Background Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) and serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor (SNRI) use is more common in the plastic surgery population compared to the general population. This study was designed to assess the theoretical effect of SSRIs and SNRIs on platelet function and the potential for increased bleeding risk. This study sought to establish the incidence of postoperative bleeding following routine bilateral breast reduction for patients on SSRIs or SNRIs. The outcomes of this study contribute to the discussion of whether these medications should be discontinued before elective surgery. Methodology A retrospective chart review of all patients who received bilateral breast reduction surgery over a 10-year period was performed. Patient charts were reviewed for postoperative hematoma formation as well as medications being used around the time of surgery. The rate of hematoma formation in patients actively taking SSRIs or SNRIs at the time of surgery was compared with the rest of the study population. Results A total of 1,022 patients met the inclusion criteria for the study. The overall incidence of postoperative hematoma was 7.7%. Of these, 1.9% of patients had clinically significant hematomas that required operative evacuation, and the remaining were treated conservatively. The only variable associated with a significantly higher risk of hematoma formation was advanced age (p = 0.005). Conclusions There was no significant difference in hematoma incidence after breast reduction in patients taking SNRIs or SSRIs compared with the general population. This contradicts some of the previously published literature and can hopefully guide clinicians in counseling their patients preoperatively.