BackgroundDietary quality has been linked to better glycemic control, but the precise molecular mechanisms giving rise to these associations are not fully understood. ObjectivesTo examine the association of metabolites associated with the intake of a healthy diet with measures of insulin/glucose homeostasis. MethodsUsing cross-sectional data from 295 United States adults, the associations between 3 diet pattern scores and metabolome-wide metabolites were estimated via linear regression models, which controlled for demographic factors and health behaviors. Subsequently, the associations between the diet-related metabolites with 6 measures of glucose/insulin homeostasis were examined in similar models. A Bonferroni correction was applied to control the familywise error rate at 5%. ResultsFifty-five metabolites were significantly associated with ≥1 diet score (all P < 1.7∗10–5). When these were summed into each of the 3 diet-specific metabolite summary scores, all 3 aggregate measures showed strong associations with 5 out of 6 measures of glucose/insulin homeostasis (P = 9.7∗10–5–4.1∗10–13). ConclusionsAdherence to a priori-defined “healthy diet” is associated with the plasma metabolites that, in turn, are associated with better glycemia. If the associations between replicated in future studies and examined using large-scale longitudinal data, the identified molecules could yield insights into mechanisms by which diet may support glucose and insulin homeostasis.