Independent Membrane Damaging Activity Research Articles

The bactericidal effect of human secreted group IID phospholipase A2 results from both hydrolytic and non-hydrolytic activities

The Human Secreted Group IID Phospholipase A(2) (hsPLA2GIID) may be involved in the human acute immune response. Here we have demonstrated that the hsPLA2GIID presents bactericidal and Ca(2+)-independent liposome membrane-damaging activities and we have compared these effects with the catalytic activity of active-site mutants of the protein. All mutants showed reduced hydrolytic activity against DOPC:DOPG liposome membranes, however bactericidal effects against Escherichia coli and Micrococcus luteus were less affected, with the D49K mutant retaining 30% killing of the Gram-negative bacteria at a concentration of 10μg/mL despite the absence of catalytic activity. The H48Q mutant maintained Ca(2+)-independent membrane-damaging activity whereas the G30S and D49K mutants were approximately 50% of the wild-type protein, demonstrating that phospholipid bilayer permeabilization by the hsPLA2GIID is independent of catalytic activity. We suggest that this Ca(2+)-independent damaging activity may play a role in the bactericidal function of the protein.

Restoration of Enzymatic Activity in a Ser-49 Phospholipase A2Homologue Decreases Its Ca2+-Independent Membrane-Damaging Activity and Increases Its Toxicity

Ammodytin L (AtnL) is a Ser-49 secretory phospholipase A2 (sPLA2) homologue with myotoxic activity. By analogy to the Lys-49 sPLA2 myotoxins, AtnL has been predicted to be enzymatically inactive due to the absence of the conserved Asp-49 that participates in coordination of the Ca2+ cofactor. By substituting Ser-49 and three other residues in the Ca2+-binding loop of AtnL, we obtained the first two enzymatically active mutants of Lys-49/Ser-49 sPLA2 homologues. The mutants LW and LV, which differed only by the presence of Trp and Val at position 31, respectively, efficiently hydrolyzed phospholipid vesicles, while recombinant AtnL displayed no activity. In contrast to AtnL but similarly to ammodytoxin A (AtxA), a homologous neurotoxic sPLA2, both mutants exhibited catalysis-dependent membrane-damaging ability, involving vesicle contents leakage and fusion. However, LW and LV also exhibited the potent, Ca2+-independent disruption of vesicle integrity characteristic of AtnL, but not of AtxA, in which leakage of the contents is not associated with membrane fusion. Although LV and, especially, LW have the advantage over AtnL of being able to act in both Ca2+-independent and Ca2+-dependent modes, and display higher cytotoxicity and higher lethal potency, they have a lower Ca2+-independent membrane-damaging potency and display reduced specificity in targeting muscle fibers in vitro. Our results indicate that, in evolution, Lys-49 and Ser-49 sPLA2 myotoxins have lost their Ca2+-binding ability and enzymatic activity through subtle changes in the Ca2+-binding network without affecting the rest of the catalytic machinery, thereby optimizing their Ca2+-independent membrane-damaging ability and myotoxic activity.

Mapping of the structural determinants of artificial and biological membrane damaging activities of a Lys49 phospholipase A 2 by scanning alanine mutagenesis

Scanning alanine mutagenesis has been used to study the structural determinants of several activities of bothropstoxin-I (BthTx-I), a lysine 49 Phospholipases A 2 from the venom of Bothrops jararacussu. A total of 31 mutants were generated in the interfacial recognition site and C-terminal loop regions of the protein. The effects of mutagenesis on the in vivo myotoxic activity, the cytolytic activity against cultured C2C12 myoblasts, the bactericidal activity, and the Ca 2+-independent membrane damaging activity against liposome membranes were compared. Residues 116–119 and 122–125 in the C-terminal loop region are structural determinants for these activities, indicating that membrane permeabilization by the BthTx-I is an important general property in all the measured effects. The structural determinants of myotoxicity and myoblast membrane permeabilization are highly correlated, demonstrating that cultured C2C12 myoblasts are a good model for the myotoxic effect. However, comparison of the structural determinants for all activities revealed several differences in the structural determinants between the effects against myoblast and bacterial membranes, and further differences when compared to the liposome membrane damaging effect. These membrane dependent effects are interpreted to be the consequence of differences in the activation of the membrane bound form of the protein on biological and artificial membranes.

A predominant role for hydrogen bonding in the stability of the homodimer of bothropstoxin-I, A lysine 49-phospholipase A 2

Bothropstoxin-I (BthTx-I) is a homodimeric Lys49-phospholipase A 2 isolated from Bothrops jararacussu venom which damages liposome membranes via a Ca 2+-independent mechanism. The Glu12/Trp77/Lys80 triad at the dimer interface forms extensive intermolecular hydrogen bonds and hydrophobic contacts, and equilibrium chemical denaturation was used to evaluate the effect on homodimer stability of site-directed mutagenesis of these residues. Changes in the intrinsic fluorescence anisotropy and farUV circular dichroism signals were analyzed using a two-step unfolding model of the BthTx-I dimer to estimate the Gibbs free energy changes of transitions between the dimer and native monomer and between the native and denatured monomers. Whereas the Trp77His, Trp77Gln and Glu12Gln mutants showed native-like dimer stabilities, the Trp77Phe, Lys80Met and Lys80Gly mutants showed significantly reduced K d values. A reduced dimer stability is correlated with a decrease in the Ca 2+-independent membrane damaging activity as monitored by the release of a liposome entrapped fluorescent marker. Although the membrane damaging activity of the monomer is fivefold less than the dimer, the myotoxic activity was unaffected, indicating that these two effects are not correlated. These data suggest that the BthTx-I dimer is predominantly stabilized by hydrogen bonding interactions, and highlight the importance of the homodimeric form for efficient Ca 2+-independent membrane damage.

A Molecular Mechanism for Lys49-Phospholipase A2 Activity Based on Ligand-induced Conformational Change

Agkistrodon contortrix laticinctus myotoxin is a Lys(49)-phospholipase A(2) (EC 3.1.1.4) isolated from the venom of the serpent A. contortrix laticinctus (broad-banded copperhead). We present here three monomeric crystal structures of the myotoxin, obtained under different crystallization conditions. The three forms present notable structural differences and reveal that the presence of a ligand in the active site (naturally presumed to be a fatty acid) induces the exposure of a hydrophobic surface (the hydrophobic knuckle) toward the C terminus. The knuckle in A. contortrix laticinctus myotoxin involves the side chains of Phe(121) and Phe(124) and is a consequence of the formation of a canonical structure for the main chain within the region of residues 118-125. Comparison with other Lys(49)-phospholipase A(2) myotoxins shows that although the knuckle is a generic structural motif common to all members of the family, it is not readily recognizable by simple sequence analyses. An activation mechanism is proposed that relates fatty acid retention at the active site to conformational changes within the C-terminal region, a part of the molecule that has long been associated with Ca(2+)-independent membrane damaging activity and myotoxicity. This provides, for the first time, a direct structural connection between the phospholipase "active site" and the C-terminal "myotoxic site," justifying the otherwise enigmatic conservation of the residues of the former in supposedly catalytically inactive molecules.

Activation of Ca2+-independent membrane-damaging activity in Lys49–phospholipase A2 promoted by amphiphilic molecules

Association of class-II phospholipase A2 (PLA2) with aggregated phospholipid substrate results in elevated levels of the Ca2+-dependent hydrolytic activity. The Asp49 residue participates in coordination of the Ca2+ ion cofactor, however, in Lys49–PLA2 homologues (Lys49–PLA2s), substitution of the Asp49 by Lys results in loss of Ca2+ binding and lack of detectable phospholipid hydrolysis. Nevertheless, Lys49–PLA2s cause Ca2+-independent damage of liposome membranes. Bothropstoxin-I is a homodimeric Lys49–PLA2 from the venom of Bothrops jararacussu, and in fluorescent marker release and dynamic light scattering experiments with DPPC liposomes we demonstrate activation of the Ca2+-independent membrane damaging activity by ∼4 molecules of sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) per protein monomer. Activation is accompanied by significant changes in the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence emission (ITFE) and near UV circular dichroism (UVCD) spectra of the protein. Subsequent binding of 7–10 SDS molecules results in further alterations in the ITFE and far UVCD spectra. Reduction in the rate of N-bromosuccinimide modification of Trp77 at the dimer interface suggests that initial binding of SDS to this region accompanies the activation of the membrane damaging activity. 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulphonic acid binding studies indicate that subsequent SDS binding to the active site is concomitant with the second structural transition. These results provide insights in the structural basis of amphiphile/protein coupling in class-II PLA2s.

Topology of the substrate-binding site of a Lys49-phospholipase A2 influences Ca2+-independent membrane-damaging activity.

BthTx-I (bothropstoxin-I) is a myotoxic Lys49-PLA2 (phospholipase A2 with Lys49) isolated from Bothrops jararacussu venom, which damages liposome membranes by a Ca2+-independent mechanism. The highly conserved Phe5/Ala102/Phe106 motif in the hydrophobic substrate-binding site of the Asp49-PLA2s is substituted by Leu5/Val102/Leu106 in the Lys49-PLA2s. The Leu5/Val102/Leu106 triad in BthTx-I was sequentially mutated via all single- and double-mutant combinations to the Phe5/Ala102/Phe106 mutant. All mutants were expressed as inclusion bodies in Escherichia coli, and the thermal stability (Tm), together with the myotoxic and Ca2+-independent membrane-damaging activities of the recombinant proteins, were evaluated. The far-UV CD profiles of the native, wild-type recombinant and the L106F (Leu106-->Phe) and L5F/F102A/L106F mutant proteins were identical. The L5F, V102A, L5F/V102A and V102A/L106F mutants showed distorted far-UV CD profiles; however, only the L5F and L5F/V102A mutants showed significant decreases in Tm. Alterations in the far-UV CD spectra correlated with decreased myotoxicity and protein-induced release of a liposome-entrapped marker. However, the V102A/L106F and L5F/V102A/L106F mutants, which presented high myotoxic activities, showed significantly reduced membrane-damaging activity. This demonstrates that the topology of the substrate-binding region of BthTx-I has a direct effect on the Ca2+-independent membrane damage, and implies that substrate binding retains an important role in this process.

Distinct sites for myotoxic and membrane-damaging activities in the C-terminal region of a Lys49-phospholipase A2.

Bothropstoxin-I (BthTx-I) is a Lys(49)-phospholipase A(2) from the venom of Bothrops jararacussu which demonstrates both myotoxic and Ca(2+)-independent membrane-damaging activities. The structural determinants of these activities are poorly defined, therefore site-directed mutagenesis has been used to substitute all cationic and aromatic residues between positions 115 and 129 in the C-terminal loop region of the protein. Substitution of lysine and arginine residues with alanine in the region 117-122 resulted in a significant reduction of myotoxic activity of the recombinant BthTx-I. With the exception of Lys(122), these same substitutions did not significantly alter the Ca(2+)-independent membrane-damaging activity. In contrast, substitution of the positively-charged residues at positions 115, 116 and 122 resulted in reduced Ca(2+)-independent membrane-damaging activity but, with the exception of Lys(122), had no effect on myotoxicity. These results indicate that the two activities are independent and are determined by discrete yet partially overlapping motifs in the C-terminal loop. Results from site-directed mutagenesis of the aromatic residues in the same part of the protein suggest that a region including residues 115-119 interacts superficially with the membrane interface and that the residues around position 125 partially insert into the lipid membrane. These results represent the first detailed mapping of a myotoxic site in a phospholipase A(2), and support a model of a Ca(2+)-independent membrane-damaging mechanism in which the C-terminal region of BthTx-I interacts with and contributes to the perturbation of the phospholipid bilayer.

A pH-induced dissociation of the dimeric form of a lysine 49-phospholipase A2 abolishes Ca2+-independent membrane damaging activity.

The hydrolysis of phospholipids by class II phospholipase A2 (PLA2) involves a Ca2+ ion cofactor bound to the Asp49 residue in the active site region. In the lysine 49 phospholipase A2 homologues (Lys49-PLA2), the Asp49 residue is substituted by Lys, and consequently the Lys49-PLA2s show no Ca2+ binding and no detectable phospholipid hydrolysis. Nevertheless, the Lys49-PLA2s demonstrate membrane damaging activity by an incompletely understood Ca2+-independent mechanism of action. Using a combination of steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence techniques, we have examined the effect of pH on the monomer-dimer equilibrium of bothropstoxin I (BthTX-I), a Lys49-PLA2 from the venom of Bothrops jararacussu which contains a single Trp77 residue located at the dimer interface. At pH 5.0, we observe a decreased quantum yield, a decreased rotational correlation time, and an increased bimolecular quenching rate constant with iodide. These results are consistent with a pH-induced dissociation of the BthTX-I dimer, with the consequent exposure of the Trp77 residue to aqueous solvent. In the presence of liposomes, membrane damaging activity is observed only under conditions in which the dimeric form of the BthTX-I is favored. These results demonstrate that the dimeric form of the protein is essential for the initiation of the Ca2+-independent membrane damaging activity.

At the interface: Crystal structures of phospholipases A 2

The protein content of many snake venoms often includes one or more phospholipases A 2 (PLA 2). In recent years a growing number of venoms from snakes of Agkistrodon, Bothrops and Trimeresurus species have been shown to contain a catalytically inactive PLA 2-homologue in which the highly conserved aspartic acid at position 49 (Asp49) is substituted by lysine (Lys49). Although demonstrating little or no catalytic activity, these Lys49–PLA 2s disrupt membranes by a Ca 2+-independent mechanism of action. In addition, this family of PLA 2s demonstrates myotoxic and cytolytic pharmacological activities, however the structural bases underlying these functional properties are poorly understood. Through the application of X-ray crystallography in combination with biophysical and bioinformatics techniques, we are studying structure/function relationships of Lys49–PLA 2s. We here present results of a systematic X-ray crystallographic and amino acid sequence analysis study of Lys49–PLA 2s and propose a model to explain the Ca 2+-independent membrane damaging activity.

Amino acid sequence of a myotoxic Lys49-phospholipase A 2 homologue from the venom of Cerrophidion ( Bothrops) godmani

The complete amino acid sequence of myotoxin II (godMT-II), a myotoxic phospholipase A 2 (PLA 2) homologue from the venom of the Central American crotaline snake Cerrophidion (Bothrops) godmani, was determined by direct protein sequencing methods. GodMT-II is a class II PLA 2 showing a Lys instead of Asp at position 49. An additional substitution in the calcium binding loop region (Asn instead of Tyr at position 28) suggests the lack of enzymatic activity observed in this toxin is due to loss of its ability to bind the co-factor Ca 2+, since the residues involved in forming the catalytic network of PLA 2s (His-48, Tyr-52 and Asp-99) are conserved in godMT-II. This myotoxin shows highest sequence homology with other Lys-49 PLA 2s from Bothrops, Agkistrodon and Trimeresurus species, suggesting that they constitute a conserved family of proteins, yet in contrast presents lower homology with Bothrops asper myotoxin III, a catalytically-active PLA 2. The C-terminal region of godMT-II, which is rich in cationic and hydrophobic residues, shares high sequence homology to the corresponding region in the myotoxin II from B. asper, which has been proposed to play an important role in the Ca 2+-independent membrane damaging activity.

A SequenceSpace analysis of Lys49 phopholipases A2: clues towards identification of residues involved in a novel mechanism of membrane damage and in myotoxicity.

'SequenceSpace' analysis is a novel approach which has been used to identify unique amino acids within a sub-family of phospholipases A2 (PLA2) in which the highly conserved active site residue Asp49 is substituted by Lys (Lys49-PLA2s). Although Lys49-PLA2s do not bind the catalytic co-factor Ca2+ and possess extremely low catalytic activity, they demonstrate a Ca2+-independent membrane damaging activity through a poorly understood mechanism, which does not involve lipid hydrolysis. Additionally, Lys49-PLA2s possess combined myotoxic, oedema forming and cardiotoxic pharmacological activities, however the structural basis of these varied functions is largely unknown. Using the 'SequenceSpace' analysis we have identified nine residues highly unique to the Lys49-PLA2 sub-family, which are grouped in three amino acid clusters in the active site, hydrophobic substrate binding channel and homodimer interface regions. These three highly specific residue clusters may have relevance for the Ca2+-independent membrane damaging activity. Of a further 15 less stringently conserved residues, nine are located in two additional clusters which are well isolated from the active site region. The less strictly conserved clusters have been used in predictive sequence searches to correlate amino acid patterns in other venom PLA2s with their pharmacological activities, and motifs for presynaptic and combined toxicities are proposed.

Crystallographic and spectroscopic characterization of a molecular hinge: conformational changes in bothropstoxin I, a dimeric Lys49-phospholipase A2 homologue.

Bothropstoxin I (BthTX-I) from the venom of Bothrops jararacussu is a myotoxic phospholipase A2 (PLA2) homologue which, although catalytically inactive due to an Asp49-->Lys substitution, disrupts the integrity of lipid membranes by a Ca2+-independent mechanism. The crystal structures of two dimeric forms of BthTX-I which diffract X-rays to resolutions of 3.1 and 2.1 angstroms have been determined. The monomers in both structures are related by an almost perfect twofold axis of rotation and the dimer interfaces are defined by contacts between the N-terminal alpha-helical regions and the tips of the beta-wings of partner monomers. Significant differences in the relative orientation of the monomers in the two crystal forms results in "open" and "closed" dimer conformations. Spectroscopic investigations of BthTX-I in solution have correlated these conformational differences with changes in the intrinsic fluorescence emission of the single tryptophan residues located at the dimer interface. The possible relevance of this structural transition in the Ca2+-independent membrane damaging activity is discussed.