Intermonomer Electron Transfer Research Articles

On the inter-monomer electron transfer in cytochrome bc1

Cytochrome bc1 is a structural and functional homodimer. The catalytically-relevant inter-monomer electron transfer has been implicated by a number of experiments, including those based on analyses of the cross-dimer mutated derivatives. As some of the original data on these derivatives have recently been questioned, we extend kinetic analysis of these mutants to confirm the enzymatic origin of the observed activities and their relevance in exploration of conditions that expose electron transfer between the monomers. While obtained data consistently implicate rapid inter-monomer electron equilibration in cytochrome bc1, the mechanistic and physiological meaning of this equilibration is yet to be established.

Investigating inter-monomer electron transfer in cytochrome bc1 and its influence on ROS generation by the quinol oxidation site

Investigating inter-monomer electron transfer in cytochrome bc1 and its influence on ROS generation by the quinol oxidation site

Catalytic Reactions and Energy Conservation in the Cytochrome bc1 and b6f Complexes of Energy-Transducing Membranes.

This review focuses on key components of respiratory and photosynthetic energy-transduction systems: the cytochrome bc1 and b6f (Cytbc1/b6f) membranous multisubunit homodimeric complexes. These remarkable molecular machines catalyze electron transfer from membranous quinones to water-soluble electron carriers (such as cytochromes c or plastocyanin), coupling electron flow to proton translocation across the energy-transducing membrane and contributing to the generation of a transmembrane electrochemical potential gradient, which powers cellular metabolism in the majority of living organisms. Cytsbc1/b6f share many similarities but also have significant differences. While decades of research have provided extensive knowledge on these enzymes, several important aspects of their molecular mechanisms remain to be elucidated. We summarize a broad range of structural, mechanistic, and physiological aspects required for function of Cytbc1/b6f, combining textbook fundamentals with new intriguing concepts that have emerged from more recent studies. The discussion covers but is not limited to (i) mechanisms of energy-conserving bifurcation of electron pathway and energy-wasting superoxide generation at the quinol oxidation site, (ii) the mechanism by which semiquinone is stabilized at the quinone reduction site, (iii) interactions with substrates and specific inhibitors, (iv) intermonomer electron transfer and the role of a dimeric complex, and (v) higher levels of organization and regulation that involve Cytsbc1/b6f. In addressing these topics, we point out existing uncertainties and controversies, which, as suggested, will drive further research in this field.

Hybrid fusions show that inter-monomer electron transfer robustly supports cytochrome bc1 function in vivo

Electronic connection between Qo and Qi quinone catalytic sites of dimeric cytochrome bc1 is a central feature of the energy-conserving Q cycle. While both the intra- and inter-monomer electron transfers were shown to connect the sites in the enzyme, mechanistic and physiological significance of the latter remains unclear. Here, using a series of mutated hybrid cytochrome bc1-like complexes, we show that inter-monomer electron transfer robustly sustains the function of the enzyme in vivo, even when the two subunits in a dimer come from different species. This indicates that minimal requirement for bioenergetic efficiency is to provide a chain of cofactors for uncompromised electron flux between the catalytic sites, while the details of protein scaffold are secondary.

Inter-monomer electron transfer in asymmetrically mutated fusion hybrid cytochrome bc1-like complex supports the enzyme function in vivo

Inter-monomer electron transfer in asymmetrically mutated fusion hybrid cytochrome bc1-like complex supports the enzyme function in vivo

Intermonomer Electron Transfer between the b Hemes of Heterodimeric Cytochrome bc1

The ubihydroquinone:cytochrome c oxidoreductase, or cytochrome bc1, is a central component of respiratory and photosynthetic energy transduction pathways in many organisms. It contributes to the generation of membrane potential and proton gradient used for cellular energy (ATP) production. The three-dimensional structures of cytochrome bc1 show a homodimeric organization of its three catalytic subunits. The unusual architecture revived the issue of whether the monomers operate independently or function cooperatively during the catalytic cycle of the enzyme. In recent years, different genetic approaches allowed the successful production of heterodimeric cytochrome bc1 variants and evidenced the occurrence of intermonomer electron transfer between the monomers of this enzyme. Here we used a version of the "two-plasmid" genetic system, also described in the preceding paper (DOI: 10.1021/bi400560p), to study a new heterodimeric mutant variant of cytochrome bc1. The strain producing this heterodimeric variant sustained photosynthetic growth of Rhodobacter capsulatus and yielded an active heterodimer. Interestingly, kinetic data showed equilibration of electrons among the four b heme cofactors of the heterodimer, via "reverse" intermonomer electron transfer between the bL hemes. Both inactive homodimeric and active heterodimeric cytochrome bc1 variants were purified to homogeneity from the same cells, and purified samples were subjected to mass spectrometry analyses. The data unequivocally supported the idea that the cytochrome b subunits carried the expected mutations and their associated epitope tags. Implications of these findings on our interpretation of light-activated transient cytochrome b and c redox kinetics and the mechanism of function of a dimeric cytochrome bc1 are discussed with respect to the previously proposed heterodimeric Q cycle model.

A Robust Genetic System for Producing Heterodimeric Native and Mutant Cytochrome bc1

The ubihydroquinone:cytochrome c oxidoreductase, or cytochrome bc1, is central to the production of ATP by oxidative phosphorylation and photophosphorylation in many organisms. Its three-dimensional structure depicts it as a homodimer with each monomer composed of the Fe-S protein, cytochrome b, and cytochrome c1 subunits. Recent genetic approaches successfully produced heterodimeric variants of this enzyme, providing insights into its mechanism of function. However, these experimental setups are inherently prone to genetic rearrangements as they carry repeated copies of cytochrome bc1 structural genes. Duplications present on a single replicon (one-plasmid system) or a double replicon (two-plasmid system) could yield heterogeneous populations via homologous recombination or other genetic events at different frequencies, especially under selective growth conditions. In this work, we assessed the origins and frequencies of genetic variations encountered in these systems and describe an improved variant of the two-plasmid system. We found that use of a recombination-deficient background (recA) minimizes spontaneous formation of co-integrant plasmids and renders the homologous recombination within the cytochrome b gene copies inconsequential. On the basis of the data, we conclude that both the newly improved RecA-deficient and the previously used RecA-proficient two-plasmid systems reliably produce native and mutant heterodimeric cytochrome bc1 variants. The two-plasmid system developed here might contribute to the study of "mitochondrial heteroplasmy"-like heterogeneous states in model bacteria (e.g., Rhodobacter species) suitable for bioenergetics studies. In the following paper (DOI 10.1021/bi400561e), we describe the use of the two-plasmid system to produce and characterize, in membranes and in purified states, an active heterodimeric cytochrome bc1 variant with unusual intermonomer electron transfer properties.

Catalytically-relevant electron transfer between two hemes bL in the hybrid cytochrome bc1-like complex containing a fusion of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and capsulatus cytochromes b

To address mechanistic questions about the functioning of dimeric cytochrome bc1 new genetic approaches have recently been developed. They were specifically designed to enable construction of asymmetrically-mutated variants suitable for functional studies. One approach exploited a fusion of two cytochromes b that replaced the separate subunits in the dimer. The fusion protein, built from two copies of the same cytochrome b of purple bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus, served as a template to create a series of asymmetrically-mutated cytochrome bc1-like complexes (B–B) which, through kinetic studies, disclosed several important principles of dimer engineering. Here, we report on construction of another fusion protein complex that adds a new tool to investigate dimeric function of the enzyme through the asymmetrically mutated forms of the protein. This complex (BS–B) contains a hybrid protein that combines two different cytochromes b: one coming from R. capsulatus and the other — from a closely related species, R. sphaeroides. With this new fusion we addressed a still controversial issue of electron transfer between the two hemes bL in the core of dimer. Kinetic data obtained with a series of BS–B variants provided new evidence confirming the previously reported observations that electron transfer between those two hemes occurs on a millisecond timescale, thus is a catalytically-relevant event. Both types of the fusion complexes (B–B and BS–B) consistently implicate that the heme-bL–bL bridge forms an electronic connection available for inter-monomer electron transfer in cytochrome bc1.

Inter-monomer electron transfer between the b hemes of cytochrome bc1

Inter-monomer electron transfer between the b hemes of cytochrome bc1

Inter-monomer electron transfer is too slow to compete with monomeric turnover in bc1 complex

The homodimeric bc1 complexes are membrane proteins essential in respiration and photosynthesis. The ~11Å distance between the two bL-hemes of the dimer opens the possibility of electron transfer between them, but contradictory reports make such inter-monomer electron transfer controversial. We have constructed in Rhodobacter sphaeroides a heterodimeric expression system similar to those used before, in which the bc1 complex can be mutated differentially in the two copies of cyt b to test for inter-monomer electron transfer, but found that genetic recombination by cross-over then occurs to produce wild-type homodimer. Selection pressure under photosynthetic growth always favored the homodimer over heterodimeric variants enforcing inter-monomer electron transfer, showing that the latter are not competitive. These results, together with kinetic analysis of myxothiazol titrations, demonstrate that inter-monomer electron transfer does not occur at rates competitive with monomeric turnover. We examine the results from other groups interpreted as demonstrating rapid inter-monomer electron transfer, conclude that similar mechanisms are likely to be in play, and suggest that such claims might need to be re-examined.

Enzymatic Activities of Isolated Cytochrome bc1-like Complexes Containing Fused Cytochrome b Subunits with Asymmetrically Inactivated Segments of Electron Transfer Chains

Homodimeric structure of cytochrome bc1, a common component of biological energy conversion systems, builds in four catalytic quinone oxidation/reduction sites and four chains of cofactors (branches) that, connected by a centrally located bridge, form a symmetric H-shaped electron transfer system. The mechanism of operation of this complex system is under constant debate. Here, we report on isolation and enzymatic examination of cytochrome bc1-like complexes containing fused cytochrome b subunits in which asymmetrically introduced mutations inactivated individual branches in various combinations. The structural asymmetry of those forms was confirmed spectroscopically. All the asymmetric forms corresponding to cytochrome bc1 with partial or full inactivation of one monomer retain high enzymatic activity but at the same time show a decrease in the maximum turnover rate by a factor close to 2. This strongly supports the model assuming independent operation of monomers. The cross-inactivated form corresponding to cytochrome bc1 with disabled complementary parts of each monomer retains the enzymatic activity at the level that, for the first time on isolated from membranes and purified to homogeneity preparations, demonstrates that intermonomer electron transfer through the bridge effectively sustains the enzymatic turnover. The results fully support the concept that electrons freely distribute between the four catalytic sites of a dimer and that any path connecting the catalytic sites on the opposite sides of the membrane is enzymatically competent. The possibility to examine enzymatic properties of isolated forms of asymmetric complexes constructed using the cytochrome b fusion system extends the array of tools available for investigating the engineering of dimeric cytochrome bc1 from the mechanistic and physiological perspectives.

Negative Cooperativity in the Reduction of Excitonically Interacting B-Hemes of the Cytochrome B6F Complex

Cytochrome b6f and bc1 (bc) complexes, which provide the central charge transfer complex in respiratory and photosynthetic electron transport chains, are symmetric dimeric structures.1 A trans-membrane electron transfer pathway between hemes bp and bn2 exists in each monomer. Based on inter-heme distances this intra-monomer pathway (bp-bn) is preferred over an inter-monomer cross-over pathway between hemes bp1. Cross-over has been reported,3,4 although the branching ratio is not known. Previous studies on ferredoxin-dependent reduction of b6f by NADPH showed only half of the b-heme reduced in thylakoid membranes,5 and biphasic reduction with isolated complex.6 It was inferred that the rapid reduction occurred through intra-monomer electron transfer and that the split circular dichroism spectrum7,8 (node of the CD spectrum in the Soret band coincides with the heme absorbance maximum), implies that the hemes bp and bn interact excitonically in the monomeric unit. Here, monophasic chemical (dithionite) reduction of monomeric b6f complex, characterized by size-exclusion chromatography, proceeds 10-20 times more rapidly than in the dimeric complex. The reduced monomer showed full amplitude of the Soret band split CD spectrum. These measurements are consistent with “half-sites reactivity” observed for b-heme reduction in the yeast bc1 complex,9,10 in which reduction of one monomer is associated with a reduced rate of electron transfer to the second monomer of the bc1 dimer. The mechanism for this negative cooperativity could arise from a larger reorganization energy11 for inter-monomer electron transfer, or constraints imposed by the Rieske protein in the dimer. NIH-GM38323.1Cramer et al. 2011; 2Yamashita et al. 2007; 3Lanciano et al. 2010; 4Swierczek et al. 2010; 5Furbacher et al. 1989; 6Hasan et al., 2011; 7Palmer and Degli-Esposti 1994; 8Schoepp et al. 2000; 9Covian and Trumpower, 2008; 10Castellani et al. 2010; 11Marcus and Sutin 1985.

X-ray structure of the dimeric cytochrome bc1 complex from the soil bacterium Paracoccus denitrificans at 2.7-Å resolution

The respiratory cytochrome bc1 complex is a fundamental enzyme in biological energy conversion. It couples electron transfer from ubiquinol to cytochrome c with generation of proton motive force which fuels ATP synthesis. The complex from the α-proteobacterium Paracoccus denitrificans, a model for the medically relevant mitochondrial complexes, lacked structural characterization. We show by LILBID mass spectrometry that truncation of the organism-specific, acidic N-terminus of cytochrome c1 changes the oligomerization state of the enzyme to a dimer. The fully functional complex was crystallized and the X-ray structure determined at 2.7-Å resolution. It has high structural homology to mitochondrial complexes and to the Rhodobacter sphaeroides complex especially for subunits cytochrome b and ISP. Species-specific binding of the inhibitor stigmatellin is noteworthy. Interestingly, cytochrome c1 shows structural differences to the mitochondrial and even between the two Rhodobacteraceae complexes. The structural diversity in the cytochrome c1 surface facing the ISP domain indicates low structural constraints on that surface for formation of a productive electron transfer complex. A similar position of the acidic N-terminal domains of cytochrome c1 and yeast subunit QCR6p is suggested in support of a similar function. A model of the electron transfer complex with membrane-anchored cytochrome c552, the natural substrate, shows that it can adopt the same orientation as the soluble substrate in the yeast complex. The full structural integrity of the P. denitrificans variant underpins previous mechanistic studies on intermonomer electron transfer and paves the way for using this model system to address open questions of structure/function relationships and inhibitor binding.

Intermonomer Electron Transfer between the Low-Potential b Hemes of Cytochrome bc1

Cytochrome (cyt) bc(1) is a structural dimer with its monomers consisting of the Fe-S protein, cyt b, and cyt c(1) subunits. Its three-dimensional architecture depicts it as a symmetrical homodimer, but the mobility of the head domain of the Fe-S protein indicates that the functional enzyme exists in asymmetrical heterodimeric conformations. Here, we report a new genetic system for studying intra- and intermonomer interactions within the cyt bc(1) using the facultative phototrophic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus. The system involves two different sets of independently expressed cyt bc(1) structural genes carried by two plasmids that are coharbored by a cell without its endogenous enzyme. Our results indicate that coexpressed cyt bc(1) subunits were matured, assorted, and assembled in vivo into homo- and heterodimeric enzymes that can bear different mutations in each monomer. Using the system, the occurrence of intermonomer electron transfer between the low-potential b hemes of cyt bc(1) was probed by choosing mutations that perturb electron transfer at the hydroquinone oxidation (Q(o)) and quinone reduction (Q(i)) sites of the enzyme. The data demonstrate that active heterodimeric variants, formed of monomers carrying mutations that abolish only one of the two (Q(o) or Q(i)) active sites of each monomer, are produced, and they support photosynthetic growth of R. capsulatus. Detailed analyses of the physicochemical properties of membranes of these mutants, as well as purified homo- and heterodimeric cyt bc(1) preparations, demonstrated that efficient and productive electron transfer occurs between the low-potential b(L) hemes of the monomers in a heterodimeric enzyme. Overall findings are discussed with respect to intra- and intermonomer interactions that take place during the catalytic turnover of cyt bc(1).

Intermonomer electron transfer in the bc1 complex dimer is controlled by the energized state and by impaired electron transfer between low and high potential hemes

The cytochrome bc 1 complex (commonly called Complex III) is the central enzyme of respiratory and photosynthetic electron transfer chains. X-ray structures have revealed the bc 1 complex to be a dimer, and show that the distance between low potential ( b L) and high potential ( b H) hemes, is similar to the distance between low potential hemes in different monomers. This suggests that electron transfer between monomers should occur at the level of the b L hemes. Here, we show that although the rate constant for b L → b L electron transfer is substantial, it is slow compared to the forward rate from b L to b H, and the intermonomer transfer only occurs after equilibration within the first monomer. The effective rate of intermonomer transfer is about 2-orders of magnitude slower than the direct intermonomer electron transfer.

The dimeric form of flavocytochrome P450 BM3 is catalytically functional as a fatty acid hydroxylase

In the model P450 BM3 system, the P450 is fused to its diflavin reductase partner in a single polypeptide. BM3 dimerizes in solution, but the catalytic relevance of the phenomenon was hitherto unknown. We show that BM3 fatty acid hydroxylase specific activity decreases sharply at low enzyme concentrations, consistent with separation of active dimer into inactive monomer. Reductase-dependent specific activities are maintained or enhanced at low concentration, suggesting inter-flavin electron transfer is unaffected. Fatty acid oxidation is reconstituted by mixing inactive oxygenase (A264H) and FMN-depleted (G570D) mutants, demonstrating that inter-monomer (FMN 1-to-heme 2) electron transfer supports oxygenase activity in the BM3 dimer.