Influence Of Surgical Experience Research Articles

The Father of Wisdom: "The Influence of Surgical Experience on Overall Survival in Patients with Malignant Gliomas".

The role of surgery in the management of malignant gliomas has been feverishly deliberated after the publication of the first expansive case series, the last two decades reinvigorating the discussion regarding the value of total removal in improving survivability. Despite numerous technologies being implemented to increase the resection rates of malignant gliomas, the role of surgical experience has been largely overlooked. This article aims to discuss the importance of a single surgeon's experience in treating high-grade gliomas over a period of 20years. In order to demonstrate the role of surgical experience, we divided the patients operated by a single neurosurgeon into two distinct intervals: between 2000 and 2009 and between 2012 and 2020, respectively. Only cases with subsequent adjuvant radio-chemotherapy were included. For objective reasons, no technologies that could assist the extent of resection (EOR) such as intraoperative MRI (iMRI) or 5-ALA could be used in the country of our study. Gross total resection was the main goal whenever possible, whereas subtotal removal was defined as a clear remnant on contrasted MRI or CT performed 24-48h postoperatively. Using the Kaplan-Meier method, we analyzed the survival and disease-free interval of our patients according to age, pathology, and degree of resection. In the 20-year interval of our retrospective study, the main author (ISF) operated 1591 cases of gliomas in a total of 1878 surgeries, including recurrences. The number of high-grade glioma (HGG) patients was 909 (57.10%), 495 of which were male (54.5%) and 414 (45.5%) female. The mean age of the HGG population was 51.9years. The most common type of HGG subtype were glioblastomas with a total number 620 cases (68.2%). Regarding overall survival (OS), average survival at 12months was better by 1.6%, and 12.1% improved at 18months and 17.8% longer at 24months in the 2012-2020 interval. The mean OS in the earlier interval was 11.00months compared to the second when it reached 13.441months (CI, 12.642-14.24). Surgical treatment represents a critical step in the multimodal treatment of malignant gliomas. According to our results, surgical experience improves not only overall survival in a manner equivalent to adjuvant chemotherapy but also the quality of life. As such, a special qualification in neurooncology may prove necessary in offering these patients a second chance at life.

Influence of Surgical Experience and Risk Factors for Surgical Failure in Primary Retinal Detachment Surgery

Introduction: The aim of this study was to report surgical outcomes and risk factors for primary surgical failure following rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD) repair. Methods: In this retrospective cohort study, RRD patients who underwent primary surgery at a tertiary center between January 1, 2006, and December 31, 2020, were enrolled. Surgical failure was defined as reoperation within 60 days postoperatively due to retinal re-detachment and putative risk factors for surgical failure were analyzed. Results: Of 2,383 eyes (2,335 patients), 1,342 (56.3%) underwent vitrectomy and 1,041 (43.7%) underwent scleral buckling. The surgical failure rate was 9.1% overall, and 6.0% and 13.1% for the vitrectomy and scleral buckling groups, respectively. In the multivariate logistic regression analysis, surgical failure was associated with surgical experience (first-year fellow vs. senior professor) (odds ratio [OR]: 1.66; p = 0.018), scleral buckling (OR: 2.33; p < 0.001), and longer axial length (AL; ≥26.5 mm) (OR: 1.49; p = 0.017). In each surgical approach, age <40 years (OR: 2.11; p = 0.029) in the vitrectomy group and age >40 years (OR, 1.84; p = 0.004), male sex (OR: 1.65; p = 0.015), and first-year fellows compared to senior professors (OR: 1.95; p = 0.013) in the scleral buckling group were associated with surgical failure. Lens status were not associated with the surgical failure rate. Conclusion: In this large retrospective study using data from Korea, vitrectomy was superior to scleral buckling in terms of primary anatomical outcomes in the management of RRD. First-year fellows were a risk factor for surgical failure, especially for scleral buckling. Longer AL was a significant parameter for predicting the success rates.

Robotic radical prostatectomy: difficult to start, fast to improve? Influence of surgical experience in robotic and open radical prostatectomy

PurposeThe assistance of robotic systems raises the concern of whether there is an improved learning in robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy (RARP) compared to open retropubic radical prostatectomy (ORP).MethodsWe retrospectively analyzed data from 1438 patients who underwent ORP (n = 735) or RARP (n = 703). For each procedure, the level of experience of three different surgeons was summarized. Perioperative and pathological parameters reflecting surgical performance were compared between both learning curves. RARP data were influenced by new introduction of the robotic system.ResultsThe median patient age at surgery was 66 years (IQR 42–80). Patients in the RARP group were younger (p < 0.001) and had a lower oncological risk (p < 0.001). Inexperienced RARP surgeons had a higher pT2-PSM rate and lower lymph node yield (13.8 ± 4.7 vs. 14.7 ± 4.8; p = 0.03) than inexperienced ORP surgeons. After 100 procedures, RARP and ORP surgeons had the same pT2-PSM rate (8% vs. 8%; p = 0.8) and lymph node yield (15.4 ± 5.4 vs. 15.4 ± 5.1; p = 1.0). In multivariate analysis for ORP, surgical inexperience (≤ 100 cases) was an independent predictor of a longer operating time (OR 9.0; p < 0.001) and higher amount of blood loss (OR 2.9; p < 0.001). For RARP, surgical inexperience (≤ 100 cases) was a predictor of a longer operating time (OR 3.9; p < 0.001), higher amount of blood loss (OR 1.9; p = 0.004), higher pT2-PSM rate (OR 1.6; p = 0.03), and lower lymph node yield (OR 0.6; p = 0.001).ConclusionsSurgical experience has a relevant impact on perioperative and pathological parameters RARP has a higher initial pT2-PSM rate and lower lymph node yield than ORP. This is relevant for patient selection for novice teaching in RARP.

Intraoperative use of cortical step sign and diameter difference sign: Accuracy, inter-rater agreement and influence of surgical experience in subtrochanteric transverse fractures

BackgroundThe cortical step sign (CSS) and diameter difference sign (DDS) are radiographic tools for torsional alignment control in intramedullary nailing. They have been found to be highly relevant in objective radiographic measurements, but for intraoperative visual identification they lack sufficient evidence yet. The aim of this experimental study was to evaluate their (1) accuracy, (2) inter-rater agreement, (3) predictors of correct identification for clinically relevant maltorsion (CRM: ≥15°), and (4) positive and negative predictive values. HypothesisSensitivity and specificity of CSS and DDS in visual identification of CRM are comparable to those in objective measurement. Material and methodsSix observers of three different levels of surgical experience evaluated 50 a.p. and 50 lateral views of subtrochanteric fractures of cadaveric specimens with internal/external maltorsion from 0° to 30° to assess for CSS, DDS, and CRM. (1) Sensitivity and specificity were evaluated. Percentage agreement and Cohen's Kappa were used to evaluate accuracy as agreement with measured/true values and (2) inter-rater agreement. To determine (3) significant predictors of correct identification of the CSS, DDS, and CRM, a mixed-effects logistic model was constructed, and (4) predictive values were calculated. Results(1) Sensitivities of CSS and DDS for CRM (0.99±0.03 and 0.88±0.06) were close to those in objective measurement (1.00 and 0.90). So were specificities (0.25±0.08 and 0.47±0.17 vs. 0.32 and 0.47). Agreement percentage for CSS was high (90–94%, kappa 0.40–0.69), for DDS and CRM it was slightly lower (74–82%, kappa 0.34–0.57 and 62–76%, kappa 0.26–0.49). (2) Inter-rater agreement also showed the highest values for CSS (88–96%, kappa 0.51–0.73) with slightly lower values for DDS (74–84%, kappa 0.36–0.63) and CRM (62–84%, kappa 0.21–0.68). (3) Training level and the magnitude of maltorsion were found the most relevant predictors of a correct identification of CSS/DDS/CRM. (4) DDS showed a higher positive predictive value (73.1%), CSS a higher negative predictive value (93.5%). DiscussionWe found visual identification of CSS and DDS to be almost as accurate as objective measurement in the detection of CRM. Estimation of maltorsion is not sufficiently reliable, but a negative CSS excludes a CRM with high probability. Both signs should be applied by experienced surgeons. Level of evidenceLevel III, experimental setting, non-randomised experimental trial.

Dynamic Navigation in Dental Implantology: The Influence of Surgical Experience on Implant Placement Accuracy and Operating Time. An in Vitro Study.

Aim: the aim of this in vitro study was to test whether the implant placement accuracy and the operating time can be influenced by the operator’s experience. Materials and methods: sixteen models underwent a (Cone Beam Computer Tomography) CBCT and implant positioning was digitally planned on this. The models were randomly assigned to four operators with different levels of surgical experience. One hundred and twelve implant sites were drilled using a dynamic navigation system and operating times were measured. Based on postoperative CBCTs, dental implants were virtually inserted and superimposed over the planned ones. Two-dimensional and 3D deviations between planned and virtually inserted implants were measured at the entry point and at the apical point. Angular and vertical errors were also calculated. Results: considering coronal and apical 3D deviations, no statistically significant differences were found between the four operators (p = 0.27; p = 0.06). Some vectorial components of the deviation at the apical point and the angular errors of some operators differed from each other. Conclusions: within the limitations of this study, dynamic navigation can be considered a reliable technique both for experienced and novice clinicians.

The Influence of Surgical Experience on Postoperative Recovery in Fast-Track Bariatric Surgery.

Short duration of surgery is an important aspect in fast-track protocols. Peroperative training of surgical residents could influence the duration of surgery, possibly affecting patient outcome. This study evaluates the influence of the operator's level of experience on patient outcome in fast-track bariatric surgery. Data was analyzed of all patients who underwent a primary laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (LRYGB) or laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy (LSG) between January 2004 and July 2018. Residents were trained according to a stepwise training program. For each operator, learning curves of both procedures were created by dividing the procedures in time-subsequent groups (TSGs). Data was also analyzed by comparing "beginners" with "experienced operators," with a cut-off point at 100 procedures. Primary outcome measure was duration of surgery. Secondary outcome measures were length of hospital stay (LOS), complications, and readmission rate within 30days postoperatively. There were 4901 primary procedures (53.1% LSG) performed by seven surgeons or surgical residents. We found no difference between beginning and experienced operators in complications or readmissions rates. The experience of the operator did not influence LOS (p = 0.201). Comparing each new operator with previous operator(s), the starting point in terms of duration of surgery was shorter, and the learning curve was steeper. The duration of surgery was significantly longer for supervised beginning operators as compared with experienced operators. Within the stepwise training program for residents, there is a slight increase in duration of surgery in the beginning of the learning curve, without affecting the patient outcome.

The impact of intraoperative residual mild regurgitation after repair of degenerative mitral regurgitation

ObjectivesDuring degenerative mitral repair, surgeons must decide if further repair is warranted for residual mild mitral regurgitation. We examined the incidence of mild mitral regurgitation, late echocardiographic and clinical outcomes, and influence of surgical experience in decision making. MethodsFrom April 2004 to June 2018, 1155 of 1195 patients with pure degenerative disease underwent repair (97% repair rate). Propensity score matching was performed between patients with trace/no mitral regurgitation and patients with mild residual mitral regurgitation. Late echocardiographic outcome and freedom from reoperation were compared using competing-risks models. A comparison of outcomes of the referent surgeon (89.8% of repairs) with all other surgeons was performed. ResultsMild mitral regurgitation was present in 73 patients (6%). Propensity score–matched analyses compared 69 patients with mild mitral regurgitation with 198 patients without mitral regurgitation. Late moderate or greater mitral regurgitation was higher in those with mild mitral regurgitation than in those with no mitral regurgitation (17% vs 7%, P = .033), as was late moderate-severe or greater mitral regurgitation (6% vs 1%, P = .016). Ten-year freedom from reoperation was low in both groups (99.5% no vs 96.9% mild; P = .10). The referent surgeon had fewer patients with mild residual mitral regurgitation (6% vs 11%, P = .027) and less progression of mitral regurgitation compared with other surgeons (late moderate or greater mitral regurgitation 6% vs 15%, P = .002). ConclusionsResidual mild mitral regurgitation was uncommon, and late progression to moderate or greater mitral regurgitation was rare and never led to late mitral reoperation. Experienced surgeons may be better able to determine repairs likely to remain stable, and most mild residual mitral regurgitation does not require re-repair.

Transanal total mesorectal excision for rectal cancer: evaluation of the learning curve.

Transanal total mesorectal excision (TaTME) provides an excellent view of the resection margins for rectal cancer from below, but is challenging due to few anatomical landmarks. During implementation of this technique, patient safety and optimal outcomes need to be ensured. The aim of this study was to evaluate the learning curve of TaTME in patients with rectal cancer in order to optimize future training programs. All consecutive patients after TaTME for rectal cancer between February 2012 and January 2017 were included in a single-center database. Influence of surgical experience on major postoperative complications, leakage rate and operating time was evaluated using cumulative sum charts and the splitting model. Correction for potential case-mix differences was performed. Over a period of 60months, a total of 138 patients were included in this study. Adjusted for case-mix, improvement in postoperative outcomes was clearly seen after the first 40 patients, showing a decrease in major postoperative complications from 47.5 to 17.5% and leakage rate from 27.5 to 5%. Mean operating time (42min) and conversion rate (from 10% to zero) was lower after transition to a two-team approach, but neither endpoint decreased with experience. Readmission and reoperation rates were not influenced by surgical experience. The learning curve of TaTME affected major (surgical) postoperative complications for the first 40 patients. A two-team approach decreased operative time and conversion rate. When implementing this new technique, a thorough teaching and supervisory program is recommended to shorten the learning curve and improve the clinical outcomes of the first patients.

Determinants of resident competence in mastoidectomy: Role of interest and deliberate practice

This study explores the influence of selected factors on achievement of competency in mastoid surgery. A prospective study of surgical performance and a retrospective survey of learner and training factors. The longitudinal performance of 15 residents was evaluated using the mastoidectomy task-based checklist (TBC). The influence of surgical experience, resident interest, and training factors (course attendance, voluntary use of simulation laboratory) was also examined and compared for the acquisition of distinct levels of technical skill difficulty (cortical mastoidectomy vs. facial recess). Ninety-six observations made during the first otology rotation were analyzed. Cortical mastoidectomy tasks showed positive associations with cumulated case numbers (OR 1.13, CI 1.04-1.23, P = .003) and interest in otology (OR 3.86, CI 1.21-12.27, P = .022). Facial recess tasks showed a larger positive association with interest in otology (OR 10.38, CI 2.25-47.94, P = .003), and negative association with extra time spent in laboratory practice (OR .05, CI 0.011-0.23, P = .000). Learning trajectory for cortical mastoidectomy and facial recess may be influenced by different factors. Interest in otology, in particular, may have a moderating effect on the acquisition of more complex skills in mastoid surgery. A negative association between self-directed laboratory simulation and performance may reflect the impact of assessment-guided feedback in promoting deliberate practice. Further investigations are suggested to explore the interactions between individual trainee differences, educational models, and learning outcomes.

Influence of Surgical Experience in the Learning Curve of a New Approach in Hip Replacement: Anterior Mini-Invasive Vs. Standard Lateral

There is conflicting evidence regarding the potential benefit of minimally invasive surgery for total hip arthroplasty (THA), especially during the 'learning curve' of individual surgeons. Sixty patients who underwent THA between January and December 2010 were evaluated. The aim was to assess the anterior mini-invasive (MI) approach performed in 30 patients during the learning curve of a single experienced hip surgeon compared with the results of 30 patients operated upon through a standard lateral approach by the same surgeon. Operation and hospitalisation times, blood loss, number of transfusions, peri-operative complications and femoral/acetabular component placement were monitored. Harris Hip Score (HHS) and Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (HOOS) were analysed before and 12 months after surgery. Pain Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) was also recorded 1 week and 1 month after surgery. Hospitalisation, blood loss, number of transfusions and VAS score 1 week postoperatively were significantly lower and operative time was significantly longer in the anterior MI approach. Similar functional outcomes 1 year after surgery, component positioning and complication rates were observed in both groups. The results suggest that anterior MI approach is a safe procedure during the learning curve of an experienced hip surgeon.

Multivisceral resection for locally advanced primary colon and rectal cancer: an analysis of prognostic factors in 201 patients.

To review a single-center experience with 201 multivisceral resections for primary colorectal cancer to determine the accuracy of intraoperative prediction of potential curability, to identify prognostic factors, and to examine the effect of surgical experience on immediate outcome and long-term results. Locally advanced colorectal cancer may require an intraoperative decision for en bloc resection of surrounding organs or structures to achieve complete tumor removal. This decision must weigh the risk of complications and death of multivisceral resection against a potential survival benefit. Little is known about prognostic factors and the influence of surgical experience on the outcome of multivisceral resection for colorectal cancer. Patients undergoing multivisceral resection for primary colon or rectal cancer between 1982 and 1998 were identified from a prospective database. Patients were followed up according to a standard protocol. Multivisceral resection was performed in 201 of 2,712 patients with a median age of 64 years. Postoperative rates of complications and death in 201 patients were 33% and 7.5%, respectively. A potentially curative resection was possible in 130 of 201 patients (65%) and histologic tumor infiltration was shown in 44% of patients with curative resection. Intraoperative assessment of curability was unreliable. After curative resection, the local recurrence rate was 11% and the overall 5-year survival rate was 51%. Multivariate analysis identified intraoperative blood loss (relative risk 1.7-6.4, P <.001), age 64 years or older (RR 3.7; P <.001), and UICC stage as independent prognostic factors (RR 2.0; P =.009). No prognostic significance was found for histologic tumor infiltration, the number of resected organs, or surgical experience. Multivisceral resection is safe, and long-term survival after curative resection is similar to that after standard resection. Because palliative resections cannot be predicted accurately at the time of surgery, every effort should be made to achieve complete tumor resection. Major blood loss but not surgical experience per se is an independent prognostic factor.

Influence of surgical experience on the results of carotid surgery

To assess the 30-day mortality and morbidity rates related to carotid endarterectomy on a nation-wide basis. Retrospective cross-sectional study based on vascular registry Finnvasc. A total of 17,465 recorded vascular and endovascular procedures included exactly 1600 carotid endarterectomies performed by 104 surgeons in 23 hospitals. Fourteen per cent of the patients were operated on for asymptomatic carotid stenosis. The combined mortality and permanent stroke rate was 3.3%, without any difference between operations done on symptomatic or asymptomatic patients. There was a clear inverse association between surgeon's carotid case load and poor outcomes in carotid surgery (p < 0.005), the critical patient mass per surgeon and year being 10 operations. There was no association between outcome after carotid surgery and hospital volume of carotid operations. Surgeon's experience in carotid surgery clearly improves the results of carotid surgery.