Inhibitory Force Feedback Research Articles

Neuromechanical Circuits of the Spinal Motor Apparatus.

The evolution of mechanisms for terrestrial locomotion has resulted in multi-segmented limbs that allow navigation on irregular terrains, changing of direction, manipulation of external objects, and control over the mechanical properties of limbs important for interaction with the environment, with corresponding changes in neural pathways in the spinal cord. This article is focused on the organization of these pathways, their interactions with the musculoskeletal system, and the integration of these neuromechanical circuits with supraspinal mechanisms to control limb impedance. It is argued that neural pathways from muscle spindles and Golgi tendon organs form a distributive impedance controller in the spinal cord that controls limb impedance and coordination during responses to external disturbances. These pathways include both monosynaptic and polysynaptic components. Autogenic, monosynaptic pathways serve to control the spring-like properties of muscles preserving the nonlinear relationship between stiffness and force. Intermuscular monosynaptic pathways compensate for inertial disparities between the inertial properties of limb segments and help to control inertial coupling between joints and axes of rotation. Reciprocal inhibition controls joint stiffness in conjunction with feedforward cocontraction commands. Excitatory force feedback becomes operational during locomotion and increases muscular stiffness to accommodate the higher inertial loads. Inhibitory force feedback is widely distributed among muscles. It is integrated with excitatory pathways from muscle spindles and Golgi tendon organs to determine limb stiffness and interjoint coordination during interactions with the environment. The intermuscular distribution of force feedback is variable and serves to modulate limb stiffness to meet the physical demands of different motor tasks. © 2024 American Physiological Society. Compr Physiol 14:5789-5838, 2024.

Redistribution of inhibitory force feedback between a long toe flexor and the major ankle extensor muscles following spinal cord injury.

Inhibitory pathways from Golgi tendon organs project widely between muscles crossing different joints and axes of rotation. Evidence suggests that the strength and distribution of this intermuscular inhibition is dependent on motor task and corresponding signals from the brainstem. The purpose of the present study was to investigate whether this sensory network is altered after spinal cord hemisection as a potential explanation for motor deficits observed after spinal cord injury (SCI). Force feedback was assessed between the long toe flexor and ankle plantarflexor (flexor hallucis longus), and the three major ankle extensors, (combined gastrocnemius, soleus, and plantaris muscles) in the hind limbs of unanesthetized, decerebrate, female cats. Data were collected from animals with intact spinal cords (control) and lateral spinal hemisections (LSHs) including chronic LSH (4-20 weeks), subchronic LSH (2weeks), and acute LSH. Muscles were stretched individually and in pairwise combinations to measure intermuscular feedback between the toe flexor and each of the ankle extensors. In control animals, three patterns were observed (balanced inhibition between toe flexor and ankle extensors, stronger inhibition from toe flexor to ankle extensor, and vice versa). Following spinal hemisection, only strong inhibition from toe flexors onto ankle extensors was observed independent of survival time. The results suggest immediate and permanent reorganization of force feedback in the injured spinal cord. The altered strength and distribution of force feedback after SCI may be an important future target for rehabilitation.

Distributed force feedback in the spinal cord and the regulation of limb mechanics.

This review is an update on the role of force feedback from Golgi tendon organs in the regulation of limb mechanics during voluntary movement. Current ideas about the role of force feedback are based on modular circuits linking idealized systems of agonists, synergists, and antagonistic muscles. In contrast, force feedback is widely distributed across the muscles of a limb and cannot be understood based on these circuit motifs. Similarly, muscle architecture cannot be understood in terms of idealized systems, since muscles cross multiple joints and axes of rotation and further influence remote joints through inertial coupling. It is hypothesized that distributed force feedback better represents the complex mechanical interactions of muscles, including the stresses in the musculoskeletal network born by muscle articulations, myofascial force transmission, and inertial coupling. Together with the strains of muscle fascicles measured by length feedback from muscle spindle receptors, this integrated proprioceptive feedback represents the mechanical state of the musculoskeletal system. Within the spinal cord, force feedback has excitatory and inhibitory components that coexist in various combinations based on motor task and integrated with length feedback at the premotoneuronal and motoneuronal levels. It is concluded that, in agreement with other investigators, autogenic, excitatory force feedback contributes to propulsion and weight support. It is further concluded that coexistent inhibitory force feedback, together with length feedback, functions to manage interjoint coordination and the mechanical properties of the limb in the face of destabilizing inertial forces and positive force feedback, as required by the accelerations and changing directions of both predator and prey.

Patterns of intermuscular inhibitory force feedback across cat hindlimbs suggest a flexible system for regulating whole limb mechanics.

Prior work has suggested that Golgi tendon organ feedback, via its distributed network linking muscles spanning all joints, could be used by the nervous system to help regulate whole limb mechanics if appropriately organized. We tested this hypothesis by characterizing the patterns of intermuscular force-dependent feedback between the primary extensor muscles spanning the knee, ankle, and toes in decerebrate cat hindlimbs. Intermuscular force feedback was evaluated by stretching tendons of selected muscles in isolation and in pairwise combinations and then measuring the resulting force-dependent intermuscular interactions. The relative inhibitory feedback between extensor muscles was examined, as well as symmetry of the interactions across limbs. Differences in the directional biases of inhibitory feedback were observed across cats, with three patterns identified as points on a spectrum: pattern 1, directional bias of inhibitory feedback onto the ankle extensors and toe flexors; pattern 2, convergence of inhibitory feedback onto ankle extensors and mostly balanced inhibitory feedback between vastus muscle group and flexor hallucis longus, and pattern 3, directional bias of inhibitory feedback onto ankle and knee extensors. The patterns of inhibitory feedback, while different across cats, were symmetric across limbs of individual cats. The variable but structured distribution of force feedback across cat hindlimbs provides preliminary evidence that inhibitory force feedback could be a regulated neural control variable. We propose the directional biases of inhibitory feedback observed experimentally could provide important task-dependent benefits, such as directionally appropriate joint compliance, joint coupling, and compensation for nonuniform inertia. NEW & NOTEWORTHY Feedback from Golgi tendon organs project widely among extensor motor nuclei in the spinal cord. The distributed nature of force feedback suggests these pathways contribute to the global regulation of limb mechanics. Analysis of this network in individual animals indicates that the strengths of these pathways can be reorganized appropriately for a variety of motor tasks, including level walking, slope walking, and landing.

Impaired Inhibitory Force Feedback in Fixed Dystonia

Complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) is a multifactorial disorder associated with an aberrant host response to tissue injury. About 25% of CRPS patients suffer poorly understood involuntary sustained muscle contractions associated with dysfunctional reflexes that result in abnormal postures (fixed dystonia). A recent modeling study simulated fixed dystonia (FD) caused by aberrant force feedback. The current study aims to validate this hypothesis by experimentally recording the modulation of reflexive force feedback in patients with FD. CRPS patients with and without FD, patients with FD but without CRPS, as well as healthy controls participated in the experiment. Three task instructions and three perturbation characteristics were used to evoke a wide range of responses to force perturbations. During position tasks ("maintain posture"), healthy subjects as well as patients resisted the perturbations, becoming more stiff than when being relaxed (i.e., the relax task). Healthy subjects and CRPS patients without FD were both more compliant during force tasks ("maintain force") than during relax tasks, meaning they actively gave way to the imposed forces. Remarkably, the patients with FD failed to do so. A neuromuscular model was fitted to the experimental data to separate the distinct contributions of position, velocity and force feedback, as well as co-contraction to the motor behavior. The neuromuscular modeling indicated that inhibitory force feedback is deregulated in patients with FD, for both CRPS and non-CRPS patients. From previously published simulation results and the present experimental study, it is concluded that aberrant force feedback plays a role in fixed dystonia.

The regulation of limb stiffness in the context of locomotor tasks.

Locomotion on ramped surfaces requires modulation of both pattern-generating circuits and limb stiffness. To meet the mechanical demands of locomotion under these conditions, muscular activation patterns must correspond to the appropriate functions, whether the muscles are serving as force generators or brakes. Limb stiffness is a critical mechanical property that determines how the body interacts with the environment, and is regulated by both intrinsic and neural mechanisms. We have recently investigated how pattern generation, stiffness, and proprioceptive feedback are modulated in a task-specific way using the decerebrate cat preparation. Our results confirm previous research using intact animals that during level and upslope walking, hip and ankle extensors are recruited for propulsion during stance. During downslope walking, hip extensors are inhibited and hip flexors are recruited during stance to provide the needed braking action. Our new data further show that endpoint stiffness of the limb is correspondingly reduced for walking down a slope, and that the reduction in stiffness is likely due to an increase in inhibitory force feedback. Our results further suggest that a body orientation signal derived from vestibular and neck proprioceptive information is responsible for the required muscular activation patterns as well as a reduction in limb stiffness. This increased compliance is consistent with the function of the distal limb to cushion the impact during the braking action of the antigravity musculature.

Altered muscular activation patterns and force feedback after spinal cord injury

One of the major clinical problems associated with spinal cord injury (SCI) is the lack of animal's ability to maintain weight support during standing or walking. We hypothesize that following SCI there is reorganization of the postural limb reflexes driven by stretch and load receptors in addition to loss of excitatory inputs from supraspinal structures to spinal interneurons that could result in altered intermuscular interactions. In control decerebrate animals there is a proximal to distal gradient in the strength of inhibitory force feedback among the limb muscles. We propose that pathways mediating this inhibition may remain inhibitory after spinal hemisection but their strengths may change to a distal to proximal gradient in the animal resulting in a loss of weight support. We also propose that ventral horn pathways are important for regulating the distribution of intermuscular force feedback. To test our hypothesis we are studying two types of SCI, namely dorsal and lateral hemisections, at both acute and chronic time points post‐injury. We measured intermuscular force feedback using combinations of stretches applied to pairs of muscles. Our most recent evidence supports our hypothesis and shows that the intermuscular force feedback is reversed after lateral but not dorsal hemisections.This work is supported by NIH grant HD32571, 1 I01 RX000243‐01A1, State of Florida BSCIRTF

Distribution of heterogenic reflexes among the quadriceps and triceps surae muscles of the cat hind limb.

Neural signals from proprioceptors in muscles provide length and force-related linkages among muscles of the limbs. The functions of this network of heterogenic reflexes remain unclear. New data are reported here on the distribution and magnitudes of neural feedback among quadriceps and triceps surae muscles in the decerebrate cat. The purpose of this paper was to distinguish whether inhibitory-force feedback is directed against muscles by virtue of the motor-unit composition or articulation of the muscle. These studies were carried out using controlled stretches and measurements of the resulting force responses of individual quadriceps and triceps surae muscles. Responses were evoked over a wide range of background force levels. In agreement with earlier electrophysiological studies, excitatory length feedback strongly linked the vastus muscles, but excitatory reflexes between each vastus and rectus femoris muscles were weak. We also observed a substantial excitatory linkage from the vastus muscles to the soleus muscle. In contrast, force-related inhibition was absent in the heterogenic reflexes among the vastus muscles but strong and bidirectional between each vastus muscle and the rectus femoris muscle and between triceps surae and quadriceps muscles. We conclude that short-latency feedback in the hindlimb is organized according to muscle articulation. Length feedback within muscle groups regulates joint stiffness while interjoint length feedback may compensate for the effects of nonuniform inertial properties of the limb. Force feedback is organized to regulate coupling between joints and, along with length feedback, determine the mechanical properties of the endpoint.