First of all, we would like to thank Frederik Dikkers for his interest in our article: Matar N, Amoussa K, Verduyckt I, Nollevaux MC, Jamart J, Lawson G, Remacle M. CO2 laser-assisted microsurgery for intracordal cysts: technique and results of 49 patients. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 267:1905–1909, as well as for his comments published recently [1]. Dr Dikkers is kind enough to recognize our expertise in laser technology and its application in microsurgery. We fully agree that the CO2 laser scanning technology is not the single best technique for treating intracordal cysts or any other benign vocal fold lesions. However, what we wanted to demonstrate is that lesions affecting the deep part of the lamina propria can be operated by CO2 laser without any injury the vocal ligament, provided that the parameters are strictly respected. That was considered impossible by many surgeons just some years ago. We have showed in a previous paper [2] that the coagulation along the incision line is 15 lm for ultra-pulse (median values) allowing sharp and precise section. Therefore, we agree that the functional results are similar for cold-steel or CO2-laser scanning, but we find presently the procedure easier to perform by CO2 laser. According to our biostatistician and co-author Jacques Jamart, calculation of medians is a popular technique in summary statistics and summarizing statistical data, because it is simple to understand and easy to calculate, while also giving a measure that is more robust in the presence of outlier values than is the mean [3]. With regard to the voice tone, we do not think that many readers of this journal are familiar with semitones and many instruments are calibrated in Hertz (Hz) [4]. Moreover, from what we know and contrary to what Dr Dikkers says, the frequency scale (Hz) by itself is not logarithmic, only the intensity scale is (in decibel or dB) [5]. This is true, however, that the pitch, a perceptual attribute of sound does not have a linear relationship with the fundamental frequency. The auditory system is more sensitive to some frequency changes than to others. In particular, the average listener is more sensitive to changes at lower frequencies. The semitone scale reflects actually this situation by an exponential growth function [6]. As we were dealing in our paper, not with the perception of the voice range, but with the improvement of the voice range itself, we found that expressing our results in hertz was more significant. We agree with Dr Dikkers that buying such an equipment only for phonosurgery would not be cost-efficient, but the versatility of this device is so extended: from cancer surgery to benign lesions of the vocal fold, from larynx and pharynx to middle ear and nose, from dermatology and gynecology to oto-rhino-laryngology.... With so many possible applications that cannot be performed by coldsteel surgery, spending money in laser technology makes a lot of sense for an institution or a group of practitioners.
Read full abstract