Book Reviews The Ghost ofthe Executed Engineer: Technology and the Fall ofthe Soviet Union. By Loren R. Graham. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1993. Pp. xiv+128; illustrations, notes, index. $22.95. Technology has played a central role in the “Soviet experiment” from its earliest days through its recent demise, but few historians have been equipped or inclined to study its intricacies. The one bright exception was Kendall E. Bailes, whose classic study, Technology and Society under Lenin and Stalin (Princeton, N.J., 1978), remains the best book on the subject; but, following his untimely death, its rich insights and research agendas have been largely unexplored. Now Bailes’s teacher, historian of Soviet science Loren Graham, has made the subject the centerpiece of this, his latest—and perhaps best—book, a well-crafted parable (some 35,000 words in all) about the importance of a humane, human-scale technology. Beautifully produced and immensely readable, the volume weaves together three related tales: the quest of the author (a chemical engineer by training) for archival information on a Soviet engineer executed in 1928, the story of that engineer’s life and ideas, and the story of the ultimate failure and demise of the Soviet Union. The book’s hero is Peter Palchinsky (1857-1928), an eldest son who entered engineering full of enthusiasm and with an apparent knack for being in the right place at the wrong time. His Social Revolutionary politics led to numerous arrests by the tsarist secret police; on the other hand, his six-year exile in Europe (1908-13) led to a four-volume work on seaports and a successful life as a mining consultant. He went home to help the Russian military during the Great War and welcomed the February 1917 revolution, soon becoming one of the ministers of the new Provincial Government—only to find himself, come October, the official in charge of the unsuccessful defense of the Winter Palace. Thereafter he was repeatedly in and out of prison, as the various organs of Bolshevik power balanced his questionable political tastes (he liked Kropotkin) against his evident talents in getting the mines working. The mid-1920s found Palchinsky busy at his Institute of the Earth’s Surface and Depths (which he had founded in 1916), publishing its journal, actively advising the government—and keeping Gommunists out of his institute (they were unprofessional). He was also an active organizer of the engineering profession, and gave voice—perhaps a bit too often—to its technocratic inclinations. (In one letter, he called not for interna tional communism but international technology—not Komintern, but “Techintern.”) Permission to reprint a review printed in this section may be obtained only from the reviewer. 168 TECHNOLOGYAND CULTURE Book Reviews 169 Then in April 1928 came the knock on the door: Palchinsky was arrested and shot within the month. Only in 1930, during the infamous Industrial Party Trial, did his fate become known—he was accused of having headed a technocratic conspiracy of engineers aimed at over throwing the Soviet government. From a secret police report, which Graham managed to examine, the real reasons for his arrest seem to be these: he argued too actively with his political bosses over their grandiose technological schemes, and he published too many unflatter ing details about the actual conditions in Soviet mining and industry. At any rate, he never went to trial, and Graham speculates that it was because, unlike most other accused engineers, he refused to “confess” to having done anything wrong. Although he supported centralized socialist planning, he had believed in local engineering and regional planning, not dictates from Moscow bosses; for him, the most important factor in engineering planning was human beings and their needs, and he had argued for improved living conditions and technical training for workers. Alas, Palchinsky’s was the path not taken. Immediately following the engineer’s death, Stalin would launch the giant “propaganda” projects that would do the Soviet image so much good abroad and wreak such havoc at home. Graham takes us through the sad litany: the Great Dnieper Dam, an economically unwise project that displaced over 10,000 prosperous Mennonite farmers from their land and into forced...