Organizational scholars and practitioners have espoused compassion as a powerful antidote to alleviating another’s suffering in the COVID-19 pandemic. Yet, past work has largely examined compassion as an in-person process. In a time where remote work and social distancing are necessary to prevent further spread of the virus, it is unclear if the influence of compassion would be diminished without face-to-face interaction. In this research, we unpack the question of how far-reaching the impact of compassion can be by examining whether compassion can spill over to third parties uninvolved in the compassion episode, and whether its impact can be transmitted virtually—the common mode of communication in this time. Drawing on social contagion theory and the theory of transactional stress and coping, we examine how observing compassion influences employees’ interpersonal (organizational citizenship behavior) and intrapersonal (performance) work outcomes, and their personal well-being (negative mood), via employees’ other-orientation. We also examine how employees’ trait sense of control attenuates the compassion spillover effects. We test our proposed theoretical model via an experiential sampling intervention across two weeks in a sample of 91 K-12 teachers—essential workers whose work routines have been entirely disrupted and subjected to uncertainty (e.g., newly online courses). Each morning, we manipulated observed compassion (vs. control) via short stories involving other teachers. Overall, we found support for our propositions. We thus offer a simple remedy—that is, sharing short stories about compassion—that organizations and employees can use to alleviate some of the ongoing suffering during this difficult time.