Despite its attractiveness for long-term carbon dioxide removal (CDR), quantifying weathering and CDR rates for enhanced weathering is a significant challenge. Moreover, the role of soil organisms, such as earthworms, in enhancing silicate weathering (both physically and chemically) has been suggested, but there is limited quantitative data on how biota, especially earthworms, contribute to inorganic carbon sequestration. To address these gaps, we conducted a mesocosm experiment with earthworms and basalt.Results indicate increases in clay and cation exchange, causing a weathering rate of over 10−12 mol total alkalinity m2 s−1, in range with other basalt experiments. Basalt amendment increased dissolved inorganic carbon export by only 4 g CO2 m−2. During the 4.5-month experiment, we observed neither a change in organic nor in inorganic carbon content.In soils without earthworms, basalt amendment reduced soil CO₂ efflux by approximately 0.2 kg CO₂ m2, suggesting considerable CDR. This decrease was about two times larger than calculated inorganic CDR equivalents, suggesting changes in soil organic matter dynamics.Interestingly, earthworms reversed the basalt-induced reduction in soil CO₂ efflux. This reversal was partly due to reduced export of dissolved inorganic carbon but mainly driven by increased organic matter decomposition. Our study highlights the importance of including organic carbon dynamics when evaluating the CDR potential of enhanced weathering.