Indirect Alloreactivity Research Articles

The phenotype of HLA-binding B cells from sensitized kidney transplant recipients correlates with clinically prognostic patterns of interferon-γ production against purified HLA proteins

B cells play crucial roles in cell-mediated alloimmune responses. Invitro, B cells can support or regulate indirect T-cell alloreactivity in response to donor antigens on ELISpot and these patterns associate with clinical outcome. Previous reports of associations between B-cell phenotype and function have examined global phenotypes and responses to polyclonal stimuli. We hypothesized that studying antigen-specific B cells, using samples from sensitized patients, would inform further study to identify novel targets for intervention. Using biotinylated HLA proteins, which bind HLA-specific B cells via the B-cell receptor in a dose-dependent fashion, we report the specific phenotype of HLA-binding B cells and define how they associated with patterns of anti-HLA response in interferon-γ ELISpot. HLA-binding class-switched and IgM+CD27+ memory cells associated strongly with B-dependent interferon-γ production and appeared not suppressible by endogenous Tregs. When the predominant HLA-binding phenotype was naïve B cells, the associated functional ELISpot phenotype was determined by other cells present. High numbers of non-HLA-binding transitional cells associated with B-suppressed interferon-γ production, especially if Tregs were present. However, high frequencies of HLA-binding marginal-zone precursors associated with B-dependent interferon-γ production that appeared suppressible by Tregs. Finally, non-HLA-binding marginal zone precursors may also suppress interferon-γ production, though this association only emerged when Tregs were absent from the ELISpot. Thus, our novel data provide a foundation on which to further define the complexities of interactions between HLA-specific T and B cells and identify new targets for intervention in new therapies for chronic rejection.

B lymphocytes contribute to indirect pathway T cell sensitization via acquisition of extracellular vesicles.

B cells have been implicated in transplant rejection via antibody-mediated mechanisms and more recently by presenting donor antigens to T cells. We have shown in patients with chronic antibody-mediated rejection that B cells control the indirect T cell alloresponses. To understand more about the role of B cells as antigen-presenting cells for CD4+ T cell with indirect allospecificity, B cells were depleted in C57BL/6 mice, using an anti-CD20 antibody, prior to receiving MHC class I-mismatched (Kd ) skin. The absence of B cells at the time of transplantation prolonged skin graft survival. To study the mechanisms behind this observation, T cells with indirect allospecificity were transferred in mice receiving a Kd skin transplant. T cell proliferation was markedly inhibited in the absence of recipient B cells, suggesting that B cells contribute to indirect pathway sensitization. Furthermore, we have shown that a possible way in which B cells present alloantigens is via acquisition of MHC-peptide complexes. Finally, we demonstrate that the addition of B cell depletion to the transfer of regulatory T cells (Tregs) with indirect alloresponse further prolonged skin graft survival. This study supports an important role for B cells in indirect T cell priming and further emphasizes the advantage of combination therapies in prolonging transplant survival.

Regulatory/inflammatory cellular response discrimination in operational tolerance

Antigen-specific cellular response is essential in immune tolerance. We tested whether antigen-specific cellular response is differentially modulated in operational tolerance (OT) in renal transplantation with respect to critical antigenic challenges in allotransplantation-donor antigens, pathogenic antigens and self-antigens. We analysed the profile of immunoregulatory (REG) and pro-inflammatory (INFLAMMA) cytokines for the antigen-specific response directed to these three antigen groups, by Luminex. We showed that, in contrast to chronic rejection and healthy individuals, OT gives rise to an immunoregulatory deviation in the cellular response to donor human leucocyte antigen DR isotype peptides, while preserving the pro-inflammatory response to pathogenic peptides. Cellular autoreactivity to the N6 heat shock protein 60 (Hsp60) peptide also showed a REG profile in OT, increasing IL4, IL-5, IL-10 and IL-13. The REG shift of donor indirect alloreactivity in OT, with inhibition of interleukin (IL)-1B, IL-8, IL-12, IL-17, granulocyte colony-stimulating factor, Interferon-γ and monocyte chemoattractant protein-1, indicates that this may be an important mechanism in OT. In addition, the differential REG profile of cellular response to the Hsp60 peptide in OT suggests that REG autoimmunity may also play a role in human transplantation tolerance. Despite cross-reactivity of antigen-specific T cell responses, a systemic functional antigen-specific discrimination takes place in OT.

B-lymphocytes support and regulate indirect T-cell alloreactivity in individual patients with chronic antibody-mediated rejection

We explored how B-lymphocytes influence in vitro T-cell alloresponses in patients with antibody-mediated rejection (AMR), testing whether B-cells would be preferentially involved in this group of patients. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were collected from 65 patients having biopsy: 14 patients with AMR and 5 with no pathology on protocol; 38 with AMR and 8 with nonimmunologic damage on 'for cause'. Using enzyme-linked immunosorbent spot assays, we found interferon-γ production by indirect allorecognition in 45 of 119 total samples from the 65 patients. B-cells preferentially processed and presented donor alloantigens in samples from AMR patients. In a further 25 samples, B-cell-dependent allo-specific reactivity was shown by depletion of CD25(+) cells and these individuals had higher percentages of CD4CD25hi cells. In 21 samples, reactivity was shown by depletion of CD19(+) cells, associated with polarized cytokine production toward IL-10 after polyclonal activation by IgG/IgM. Overall, this shows a significant contribution by B-cells to indirect donor-specific T-cell reactivity in vitro in patients with AMR. Active suppression by distinct phenotypes of T- or B-cells in approximately half of the patients indicates that chronic AMR is not characterized by a universal loss of immune regulation. Thus, stratified approaches that accommodate the heterogeneity of cell-mediated immunity might be beneficial to treat graft dysfunction.

Cellular and molecular immune profiles in renal transplant recipients after conversion from tacrolimus to sirolimus

Tacrolimus and Sirolimus are commonly used maintenance immunesuppressants in kidney transplantation. Since their effects on immune cells and allograft molecular profiles have not been elucidated, we characterized the effects of Tacrolimus to Sirolimus conversion on frequency and function of T cells, and on graft molecular profiles. Samples from renal transplant patients in a randomized trial of 18 patients with late Sirolimus conversion and 12 on Tacrolimus maintenance were utilized. Peripheral blood was collected at 0, 6, 12 and 24-months post-randomization with T cell subpopulations analyzed by flow cytometry and T cell alloreactivity tested by IFN-γ ELISPOT. Graft biopsy samples obtained 24-months post-randomization were used for gene expression analysis. Sirolimus conversion led to an increase in CD4+25+++Foxp3+ regulatory T cells. While Tacrolimus-maintained patients showed a decrease in indirect alloreactivity over time post-transplant, Sirolimus conversion increased indirect alloreactive T cell frequencies compared to Tacrolimus-maintained patients. No histological differences were found in graft biopsies, but molecular profiles showed activation of the antigen presentation, IL-12 signaling, oxidative stress, macrophage-derived production pathways, and increased inflammatory and immune response in Sirolimus-converted patients. Thus, chronic immune alterations are induced after Sirolimus conversion. Despite the molecular profile being favorable to calcineurin inhibitor-based regimen, there was no impact in renal function over 30 months of follow-up.

Both rejection and tolerance of allografts can occur in the absence of secondary lymphoid tissues.

In this study, we showed that aly/aly mice, which are devoid of lymph nodes and Peyer's patches, acutely rejected fully allogeneic skin and heart grafts. They mounted potent inflammatory direct alloresponses but failed to develop indirect alloreactivity after transplantation. Remarkably, skin allografts also were rejected acutely by splenectomized aly/aly (aly/aly-spl(-)) mice devoid of all secondary lymphoid organs. In these recipients, the rejection was mediated by alloreactive CD8(+) T cells presumably primed in the bone marrow. In contrast, cardiac transplants were not rejected by aly/aly-spl(-) mice. Actually, aly/aly-spl(-) mice that spontaneously accepted a heart allotransplant and displayed donor-specific tolerance also accepted skin grafts from the same, but not a third-party, donor via a mechanism involving CD4(+) regulatory T cells producing IL-10 cytokine. Therefore, direct priming of alloreactive T cells, as well as rejection and regulatory tolerance of allogeneic transplants, can occur in recipient mice lacking secondary lymphoid organs.

Generation of human alloantigen-specific T cells from peripheral blood.

The study of human T lymphocyte biology often involves examination of responses to activating ligands. T cells recognize and respond to processed peptide antigens presented by MHC (human ortholog HLA) molecules through the T cell receptor (TCR) in a highly sensitive and specific manner. While the primary function of T cells is to mediate protective immune responses to foreign antigens presented by self-MHC, T cells respond robustly to antigenic differences in allogeneic tissues. T cell responses to alloantigens can be described as either direct or indirect alloreactivity. In alloreactivity, the T cell responds through highly specific recognition of both the presented peptide and the MHC molecule. The robust oligoclonal response of T cells to allogeneic stimulation reflects the large number of potentially stimulatory alloantigens present in allogeneic tissues. While the breadth of alloreactive T cell responses is an important factor in initiating and mediating the pathology associated with biologically-relevant alloreactive responses such as graft versus host disease and allograft rejection, it can preclude analysis of T cell responses to allogeneic ligands. To this end, this protocol describes a method for generating alloreactive T cells from naive human peripheral blood leukocytes (PBL) that respond to known peptide-MHC (pMHC) alloantigens. The protocol applies pMHC multimer labeling, magnetic bead enrichment and flow cytometry to single cell in vitro culture methods for the generation of alloantigen-specific T cell clones. This enables studies of the biochemistry and function of T cells responding to allogeneic stimulation.

Development of an ex vivo assay measuring T cells with indirect alloreactivity using messenger RNA electroporation

Development of an ex vivo assay measuring T cells with indirect alloreactivity using messenger RNA electroporation

Development of an Ex Vivo Assay Measuring Human CD4+ T Cells With Indirect Alloreactivity Using Messenger RNA Electroporation.

Development of an Ex Vivo Assay Measuring Human CD4+ T Cells With Indirect Alloreactivity Using Messenger RNA Electroporation.

P2X7Rs Are Required for Th17 Mediated Auto- or Indirect Allo-Reactivity But Not for Th1 Controlled Viral or Bacterial Responses in Transplant Recipients.

P2X7Rs Are Required for Th17 Mediated Auto- or Indirect Allo-Reactivity But Not for Th1 Controlled Viral or Bacterial Responses in Transplant Recipients.

Effects of Lymphangiogenesis Blockade On Cell Trafficking, Alloimmunity and Rejection After Skin or Heart Transplantation.

Seminal studies from Billingham and others have demonstrated the key role of afferent lymphatics in the migration of donor passenger leukocytes to the recipient's lymph nodes after skin transplantation. In the present study, we tested the effect of mF4-31C, an anti-VEGFR3 antibody known to alter lymphangiogenesis, on the donor cell trafficking, T cell alloresponse and rejection after placement of skin or heart allografts. First, BALB/c mice were treated with mF4-31C (0.25 mg, i.p. at day 1, 3 and 5 post-Tx) or mF4-31C + MR1 (anti-CD40L mAb) and transplanted with a fully allogeneic B6-GFP skin graft. mF4-31C treatment resulted in an absence of donor passenger leukocytes in the recipient's draining lymph nodes (day 6 post-Tx), a reduction of the direct alloresponse and an abrogation of the indirect alloresponse by T cells but no prolongation of allograft survival (MST 10-12 days). Co-treatment with mF4-31C and MR1 abrogated both direct and indirect T cell alloresponses and significantly prolonged skin graft survival (MST > 40 days). Next, mF4-31 mAbs were tested for their ability to impact indirect alloimmunity and rejection of minor antigen-mismatched allografts. B6 mice were transplanted with B6-GFP skin or cardiac allografts and treated with mF4-31C, as described above. We observed a marked reduction of the indirect alloresponse by T cells as well as well as a prolongation of graft survival (> 25 days for both skin and heart transplants). Therefore, blockade of lymphangiogenesis represents a promising approach for the inhibition of indirect alloreactivity and may be used in combination with leukocyte costimulation blockade or conventional immunosuppression to prolong allograft survival.

Predicting alloreactivity in transplantation.

Human leukocyte Antigen (HLA) mismatching leads to severe complications after solid-organ transplantation and hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation. The alloreactive responses underlying the posttransplantation complications include both direct recognition of allogeneic HLA by HLA-specific alloantibodies and T cells and indirect T-cell recognition. However, the immunogenicity of HLA mismatches is highly variable; some HLA mismatches lead to severe clinical B-cell- and T-cell-mediated alloreactivity, whereas others are well tolerated. Definition of the permissibility of HLA mismatches prior to transplantation allows selection of donor-recipient combinations that will have a reduced chance to develop deleterious host-versus-graft responses after solid-organ transplantation and graft-versus-host responses after hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation. Therefore, several methods have been developed to predict permissible HLA-mismatch combinations. In this review we aim to give a comprehensive overview about the current knowledge regarding HLA-directed alloreactivity and several developed in vitro and in silico tools that aim to predict direct and indirect alloreactivity.

Primary Vascularization of Allografts Governs Their Immunogenicity and Susceptibility to Tolerogenesis

We investigated the influence of allograft primary vascularization on alloimmunity, rejection, and tolerance in mice. First, we showed that fully allogeneic primarily vascularized and conventional skin transplants were rejected at the same pace. Remarkably, however, short-term treatment of mice with anti-CD40L Abs achieved long-term survival of vascularized skin and cardiac transplants but not conventional skin grafts. Nonvascularized skin transplants triggered vigorous direct and indirect proinflammatory type 1 T cell responses (IL-2 and IFN-γ), whereas primarily vascularized skin allografts failed to trigger a significant indirect alloresponse. A similar lack of indirect alloreactivity was also observed after placement of different vascularized organ transplants, including hearts and kidneys, whereas hearts placed under the skin (nonvascularized) triggered potent indirect alloresponses. Altogether, these results suggest that primary vascularization of allografts is associated with a lack of indirect T cell alloreactivity. Finally, we show that long-term survival of vascularized skin allografts induced by anti-CD40L Abs was associated with a combined lack of indirect alloresponse and a shift of the direct alloresponse toward a type 2 cytokine (IL-4, IL-10)-secretion pattern but no activation/expansion of Foxp3(+) regulatory T cells. Therefore, primary vascularization of allografts governs their immunogenicity and tolerogenicity.

Direct Alloreactivity Is More Susceptible to Regulation by Natural Regulatory T Cells Than Indirect Alloreactivity

The contribution of natural CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory T cells (nTregs) in controlling graft rejection and the mechanism used remain controversial. Using the duality of the 2.102 TCR Ag recognition, we were able to study, for the first time to our knowledge, the involvement of nTregs in the two pathways of allorecognition in a murine adoptive transfer model in which TCR-transgenic nTregs were or were not depleted before transplantation. We show that nTregs used at a physiological ratio were able to delay graft rejection after direct alloreactivity by controlling proliferation and differentiation of alloreactive CD4(+) conventional T cells in draining lymph nodes. In contrast, similar results were found in the indirect alloreactivity pathway only when nTregs were used in high numbers. In the latter pathway, nTregs used at a physiological ratio failed to delay graft rejection and to control proliferation of conventional T cells. These results support recent therapeutic approaches aimed at producing and using in vitro Ag-specific Foxp3(+) nTregs to control graft rejection in transplantation. Finally, late inhibition of Th1 differentiation was shown in indirect alloreactivity, but this suppression could also be mediated by Foxp3(+)-induced Tregs.

Contributions of Direct and Indirect Alloresponses to Chronic Rejection of Kidney Allografts in Nonhuman Primates

The relative contribution of direct and indirect allorecognition pathways to chronic rejection of allogeneic organ transplants in primates remains unclear. In this study, we evaluated T and B cell alloresponses in cynomolgus monkeys that had received combined kidney/bone marrow allografts and myeloablative immunosuppressive treatments. We measured donor-specific direct and indirect T cell responses and alloantibody production in monkeys (n = 5) that did not reject their transplant acutely but developed chronic humoral rejection (CHR) and in tolerant recipients (n = 4) that never displayed signs of CHR. All CHR recipients exhibited high levels of anti-donor Abs and mounted potent direct T cell alloresponses in vitro. Such direct alloreactivity could be detected for more than 1 y after transplantation. In contrast, only two of five monkeys with CHR had a detectable indirect alloresponse. No indirect alloresponse by T cells and no alloantibody responses were found in any of the tolerant monkeys. Only one of four tolerant monkeys displayed a direct T cell alloresponse. These observations indicate that direct T cell alloresponses can be sustained for prolonged periods posttransplantation and result in alloantibody production and chronic rejection of kidney transplants, even in the absence of detectable indirect alloreactivity.

KIR and HLA-C Interactions Promote Differential Dendritic Cell Maturation and Is a Major Determinant of Graft Failure following Kidney Transplantation

BackgroundHLA-C is an important ligand for killer immunoglobulin like receptors (KIR) that regulate natural killer (NK) cell function. Based on KIR specificity HLA-C molecules are allocated into two groups, HLA-C1 or HLA-C2; HLA-C2 is more inhibiting to NK cell function than HLA-C1. We studied the clinical importance of HLA-C genotypes on the long-term graft survival of 760 kidney transplants performed at our centre utilising a population based genetic study and cell culture model to define putative mechanisms.Methods and FindingsGenotyping was performed using conventional DNA PCR techniques and correlations made to clinical outcomes. We found that transplant recipients with HLA-C2 had significantly better long-term graft survival than transplant recipients with HLA-C1 (66% versus 44% at 10 years, log-rank p = 0.002, HR = 1.51, 95%CI = 1.16–1.97). In in-vitro NK and dendritic cell (DC) co-culture model we made several key observations that correlated with the population based genetic study. We observed that donor derived NK cells, on activation with IL-15, promoted differential HLA-C genotype dependent DC maturation. In NK-DC co-culture, the possession of HLA-C2 by DC was associated with anti-inflammatory cytokine production (IL-1RA/IL-6), diminished DC maturation (CD86, HLA-DR), and absent CCR7 expression. Conversely, possession of HLA-C1 by DC was associated with pro-inflammatory cytokine synthesis (TNF-α, IL-12p40/p70), enhanced DC maturation and up-regulation of CCR7 expression. By immunohistochemistry the presence of donor NK cells was confirmed in pre-transplant kidneys.ConclusionsWe propose that after kidney transplantation IL-15 activated donor derived NK cells interact with recipient DC with less activation of indirect allo-reactivity in HLA-C2 positive recipients than HLA-C1 positive recipients; this has implications for long-term graft survival. Early events following kidney transplantation involving NK-DC interaction via KIR and HLA-C immune synapse may have a central role in long-term kidney transplant outcomes.

NK Cell Patrolling and Elimination of Donor-Derived Dendritic Cells Favor Indirect Alloreactivity

Direct presentation of foreign MHC molecules expressed by donor-derived dendritic cells (DCs) has generally been considered the dominant pathway of allorecognition in acute transplant rejection. However, recent studies implicate preferential activation of the indirect pathway by host DCs. The respective importance of each pathway and the mechanisms that determine their relative contributions remain to be clearly established. In this study, using two-photon microscopy, we visualized host NK cell interactions with syngeneic and allogeneic DCs within intact lymph nodes of mice. Upon contact with allogeneic DCs, NK cells formed prolonged interactions that led directly to target cell lysis. This rapid elimination limited the ability of allogeneic DCs to stimulate primary and recall T cell responses. To discriminate whether donor or host DCs are principally involved in presenting Ag derived from allografts, we used CD11c-diphtheria toxoid receptor mice to conditionally ablate CD11c(+) DCs and to show that direct presentation by donor DCs is alone insufficient to elicit acute allograft rejection. We thus propose that rapid elimination of allogeneic DCs limits direct Ag presentation and thereby favors the indirect pathway of alloreactivity.

Analysis of indirect pathway CD4+ T cells in a patient with metastable tolerance to a kidney allograft: Possible relevance to superior graft survival of HLA class II closely matched renal allografts

MHC class I mismatched, but class II matched kidney transplants are tolerogenic in large animal models. CD4 + T regulatory cells specific for HLA-B⁎1501-derived peptide p37-MA (DSDAASPR MAPRAPWIEQ) developed in a long term (> 12 years) tolerant patient who received an HLA-B⁎1501 mismatched, HLA class II closely matched renal allograft. We hypothesized that class II matching favored T regulatory cell development by allowing allopeptide presentation on either recipient (DR4/DQ7 +) or donor (DR4/DQ8 +) antigen presenting cells (APC). Indirect pathway CD4 + T cell clones were generated from recipient PBMC by sorting antigen-stimulated, proliferating cells. Most clones responded to p37-MA-pulsed B⁎1501 − autologous, but not to DQ8 +B⁎1501 + donor B-lymphoblastoid cell lines (B-LCL). However, some clones responded to both; in fact, one responded even more strongly to donor B-LCL than to p37-MA-pulsed autologous B-LCL. P37-MA contained a DQ8-binding motif and induced strong TH1 responses from DQ8 but not DQ6 transgenic mice. Microchimerism was found to be enriched in the dendritic cells (DC) cultured from adherent PBMC. This indicates donor APC could possibly present p37-MA peptide directly to p37-MA specific T cells. These data support the concept that, when the donor is MHC class II closely matched, a “hybrid” form of allorecognition (direct/indirect) occurs. This may favor the generation of a beneficial form of indirect pathway alloreactivity, i.e. allopeptide-specific CD4 + T regulatory cells, in the context of long term DC microchimerism.

Induction of Donor-Specific T-Cell Hyporesponsiveness Using Dexamethasone-Treated Dendritic Cells in Two Fully Mismatched Rat Kidney Transplantation Models

Dendritic cells (DC) can exert powerful immune stimulatory as well as regulatory functions and are therefore important tools for therapeutic strategies. Dexamethasone (Dex) was previously shown to inhibit DC maturation and to induce regulatory properties both in vitro and in vivo. Here, we investigated the immunoregulatory role of DexDC in two different rat acute rejection models of kidney transplantation. Rat DC were generated from BN and DA bone marrow in the presence of the corticosteroid, Dex. The function of Dex-modulated DC was analyzed in vitro and in vivo, using a BN to LEW and a DA to LEW renal transplantation model in the absence of other forms of immunosuppression. T cells of transplanted rats were isolated and restimulated with donor mature DC (lipopolysaccharide [LPS] or CD40L activated). T-cell responsiveness was analyzed by proliferative capacity and IFN-gamma production. Stimulation of Dex-modulated rat DC with LPS resulted in normal IL-10 production, whereas synthesis of IL-12 was impaired. In accordance, the capacity of LPS-DexDC to stimulate T-cell activation was decreased. In both renal transplantation models, treatment with donor-derived LPS-DexDC induced a significant donor-specific T-cell hyporesponse. However, pretreatment did not result in a prolonged graft survival. In two fully mismatched kidney transplantation models, donor-derived LPS-DexDC induce a donor-specific T-cell hyporesponse. However, in this setting allograft survival was not improved, suggesting an important role for T cells with indirect alloreactivity. Understanding the underlying mechanism involved in the rejection process will improve the development of a cell-based immunotherapy.

A pilot study on the immunological effects of oral administration of donor major histocompatibility complex class II peptides in renal transplant recipients

Oral tolerance is an important physiological mechanism of immune hyporesponsiveness to dietary antigens and the commensal flora of the gastrointestinal tract. Feeding of alloantigens, therefore, has the potential to suppress undesirable immune responses after transplantation. To date, there are no published reports on the effects of such an approach in human transplant recipients. In the present pilot study, we demonstrate complete suppression of baseline indirect alloreactivity in patients with chronic renal allograft dysfunction following the oral feeding of low (0.5 mg/d) but not higher (1.0 and 5.0 mg/d) doses of donor major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II peptides. The regimen was well tolerated with no evidence for sensitization to the donor antigen. Our results indicate that oral feeding of low dose donor MHC peptide may represent a safe and effective therapy to suppress indirect alloreactivity in renal transplant recipients with chronic allograft dysfunction and warrants further clinical investigation.