Hip fractures significantly impact morbidity and mortality among frail older adults, posing ongoing challenges in orthogeriatric care despite significant advancements. Established in the 1960s by Devas and Irvine, this field integrates orthopedics, trauma services, and geriatric medicine to address the complex needs of this population comprehensively. A critical and underexplored aspect is the precise identification and tailored treatment of various fracture types, each linked to unique clinical challenges and outcomes. This special article emphasizes the complex interplay between specific fracture types, their management options, and the roles of comorbidity and polypharmacy, highlighting the essential role of orthogeriatricians. Orthogeriatricians navigate the complexities posed by comorbidities, frailty, and polypharmacy, significantly influencing treatment outcomes. Their roles have expanded to include decision making about both operative and nonoperative strategies, emphasizing patient-centered care and moving beyond simplistic categorizations of “hip fractures.” As future experts on the nuances of fracture types and their broader health implications, orthogeriatricians are also crucial in advancing treatment protocols that address preoperative and postoperative needs. Their comprehensive knowledge ensures effective in-hospital management and postdischarge planning, aligning treatment strategies with the holistic needs of frail older adults. The ongoing evolution of orthogeriatric practices promises to enhance decision-making and patient outcomes through a more informed and integrated care approach.