Intrathymic Tolerance Research Articles

T cells specific for post-translational modifications escape intrathymic tolerance induction

Establishing effective central tolerance requires the promiscuous expression of tissue-restricted antigens by medullary thymic epithelial cells. However, whether central tolerance also extends to post-translationally modified proteins is not clear. Here we show a mouse model of autoimmunity in which disease development is dependent on post-translational modification (PTM) of the tissue-restricted self-antigen collagen type II. T cells specific for the non-modified antigen undergo efficient central tolerance. By contrast, PTM-reactive T cells escape thymic selection, though the PTM variant constitutes the dominant form in the periphery. This finding implies that the PTM protein is absent in the thymus, or present at concentrations insufficient to induce negative selection of developing thymocytes and explains the lower level of tolerance induction against the PTM antigen. As the majority of self-antigens are post-translationally modified, these data raise the possibility that T cells specific for other self-antigens naturally subjected to PTM may escape central tolerance induction by a similar mechanism.

Non-myeloablative transplantation of bone marrow expressing self-antigen establishes peripheral tolerance and completely prevents autoimmunity in mice

Myeloablative transplantation of bone marrow (BM) engineered to express myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG) establishes central intrathymic tolerance and completely prevents MOG-induced experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) in mice. Here we asked whether non-myeloablative transplantation of MOG expressing BM (pMOG-bone marrow transplantation (BMT)) can also provide the same protection. Using stepwise reduction of irradiation doses, 275 cGy irradiation with pMOG-BMT protected 100% of mice from EAE development even with two subsequent re-challenge with MOG. Irradiation doses <275 cGy produced dose-dependent partial protection with significant disease protection still evident at 50 cGy. Splenocytes from 275 cGy recipients proliferated to MOG stimulation in vitro, indicating that MOG-reactive cells are present in the periphery but failed to induce disease. MOG-stimulated splenocytes produced little or no interleukin-17, interferon-γ, granulocyte-monocyte colony stimulating factor and tumor necrosis factor-α compared with EAE control. Adoptive transfer of CD4 T cells from EAE-resistant mice into Rag2(-/-) mice devoid of MOG expression resulted in MOG-induced EAE in ~74% of mice. Treatment of EAE-resistant mice with anti-programmed death 1 (PD-1) monoclonal antibody-induced EAE in 67% of mice. We conclude that non-myeloablative transplantation of self-antigen expressing BM induces robust peripheral tolerance that completely prevented EAE development. Our findings implicate clonal anergy and the PD-1 pathway in the maintenance of peripheral tolerance.

Studies of Immune Mechanisms of Diabetes and Treatment with Isolated Pancreatic Islets

Reviewed here are studies in animal models of type I diabetes that have led to better understanding of the disease and progress to its cure by of pancreatic islet transplantation and/or manipu-lations of the immune system. These studies include: 1) the first complete and permanent cure of chemi-cally induced diabetes in rodents; 2) demons-tration of autoimmune recurrence of diabetes in islet recipients; 3) induction of intrathymic tolerance to islets; 4) prevention of autoimmune diabetes by thymic manipulation; and 5) demonstration of the importance of B lymphocytes in autoimmune diabetes and islet rejection. These experimental studies over the last four decades are the basis of a successful ongoing human islet transplant program.

Efficient Intrathymic Gene Transfer Following In Situ Administration of a rAAV Serotype 8 Vector in Mice and Nonhuman Primates

The thymus is the primary site of T-cell development and plays a key role in the induction of self-tolerance. We previously showed that the intrathymic (i.t.) injection of a transgene-expressing lentiviral vector (LV) in mice can result in the correction of a T cell-specific genetic defect. Nevertheless, the efficiency of thymocyte transduction did not exceed 0.1-0.3% and we were unable to detect any thymus transduction in macaques. As such, we initiated studies to assess the capacity of recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vectors to transduce murine and primate thymic cells. In vivo administration of AAV serotype 2-derived single-stranded AAV (ssAAV) and self-complementary AAV (scAAV) vectors pseudotyped with capsid proteins of serotypes 1, 2, 4, 5, and 8 demonstrated that murine thymus transduction was significantly enhanced by scAAV2/8. Transgene expression was detected in 5% of thymocytes and, notably, transduced cells represented 1% of peripheral T lymphocytes. Moreover, i.t. administration of scAAV2/8 particles in macaques, by endoscopic-mediated guidance, resulted in significant gene transfer. Thus, in healthy animals, where thymic gene transfer does not provide a selective advantage, scAAV2/8 is a unique tool promoting the in situ transduction of thymocytes with the subsequent export of gene-modified lymphocytes to the periphery.

Tolerance Induction in a Large-Animal Model Using Total Lymphoid Irradiation and Intrathymic Bone Marrow

Immunological unresponsiveness of T cells to alloantigen can be induced by intrathymic injection of donor-specific antigen in small-animal models. Intrathymic tolerance to vascularized grafts in large animals has not previously been reported. Thirty-two dogs were allocated into dog leukocyte antigen DP locus allele (class II)-matched donor-recipient pairs. Female recipients were paired with male donors. Tissue typing was based on restriction fragment length polymorphism. Recipients were given 18 Gy total lymphoid irradiation in 16 fractions (1.125 Gy each) over 4 weeks. Thoracotomy after the 6th fraction permitted perithymic (n=4) or intrathymic (n=4) injection of donor bone marrow (BM) or intrathymic injection of saline (n=5). Another group received intravenous peripheral BM infusion (n=3). Fifty days postthoracotomy recipients underwent bilateral nephrectomy and donor-specific kidney transplantation. Acute rejection, suspected when serum creatinine was more than 600 mumol/L or urea was more than 40 mmol/L, was confirmed histologically. Full-thickness skin grafts followed more than 100 days posttransplantation. Tissue samples were taken for Y-chromosome polymerase chain reaction. One intrathymic (25%) and three perithymic (75%) BM recipients developed tolerance to renal allografts. Three intrathymic BM recipients rejected after 27, 32, and 54 days and one perithymic BM recipient rejected after 42 days. All recipients given peripheral BM or saline had rejected by 29 and 38 days, respectively. All recipients surviving more than 100 days posttransplantation, accepted donor specific and rejected dog leukocyte antigen-DP locus allele (class II) identical third-party skin grafts. Polymerase chain reaction detected intrathymic but not hematopoietic chimerism in sex-mismatched pairs. Fractionated total lymphoid irradiation and perithymic or intrathymic donor-specific BM induced tolerance to renal and skin allografts without inducing hematopoietic chimerism.

Low-density cells isolated from the rat thymus resemble branched cortical macrophages and have a reduced capability of rescuing double-positive thymocytes from apoptosis in the BB-DP rat

Biobreeding-diabetes prone (BB-DP) rats spontaneously develop organ-specific autoimmunity and are severely lymphopenic and particularly deficient in ART2(+) regulatory T cells. A special breed, the so-called BB-diabetic-resistant (DR) rats, are not lymphopenic and do not develop organ-specific autoimmunity. The genetic difference between both strains is the lymphopenia (lyp) gene. Intrathymic tolerance mechanisms are important to prevent autoimmunity, and next to thymus epithelial cells, thymus APC play a prominent part in this tolerance. We here embarked on a study to detect defects in thymus APC of the BB-DP rat and isolated thymus APC using a protocol based on the low-density and nonadherent character of the cells. We used BB-DP, BB-DR, wild-type F344, and F344 rats congenic for the lyp gene-containing region. The isolated thymus, nonadherent, low-density cells appeared to be predominantly ED2(+) branched cortical macrophages and not OX62(+) thymus medullary and cortico-medullary dendritic cells. Functionally, these ED2(+) macrophages were excellent stimulators of T cell proliferation, but it is more important that they rescued double-positive thymocytes from apoptosis. The isolated thymus ED2(+) macrophages of the BB-DP and the F344.lyp/lyp rat exhibited a reduced T cell stimulatory capacity as compared with such cells of nonlymphopenic rats. They had a strongly diminished capability of rescuing thymocytes from apoptosis (also of ART2(+) T cells) and showed a reduced Ian5 expression (as lyp/lyp thymocytes do). Our experiments strongly suggest that branched cortical macrophages play a role in positive selection of T cells in the thymus and point to defects in these cells in BB-DP rats.

Mechanisms of tolerance induced via mixed chimerism

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism provides a powerful means of inducing robust, donor-specific tolerance. In this article, the minimal requirements for achieving mixed chimerism, the development of new reagents that promote its achievement, and the mechanisms by which peripheral and intrathymic tolerance are achieved via mixed chimerism are discussed. An emerging understanding of these mechanisms, along with the development of new immunosuppressive reagents, is allowing advancement toward clinical application of this approach.

Stem cells engineered to express self-antigen to treat autoimmunity

Autoimmune diseases are incurable. We propose a combination curative strategy using haematopoietic stem cells and gene therapy. The strategy should establish molecular chimerism with culprit antigen expressed by donor antigen-presenting cells in the thymus, resulting in immunological tolerance. Our strategy is based on the intrathymic tolerance and disease resistance established by transgenic expression of antigen in the thymus under control of an MHC class II promoter. We propose that transplantation with genetically engineered stem cells provides an advance over current autologous bone marrow transplantation, in that it should remove the significant risk of disease relapse.

Efficiency of intrathymic tolerance induction in various inbred rat strains: relationship with T H1/T H2 status of the recipient?

Summary The simultaneous transplantation and intrathymic tolerance induction (STITTI) protocol induces a longlasting state of functional tolerance in over 90% of AO (RT1 u ) recipients transplanted with a fully MHC-incompatible PVG (RT1 c ) cardiac allograft. Similar results are obtained when using LEWIS (RT1 1 ) rats as recipients of either PVG or DA (RT1 avl ) grafts. However, when STITTI is performed on PVG and BN (RT1 n ) as recipient animals receiving spleen cells intrathymically and a cardiac allograft from respectively AO and PVG rats, this procedure results in significantly shorter graft survival (MST PVG → BN 25 ± 9 days; AO → PVG 31 ± 8 days) as compared to the combinations using AO (MST PVG → AO > 236 ± 28 days) and LEWIS (MST PVG → LEW > 366 ± 51 days; DA → LEW > 123 ± 33 days) rats as recipients. Since both PVG and BN rats are relatively deficient in their ability to produce IFNγ and intrathymic IFNγ responses are very dominant upon intrathymic injection of alloantigens, it is argued that the inability to effectively induce a longlasting state of functional tolerance in BN and PVG rats using the STITTI protocol may be related to their decreased IFNγ-production potential.

An alternative model to study intrathymic tolerance induction: the neonatal heart-in-ear transplantation model in the rat

An alternative model to study intrathymic tolerance induction: the neonatal heart-in-ear transplantation model in the rat

New insights on the mechanisms of acquired intrathymic tolerance

Intrathymic administration of antigen is a versatile strategy for the induction of tolerance to a wide range of allo-, xeno-, and autoantigens. Interest has now turned to developing methods allowing efficient delivery of antigen to the thymus, and to elucidating the mechanisms responsible for tolera

Direct allorecognition: a mechanism in intrathymic tolerance induction

Direct allorecognition: a mechanism in intrathymic tolerance induction

Simultaneous inoculation of donor lymphocyte subsets with transplantation in a rat cardiac allograft model

Intrathymic (IT) inoculation of soluble alloantigens (Ag) obtained from 3 M KCI extracts of resting T-cells induces donor-specific tolerance to cardiac allografts and islet allografts. This study examined the cellular basis of induction of transplantation tolerance by IT injection of soluble Ag. Our results show that while IT inoculation of 2 mg soluble donor Ag on Day -7 relative to Lewis islet transplantation induced specific unresponsiveness to islet allografts (>200 days) in naive diabetic recipients, IT inoculation of 2 mg soluble Ag on the same day as islet transplantation did not prolong islet allograft survival in the same Lewis-to-WF rat combination. To define the role of donor APCs in intrathymic tolerance, we showed that IT injection of an admixture of 1 × 104 donor DC and 2 mg soluble Ag caused acute islet graft rejection. In contrast, addition of 1 × 104 recipient-type DC to the IT inoculum did not prevent long-term graft survival. This finding suggests that while the presence of donor APCs in the inoculum does not appear neccessary for IT-alloantigen to induce peripheral tolerance, presentation of the soluble Ag in the thymus is dependent on host APCs. This conclusion is supported by our in vitro MLR experiments which showed that in vivo WF-Ag-primed Lewis T-cells proliferated specifically to WF-soluble Ag and that the response was enhanced 14-fold by the addition of responder-type DC. Addition of anti-Lewis MHC class II mAb specifically blocked the alloresponse, thus suggesting that in vivo Ag-primed T-cells are capable of recognizing and proliferating in response to allopeptides presented by responder APCs. We also showed that adoptive transfer of syngeneic naive T-cells into unresponsive recipients failed to break tolerance to long-term surviving islet allografts. This finding suggests that tolerance in this model is not due to a lack of T help. On the other hand, the adoptive transfer of spleen cells, but not sera, from the unresponsive WF recipients bearing long-term (> 120 days) functioning Lewis islets resulted in prolonged survival of donor-type but not third-party islet allografts in secondary syngeneic hosts. Our data suggest that the tolerogenic effect of IT inoculation of soluble Ag is dependent on the indirect pathway of Ag presentation and clonal deletion of alloreactive T-cells in the thymus, while suppresser/regulatory mechanism may be involved in the maintenance of peripheral tolerance.

PROLONGATION OF CARDIAC ALLOGRAFT SURVIVAL BY INTRATHYMIC INJECTION OF ANTI-FAS MONOCLONAL ANTIBODY

58 Intrathymic (IT) administration of donor antigen induces deletion of donor reactive thymocytes. In this model of acquired thymic tolerance and in neonatal tolerance, apoptosis (programmed cell death) is thought to play a role in the deletion of donor reactive clones. A major initiator of apoptosis is the interaction of FasL with its receptor Fas. To determine the role of Fas-FasL mediated apoptosis in IT tolerance we studied the effect of IT injection of an apoptosis inducing anti-Fas monoclonal Ab(Jo2) on allograft survival. Methods: Neonatal C3H cardiac grafts were transplanted into a subcutaneous ear pocket of 6-8 wk old C57BL/6 or lpr Fas deficient mice recipients. Groups included: no thymic manipulation, injection of 2.5 or 5µg (in 25µl) Jo2/thymic lobe, 2.5µg/lobe hamster IgG (HIgG, isotype control) or K10 (anti Fas-L) injected IT, surgical thymectomy prior to transplant and 5µg of Jo2 injected intraperitoneally (IP). There were 4 to 6 animals/group. Results: Injection of 5 µg of Jo2 IT significantly improved allograft survival compared to untreated controls. This was Fas-specific (b vs cde), was not the result of a "chemical thymectomy" (b vs f), was not due to a systemic effect of Jo2 (b vs g) and did require precise dosage (b vs h). Naive thymocytes exposed to Jo2 in vitro and thymocytes harvested from Jo2 IT injected animals were assayed for apoptosis by FACS analysis with Hoechst dye 342 and propidium iodide. FACS analysis showed dramatically increased amounts of thymocyte apoptosis compared with controls. TableTableConclusions: IT injection of anti-Fas Ab prolonged murine cardiac allograft survival. This effect may be due to apoptosis of thymocytes and/or activated lymphocytes recirculating through the thymus, or to the systemic release of cytokines and soluble HLA molecules after apoptosis in the thymus.

Viral Superantigen-Induced Negative Selection of TCR Transgenic CD4+ CD8+ Thymocytes Depends on Activation, but not Proliferation

T-cell negative selection, a process by which intrathymic immunological tolerance is induced, involves the apoptosis-mediated clonal deletion of potentially autoreactive T cells. Although different experimental approaches suggest that this process is triggered as the result of activation-mediated cell death, the signal transduction pathways underlying this process is not fully understood. In the present report we have used an in vitro system to analyze the cell activation and proliferation requirements for the deletion of viral superantigen (SAg)-reactive Vβ8.1 T-cell receptor (TCR) transgenic (TG) thymocytes. Our results indicate that in vitro negative selection of viral SAg-reactive CD4+ CD8+thymocytes is dependent on thymocyte activation but does not require the proliferation of the negatively signaled thymocytes.

Mechanisms of intrathymic tolerance induction to isolated rat hepatocyte allografts.

Intrathymic injection of alloantigen in young adult rats is capable of mediating long-lived transplantation tolerance. In this study, we use a well-defined model of isolated hepatocyte transplantation to define the mechanisms of intrathymic induced tolerance. The recipient rats are Nagase analbuminemic rats (NAR) that are deficient in albumin, to allow for following transplant acceptance using metabolic and genetic markers. Tolerance to allogeneic hepatocyte transplants could be mediated by intrathymic injection of live allogeneic splenocytes, lethally irradiated splenocytes, or isolated hepatocytes. Intrathymic injection of live allogeneic splenocytes, but not of hepatocytes or irradiated splenocytes, resulted in donor microchimerism in peripheral lymphoid organs, with preferential expansion of CD4-positive T cells in the recipient spleens. Tolerance could be adoptively transferred from tolerant animals to naive recipients, but only from those animals that had been inoculated with intrathymic donor splenocytes. We conclude that donor microchimerism is found after intrathymic inoculation of live splenocytes, but is not required for tolerance induction and that microchimerism is not an absolute requirement for the generation of regulatory cells.

Mechanisms of intrathymic tolerance induction to isolated rat hepatocyte allografts

Intrathymic injection of alloantigen in young adult rats is capable of mediating long-lived transplantation tolerance. In this study, we use a well-defined model of isolated hepatocyte transplantation to define the mechanisms of intrathymic induced tolerance. The recipient rats are Nagase analbuminemic rats (NAR) that are deficient in albumin, to allow for following transplant acceptance using metabolic and genetic markers. Tolerance to allogeneic hepatocyte transplants could be mediated by intrathymic injection of live allogeneic splenocytes, lethally irradiated splenocytes, or isolated hepatocytes. Intrathymic injection of live allogeneic splenocytes, but not of hepatocytes or irradiated splenocytes, resulted in donor microchimerism in peripheral lymphoid organs, with preferential expansion of CD4-positive T cells in the recipient spleens. Tolerance could be adoptively transferred from tolerant animals to naive recipients, but only from those animals that had been inoculated with intrathymic donor splenocytes. We conclude that donor microchimerism is found after intrathymic inoculation of live splenocytes, but is not required for tolerance induction and that microchimerism is not an absolute requirement for the generation of regulatory cells. (Hepatology 1997 Nov;26(5):1287-95)

Long-lasting adenovirus transgene expression in mice through neonatal intrathymic tolerance induction without the use of immunosuppression.

The major barrier to the clinical application of adenovirus gene therapy for diseases that require stable transgene expression is the immunogenicity of recombinant adenovirus, which ordinarily limits the duration of its effects to a period of about 2 weeks. We postulated that tolerance to adenovirus could be induced and transgene expression could be prolonged if T lymphocytes underwent thymic selection in the presence of adenovirus antigens. Mice were inoculated in the thymus with a recombinant adenovirus containing the lacZ marker gene during the neonatal period at a time before T-cell maturation had occurred. When the virus was administered intravenously to these mice in adulthood, they were found to have an impaired adenovirus-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response which allowed prolonged hepatic lacZ expression, for up to 260 days. The ability to achieve unresponsiveness to a recombinant adenovirus after inoculation of the thymus in neonates extends the paradigm of intrathymic tolerance induction. Furthermore, this model will enable the study of stable adenovirus transgene expression in vivo without the use of immunosuppression and ultimately may have clinical utility.

Effects of intrathymic tolerance on mouse heart and skin allograft acceptance

Effects of intrathymic tolerance on mouse heart and skin allograft acceptance

Expression and presentation of endogenous mouse mammary tumor virus superantigens by thymic and splenic dendritic cells and B cells.

Tolerance against superantigens (SAgs) encoded by endogenous mouse mammary tumor virus (Mtv) loci involves the intrathymic deletion of SAg-reactive T cells expressing a particular TCR V beta-chain, presumably upon presentation of the SAg by specialized APC. However, although the role of dendritic cells (DC) in the induction of tolerance against conventional Ags has been demonstrated, little is known about the role played by DC in tolerance induction against Mtv SAgs. Moreover, there is conflicting evidence concerning the capacity of DC to express and present Mtv SAgs. In this report we have analyzed the expression of Mtv SAgs in highly purified thymic and splenic DC and B cells by reverse transcriptase-PCR, using primers amplifying Mtv SAg-specific spliced mRNAs. DC express Mtv SAgs at levels comparable to B cells, but display a differential expression pattern of the various Mtv loci compared with B cells. Furthermore, our results show that DC are able to induce the deletion of SAg-reactive thymocytes in an in vitro assay, indicating that Mtv SAgs are functionally expressed on the DC surface. Collectively, our data are consistent with the hypothesis that DC play a role in the induction of intrathymic tolerance to Mtv SAgs.