Purpose: Over 50% of osteoarthritis (OA) patients show synovial inflammation, even relatively early during the disease. However, the mechanisms through which this synovial activation contributes to the irreversible joint pathology that characterizes OA, are not known. In the present study we used microarray analysis of synovial tissue of early OA patients and of experimental OA, to identify common pathways that determine cartilage damage in this disease. Methods: From a subpopulation of patients that entered the CHECK Cohort study (Cohort Hip and Cohort Knee), synovial biopsies were collected. CHECK is a prospective 10-year follow-up study that was initiated by the Dutch Arthritis Association on participants with early osteoarthritis-related complaints of hip and/or knee. Radiographs are taken in a standardized manner and scored (Kellgren&Lawrence KL) at inclusion (n=18). In addition, biopsies of 7 control synovia were collected. A longitudinal expression analysis was performed on murine synovial tissue at day 7, day 21 and day 42 after induction of collagenase induced OA (CIOA). CIOA was induced by intra-articular injection of collagenase, which causes joint instability, and contra lateral knee joints served as controls. Initial analysis of microarray data was performed using Partek software and functional annotation clustering (FAC) and pathway analysis was done using DAVID. Results: Gene expression profiles of control synovia were compared to CHECK synovia. Analysis using DAVID indicated enrichment of several biological processes and signaling pathways, including regulation of macrophage differentiation, innate immune responses, cell migration, TGFβ-, BMP- and wnt-signaling. This indicates clear activation of the synovium in the CHECK patients compared to controls. Next we compared synovial tissue of CHECK-patients with radiological damage (KL≥1) with CHECK-patients without joint damage (KL=0). Among the top 30 genes that were strongest associated with cartilage damage were MMP-1 (18-fold), MMP-3 (10-fold), S100A8 (6-fold) and cartilage glycoprotein-39 (6-fold), all of which have been associated with cartilage damage. Immunohistochemical staining revealed that expression of MMP-1 and MMP-3 was highest in the synovial lining layer. FAC analysis showed that, among others, response to wounding, chemotaxis, innate immune response and metalloproteases were strongly and significantly enriched and thus associated with joint damage. Pathway analysis demonstrated that in the synovium of patients with joint damage the complement-activation pathway, TGFβ- and BMP-signaling and TLR-activation were significantly upregulated. These results were further underlined by analysis of synovium from experimental OA. Among the genes that were strongly upregulated on all 3 time points after induction were MMP-3 (6-fold), MMP-13 (16-fold), MMP-14 (6-fold) and COMP (13-fold). Again, wound healing, innate immune response and metalloproteases were significantly enriched, as were the complement pathway, the TLR-, TGFβ, BMP and wnt-signaling pathways. In a recent publication, complement was demonstrated to be essential in experimental OA. We therefore determined whether the synovium expressed complement activating proteins, and found a strong upregulation of COMP, lumican, osteomodulin, biglycan, decorin and fibromodulin. In addition, biglycan expression was strongly enhanced (2.5-fold) in human CHECK-samples from patients with joint damage. Conclusions: All in all, these data suggest an active role for the synovium in OA pathology, and identifies pathways that are likely to be involved. One of the strongest associations was of the complement-pathway with cartilage damage. In addition, TGFβ-, BMP- and wnt-signaling in the synovium, may contribute to further joint damage. The enhanced expression of cartilage damaging MMP-1, MMP-3 and MMP-13 again suggests an active role of the synovium in OA pathology. Future studies will focus on association of gene expression patterns with progression of damage of CHECK-patients.
Read full abstract