Various geological processes that affect Earth's crust may be encoded into isotopic tracers preserved in rocks and minerals. The enhanced sensitivity of U, Th, and Pb to crustal fractionation processes allows Pb isotopes to complement information from the Nd and Hf isotope systems. However, melt fractionation, crustal contamination and recycling, hydrothermal fluid flow and fluid-rock interaction, and other processes in the continental crust can lead to mixing of Pb isotopic signatures. Here, we report new Pb isotopic data from granite-K-feldspar and integrate these data with published Pb isotope ratios from granite K-feldspar and Pb-rich ores across the Yilgarn Craton in Western Australia. The aim of this study is to explore how the variability of Pb isotope ratios and derivative parameters can be used to gain information on specific geological processes occurring throughout the crustal column. We develop a model that subdivides different sampling media into chemical process groups and links their initial Pb signatures to Pb source regions and fractionation processes at various locations within the crust and upper mantle. Equilibration of Pb signatures with a primary mantle source reservoir (in part represented by volcanic-hosted massive sulfides) is contrasted with granite formation in the mid to lower crust (granite K-feldspar), and mineralization of ore deposits in the mid to upper crust (Pb-rich ores). Spatial trends similar to those in Nd and Hf isotopic data are recorded by Pb isotopic derivative parameters (μ = source 238U/204Pb, ω = 232Th/204Pb, and Δt - the difference between true sample age and Pb model age) calculated for komatiite-hosted Ni sulfide ores, granite K-feldspar, and volcanic-hosted massive sulfide (VHMS) ores. The significance of subtle differences in absolute values of derivative parameters is supported by the diversity of Pb isotope ratios, Pb model ages, and ∆t as tracked by a statistical metric, quantifying the variability of Pb sources involved in the formation of different chemical process groups. Generally greater variety in an older terrane (Youanmi) documents more ancient and recycled continental crust as compared with more homogeneous Pb isotopic signatures in a younger terrane (Eastern Goldfields Superterrane). The Pb signatures are interpreted, in part, to relate to the timing of source fractionation in the upper mantle with a legacy of this source signal preserved through various depths in the lithospheric section. The least radiogenic VHMS ore samples appear to provide a good approximation of mantle Pb signatures, indicated for example by a deficit in 206Pb and 208Pb relative to the other process groups. A significant heterogeneity recorded in Pb isotopic data from Pb-rich gold ores is explained by the interplay of hydrothermal fluids with diverse sources leading to the mineralization of gold deposits (e.g., leaching of Pb from surrounding rocks or fluid mixing). Such gold ore Pb signatures are distinct from other process groups, which together track sources less heterogeneous in age and/or U and Th.
Read full abstract