua non of every functional assignment to membrane transporters. The basis of our current solubility diffusion model was laid by Meyer and Overton. It correlates the solubility of a substance in an organic phase with its membrane permeability. Since then, a wide range of studies challenging this rule have appeared. Commonly, the discrepancies have their origin in ill-used measurement approaches, as we demonstrate on the example of membrane CO2 transport. On the basis of the insight that scanning electrochemical microscopy offered into solute concentration distributions in immediate membrane vicinity of planar membranes, we analyzed the interplay between chemical reactions and diffusion for solvent transport, weak acid permeation, and enzymatic reactions adjacent to membranes. We conclude that buffer reactions must also be considered in spectroscopic investigations of weak acid transport in vesicular suspensions. The evaluation of energetic contributions to membrane translocation of charged species demonstrates the compatibility of the resulting membrane current with the solubility diffusion model. A local partition coefficient that depends on membrane penetration depth governs spontaneous membrane translocation of both charged and uncharged molecules. It is determined not only by the solubility in an organic phase but also by other factors like cholesterol concentration and intrinsic electric membrane potentials.

Logistic Classification Models for pH-Permeability Profile: Predicting Permeability Classes for the Biopharmaceutical Classification System.

Permeability is used to describe and evaluate the absorption of drug substances in the human gastrointestinal tract (GIT). Permeability is largely dependent on fluctuating pH that causes the ionization of drug substances and also influences regional absorption in the GIT. Therefore, classification models that characterize permeability at wide ranges of pH were derived in the current study. For this, drug substances were described with six data series that were measured with a parallel artificial membrane permeability assay (PAMPA), including a permeability profile at four pH values (3, 5, 7.4, and 9), and the highest and intrinsic membrane permeability. Logistic regression classification models were developed and compared by using two distinct sets of descriptors: (1) a hydrophobicity descriptor, the logarithm of the octanol-water partition (logPow) or distribution (logD) coefficient and (2) theoretical molecular descriptors. In both cases, models have good classification and descriptive capabilities for the training set (accuracy: 0.76-0.91). Triple validation with three sets of drug substances shows good prediction capability for all models: validation set (accuracy: 0.73-0.91), external validation set (accuracy: 0.72-0.9), and the permeability classes of FDA reference drugs for the biopharmaceutical classification system (BCS) (accuracy: 0.72-0.88). The identification of BCS permeability classes was further improved with decision trees that consolidated predictions from models with each descriptor type. These decision trees have higher confidence and accuracy (0.91 for theoretical molecular descriptors and 0.81 for hydrophobicity descriptors) than the individual models in assigning drug substances into BCS permeability classes. A detailed analysis of classification models and related decision trees suggests that they are suitable for predicting classes of permeability for passively transported drug substances, including specifically within the BCS framework. All developed models are available at the QsarDB repository ( http://dx.doi.org/10.15152/QDB.206 ).

Structure-Property Basis for Solving Transporter-Mediated Efflux and Pan-Genotypic Inhibition in HCV NS5B Inhibitors.

In solving the P-gp and BCRP transporter-mediated efflux issue in a series of benzofuran-derived pan-genotypic palm site inhibitors of the hepatitis C virus NS5B replicase, it was found that close attention to physicochemical properties was essential. In these compounds, where both molecular weight (MW >579) and TPSA (>110 Å2) were high, attenuation of polar surface area together with weakening of hydrogen bond acceptor strength of the molecule provided a higher intrinsic membrane permeability and more desirable Caco-2 parameters, as demonstrated by trifluoroacetamide 11 and the benchmark N-ethylamino analog 12. In addition, the tendency of these inhibitors to form intramolecular hydrogen bonds potentially contributes favorably to the improved membrane permeability and absorption. The functional group minimization that resolved the efflux problem simultaneously maintained potent inhibitory activity toward a gt-2 HCV replicon due to a switching of the role of substituents in interacting with the Gln414 binding pocket, as observed in gt-2a NS5B/inhibitor complex cocrystal structures, thus increasing the efficiency of the optimization. Noteworthy, a novel intermolecular S=O···C=O n → π* type interaction between the ligand sulfonamide oxygen atom and the carbonyl moiety of the side chain of Gln414 was observed. The insights from these structure-property studies and crystallography information provided a direction for optimization in a campaign to identify second generation pan-genotypic NS5B inhibitors.

PH-permeability profiles for drug substances: Experimental detection, comparison with human intestinal absorption and modelling

The influence of pH on human intestinal absorption is frequently not considered in early drug discovery studies in the modelling and subsequent prediction of intestinal absorption for drug candidates. To bridge this gap, in this study, experimental membrane permeability data were measured for current and former drug substances with a parallel artificial membrane permeability assay (PAMPA) at different pH values (3, 5, 7.4 and 9). The presented data are in good agreement with human intestinal absorption, showing a clear influence of pH on the efficiency of intestinal absorption. For the measured data, simple and general quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSARs) were developed for each pH that makes it possible to predict the pH profiles for passive membrane permeability (i.e., a pH-permeability profile), and these predictions coincide well with the experimental data. QSARs are also proposed for the data series of highest and intrinsic membrane permeability. The molecular descriptors in the models were analysed and mechanistically related to the interaction pattern of permeability in membranes. In addition to the regression models, classification models are also proposed. All models were successfully validated and blind tested with external data. The models are available in the QsarDB repository (http://dx.doi.org/10.15152/QDB.203).

Fatty Acid/Phospholipid Blended Membranes: A Potential Intermediate State in Protocellular Evolution.

Prior to the evolution of membrane proteins, intrinsic membrane stability and permeability to polar solutes are essential features of a primitive cell membrane. These features are difficult to achieve simultaneously in model protocells made of either pure fatty acid or phospholipid membranes, raising the intriguing question of how the transition from fatty acid to phospholipid membranes might have occurred while continuously supporting encapsulated reactions required for genomic replication. Here, the properties of a blended membrane system composed of both oleic acid (OA), a monoacyl fatty acid, and 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC), a diacyl phospholipid are described. This hybrid vesicle system exhibits high stability to divalent cations (Mg2+ ), while simultaneously maintaining its permeability to small charged molecules such as nucleotides and divalent ions such as Mg2+ . This combination of features facilitates key reactions expected to occur during a transition from primitive to modern cells, including nonenzymatic RNA replication, and is also compatible with highly evolved functions such as the ribosomal translation of a protein. The observations support the hypothesis that the early transition from fatty acid to phospholipid membranes could be accomplished through intermediate states in which membranes are composed of amphiphile mixtures, and do not require protein transporters.

Predicting apparent passive permeability of Caco-2 and MDCK cell-monolayers: A mechanistic model.

Experimentally derived apparent permeabilities, Papp, through cell monolayers such as Caco-2 and MDCK are considered to be an in-vitro gold standard for assessing the uptake efficiency of drugs. Here, we present a mechanistic model that describes ‘passive’ Papp values (i.e., neglecting active transport) by accounting for the different resistances solutes encounter when permeating a cell monolayer. We described three parallel permeation pathways, namely a cytosolic-, paracellular-, and lateral route, each of which consists of a number of serial resistances. These resistances were accounted for via a mechanistic depiction of the underlying processes that are largely based on literature work. For the present Papp dataset, about as much chemicals are dominated by the cytosolic route as were dominated by the paracellular route, while the lateral route was negligible. For the cytosolic route by far the most chemicals found their main resistance in the various water layers and not in the membrane. Although correlations within the subclasses of chemicals dominated by a specific permeation route were rather poor, we could overall satisfyingly predict Papp for 151 chemicals at a pH of 7.4 (R2 = 0.77, RMSE = 0.48). For a specific evaluation of the intrinsic membrane permeability, Pm, a second experimental dataset based on experiments with black lipid membranes, BLM, was evaluated. Pm could be predicted for 37 chemicals with R2 = 0.91 and RMSE = 0.64 log units.

Rheological Droplet Interface Bilayers (rheo-DIBs): Probing the Unstirred Water Layer Effect on Membrane Permeability via Spinning Disk Induced Shear Stress

A new rheological droplet interface bilayer (rheo-DIB) device is presented as a tool to apply shear stress on biological lipid membranes. Despite their exciting potential for affecting high-throughput membrane translocation studies, permeability assays conducted using DIBs have neglected the effect of the unstirred water layer (UWL). However as demonstrated in this study, neglecting this phenomenon can cause significant underestimates in membrane permeability measurements which in turn limits their ability to predict key processes such as drug translocation rates across lipid membranes. With the use of the rheo-DIB chip, the effective bilayer permeability can be modulated by applying shear stress to the droplet interfaces, inducing flow parallel to the DIB membranes. By analysing the relation between the effective membrane permeability and the applied stress, both the intrinsic membrane permeability and UWL thickness can be determined for the first time using this model membrane approach, thereby unlocking the potential of DIBs for undertaking diffusion assays. The results are also validated with numerical simulations.

Bacterial Nanocellulose Aerogel Membranes: Novel High-Porosity Materials for Membrane Distillation

We fabricated, characterized, and tested novel fibrous aerogel membranes in direct contact membrane distillation (MD) to elucidate the effects of a model high-porosity membrane material on MD performance. Unsupported bacterial nanocellulose aerogels exhibit higher porosity, thinner fibers, and lower bulk thermal conductivity than any previously reported MD materials. Modeling and experiments demonstrate that these material properties confer significantly higher intrinsic membrane permeability and thermal efficiency than symmetric PVDF phase inversion membranes with lower porosity. Development of macroporous fibrous membranes with aerogel-like porosity and thermal conductivity (>98% and <0.03 W m–1 K–1, respectively) in thinner-film formats may further improve MD flux.

Drug interaction profile of the HIV integrase inhibitor cabotegravir: assessment from in vitro studies and a clinical investigation with midazolam

1. Cabotegravir (CAB; GSK1265744) is a potent HIV integrase inhibitor in clinical development as an oral lead-in tablet and long-acting injectable for the treatment and prevention of HIV infection.2. This work investigated if CAB was a substrate for efflux transporters, the potential for CAB to interact with drug-metabolizing enzymes and transporters to cause clinical drug interactions, and the effect of CAB on the pharmacokinetics of midazolam, a CYP3A4 probe substrate, in humans.3. CAB is a substrate for Pgp and BCRP; however, its high intrinsic membrane permeability limits the impact of these transporters on its intestinal absorption.4. At clinically relevant concentrations, CAB did not inhibit or induce any of the CYP or UGT enzymes evaluated in vitro and had no effect on the clinical pharmacokinetics of midazolam.5. CAB is an inhibitor of OAT1 (IC50 0.81 µM) and OAT3 (IC50 0.41 µM) but did not or only weakly inhibited Pgp, BCRP, MRP2, MRP4, MATE1, MATE2-K, OATP1B1, OATP1B3, OCT1, OCT2 or BSEP.6. Based on regulatory guidelines and quantitative extrapolations, CAB has a low propensity to cause clinically significant drug interactions, except for coadministration with OAT1 or OAT3 substrates.

How do antimalarial drugs reach their intracellular targets?

Drugs represent the primary treatment available for human malaria, as caused by Plasmodium spp. Currently approved drugs and antimalarial drug leads generally work against parasite enzymes or activities within infected erythrocytes. To reach their specific targets, these chemicals must cross at least three membranes beginning with the host cell membrane. Uptake at each membrane may involve partitioning and diffusion through the lipid bilayer or facilitated transport through channels or carriers. Here, we review the features of available antimalarials and examine whether transporters may be required for their uptake. Our computational analysis suggests that most antimalarials have high intrinsic membrane permeability, obviating the need for uptake via transporters; a subset of compounds appear to require facilitated uptake. We also review parasite and host transporters that may contribute to drug uptake. Broad permeability channels at the erythrocyte and parasitophorous vacuolar membranes of infected cells relax permeability constraints on antimalarial drug design; however, this uptake mechanism is prone to acquired resistance as the parasite may alter channel activity to reduce drug uptake. A better understanding of how antimalarial drugs reach their intracellular targets is critical to prioritizing drug leads for antimalarial development and may reveal new targets for therapeutic intervention.

Synthesis of the novel symmetric buckypaper supported ionic liquid membrane for the dehydration of ethylene glycol by pervaporation

In this study, a novel symmetric supported ionic liquid membrane (SILM) was prepared by infiltrating 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate [Bmim][BF4] into a buckypaper (BP) to form a so-called buckypaper supported ionic liquid membrane (BP-SILM). The [Bmim][BF4] was blended with polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) prior to the infiltration. The role of BP as a support can effectively entrap the infiltrated [Bmim][BF4]–PVA in the interstitial pores and supply the necessary mechanical stability for the resulting BP-SILM. The BP-SILM structure, in which the membrane and support phases were merged into a single layer, was found to be different from that of conventional asymmetric membranes. The BP-SILM structure allows the formation of a thinner symmetric membrane without compromising its mechanical properties. During the application of the BP-SILM in the pervaporation process to dehydrate ethylene glycol aqueous solution, the presence of BP and [Bmim][BF4] was observed to significantly enhance the separation performance and enhance the intrinsic membrane permeability. The BP-SILM exhibited high pervaporation performance with a permeation flux of 102gm−2h−1, a separation factor as high as 1014, and a water permeance of 9046gpu. The BP-SILM also demonstrated a robust pervaporation performance over an operation of 120h.