Structures’ ultimate strength has been increasingly valued in the past few decades. The model test is an important and reliable way to estimate the ultimate strength. For large and complex structures, like ship hull structures, the test subject is usually scale models due to the limitation of loading capacity and space of laboratories. Therefore, the similarity method and the design of scale models are of great importance. The stiffened plate is the minimum unit that makes up thin-walled structures. The similarity method of the ultimate strength of stiffened plates is the base of the similarity method of large and complex structures. This paper is a further study of an existing similarity method proposed in our previous work. A stiffened plate from a real ship is taken as the subject. 22 combinations of scale ratios are used to design scale models. The 23 models (including the original model) are subjected to a combined load of longitudinal compression and lateral pressure. The non-linear finite element method is used to analyze these models. The results revealed that the previous method is only suitable for scale models with small degrees of geometrical distortion. It didn't consider the effect of geometrical distortions. An improved similarity method and scale model design method are proposed to solve these problems. The improved methods consider the geometrical distortion of scale models and are applicable to more geometrically distorted scale models. More numerical examples are performed to verify the correctness and advantage of the improved methods.