Objectives: Surgical scaffolds are used to augment rotator cuff tendon repairs. Interactions between recruited immune cells and tendon-resident stromal cells influence whether the scaffold is integrated or rejected by the body. The primary aim of this in vitro study was to compare the inflammatory response of human monocytes to different surgical scaffolds. The secondary aim was to determine how this monocyte response affects the behavior of human rotator cuff tendon-derived stromal cells in vitro. Methods: Primary human monocytes were cultured on four commercially available scaffolds: LARS ligament (synthetic); GraftJacket (allograft), Permacol (xenograft, cross-linked), and Conexa (xenograft, noncross-linked). Secreted inflammatory proteins were measured after 1 and 10 days. Foreign body giant cell formation was assessed after 10 days. Proliferation and gene expression of tendon stromal cells were assessed after being grown in a conditioned medium from monocyte-scaffold cultures. Results: After 10 days, monocytes cultured on the Conexa scaffold secreted the highest levels of the pro-inflammatory markers GM-CSF, IL-8, and IL-10 (fig. 1). After 1 day, tendon stromal cells incubated in conditioned media from Conexa-monocyte cultures expressed lower Collagen Type VI and increased MMP3 and MMP6 mRNA (fig. 2). Foreign Body Giant Cell formation was most prominent in monocytes cultured on the Permacol scaffold (Figure 3). Conclusions: In vitro experiments demonstrated that xenograft scaffolds elicited a more pronounced pro-inflammatory response in human monocytes compared to synthetic and allograft scaffolds. Inflammatory cytokines secreted by monocytes in response to xenografts may modulate scaffold integration through paracrine signaling to tendon stromal cells. These findings may help explain the clinical performance of xenograft scaffolds for tendon repair and inform future scaffold design.
Read full abstract