The consumer-generated media has become a significant force in the hospitality marketplace. This article reports the results of an experiment that was conducted to determine the moderating effect of consumer rebuttals and management responses to negative postings on travel review boards. The results suggest that potential hotel guests react more favorably to a rebuttal of a negative review posted by a fellow traveler than they do to a response posted by the hotel management but that both have the power to positively influence consumer attitudes toward the property. Managerial suggestions are provided.