Indirect Readout Mechanism Research Articles

The bacterial iron sensor IdeR recognizes its DNA targets by indirect readout.

The iron-dependent regulator IdeR is the main transcriptional regulator controlling iron homeostasis genes in Actinobacteria, including species from the Corynebacterium, Mycobacterium and Streptomyces genera, as well as the erythromycin-producing bacterium Saccharopolyspora erythraea. Despite being a well-studied transcription factor since the identification of the Diphtheria toxin repressor DtxR three decades ago, the details of how IdeR proteins recognize their highly conserved 19-bp DNA target remain to be elucidated. IdeR makes few direct contacts with DNA bases in its target sequence, and we show here that these contacts are not required for target recognition. The results of our structural and mutational studies support a model wherein IdeR mainly uses an indirect readout mechanism, identifying its targets via the sequence-dependent DNA backbone structure rather than through specific contacts with the DNA bases. Furthermore, we show that IdeR efficiently recognizes a shorter palindromic sequence corresponding to a half binding site as compared to the full 19-bp target previously reported, expanding the number of potential target genes controlled by IdeR proteins.

Hinge like domain motion facilitates human RBMS1 protein binding to proto-oncogene c-myc promoter.

DNA binding proteins recognize DNA specifically or non-specifically using direct and indirect readout mechanisms like sliding, hopping, and diffusion. However, a common difficulty in explicitly elucidating any particular mechanism of site-specific DNA-protein recognition is the lack of knowledge regarding target sequences and inadequate account of non-specific interactions, in general. Here, we decipher the structural basis of target search performed by the key regulator of expression of c-myc proto-oncogene, the human RBMS1 protein. In this study, we have shown the structural reorganization of this multi-domain protein required for recognizing the specific c-myc promoter sequence. The results suggest that a synergy between structural re-organization and thermodynamics is necessary for the recognition of target sequences. The study presents another perspective of looking at the DNA-protein interactions.

Control of virulence gene transcription by indirect readout in Vibrio cholerae and Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium.

SummaryIndirect readout mechanisms of transcription control rely on the recognition of DNA shape by transcription factors (TFs). TFs may also employ a direct readout mechanism that involves the reading of the base sequence in the DNA major groove at the binding site. TFs with winged helix–turn–helix (wHTH) motifs use an alpha helix to read the base sequence in the major groove while inserting a beta sheet ‘wing’ into the adjacent minor groove. Such wHTH proteins are important regulators of virulence gene transcription in many pathogens; they also control housekeeping genes. This article considers the cases of the non‐invasive Gram‐negative pathogen Vibrio cholerae and the invasive pathogen Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium. Both possess clusters of A + T‐rich horizontally acquired virulence genes that are silenced by the nucleoid‐associated protein H‐NS and regulated positively or negatively by wHTH TFs: for example, ToxR and LeuO in V. cholerae; HilA, LeuO, SlyA and OmpR in S. Typhimurium. Because of their relatively relaxed base sequence requirements for target recognition, indirect readout mechanisms have the potential to engage regulatory proteins with many more targets than might be the case using direct readout, making indirect readout an important, yet often ignored, contributor to the expression of pathogenic phenotypes.

DNA minor groove electrostatic potential: influence of sequence-specific transitions of the torsion angle gamma and deoxyribose conformations

The structural adjustments of the sugar-phosphate DNA backbone (switching of the γ angle (O5′–C5′–C4′–C3′) from canonical to alternative conformations and/or C2′-endo → C3′-endo transition of deoxyribose) lead to the sequence-specific changes in accessible surface area of both polar and non-polar atoms of the grooves and the polar/hydrophobic profile of the latter ones. The distribution of the minor groove electrostatic potential is likely to be changing as a result of such conformational rearrangements in sugar-phosphate DNA backbone. Our analysis of the crystal structures of the short free DNA fragments and calculation of their electrostatic potentials allowed us to determine: (1) the number of classical and alternative γ angle conformations in the free B-DNA; (2) changes in the minor groove electrostatic potential, depending on the conformation of the sugar-phosphate DNA backbone; (3) the effect of the DNA sequence on the minor groove electrostatic potential. We have demonstrated that the structural adjustments of the DNA double helix (the conformations of the sugar-phosphate backbone and the minor groove dimensions) induce changes in the distribution of the minor groove electrostatic potential and are sequence-specific. Therefore, these features of the minor groove sizes and distribution of minor groove electrostatic potential can be used as a signal for recognition of the target DNA sequence by protein in the implementation of the indirect readout mechanism.

Effect of Hydroxymethylcytosine on the Structure and Stability of Holliday Junctions.

5-Hydroxymethylcytosine (5hmC) is an epigenetic marker that has recently been shown to promote homologous recombination (HR). In this study, we determine the effects of 5hmC on the structure, thermodynamics, and conformational dynamics of the Holliday junction (the four-stranded DNA intermediate associated with HR) in its native stacked-X form. The hydroxymethyl and the control methyl substituents are placed in the context of an amphimorphic GxCC trinucleotide core sequence (where xC is C, 5hmC, or the methylated 5mC), which is part of a sequence also recognized by endonuclease G to promote HR. The hydroxymethyl group of the 5hmC junction adopts two distinct rotational conformations, with an in-base-plane form being dominant over the competing out-of-plane rotamer that has typically been seen in duplex structures. The in-plane rotamer is seen to be stabilized by a more stable intramolecular hydrogen bond to the junction backbone. Stabilizing hydrogen bonds (H-bonds) formed by the hydroxyl substituent in 5hmC or from a bridging water in the 5mC structure provide approximately 1.5-2 kcal/mol per interaction of stability to the junction, which is mostly offset by entropy compensation, thereby leaving the overall stability of the G5hmCC and G5mCC constructs similar to that of the GCC core. Thus, both methyl and hydroxymethyl modifications are accommodated without disrupting the structure or stability of the Holliday junction. Both 5hmC and 5mC are shown to open the structure to make the junction core more accessible. The overall consequences of incorporating 5hmC into a DNA junction are thus discussed in the context of the specificity in protein recognition of the hydroxymethyl substituent through direct and indirect readout mechanisms.

Quantitative characterization of conformational-specific protein-DNA binding using a dual-spectral interferometric imaging biosensor.

DNA-binding proteins play crucial roles in the maintenance and functions of the genome and yet, their specific binding mechanisms are not fully understood. Recently, it was discovered that DNA-binding proteins recognize specific binding sites to carry out their functions through an indirect readout mechanism by recognizing and capturing DNA conformational flexibility and deformation. High-throughput DNA microarray-based methods that provide large-scale protein-DNA binding information have shown effective and comprehensive analysis of protein-DNA binding affinities, but do not provide information of DNA conformational changes in specific protein-DNA complexes. Building on the high-throughput capability of DNA microarrays, we demonstrate a quantitative approach that simultaneously measures the amount of protein binding to DNA and nanometer-scale DNA conformational change induced by protein binding in a microarray format. Both measurements rely on spectral interferometry on a layered substrate using a single optical instrument in two distinct modalities. In the first modality, we quantitate the amount of binding of protein to surface-immobilized DNA in each DNA spot using a label-free spectral reflectivity technique that accurately measures the surface densities of protein and DNA accumulated on the substrate. In the second modality, for each DNA spot, we simultaneously measure DNA conformational change using a fluorescence vertical sectioning technique that determines average axial height of fluorophores tagged to specific nucleotides of the surface-immobilized DNA. The approach presented in this paper, when combined with current high-throughput DNA microarray-based technologies, has the potential to serve as a rapid and simple method for quantitative and large-scale characterization of conformational specific protein-DNA interactions.

Role of indirect readout mechanism in TATA box binding protein-DNA interaction.

Gene expression generally initiates from recognition of TATA-box binding protein (TBP) to the minor groove of DNA of TATA box sequence where the DNA structure is significantly different from B-DNA. We have carried out molecular dynamics simulation studies of TBP-DNA system to understand how the DNA structure alters for efficient binding. We observed rigid nature of the protein while the DNA of TATA box sequence has an inherent flexibility in terms of bending and minor groove widening. The bending analysis of the free DNA and the TBP bound DNA systems indicate presence of some similar structures. Principal coordinate ordination analysis also indicates some structural features of the protein bound and free DNA are similar. Thus we suggest that the DNA of TATA box sequence regularly oscillates between several alternate structures and the one suitable for TBP binding is induced further by the protein for proper complex formation.

The transcriptional regulator CprK detects chlorination by combining direct and indirect readout mechanisms

The transcriptional regulator CprK controls the expression of the reductive dehalogenase CprA in organohalide-respiring bacteria. Desulfitobacterium hafniense CprA catalyses the reductive dechlorination of the terminal electron acceptor o-chlorophenol acetic acid, generating the phenol acetic acid product. It has been shown that CprK has ability to distinguish between the chlorinated CprA substrate and the de-halogenated end product, with an estimated an estimated 104-fold difference in affinity. Using a green fluorescent protein GFPUV-based transcriptional reporter system, we establish that CprK can sense o-chlorophenol acetic acid at the nanomolar level, whereas phenol acetic acid leads to transcriptional activation only when approaching micromolar levels. A structure–activity relationship study, using a range of o-chlorophenol acetic-acid-related compounds and key CprK mutants, combined with pKa calculations on the effector binding site, suggests that the sensitive detection of chlorination is achieved through a combination of direct and indirect readout mechanisms. Both the physical presence of the bulky chloride substituent as well as the accompanying electronic effects lowering the inherent phenol pKa are required for high affinity. Indeed, transcriptional activation by CprK appears strictly dependent on establishing a phenolate–K133 salt bridge interaction, rather than on the presence of a halogen atom per se. As K133 is strictly conserved within the CprK family, our data suggest that physiological function and future applications in biosensing are probably restricted to phenolic compounds.

On the Origin of the Selectivity of Plasmidic H-NS towards Horizontally Acquired DNA: Linking H-NS Oligomerization and Cooperative DNA Binding

The nucleoid-associated protein H-NS is a global modulator of the expression of genes associated with adaptation to environmental changes. A variant of H-NS expressed in the R27 plasmid was previously shown to selectively modulate the expression of horizontally acquired genes, with minimal effects on core genes that are repressed by the chromosomal form of H-NS. Both H-NS proteins are formed by an oligomerization domain and a DNA-binding domain, which are connected by a linker that is highly flexible in the absence of DNA.We studied DNA binding by means of oligomer-forming chimeric proteins in which domains of the chromosomal and plasmidic variants are exchanged, as well as in monomeric truncated forms containing the DNA-binding domain and variable portions of the linker. Point mutations in the linker were also examined in full-length and truncated H-NS constructs. These experiments show that the linker region contributes to DNA binding affinity and that it is a main component of the distinct DNA binding properties of chromosomal and plasmidic H-NS.We propose that interactions between the linker and DNA limit the flexibility of the connection between H-NS oligomerization and DNA binding and provide an allosteric indirect readout mechanism to detect long-range distortions of DNA, thus enabling discrimination between core and horizontally acquired DNA.

Protein-DNA docking with a coarse-grained force field

BackgroundProtein-DNA interactions are important for many cellular processes, however structural knowledge for a large fraction of known and putative complexes is still lacking. Computational docking methods aim at the prediction of complex architecture given detailed structures of its constituents. They are becoming an increasingly important tool in the field of macromolecular assemblies, complementing particularly demanding protein-nucleic acids X ray crystallography and providing means for the refinement and integration of low resolution data coming from rapidly advancing methods such as cryoelectron microscopy.ResultsWe present a new coarse-grained force field suitable for protein-DNA docking. The force field is an extension of previously developed parameter sets for protein-RNA and protein-protein interactions. The docking is based on potential energy minimization in translational and orientational degrees of freedom of the binding partners. It allows for fast and efficient systematic search for native-like complex geometry without any prior knowledge regarding binding site location.ConclusionsWe find that the force field gives very good results for bound docking. The quality of predictions in the case of unbound docking varies, depending on the level of structural deviation from bound geometries. We analyze the role of specific protein-DNA interactions on force field performance, both with respect to complex structure prediction, and the reproduction of experimental binding affinities. We find that such direct, specific interactions only partially contribute to protein-DNA recognition, indicating an important role of shape complementarity and sequence-dependent DNA internal energy, in line with the concept of indirect protein-DNA readout mechanism.

Functional Specificity of a Protein-DNA Complex Mediated by Two Arginines Bound to the Minor Groove

A bacteriophage Ø29 transcriptional regulator, protein p4, interacts with its DNA target by employing two mechanisms: by direct readout of the chemical signatures of only one DNA base and by inducing local modification on the topology of short A tracts (indirect readout). p4 binds as a dimer to targets consisting of imperfect inverted repeats. Here we used molecular dynamic simulation to define interactions of a cluster of 12 positively charged amino acids of p4 with DNA and biochemical assays with modified DNA targets and mutated proteins to quantify the contribution of residues in the nucleoprotein complex. Our results show the implication of Arg54, with non-base-specific interaction in the central A tract, in p4 binding affinity. Despite being chemically equivalent and in identical protein monomers, the two Arg54 residues differed in their interactions with DNA. We discuss an indirect-readout mechanism for p4-DNA recognition mediated by dissimilar interaction of arginines penetrating the minor groove and the inherent properties of the A tract. Our findings extend the current understanding of protein-DNA recognition and contribute to the relevance of the sequence-dependent conformational malleability of the DNA, shedding light on the role of arginines in binding affinity. Characterization of mutant p4R54A shows that the residue is required for the activity of the protein as a transcriptional regulator.

A new method for evaluating the specificity of indirect readout in protein–DNA recognition

Proteins recognize a specific DNA sequence not only through direct contact (direct readout) with base pairs but also through sequence-dependent conformation and/or flexibility of DNA (indirect readout). However, it is difficult to assess the contribution of indirect readout to the sequence specificity. What is needed is a straightforward method for quantifying its contributions to specificity. Using Bayesian statistics, we derived the probability of a particular sequence for a given DNA structure from the trajectories of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of DNAs containing all possible tetramer sequences. Then, we quantified the specificity of indirect readout based on the information entropy associated with the probability. We tested this method with known structures of protein–DNA complexes. This method enabled us to correctly predict those regions where experiments suggested the involvement of indirect readout. The results also indicated new regions where the indirect readout mechanism makes major contributions to the recognition. The present method can be used to estimate the contribution of indirect readout without approximations to the distributions in the conformational ensembles of DNA, and would serve as a powerful tool to study the mechanism of protein–DNA recognition.

Indirect DNA Readout by an H-NS Related Protein: Structure of the DNA Complex of the C-Terminal Domain of Ler

Ler, a member of the H-NS protein family, is the master regulator of the LEE pathogenicity island in virulent Escherichia coli strains. Here, we determined the structure of a complex between the DNA-binding domain of Ler (CT-Ler) and a 15-mer DNA duplex. CT-Ler recognizes a preexisting structural pattern in the DNA minor groove formed by two consecutive regions which are narrower and wider, respectively, compared with standard B-DNA. The compressed region, associated with an AT-tract, is sensed by the side chain of Arg90, whose mutation abolishes the capacity of Ler to bind DNA. The expanded groove allows the approach of the loop in which Arg90 is located. This is the first report of an experimental structure of a DNA complex that includes a protein belonging to the H-NS family. The indirect readout mechanism not only explains the capacity of H-NS and other H-NS family members to modulate the expression of a large number of genes but also the origin of the specificity displayed by Ler. Our results point to a general mechanism by which horizontally acquired genes may be specifically recognized by members of the H-NS family.

Structural basis for the cooperative DNA recognition by Smad4 MH1 dimers

Smad proteins form multimeric complexes consisting of the ‘common partner’ Smad4 and receptor regulated R-Smads on clustered DNA binding sites. Deciphering how pathway specific Smad complexes multimerize on DNA to regulate gene expression is critical for a better understanding of the cis-regulatory logic of TGF-β and BMP signaling. To this end, we solved the crystal structure of the dimeric Smad4 MH1 domain bound to a palindromic Smad binding element. Surprisingly, the Smad4 MH1 forms a constitutive dimer on the SBE DNA without exhibiting any direct protein–protein interactions suggesting a DNA mediated indirect readout mechanism. However, the R-Smads Smad1, Smad2 and Smad3 homodimerize with substantially decreased efficiency despite pronounced structural similarities to Smad4. Therefore, intricate variations in the DNA structure induced by different Smads and/or variant energetic profiles likely contribute to their propensity to dimerize on DNA. Indeed, competitive binding assays revealed that the Smad4/R-Smad heterodimers predominate under equilibrium conditions while R-Smad homodimers are least favored. Together, we present the structural basis for DNA recognition by Smad4 and demonstrate that Smad4 constitutively homo- and heterodimerizes on DNA in contrast to its R-Smad partner proteins by a mechanism independent of direct protein contacts.

Molecular Interactions and Protein-Induced DNA Hairpin in the Transcriptional Control of Bacteriophage Ø29 DNA

Studies on the regulation of phage Ø29 gene expression revealed a new mechanism to accomplish simultaneous activation and repression of transcription leading to orderly gene expression. Two phage-encoded early proteins, p4 and p6, bind synergistically to DNA, modifying the topology of the sequences encompassing early promoters A2c and A2b and late promoter A3 in a hairpin that allows the switch from early to late transcription. Protein p6 is a nucleoid-like protein that binds DNA in a non-sequence specific manner. Protein p4 is a sequence-specific DNA binding protein with multifaceted sequence-readout properties. The protein recognizes the chemical signature of only one DNA base on the inverted repeat of its target sequence through a direct-readout mechanism. In addition, p4 specific binding depends on the recognition of three A-tracts by indirect-readout mechanisms. The biological importance of those three A-tracts resides in their individual properties rather than in the global curvature that they may induce.

Indirect DNA Readout on the Protein Side: Coupling between Histidine Protonation, Global Structural Cooperativity, Dynamics, and DNA Binding of the Human Papillomavirus Type 16 E2C Domain

DNA sequence recognition by the homodimeric C-terminal domain of the human papillomavirus type 16 E2 protein (E2C) is known to involve both direct readout and DNA-dependent indirect readout mechanisms, while protein-dependent indirect readout has been deduced but not directly observed. We have investigated coupling between specific DNA binding and the dynamics of the unusual E2C fold, using pH as an external variable. Nuclear magnetic resonance and isothermal titration calorimetry show that pH titration of His318 in the complex interface and His288 in the core of the domain is coupled to both binding and the dynamics of the β-barrel core of E2C, with a tradeoff between dimer stability and function. Specific DNA binding is, in turn, coupled to the slow dynamics and amide hydrogen exchange in the entire β-barrel, reaching residues far apart from the DNA recognition elements but not affecting the two helices of each monomer. The changes are largest in the dimerization interface, suggesting that the E2C β-barrel acts as a hinge that regulates the relative position of the DNA recognition helices. In conclusion, the cooperative dynamics of the human papillomavirus type 16 E2C β-barrel is coupled to sequence recognition in a protein-dependent indirect readout mechanism. The patterns of residue substitution in genital papillomaviruses support the importance of the protonation states of His288 and His318 and suggest that protein-dependent indirect readout and histidine pH titration may regulate DNA binding in the cell.

The Role of DNA “Bendability” in the Indirect Read-Out Mechanism of Protein-DNA Interactions

Integration host factor (IHF) from E. coli is a DNA-bending protein that recognizes and binds to its specific sites primarily by the indirect read-out mechanism, in which sequence-dependent DNA dynamics and flexibility play an important role. The crystal structure of IHF bound to a 35-bp long cognate site H' indicates that the DNA is kinked at two sites separated by ∼9 bp, resulting in a “U-turn” bend of the DNA. We use laser temperature-jump to perturb the IHF-DNA complex, and time-resolved FRET on end-labeled DNA substrates to monitor the bending/unbending dynamics. In our previous studies, we suggested that spontaneous DNA bending from transient disruption of base-pairing and/or stacking interactions at the site of the kinks may be the rate-limiting step in the transition from the nonspecific to the specific complex. Here, we investigate DNA bending kinetics for substrates with mismatched pairs introduced at the site of the kinks. These internal “loops” are expected to decrease the energetic cost of bending the DNA, which is reflected in the >10-fold increase in the binding affinity. Kinetics measurements on IHF bound to such DNA reveal deviations from single exponential relaxation, indicating two distinct phases. Of particular interest is the observation that the rapid phase has a rate that is 10-20 times faster than the bending rate observed in the IHF-H' complex. Thus, reducing the energetic cost of bending/kinking DNA speeds up the bending rate by nearly the same factor as the increase in binding affinity, indicating that the free energy of the transition state is lowered by the same amount as the free energy of the complex. These results support our earlier conclusion, that spontaneous bending of DNA is the first step in the recognition mechanism.

Early interrogation and recognition of DNA sequence by indirect readout.

Control of replication, transcription, recombination and repair requires proteins capable of finding particular DNA sequences in a background of a large excess of nonspecific sequences. Such recognition can involve direct readout, with direct contacts to the bases of DNA, or in some cases through the less well-characterized indirect readout mechanisms. In order to measure the relative contributions of direct and indirect readout by a sequence specific endonuclease, HincII, a mutant enzyme deficient in a direct contact, was characterized, and surprisingly showed no loss of sequence specificity. The three dimensional crystal structure shows the loss of most of the direct readout contacts to the DNA, possibly capturing an early stage in target site recognition using predominately indirect readout to prescreen sites before full sequence interrogation.

31P NMR investigation of backbone dynamics in DNA binding sites.

The backbone conformation of DNA plays an important role in the indirect readout mechanisms for protein--DNA recognition events. Thus, investigating the backbone dynamics of each step in DNA binding sequences provides useful information necessary for the characterization of these interactions. Here, we use 31P dynamic NMR to characterize the backbone conformation and dynamics in the Dickerson dodecamer, a sequence containing the EcoRI binding site, and confirm solid-state 2H NMR results showing that the C3pG4 and C9pG10 steps experience unique dynamics and that these dynamics are quenched upon cytosine methylation. In addition, we show that cytosine methylation affects the conformation and dynamics of neighboring nucleotide steps, but this effect is localized to only near neighbors and base-pairing partners. Last, we have been able to characterize the percent BII in each backbone step and illustrate that the C3pG4 and C9pG10 favor the noncanonical BII conformation, even at low temperatures. Our results demonstrate that 31P dynamic NMR provides a robust and efficient method for characterizing the backbone dynamics in DNA. This allows simple, rapid determination of sequence-dependent dynamical information, providing a useful method for studying trends in protein-DNA recognition events.

Indirect readout in drug-DNA recognition: role of sequence-dependent DNA conformation.

DNA-binding drugs have numerous applications in the engineered gene regulation. However, the drug-DNA recognition mechanism is poorly understood. Drugs can recognize specific DNA sequences not only through direct contacts but also indirectly through sequence-dependent conformation, in a similar manner to the indirect readout mechanism in protein-DNA recognition. We used a knowledge-based technique that takes advantage of known DNA structures to evaluate the conformational energies. We built a dataset of non-redundant free B-DNA crystal structures to calculate the distributions of adjacent base-step and base-pair conformations, and estimated the effective harmonic potentials of mean force (PMF). These PMFs were used to calculate the conformational energy of drug-DNA complexes, and the Z-score as a measure of the binding specificity. Comparing the Z-scores for drug-DNA complexes with those for free DNA structures with the same sequence, we observed that in several cases the Z-scores became more negative upon drug binding. Furthermore, the specificity is position-dependent within the drug-bound region of DNA. These results suggest that DNA conformation plays an important role in the drug-DNA recognition. The presented method provides a tool for the analysis of drug-DNA recognition and can facilitate the development of drugs for targeting a specific DNA sequence.