Incomparable States Research Articles

Statistics of entanglement transformation with hierarchies among catalysts

The distribution of typical bipartite pure states is studied within the framework of state transformation via local operation and classical communication (LOCC). We report the statistics of comparable and incomparable states in different dimensions for single- and multi-copy regimes and establish a connection between state transformation and the difference between the entanglement contents of the initial and the target states. From the analysis of catalyst resources, required to further otherwise impossible LOCC transformations between pairs, we demonstrate a universal pattern in the average and minimum entanglement of the randomly generated catalysts. Furthermore, we introduce a concept of hierarchy between different kinds of catalysts and show how they can not only aid in the conversion of incomparable states but can also act as a less costly resource towards this goal. We confirm the existence of catalysts, referred to as strong catalysts, which can activate LOCC transformation between pairs at the single-copy level, when it is initially impossible even with multiple copies.

Incomparability, entropy, and mixing dynamics

Boltzmann states are considered in a fundamentally new way, specifically their mixing character. The mixing character of these states is known to be partially ordered by majorization and thus contains information regarding their incomparability. Previously we showed that Boltzmann entropy states had a huge range in the number of incomparable states. Here we phase average incomparability across Boltzmann states. We propose the consequent function as a new state variable, complimentary to entropy, that provides new insights to Boltzmann systems. This function can be related to a traditional complexity viewpoint and so we call it average Boltzmann complexity (ABC). The evolution of Boltzmann complexity is explored via a Monte Carlo lattice dynamics approach and is shown to be consistent with the view of entropy as the arrow of time. Our report concludes with a discussion of the information contained in Boltzmann complexity and offers suggestions for further studies.

Character of superposed states under deterministic LOCC

In this paper we investigate the effect of superposition of states on local conversion of pure bipartite states under deterministic LOCC. We are able to form a bridge between comparable and incomparable classes of states through the linear superposition of states. For example, if we consider two pairs of incomparable states, then their superposition may result into a comparable pair of states. We investigate many such cases and provide some of the results in tabular form. We also investigate the entanglement behavior of such classes of states, specifically their monotone nature. Finally we provide some bounds of different measures of entanglement based on the idea of comparability and incomparability under deterministic LOCC.

Entanglement of formation is non-monotonic with concurrence: a simple proof

In this paper we explore the non-monotonic nature of entanglement of formation with respect to concurrence for pure bipartite states. For pure bipartite system, one of the basic physical reason of this non-monotonicity character is due to the existence of incomparable states, i.e., the pure bipartite states which are not convertible to each other by LOCC with certainty.

Character of locally inequivalent classes of states and entropy of entanglement

In this Rapid Communication we have established the physical character of pure bipartite states with the same amount of entanglement in the same Schmidt rank that either they are local unitarily connected or they are incomparable. There exists an infinite number of deterministically locally inequivalent classes of pure bipartite states in the same Schmidt rank (starting from three) having the same amount of entanglement. Further, if there exists incomparable states with the same entanglement in higher Schmidt ranks (greater than three), then they should differ in at least three Schmidt coefficients.

General classes of impossible operations through the existence of incomparable states

In this work we show that the most general class of anti-unitary operators are nonphysical in nature through the existence of incomparable pure bipartite entangled states. It is also shown that a large class of inner-product-preserving operations defined only on the three qubits having spin-directions along x,y and z are impossible. If we perform such an operation locally on a particular pure bipartite state then it will exactly transform to another pure bipartite state that is incomparable with the original one. As subcases of the above results we find the nonphysical nature of universal exact flipping operation and existence of universal Hadamard gate. Beyond the information conservation in terms of entanglement, this work shows how an impossible local operation evolve with the joint system in a nonphysical way.

No-Cloning and No-Deleting Theorems through the Existence of Incomparable States Under LOCC

No-Cloning and No-Deleting theorems are verified with the constraint on local state transformations via the existence of incomparable states. Assuming the existence of exact cloning or deleting operation defined on a minimum number of two arbitrary states, an incomparable pair of states of the joint system between two parties can be made to compare under deterministic LOCC. We have restricted our proof with the assumption that the machine states of the cloning or deleting operations do not keep any information about the input states. We use the same setting to establish the no-cloning and no-deleting theorems via incomparability that supports the reciprocity of the two operations in their operational senses. The work associates the impossibility of operations with the evolution of an entangled system by LOCC.

Impossibility of exact flipping of three arbitrary quantum states via incomparability

We present here a scheme that relates seemingly two different kinds of physical impossibilities of quantum information processing. We derive, exact flipping of three arbitrary states not lying in one great circle is not possible with certainty, by using the existence of incomparable states which are not interconvertible deterministically by local operations and classical communications. In contrast, considering the non-existence of exact universal flipper, the incomparability of a pair of bipartite pure entangled states can be established.

Deterministic Local Conversion of Incomparable States by Collective LOCC

Incomparability of pure bipartite entangled states under deterministic LOCC is a very strange phenomena. We find two possible ways of getting our desired pure entangled state which is incomparable with the given input state, by collective LOCC with certainty. The first one is by providing some pure entanglement through the lower dimensional maximally-entangled states or using further less amount of entanglement and the next one is by collective operation on two pairs which are individually incomparable. It is quite surprising that we are able to achieve maximally entangled states of any Schmidt rank from a finite number of 2x2 pure entangled states only by deterministic LOCC. We provide general theory for the case of 3x3 system of incomparable states by the above processes where incomparability seems to be the most hardest one.

Efficiency of deterministic entanglement transformation

We prove that sufficiently many copies of a bipartite entangled pure state can always be transformed into some copies of another one with certainty by local quantum operations and classical communication. The efficiency of such a transformation is characterized by deterministic entanglement exchange rate, and it is proved to be always positive and bounded from top by the infimum of the ratios of Renyi's entropies of source state and target state. A careful analysis shows that the deterministic entanglement exchange rate cannot be increased even in the presence of catalysts. As an application, we show that there can be two incomparable states with deterministic entanglement exchange rate strictly exceeding 1.

The existence of quantum entanglement catalysts

Without additional resources, it is often impossible to transform one entangled quantum state into another with local quantum operations and classical communication. Jonathan and Plenio (Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 83, p. 3566, 1999) presented an interesting example showing that the presence of another state, called a catalyst, enables such a transformation without changing the catalyst. They also pointed out that in general it is very hard to find an analytical condition under which a catalyst exists. In this paper, we study the existence of catalysts for two incomparable quantum states. For the simplest case of 2/spl times/2 catalysts for transformations from one 4/spl times/4 state to another, a necessary and sufficient condition for existence is found. For the general case, we give an efficient polynomial time algorithm to decide whether a k/spl times/k catalyst exists for two n/spl times/n incomparable states, where k is treated as a constant.

Entanglement convertibility for infinite-dimensional pure bipartite states

It is shown that the order property of pure bipartite states under SLOCC (stochastic local operations and classical communications) changes radically when dimensionality shifts from finite to infinite. In contrast to finite dimensional systems where there is no pure incomparable state, the existence of infinitely many mutually SLOCC incomparable states is shown for infinite dimensional systems even under the bounded energy and finite information exchange condition. These results show that the effect of the infinite dimensionality of Hilbert space, the ``infinite workspace'' property, remains even in physically relevant infinite dimensional systems.

Classification of nonasymptotic bipartite pure-state entanglement transformations

Let (\{| \psi> ,| \phi>}) be an incomparable pair of states ((| \psi \nleftrightarrow | \phi>)), \emph, i.e., (| \psi>) and (| \phi>) cannot be transformed to each other with probability one by local transformations and classical communication (LOCC). We show that incomparable states can be multiple-copy transformable, \emph, i.e., there can exist a \emph{k}, such that (| \psi> ^{\otimes k+1}\to | \phi> ^{\otimes k+1}), i.e., (k+1) copies of (| \psi>) can be transformed to (k+1) copies of (| \phi>) with probability one by LOCC but (| \psi> ^{\otimes n}\nleftrightarrow | \phi> ^{\otimes n} \forall n\leq k). We call such states \emph{k}-copy LOCC incomparable. We provide a necessary condition for a given pair of states to be \emph{k}-copy LOCC incomparable for some \emph{k}. We also show that there exist states that are neither \emph{k}-copy LOCC incomparable for any \emph{k} nor catalyzable even with multiple copies. We call such states strongly incomparable. We give a sufficient condition for strong incomparability. We demonstrate that the optimal probability of a conclusive transformation involving many copies, (p_{max}(| \psi> ^{\otimes m}\to | \phi> ^{\otimes m})) can decrease exponentially with the number of source states (m), even if the source state has \emph{more} entropy of entanglement.

Relativity of Pure States Entanglement

Entanglement of any pure state of an N×N bi-partite quantum system may be characterized by the vector of coefficients arising by its Schmidt decomposition. We analyze various measures of entanglement derived from the generalized entropies of the vector of Schmidt coefficients. For N≥3 they generate different ordering in the set of pure states and for some states their ordering depends on the measure of entanglement used. This odd-looking property is acceptable, since these incomparable states cannot be transformed to each other with unit efficiency by any local operation. In analogy to special relativity the set of pure states equivalent under local unitaries has a causal structure so that at each point the set splits into three parts: the “Future,” the “Past,” and the set of noncomparable states.

Basic limitations for entanglement catalysis

In this Letter we summarize the necessary condition for incomparable states which can be catalyzed under entanglement-assisted LQCC (ELQCC). When we apply an extended condition for entanglement transformation to entanglement-assisted local manipulation we obtain a fundamental limit for entanglement catalysts. Some relative questions are also discussed.

Recovery of entanglement lost in entanglement manipulation

When an entangled state is transformed into another one with probability one by local operations and classical communication, the quantity of entanglement decreases. This Letter shows that entanglement lost in the manipulation can be partially recovered by an auxiliary entangled pair. As an application, a maximally entangled pair can be obtained from two partially entangled pairs with probability one. Finally, this recovery scheme reveals a fundamental property of entanglement relevant to the existence of incomparable states.