Individual Foraging Research Articles

BaYaka mothers balance childcare and subsistence tasks during collaborative foraging in Congo Basin

Across cultures, mothers balance childcare with other labour. Hunter-gatherer mothers face a daily choice of whether to take infants on foraging trips or leave them with caregivers in the settlement, as well as deciding with whom to forage. Yet, it remains unclear how infant presence affects mothers’ mobility and food returns during group foraging. Using GPS, heart rate measurements, and food return data from 348 foraging trips by 22 BaYaka mothers in the Republic of the Congo, we found that mothers go on longer-duration foraging trips when they take infants along, compared to when they leave them behind. Despite this, infant presence does not affect mothers’ mobility, energy expenditure, or food returns. Mothers also go on longer-duration and longer-distance trips during group foraging, compared to foraging alone. However, they have decreased food returns in larger groups with more adults, possibly due to food competition. Nevertheless, BaYaka mothers maintain their energy expenditure and net food returns in general, regardless of infant presence or group dynamics, likely due to their individual foraging strategies and support from group members. Particularly, children in foraging groups increase mothers’ food returns, aligning with women’s reports of children assisting as caregivers. These findings provide insights into how BaYaka mothers accommodate childcare with subsistence activities during group foraging.

Dispersal of optimal foragers in a patchy environment: Simulations with a mathematical model and tests of predictions in field experiments

To predict the effect of density on the dispersal of foraging parasitoids, we developed a spatially explicit individual-based model in which parasitoids move among host patches at random but use an optimal decision-rule about when to leave these patches. We used a simple decision rule where an individual forager exploits a patch as long as the instantaneous attack rate is higher than the average attack rate it has experienced in the environment. Such a rule implies that foragers compute and remember attack rates as they forage. Simulations with different combinations of patch distribution, host density, mutual interference, and parasitoid density predicted that dispersal distance should increase with parasitoid density. To test this prediction, we used data from two field experiments in which we released either few or many adults of the aphid parasitoid Aphelinus asychis in replicated sites, and subsequently assessed dispersal from the spatial distribution of parasitoid offspring. In the first experiment, we did not to detect a relation between the number released and dispersal distance, but in the second experiment, dispersal distance increased with initial density, as predicted by our model. We propose two hypotheses to explain the discrepancy between the experiments. Different levels of environmental variability among experiments, resulting from differences in experimental designs, could cause differences in statistical conclusions. However, there could be a threshold density below which dispersal is not density-dependent, and this threshold may have been exceeded in the second experiment where large releases involved many more individuals than in the first experiment. In any case, our approach linked individual behavior and spatial distribution, and our results show that the insect distributions in the field can be predicted, qualitatively, from theory about individual behavior.

The Hole Truth: Why Do Bumble Bees Rob Flowers More Than Once?

Primary nectar-robbers feed through holes they make in flowers, often bypassing the plant's reproductive organs in the process. In many robbed plants, multiple holes are made in a single flower. Why a flower should be robbed repeatedly is difficult to understand: a hole signals that a nectar forager has already fed, which would seem likely to predict low rewards. We tested three explanations for this pattern in Corydalis caseana (Fumariaceae), a bumble bee pollinated and robbed plant: (1) multiple holes appear only after all flowers have been robbed once; (2) individual foragers make multiple holes during single visits; and (3) it is more profitable for bees to rob older flowers, even if they have already been robbed. We tested these hypotheses from 2014 to 2016 in a Colorado, USA population using data on robbing rates over time, floral longevity, nectar accumulation in visited and unvisited flowers, and the accumulation of robbing holes across the life of flowers. Multiple holes were already appearing when two-thirds of flowers still lacked a single hole, allowing us to reject the first hypothesis. The second hypothesis cannot offer a full explanation for multiple robbing holes because 35% of additional holes appeared in flowers one or more days after the first hole was made. Repeated sampling of bagged and exposed inflorescences revealed that flowers filled at a constant rate and refilled completely after being drained. Consequently, young flowers are of consistently low value to foragers compared to older flowers even if they had previously been robbed, consistent with the third hypothesis. While further studies are needed, these results offer a simple explanation for the paradoxical clustering of nectar-robbing damage in this and possibly other plant species.

Individual foraging site fidelity persists within and across stopover seasons in a migratory shorebird, Numenius phaeopus (Whimbrel)

Abstract Site fidelity—returning repeatedly to the same site—can help many migratory species reduce uncertainty in their environment, especially when migratory stopover periods leave little time to explore and evaluate new habitat. Avian taxa, though, have shown wide variation in their levels of site fidelity during migration, and few studies have been able to examine individual-level fidelity at fine spatiotemporal scales. We used a high-resolution GPS tracking dataset of Numenius phaeopus (Whimbrel), a long-distance migratory shorebird, to assess levels of fidelity to specific foraging and roosting sites during migration, both within and between stopover seasons. We found that individuals are almost exclusively faithful to one shared roost site at night, but disperse to individual foraging territories during the day that overlap with each other by <20%. Individuals remain faithful to these distinct territories over time, on average shifting the center of their daily home ranges by <1.5 km within a single season, and overlapping with their previous season’s home range by 70% when they return during subsequent stopovers. Our findings reveal for the first time that a shorebird species exhibits fine-scale, individual foraging site fidelity during and between migratory stopovers—an important insight to inform effective conservation and management action.

Fitness benefits of grouping during foraging in beef cattle: Social behaviour or affinity to vegetation resources?

Grouping behaviour in gregarious species expresses a dynamic cost-benefit equilibrium. The balance between costs and benefits differs amongst individuals that were selected to maximize their individual fitness. In environments where resources are limited, benefits of grouping may come at the expense of increased competition over resources. This study aimed to test whether grouping behaviour during foraging in a free-ranging beef cattle herd is a social choice bearing fitness benefits for all participants, or reflects affinity to vegetation resources with possible differentiating fitness benefits. GPS location data were recorded in a herd of 60 beef cows grazing a semi-arid pasture in northern Israel. Pasture vegetation was chemically and spectrally analysed. GPS location data were used to investigate individual and shared foraging locations and the temporal sequence of initiating foraging movement. Co-travel function in ArcPro v3.0 was used to investigate the amount and variability of individual proximity associations and their correlation with fitness. Fitness proxies were conception result (yes/no) and the interval between calving and conception within the cows who conceived. A positive correlation was found between fitness and the individual number of proximity associations, but not with the variability in associations' partners. No significant correlations were found between fitness and vegetation biomass, N content and spectral properties measured by REEVI2 index in foraging locations. Individual sequence of arrival at shared foraging locations and foraging movement initiation sequence were also not correlated with fitness. Vegetation biomass in grouping locations was lower than in individually foraged locations, but no difference was found in N content between individual and shared foraging locations. No differences were found in vegetation biomass and N content between herd foraging locations and random locations, thus no evidence for herd foraging strategy aimed to increase biomass or N consumption was found. No further differences in pasture resources availability, i.e., water, shade, human or predator presence could explain grouping. Circular variance values implied the absence of preferred movement direction. Our results suggest that grouping during foraging is fitness beneficial and is not related to vegetation biomass or N content. Our results further suggest the absence of consistent leading individuals and no significant correlations between foraging movement initiation and fitness. This study provides insights into social and vegetation factors affecting cattle foraging behaviour in constrained pasture, and may allow ranchers to improve grazing management systems. We suggest that further research into pasture characteristics that affect beef cattle pasture location choice is needed.

Competition through ritualized aggressive interactions between sympatric colonies in solitary foraging neotropical ants.

Understanding the structure of food competition between conspecifics in their natural settings is paramount to addressing more complex questions in ecology, evolution, and conservation. While much research on ants focuses on aggressive food competition between large and foraging trail-using societies, we lack a thorough understanding of inter-colony competition in socially less derived, solitarily foraging species. To fill this gap, we explored the activity of ten neighbouring colonies of the giant ant Dinoponera quadriceps, monitoring 2513 foraging trips of hundreds of workers and all its inter-individual interactions. We found that, on encountering, workers from different colonies rarely engaged in aggressive fights but instead avoided each other or performed ritualised agonistic bouts. We discovered that during foraging trips, a few workers within each colony repeatedly rubbed their gaster on the substrate, a behaviour not observed in the field before. We propose that workers use this behaviour to mark the foraging area and mark more frequently in its periphery. Only 25% of the individuals specialised in this behaviour, and we hypothesise that the specialisation results from the history of interactions and experience of individual foragers. Our study suggests that workers of contiguous D. quadriceps colonies engage in low-risk conflict, mainly displaying ritualised behaviours. As these small societies mainly rely on tiny, unpredictably scattered, albeit abundant in the environment, arthropod prey, and not on persistent food sources, they do not aggressively defend exclusive foraging territories. On the other hand, colonies rely on large overlapping foraging areas to sustain their survival and growth, most often tolerating foragers from nearby colonies. We discuss whether this type of competitive interaction is expected in all solitary foraging species.

The effects of feeding liquid or pelleted formulations of Asparagopsis armata to lactating dairy cows on methane production, dry matter intake, milk production and milk composition

Asparagopsis armata has been reported to have strong antimethanogenic effects when fed to dairy cows. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of a liquid and a pelleted formulation of A. armata when fed to lactating dairy cows as a supplemental feed twice daily at milking on i) enteric methane emissions, milk yield and dry matter intake (DMI), and ii) presence of halogenated compounds in milk, urine, faeces, and blood. Forty lactating, multiparous, Holstein-Friesian cows (117 ± 20.2 days in milk) were randomly allocated one of four treatments; 1) CON1: basal diet plus liquid supplement without A. armata, 2) AA1: basal diet plus liquid supplement with A. armata, 3) CON2: basal diet plus pellet supplement without A. armata, and 4) AA2: basal diet plus pellet supplement with A. armata. The liquid and pelleted supplements were offered twice daily for 34 days. Supplements were offered with a grain mix during each milking. The basal diet consisted of vetch hay ad libitum and 6.15 kg dry matter (DM)/d of a grain mix fed as 3.07 kg DM in the dairy per milking. Cows given the AA1 treatment received 298 mg bromoform per day while cows on the AA2 treatment received 293 mg bromoform per day. Individual forage DMI were measured daily via electronic monitoring of individual cows at the feed bins. Methane emissions were measured using the modified sulphur hexafluoride tracer technique on the last 5 days of the experiment. Feeding the A. armata formulations showed no effect on total DMI, forage DMI, concentrate DMI or milk yield. Methane production (g CH4/d), methane yield (g CH4/kg DMI) and methane intensity (g CH4/kg energy corrected milk) were reduced by about 20 % for both the liquid and the pelleted A. armata formulations. Feeding the A. armata formulations led to increased bromoform concentrations in milk (∼2.0 µg/L) but were well below the limit for safe consumption (100 µg/L). It is concluded that both formulations were effective in reducing enteric methane emissions and that milk from cows fed these A. armata formulations is safe for human consumption.

Evolution of explorative and exploitative search strategies in collective foraging

Evolutionary theories of foraging hypothesize that foraging strategies evolve to maximize search efficiency. Many studies have investigated the central trade-off between explore–exploit and how individual foragers manage it under various conditions. For foragers in groups, this trade-off can be affected by the social environment, influencing the evolution of individual search strategies. Previous work has shown that when learning socially, explorative search strategies can optimize group search efficiency. However, social learning can cause discrepancies in strategies that benefit the group versus an individual. We model the evolution of explorative and exploitative strategies using Lévy exponents under different levels of social learning and investigate their effect on individual and group search efficiencies. We show that reliance on social learning can lead to the evolution of mixed groups that are not optimally efficient. Exploiters can have a selective advantage in scrounging findings by explorers, but too many exploiters can diminish group efficiencies. However, greater opportunities for social learning can increase the benefits of explorative strategies. Finally, we show that area-restricted search can help individuals balance exploration and exploitation, and make groups more efficient. Our results demonstrate how exploration and exploitation must be balanced at both individual and collective levels for efficient search.

Effect of the Meal Interval Setting of an Automated Concentrate Feeding System on Feed Intake and Feeding Behavior in Fattening Hanwoo Steers.

An automatic concentrate feeding system (ACFS) divides the day into several intervals, allowing cattle to consume a predetermined amount of concentrate mix per interval. This study investigated the impact of changing these intervals (four vs. six) in an ACFS on its precision in monitoring the feed intake and feeding behavior of fattening Hanwoo steers. The experiment, involving 29 fattening Hanwoo steers (688 ± 43.3 kg of body weight, 24 months old), employed a switchback design with two interval settings: four and six per day. Both individual forage and concentrate intakes and feeding behaviors were automatically recorded; however, the ACFS measured feed supply, not actual intake. The precision of the ACFS's intake recordings was tested by manually assessing feed residuals per visit using video recordings. Although no difference was observed in the concentrate intake (p > 0.05), the six-interval setting reduced concentrate residuals by 0.2 kg per visit (p < 0.05). The increased interval setting also resulted in fewer visits for forage consumption and decreased forage and total dry matter intakes (p < 0.05). In conclusion, the increased interval setting for the ACFS reduced the visit frequency for forage consumption and actual forage consumption while improving the precision of the ACFS's intake recordings.

Variability of Vairimorpha (=Nosema) ceranae infection level in individual honey bees and its implications on the pooled sample size

Nosemosis is caused by two microsporidian species of the genus recently renamed Vairimorpha (=Nosema) that parasitize the midgut of Apis mellifera. Usually, pooled samples of 60 bees are used for diagnosis. Reported differences in the efficiency of treatments against Vairimorpha sp. led us to wonder if the sample size may be one of the causes of these unpredictable results. This study focuses on the distribution of the spore load of V. ceranae among forager bees within a colony using statistical approaches in relation to sample size. Spore counts per bee were used to describe the spore distribution and to test whether they fit different statistical distributions. Standard errors were calculated and two-sided 95% confidence intervals were constructed for the spore count means, using standard (Student’s t) and non-parametric bootstrap methods (Percentil and bias-corrected and accelerated-BCa). Bees with a high degree of infection appear in low percentage but are very influential on the mean value. Data showed a poor fit to all of the distributions evaluated. To obtain a relative standard error below 10% of the mean, pooled samples should have more than 1,500 bees. The BCa interval showed better coverage than others being acceptable starting at 100 data of individual foragers. Results show that, when using the traditional sample size (pooled samples n = 60), the accuracy for estimating the mean spore load is low in V. ceranae infected hives, regardless of the statistical method applied. Thus, this work could justify some erratic results reported for treatments with commercial products.

Can the inclusion of ribwort plantain or chicory increase the seasonal and annual dry matter production of intensive dairy grazing swards?

Pasture species complementarity leading to increased dry matter (DM) production has been observed in multispecies (MS) swards which include legumes and forage herbs along with grasses. This effect has been measured in mechanically defoliated plots with little data available from grazing scenarios. There is a scarcity of data available regarding individual forage herb species contribution to increased sward DM production where only plant functional group has been monitored previously. The objective of this three year study was to assess the DM production, N fertiliser response and change of botanical composition in grazed plots across nine MS sward mixtures compared to a PRG monoculture. Multispecies swards included various combinations of species from the three plant functional groups; N fertiliser treatments of 0, 100, 150 and 200 kg N/ha/year were applied. While year influenced the effect of sward mixture on annual DM production, swards that included white clover (Trifolium repens. L.) produced an average of 1688 kg DM/ha/year more than those which did not (P < 0.05); including forage herbs did not increase either annual or seasonal sward DM production. In the final year of the study sward chicory (Chicorium intybus. L.) content was 5% in mixtures including three plant functional groups while ribwort plantain (Plantago lanceolate. L.; PL) content was 37% in the same sward types. Although PL did not increase grazed sward DM production in the current study it did persist well under grazing and may provide other beneficial ecosystem services in dairy grazing systems.

More than mesolectic: Characterizing the nutritional niche of Osmia cornifrons.

Characterizing the nutritional needs of wild bee species is an essential step to better understanding bee biology and providing suitable supplemental forage for at-risk species. Here, we aim to characterize the nutritional needs of a model solitary bee species, Osmia cornifrons (Radoszkowski), by using dietary protein-to-lipid ratio (P:L ratio) as a proxy for nutritional niche and niche breadth. We first identified the mean target P:L ratio (~3.02:1) and P:L collection range (0.75-6.26:1) from pollen provisions collected across a variety of sites and time points. We then investigated the P:L tolerance range of larvae by rearing bees invitro on a variety of diets. Multifloral and single-source pollen diets with P:L ratios within the range of surveyed provisions did not always support larval development, indicating that other dietary components such as plant secondary compounds and micronutrients must also be considered in bee nutritional experiments. Finally, we used pollen metabarcoding to identify pollen from whole larval provisions to understand how much pollen bees used from plants outside of their host plant families to meet their nutritional needs, as well as pollen from individual forager bouts, to observe if bees maintained strict floral constancy or visited multiple plant genera per foraging bout. Whole larval provision surveys revealed a surprising range of host plant pollen use, ranging from ~5% to 70% of host plant pollen per provision. Samples from individual foraging trips contained pollen from multiple genera, suggesting that bees are using some form of foraging decision making. Overall, these results suggest that O. cornifrons have a wide nutritional niche breadth, but while pollen P:L ratio tolerance is broad, a tolerable P:L ratio alone is not enough to create a quality diet for O. cornifrons, and the plant species that make up these diets must also be carefully considered.

Reciprocated competition between two forest carnivores drives dietary specialization.

Competition shapes animal communities, but the strength of the interaction varies spatially depending on the availability and aggregation of resources and competitors. Among carnivores, competition is particularly pronounced with the strongest interactions between similar species with intermediate differences in body size. While ecologists have emphasized interference competition among carnivores based on dominance hierarchies from body size (smaller = subordinate; larger = dominant), the reciprocity of exploitative competition from subordinate species has been overlooked even though efficient exploitation can limit resource availability and influence foraging. Across North America, fishers Pekania pennanti and martens (Martes spp.) are two phylogenetically related forest carnivores that exhibit a high degree of overlap in habitat use and diet and differ in body size by a factor of 2-5×, eliciting particularly strong interspecific competition. In the Great Lakes region, fishers and martens occur both allopatrically and sympatrically; where they co-occur, the numerically dominant species varies spatially. This natural variation in competitors and environmental conditions enables comparisons to understand how interference and exploitative competition alter dietary niche overlap and foraging strategies. We analysed stable isotopes (δ13 C and δ15 N) from 317 martens and 132 fishers, as well as dietary items (n = 629) from 20 different genera, to compare niche size and overlap. We then quantified individual diet specialization and modelled the response to environmental conditions that were hypothesized to influence individual foraging. Martens and fishers exhibited high overlap in both available and core isotopic δ-space, but no overlap of core dietary proportions. When the competitor was absent or rare, both martens and fishers consumed more smaller-bodied prey. Notably, the dominant fisher switched from being a specialist of larger to smaller prey in the absence of the subordinate marten. Environmental context also influenced dietary specialization: increasing land cover diversity and prey abundance reduced specialization in martens whereas vegetation productivity increased specialization for both martens and fishers. Despite an important dominance hierarchy, fishers adjusted their niche in the face of a subordinate, but superior, exploitative competitor. These findings highlight the underappreciated role of the subordinate competitor in shaping the dietary niche of a dominant competitor.

Individual bee foragers are less‐efficient transporters of pollen for plants from which they collect the most pollen in their scopae

Bees provision most of the pollen they remove from anthers to their larvae and transport only a small proportion to stigmas, which can negatively affect plant fitness. Though most bee species collect pollen from multiple plant species, we know little about how the efficiency of bees' pollen transport varies among host plant species, or how it relates to other aspects of generalist bee foraging behavior that benefit plant fitness, such as specialization on individual foraging bouts. We compared the pollen collected and transported by three bee species for 46 co-occurring plant species. Specifically, we compared the relative abundance of pollen taxa in individual bees' scopae, structures where bees store pollen to provision larvae, with the relative abundance of pollen taxa on the rest of bees' bodies, which is more likely to be transferred to stigmas. Bees carried five times more pollen grains in their scopae than elsewhere on their bodies. Within foraging bouts, bees were relatively specialized in their pollen collection, but transported proportionally less pollen for the host plants on which they specialized. Across foraging bouts, two bee species transported proportionally less pollen for some of their host plants than for others, though differences didn't consistently follow the same trend as at the foraging bout scale. Our results suggest that foraging bout specialization, which is known to reduce heterospecific pollen transfer, also results in less efficient pollen transport. Thus, bee foragers that visit predominantly one plant species may have contrasting effects on that plant's fitness. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Individual feed intake and performance of finishing steers on ryegrass pasture supplemented with increasing amounts of corn using an automated feeding system

Beef production in subtropical areas is mainly based on extensive grazing systems. During the winter, a drop in the forage quantity is common, energy supplementation may help maintain desired production levels. To measure the effect of increasing levels of corn supplementation on the individual forage intake and feed efficiency of finishing steers, we conducted a 99-d experiment during the winter-spring season in Uruguay. Sixty Aberdeen Angus steers (average BW 464.0 ± 29.7 kg) with access to the same sward of ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum Lam.) were managed under a strip-grazing system (sward height post-grazing: 5 cm) and access to an automated supplement feeder until slaughter. Steers were blocked by BW and previous supplement intake and randomly assigned to one of four groups of 15 animals: control (CON, 0.1% BW of corn), low supplementation (LS, 0.4% BW of corn), moderate supplementation (MS, 0.8% BW of corn), and high supplementation (HS, 1.2% BW of corn). Corn was pelleted with TiO2 to estimate fecal production. Diet digestibility was estimated with acid-insoluble ash concentration. The average daily forage allowance was 3.6 kg DM/100 kg BW per day. Supplement intake was 0.5, 1.8, 3.6, and 4.3 kg DM/d for CON, LS, MS, and HS group, respectively. Corn added at 0.4% BW resulted in a greater (P ≤ 0.01) forage intake than other treatments. A quadratic response was observed for forage (P ≤ 0.05) and total diet (P ≤ 0.01) intake to increasing rations of supplements. Total diet digestibility was greater (P ≤ 0.01) for CON and LS steers than for those from MS and HS; and an inverse, linear relationship with supplementation levels was observed (P ≤ 0.01). Steers grew faster with increasing amounts of supplementation (P ≤ 0.01) in comparison to CON cattle, responding quadratically (P ≤ 0.05) to added corn. Cattle from the CON group showed the lowest hot carcass weight (P ≤ 0.01). Finishing cattle on ryegrass pasture (low post-grazing sward height) using 0.6 to 0.8% BW of corn supplementation is the best option to obtain a better intake, performance, and carcass weight, being an alternative to reduce days on fattening and/or the cost of feeding animals.

Hunting behavior of a solitary sailfish Istiophorus platypterus and estimated energy gain after prey capture

Foraging behavior and interaction with prey is an integral component of the ecological niche of predators but is inherently difficult to observe for highly mobile animals in the marine environment. Billfishes have been described as energy speculators, expending a large amount of energy foraging, expecting to offset high costs with periodic high energetic gain. Surface-based group feeding of sailfish, Istiophorus platypterus, is commonly observed, yet sailfish are believed to be largely solitary roaming predators with high metabolic requirements, suggesting that individual foraging also represents a major component of predator–prey interactions. Here, we use biologging data and video to examine daily activity levels and foraging behavior, estimate metabolic costs, and document a solitary predation event for a 40 kg sailfish. We estimate a median active metabolic rate of 218.9 ± 70.5 mgO2 kg−1 h−1 which increased to 518.8 ± 586.3 mgO2 kg−1 h−1 during prey pursuit. Assuming a successful predation, we estimate a daily net energy gain of 2.4 MJ (5.1 MJ acquired, 2.7 MJ expended), supporting the energy speculator model. While group hunting may be a common activity used by sailfish to acquire energy, our calculations indicate that opportunistic individual foraging events offer a net energy return that contributes to the fitness of these highly mobile predators.

The effect of individual personality on novel food preference in a social context in the cinereous tit (Parus cinereus)

Abstract Exploratory behaviour is one of the best-investigated behavioural traits. However, little is known about the influence of personality on novel food preferences in the social context, i.e., whether knowledge and previous experience can influence individual preference or if the presence of conspecifics can alter their choice. In the present study, we examined in cinereous tit (Parus cinereus) whether individuals with different personality types in the social context will prefer their own previously chosen novel food or change their preference in the presence of conspecifics. Second, we studied how the presence and behaviour of conspecifics may mediate individual personality. We conducted a standardized personality assay (exploratory behaviour) to analyse the individual personality. Birds were trained and provided with three different types of novel human-derived materials in both asocial and social contexts (with a conspecific). We recorded the latency to feed, time spent at the feeder, and the number of visits by fast and slow explorers in the two contexts, i.e., asocial and social. After the analyses of experimental data, we found that fast-exploring cinereous tits preferred peanuts in an asocial context, while slow explorers consumed a greater amount of sunflower seeds. In the social context, individuals of both personality types preferred peanuts to sunflower seeds. Additionally, individuals took less latency to eat food, made more visits to the feeder, and spent more time at the feeder in the social context than in the asocial context. Our findings show that foraging success may be determined by personality and social context. However, personality traits may be subject to constraints arising from correlations with other behavioural traits, and it remains a major challenge to understand the functional significance of individual foraging strategies.

Twice daily feeding of canola oil steeped with Asparagopsis armata reduced methane emissions of lactating dairy cows

Red seaweeds have emerged as a potent methane-mitigating feed additive in ruminant diets. However, to date they have only been applied to production systems where total mixed rations (TMR) are given. New formulations are being developed to increase the application of red seaweeds, mainly Asparagopsis spp., across different production systems including those without TMR such as grazing-based systems. One product of interest is Asparagopsis armata steeped in edible oil (ASP-Oil) to extract and stabilise the primary antimethanogenic compound, bromoform. The aim of this study was to determine the effect of feeding two formulations of ASP-Oil, with (ASP-Oil 1) and without (ASP-Oil 2) the seaweed biomass removed, on enteric methane emissions, dry matter intake (DMI), milk yield and milk composition of dairy cows over 32 d. Thirty-nine lactating, multiparous, Holstein-Friesian (75 ± 20.6 days in milk) were randomly allocated to one of the three treatments; control (CON; basal diet + 134 g canola oil), ASP-Oil with the seaweed biomass removed (ASP1; basal diet + 134 g ASP-Oil 1), and ASP-Oil without the seaweed biomass removed (ASP2; basal diet + 145 g ASP-Oil 2 + 12 g canola oil). The treatments were given twice daily, using a pulse feeding technique, as a concentrate/oil supplement during each milking. The basal diet consisted of vetch hay ad libitum and 7.0 kg DM/d of a grain mix. Individual forage intakes were measured daily via electronic monitoring of individual cows at the feed bins. Methane emissions were measured using the modified sulphur hexafluoride tracer technique on days 27–32. At the rate of 136 g/d, there was no significant effect of treatment on DMI or milk yield, however during the transition period a rate of 268 g/d decreased hay intake. The supplementation of ASP1 and ASP2 decreased energy corrected milk (ECM; P = 0.029) compared to those cows offered the CON diet. Methane production (g/d) of cows given the ASP1 diet was 44 % lower than cows on the CON diet, methane yield (g/kg DMI) was 44 % lower, and methane intensity (g/kg ECM) was 38 % lower. For the ASP2 cows, the reductions were 39 % for methane production, 33 % for methane yield, and 31 % for methane intensity. Feeding the ASP-Oil increased bromoform concentrations in milk. However, the concentrations detected were demonstrated to be considerably lower than published safe concentrations in milk for human consumption (100 μg/L). These results show that the ASP-Oil has potential to be used as a methane mitigating feed additive when fed in a pulse feeding system.

Mechanisms of individual variation in large herbivore diets: Roles of spatial heterogeneity and state-dependent foraging.

Many populations of consumers consist of relatively specialized individuals that eat only a subset of the foods consumed by the population at large. Although the ecological significance of individual-level diet variation is recognized, such variation is difficult to document, and its underlying mechanisms are poorly understood. Optimal foraging theory provides a useful framework for predicting how individuals might select different diets, positing that animals balance the "opportunity cost" of stopping to eat an available food item against the cost of searching for something more nutritious; diet composition should be contingent on the distribution of food, and individual foragers should be more selective when they have greater energy reserves to invest in searching for high-quality foods. We tested these predicted mechanisms of individual niche differentiation by quantifying environmental (resource heterogeneity) and organismal (nutritional condition) determinants of diet in a widespread browsing antelope (bushbuck, Tragelaphus sylvaticus) in an African floodplain-savanna ecosystem. We quantified individuals' realized dietary niches (taxonomic richness and composition) using DNA metabarcoding of fecal samples collected repeatedly from 15 GPS-collared animals (range 6-14 samples per individual, median 12). Bushbuck diets were structured by spatial heterogeneity and constrained by individual condition. We observed significant individual-level partitioning of food plants by bushbuck both within and between two adjacent habitat types (floodplain and woodland). Individuals with home ranges that were closer together and/or had similar vegetation structure (measured using LiDAR) ate more similar diets, supporting the prediction that heterogeneous resource distribution promotes individual differentiation. Individuals in good nutritional condition had significantly narrower diets (fewer plant taxa), searched their home ranges more intensively (intensity-of-use index), and had higher-quality diets (percent digestible protein) than those in poor condition, supporting the prediction that animals with greater endogenous reserves have narrower realized niches because they can invest more time in searching for nutritious foods. Our results support predictions from optimal foraging theory about the energetic basis of individual-level dietary variation and provide a potentially generalizable framework for understanding how individuals' realized niche width is governed by animal behavior and physiology in heterogeneous landscapes.

Foraging in heterogeneous landscapes: variation in movement patterns of a tropical sand-bubbler crab

Abstract Acquiring food in heterogeneous landscapes presents a challenge to many foragers, as searching for food in an optimal manner is difficult in spatially and temporally variable environments. Investigating individual foraging patterns can elucidate how environmental variations at different scales constrain or select for energy-optimizing movements, which can inform conservation and management strategies by identifying spatio-temporal variations in species’ habitat use. To test how such movements vary with environmental conditions, we investigated foraging patterns of the deposit-feeding sand-bubbler crab, Scopimera intermedia Balss, 1934 at multiple spatial and temporal scales on soft sediment shores in Hong Kong. On a broad, annual, scale the crabs produced foraging tracks of different length and foraged over different areas around their burrows between hot and cool seasons. Although foraging movements of the crabs were slower and more restricted during the cool season, probably due to low environmental temperatures, foraging areas during the hot season were larger but limited by increasing conspecific interactions. Over a smaller scale at which the crabs make movement decisions, parameters such as turning angle and speed were variable, even within individual foraging excursions. Such variations appeared to be responses to small-scale variations in sediment food patches, which resulted in the crabs employing multiple movement modes. This context-dependent foraging strategy enables the crabs to feed for a longer time in food-rich patches compared with a fixed strategy and is, therefore, critical for species living in environments such as intertidal sediments, where food distribution is heterogeneous and foraging time is constrained by the tide.